• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Penalty fare issued 15 seconds into journey as asking for ticket

Status
Not open for further replies.

cumfy

Member
Joined
11 Sep 2011
Messages
64
I just caught the 1304 from Bradford on Avon to Bristol which was running about 3 minutes late.
2 carriages, sat down straightaway halfway down first carriage and immediately saw train staff coming down the carriage he seemed to be walking past but I was geting my wallet out and managed to catch his attention and asked for a cheap day return to Oldfield Park, about 15 seconds after the train had set off from BOA.

He spoke vey quietly and seemed to say somethng about a penalty fare.
I had to clarify what he was saying and really took 2-3 attempts to clarify he was charging me a penalty fare.
Baically he didnt dispute that I was running late and purchasing a ticket at the first opportunity.
Tough. 20 quid thanks.

Is it really supposed to work like this ?
Whats the point of the stuff on nationalrail.co.uk saying buying on train at 1st opportunity is ok ?
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

TheEdge

Established Member
Joined
29 Nov 2012
Messages
4,489
Location
Norwich
Is it really supposed to work like this ?

Yes.

Whats the point of the stuff on nationalrail.co.uk saying buying on train at 1st opportunity is ok ?

It doesn't. The national rail page for Bradford on Avon lists both a ticket office and machines plus a warning that FGW charge penalty fares from there.
 

First class

Established Member
Joined
9 Aug 2008
Messages
2,731
I just caught the 1304 from Bradford on Avon to Bristol which was running about 3 minutes late.
2 carriages, sat down straightaway halfway down first carriage and immediately saw train staff coming down the carriage he seemed to be walking past but I was geting my wallet out and managed to catch his attention and asked for a cheap day return to Oldfield Park, about 15 seconds after the train had set off from BOA.

He spoke vey quietly and seemed to say somethng about a penalty fare.
I had to clarify what he was saying and really took 2-3 attempts to clarify he was charging me a penalty fare.
Baically he didnt dispute that I was running late and purchasing a ticket at the first opportunity.
Tough. 20 quid thanks.

Is it really supposed to work like this ?
Whats the point of the stuff on nationalrail.co.uk saying buying on train at 1st opportunity is ok ?

That's exactly what a Penalty Fare is for.

You failed to use the ticket facilities prior to boarding, because you were running late (which isn't the railway's problem).

A Penalty Fare is effectively just a higher priced ticket only sold when you have made an error.
 

najaB

Veteran Member
Joined
28 Aug 2011
Messages
30,689
Location
Scotland
I just caught the 1304 from Bradford on Avon to Bristol which was running about 3 minutes late....

Whats the point of the stuff on nationalrail.co.uk saying buying on train at 1st opportunity is ok ?
According to National Rail Enquiries, Bradford-on-Avon has a ticket office that is open until 13:40 Monday to Friday. This would have been your first opportunity to buy.
 

CC 72100

Established Member
Joined
23 Jan 2012
Messages
3,777
Which page on NRE are you referring to?

I've done a search for 'Purchasing tickets' and this is what I get in regards to buying on the train:

If there are no ticket purchasing facilities at the station (such as a booking office or a ticket machine, or they are closed/out of service), you may be able to buy your ticket on board the train.
http://www.nationalrail.co.uk/times_fares/ticket_types.aspx

However, Bradford-on-Avon has both a ticket vending machine and a booking office. This is the 1st opportunity to buy: http://www.nationalrail.co.uk/stations_destinations/BOA.aspx

FGW policy stance on therefore not using this opportunity to buy:
If you board any of our trains without a ticket, at a station where ticket buying services are available, you may be charged the full Single or Return fare relevant to your journey, or be reported for prosecution, or receive a penalty fare (if travelling from a station within the penalty fares zone). If purchasing tickets on board you will not be eligible for any railcard or other discounts.
https://www.firstgreatwestern.co.uk/train-times-and-tickets/buy-before-you-board---penalty-fares

Bradford-on-Avon, as this map shows, is in the Penalty Fares scheme: https://www.firstgreatwestern.co.uk...buybeforeyouboard/penaltfares-map-b.pdf?la=en
 

First class

Established Member
Joined
9 Aug 2008
Messages
2,731

That page clearly says:

Where Penalty Fares apply, rail passengers must buy their tickets before they start their journey wherever there are facilities for them to do so. If a passenger gets on a train without a ticket at a station where ticket facilities are available, they will have to pay a Penalty Fare if asked to do so by a ticket inspector who has been appointed as an 'authorised collector'.

To avoid paying a Penalty Fare, you must purchase a valid ticket to your destination for the class of travel you wish to use before starting your journey.

When can Penalty Fares be issued?

Penalty Fares can be issued if a passenger:
travels without a valid ticket

You may be surprised to know that you actually committed a criminal offence which some TOCs would have prosecuted you (successfully) for.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Bevan Price

Established Member
Joined
22 Apr 2010
Messages
7,320
I just caught the 1304 from Bradford on Avon to Bristol which was running about 3 minutes late.
2 carriages, sat down straightaway halfway down first carriage and immediately saw train staff coming down the carriage he seemed to be walking past but I was geting my wallet out and managed to catch his attention and asked for a cheap day return to Oldfield Park, about 15 seconds after the train had set off from BOA.

He spoke vey quietly and seemed to say somethng about a penalty fare.
I had to clarify what he was saying and really took 2-3 attempts to clarify he was charging me a penalty fare.
Baically he didnt dispute that I was running late and purchasing a ticket at the first opportunity.
Tough. 20 quid thanks.

Is it really supposed to work like this ?
Whats the point of the stuff on nationalrail.co.uk saying buying on train at 1st opportunity is ok ?

Because some dishonest people try to avoid payment, the TOCs regard everybody as a potential criminal, and surcharge even the honest people who, for various reasons, have been unable to purchase a ticket at the right time/location, or who have got the wrong ticket because they failed to understand the fiendishly complex ticketing system. Welcome to Rip-Off land.

Oh, and the same would apply if you arrived early at a station, but the inadequate numbers of staff had been unable to sell a ticket to everybody in the queue before the train departed.
 
Last edited:

najaB

Veteran Member
Joined
28 Aug 2011
Messages
30,689
Location
Scotland
cumfy as I see it, you walked past an open ticket office and a TVM and boarded a train in a penalty fare area and you got a penalty fare. Surprised much?
 

najaB

Veteran Member
Joined
28 Aug 2011
Messages
30,689
Location
Scotland
...surcharge even the honest people who, for various reasons, have been unable to purchase a ticket at the right time/location...
By his own admission, cumfey made no attempt to purchase a ticket before boarding a train on which penalty fares apply. I don't get why the result comes as a surprise.
 

johnnychips

Established Member
Joined
19 Nov 2011
Messages
3,675
Location
Sheffield
By his own admission, cumfey made no attempt to purchase a ticket before boarding a train on which penalty fares apply. I don't get why the result comes as a surprise.

I can't read cumfy's mind, but how about he didn't realise he couldn't buy a ticket on the train? While there is no doubt the PF was correctly issued, not everybody is a fare expert like on here, and if you don't frequently travel on a line you might not realise you can't do this.
 

najaB

Veteran Member
Joined
28 Aug 2011
Messages
30,689
Location
Scotland
I can't read cumfy's mind, but how about he didn't realise he couldn't buy a ticket on the train? While there is no doubt the PF was correctly issued, not everybody is a fare expert like on here, and if you don't frequently travel on a line you might not realise you can't do this.
I don't pretend to be able to read minds either, but the PF was correctly issued. I have empathy for the sting in the wallet but I don't see that there any reason for indignation. Searching out and misquoting web pages after the fact isn't going to make it invalid.
 

CC 72100

Established Member
Joined
23 Jan 2012
Messages
3,777
I don't know Bradford-on-Avon station, but all of the FGW stations that I use frequently - even those which do not involve walking through a physical station building if it is closed/ TVM only - do have Yellow penalty fares posters up to warn people of 'what is expected of them'.
 

EM2

Established Member
Joined
16 Nov 2008
Messages
7,523
Location
The home of the concrete cow
I can't read cumfy's mind, but how about he didn't realise he couldn't buy a ticket on the train? While there is no doubt the PF was correctly issued, not everybody is a fare expert like on here, and if you don't frequently travel on a line you might not realise you can't do this.
The open ticket office and ticket machine should be a big clue.
 

najaB

Veteran Member
Joined
28 Aug 2011
Messages
30,689
Location
Scotland
The reasoning in http://www.nationalrail.co.uk/times_fares/ticket_types/46592.aspx seems strange to me. It says that the reason for penalty fares is that it is not always possible to check everyones ticket but surely in order to charge penalty fares all tickets must be checked. Is there a flaw in my logic.
They're saying that because they can't check everyone's ticket they put a penalty in place to encourage people to buy tickets who otherwise might not.

Think of it from a fare dodger's point of view: without penalty fares, if I don't buy a ticket and get caught I just pay the fare. With penalty fares, if I don't buy a ticket and get caught I feel the pain in my wallet.
 

DaleCooper

Established Member
Joined
2 Mar 2015
Messages
3,507
Location
Mulholland Drive
They're saying that because they can't check everyone's ticket they put a penalty in place to encourage people to buy tickets who otherwise might not.

Think of it from a fare dodger's point of view: without penalty fares, if I don't buy a ticket and get caught I just pay the fare. With penalty fares, if I don't buy a ticket and get caught I feel the pain in my wallet.

Thanks, I didn't think to look at it from that angle.
 

johnnychips

Established Member
Joined
19 Nov 2011
Messages
3,675
Location
Sheffield
The open ticket office and ticket machine should be a big clue.

Yes, I know what you mean, but I think there are some train companies where you can ignore them and pay on the train. You certainly could do this at Donny with NT and TPE in the past and still can with GC. And I know this was a PF zone, but how many people read the notices?

I also wonder sometimes about "discretion". A lot of staff on this site say they can recognise someone who has made a genuine mistake and those who are trying it on. If guards show discretion - or perhaps they aren't allowed to? - and others see this happening they may assume it's OK.

As I said, there is no doubt the PF is correct, but I can also see why the OP could have been surprised and annoyed.
 

Haydn1971

Established Member
Joined
11 Dec 2012
Messages
2,099
Location
Sheffield
Yes, I know what you mean, but I think there are some train companies where you can ignore them and pay on the train. You certainly could do this at Donny with NT and TPE in the past and still can with GC. And I know this was a PF zone, but how many people read the notices?



I also wonder sometimes about "discretion". A lot of staff on this site say they can recognise someone who has made a genuine mistake and those who are trying it on. If guards show discretion - or perhaps they aren't allowed to? - and others see this happening they may assume it's OK.



As I said, there is no doubt the PF is correct, but I can also see why the OP could have been surprised and annoyed.


This exactly ! I've had a very small number of comments on Northern re getting a ticket before travel, yet on 99% of trips I've been sold one on the train - similarly, my old boss a very respectable sort, six figure salary was stumped at being selected for a finger wag on TPE going from Hull to Manchester - a journey he makes several times a month and has always bought a ticket on the train - operators can't have it both ways, you either can or you can't - stop profiteering on customers.
 

Flamingo

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2010
Messages
6,810
The OP was caught.

I tell lots of people that "I was running for the train" is not an excuse that RPI's accept, usually to get a snide comment back. This just proves that it isn't an excuse they accept.

If anybody feels this is unfair, they don't have to accept the PF, they can discover that a Magistrate won't accept it as an excuse either.

NajaB summed it up best in his post!
 

Flamingo

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2010
Messages
6,810
I'm not actually saying it's unfair, I'm saying it should be consistent !

Only RPI's can issue them. They are not on every train. The OP does have some sympathy from me, the odds of meeting one on my patch is about the same as winning the lottery.
 

edwin_m

Veteran Member
Joined
21 Apr 2013
Messages
24,792
Location
Nottingham
It seems to me the problem, on some TOCs at least, is that the regular conductors are happy to sell tickets on the train. This may be due to either or both of them getting commission on the tickets, or that they want to avoid a confrontation when they have no backup.

Then when there happen to be RPIs on the train, passengers who are accustomed to buying a ticket suddenly find they are being "penalised".

Perhaps it would be better described as an "on-board booking fee"?
 

cumfy

Member
Joined
11 Sep 2011
Messages
64
So if I had let the RP pass as he was in fact doing would I not have been able to buy a ticket from the guard ?

Oh and what happens if a passenger steadfastly claims they got on at the first non-PF station prior to their station ?
 

najaB

Veteran Member
Joined
28 Aug 2011
Messages
30,689
Location
Scotland
So if I had let the RP pass as he was in fact doing would I not have been able to buy a ticket from the guard ?
Most likely if there was also a guard they would've summoned the RPI.
Oh and what happens if a passenger steadfastly claims they got on at the first non-PF station prior to their station ?
Difficult to claim that if they're asking for a ticket from the PF station. But if the RPI wasn't able to prove the passenger's starting station they would have to get the benefit of the doubt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top