• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Proposal to reduce Routemaster 15H 'Heritage' operation in London

Status
Not open for further replies.

theblackwatch

Established Member
Joined
15 Feb 2006
Messages
10,713
The Routemaster Association is reporting that TfL is proposing to cut the days of operation of the 15H Routemaster service to just summer weekends and Bank Holidays from its current daily operation. According to a post on their Facebook page, TfL have said:

We are proposing to make changes to the route 15 heritage vehicle service and would like to hear your views.

Currently, the 15 heritage service operates between Tower Gateway and Trafalgar Square daily between 9:30am and 6:30pm. Other buses that cover this route include the 11 and 26, as well as the main route 15 service.

We are proposing to reduce the 15 heritage service to run on summer weekends and bank holidays only.

This is due to a number of factors, including:
o Falling weekday ridership
o The bus does not allow step-free access

This is a huge reduction from what I assume is a 364 day operation to probably under 40 days. Although I'm not from London, I'm down there every couple of months and regularly travel on Tfl tub/train services, and I've never seen anything advertising 'ride on an iconic bus' or similar - I'm sure more mebers of the public would if they knew they could and where.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

carlberry

Established Member
Joined
19 Dec 2014
Messages
3,169
The Routemaster Association is reporting that TfL is proposing to cut the days of operation of the 15H Routemaster service to just summer weekends and Bank Holidays from its current daily operation. According to a post on their Facebook page, TfL have said:



This is a huge reduction from what I assume is a 364 day operation to probably under 40 days. Although I'm not from London, I'm down there every couple of months and regularly travel on Tfl tub/train services, and I've never seen anything advertising 'ride on an iconic bus' or similar - I'm sure more mebers of the public would if they knew they could and where.
TfL have to save money and it's better to cut stuff like this than real services.
 

Robertj21a

On Moderation
Joined
22 Sep 2013
Messages
7,518
The Routemaster Association is reporting that TfL is proposing to cut the days of operation of the 15H Routemaster service to just summer weekends and Bank Holidays from its current daily operation. According to a post on their Facebook page, TfL have said:



This is a huge reduction from what I assume is a 364 day operation to probably under 40 days. Although I'm not from London, I'm down there every couple of months and regularly travel on Tfl tub/train services, and I've never seen anything advertising 'ride on an iconic bus' or similar - I'm sure more mebers of the public would if they knew they could and where.

It's been going for long enough. Only really originally intended to shut up certain people, and provide a bit of a sight for tourists. TfL need to cut costs.
 

Busaholic

Veteran Member
Joined
7 Jun 2014
Messages
14,068
The Routemaster Association is reporting that TfL is proposing to cut the days of operation of the 15H Routemaster service to just summer weekends and Bank Holidays from its current daily operation. According to a post on their Facebook page, TfL have said:



This is a huge reduction from what I assume is a 364 day operation to probably under 40 days. Although I'm not from London, I'm down there every couple of months and regularly travel on Tfl tub/train services, and I've never seen anything advertising 'ride on an iconic bus' or similar - I'm sure more mebers of the public would if they knew they could and where.
This service, and another known as the 9H, were started in November 2005, just a month or so before regular Routemaster operation in London ceased on conversion of the 159 to opo. It was, at least in part, a sop to those who were critical of TfL's change in policy under Mayor Ken Livingstone to remove mainstream RM operation. The RMs/RMLs that were used on the 159 were each plastered with ads saying that Routemaster buses were not going from the streets of London as these two 'heritage' routes would still feature the buses. A personal view, but as one who had spent many hours as a kid stood at Crystal -Palace Parade waiting for RM1 to appear on route 2, when it was the sole Routemaster, etc etc, I considered this to be rather disingenuous. When the last trams went in 1952 (and, living in Eltham, I CAN just remember that, though very young) there were posters on the side saying, from memory, 'This week we say goodbye to London' and I feel the RMs on the 159 should have carried much the same message. Now, that doesn't answer your point as to how well the services (the 9H went two or three years ago) were advertised thereafter: I think the most significant factor in their severe truncation was Leon Daniels' vacation of the hot seat as head of London buses a year ago, because he was a champion of them.
 

James H

Member
Joined
25 Jun 2014
Messages
1,098
The fact that the 15H doesn't accept contactless has prevented me from using it on several occasions.
 

Journeyman

Established Member
Joined
16 Apr 2014
Messages
6,295
It's been going for long enough. Only really originally intended to shut up certain people, and provide a bit of a sight for tourists. TfL need to cut costs.

Agreed. There's plenty of opportunities to ride Routemasters at various events anyway. I don't really think it will be missed, and I agree that TfL have bigger fish to fry.
 

Teflon Lettuce

Established Member
Joined
22 Aug 2013
Messages
1,750
Surely the best way of operating a heritage operation would be to invite enthusiast groups to provide vehicles for a skeleton service on Christmas Day... all pay on the bus and all profits going to charity.
 

Max

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Administrator
Joined
8 Jun 2005
Messages
5,457
Location
Cardiff
The fact that the 15H doesn't accept contactless has prevented me from using it on several occasions.

Completely agree with this. I hadn't been aware of this absurdity until I attempted to use it with my partner's dad on their holiday to London. As somebody who doesn't have a paper season or use Oyster on a regular basis, (let's be honest, who does now if they don't have a season or get a railcard discount), I felt quite disgruntled!
 

tbtc

Veteran Member
Joined
16 Dec 2008
Messages
17,882
Location
Reston City Centre
The average net cost (subsidy) per customer on the service is £9.00. This compares to the average net cost of 48p on the main Route 15 and 23p on the network as a whole

Gosh!

That puts things in a little context, I suppose - there must be a lot of rural bus services chopped that required lower passenger subsidies than that (especially as the 15H was a relatively short route).
 

Jordan Adam

Established Member
Joined
12 Sep 2017
Messages
5,526
Location
Aberdeen
I'm surprised there's not the typical lot of people who we all know about crying and protesting about this being the end of the world! I agree with the comment earlier in this thread that it's better to cut something like this rather than an actual vital service.
 

Mikey C

Established Member
Joined
11 Feb 2013
Messages
6,842
I've always thought that the heritage routes were poorly advertised. When tourists see them, do they think they are normal TfL routes or do they assume they're special sightseeing routes?

I occasionally used the 9H when I worked in High St Ken. It was a nice way into the West End. I remember the final day, and how knackered the RM I was on looked! It was "easy" to remove the 9H though as the normal 9 had Borismasters with the open platform (i.e. with the platform supervisor)
 

Andyh82

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2014
Messages
3,525
I would perhaps of reduced it to summer, rather than just summer weekends, as if you are a tourist in London a weekend is no different from a weekday.

In reality how many summer weekends will the service actually be able to be run as advertised due to all the various planned events?

The service is very poorly advertised, and many tourists might not think it is a public service able to be used by normal Oyster card holders. They stand out no more than a pre booked private Routemaster tour bus that you will often see in Central London
 

Tetchytyke

Veteran Member
Joined
12 Sep 2013
Messages
13,305
Location
Isle of Man
I'm amazed it lasted this long after the 9H ended. As Max says, the fact you can't use Contactless on them only makes them less appealing (though IME the conductors are sympathetic and sensible if you have Contactless).

Controversial opinion, but I don't think TfL should be subsidising these museum pieces when they're cutting frequencies elsewhere. Let the tour bus operators have them.
 

Andyh82

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2014
Messages
3,525
In the world of London bus operations, if Stagecoach wanted to take it on commercially what barriers would they face?
 

Robertj21a

On Moderation
Joined
22 Sep 2013
Messages
7,518
In the world of London bus operations, if Stagecoach wanted to take it on commercially what barriers would they face?

They couldn't operate it with the 'heritage' Routemasters as a normal service as the buses don't meet the disability regulations.
 

Shimbleshanks

Member
Joined
2 Jan 2012
Messages
1,020
Location
Purley
I've always thought that the heritage routes were poorly advertised. When tourists see them, do they think they are normal TfL routes or do they assume they're special sightseeing routes?
Yes, quite - especially as TfL have possibly more prime advertising space than anyone else in London - the service could effecitvely have been advertised for free. In my opinion they should be made to advertise it properly and only then take a decision on cutting it back.
 

Busaholic

Veteran Member
Joined
7 Jun 2014
Messages
14,068
In the world of London bus operations, if Stagecoach wanted to take it on commercially what barriers would they face?
I introduced this subject on to another, specialised bus forum, as I thought that might be something Stagecoach would consider, but no-one agreed with me. I certainly don't think it could form part of the TfL bus network, so Oyster cards couldn't be accepted, and an added factor since the original proposal is that Stagecoach no longer operate the 'proper' 15, so that would probably make them less interested.

I'd take the subsidy per passenger figure with a ladle of salt, personally, as it has increased by several hundred per cent according to TfL's figures in two or three years! It's well-known that many passengers on the route try to make payment for their journey and are unable to (no cash fares, no contactless cards, and no ability to either purchase or top-up on Oyster.) TfL, once Peter Hendy and then Leon Daniels had departed, had no advocates left for the 15H, and some might say for buses in central London per se.
 

158756

Established Member
Joined
12 Aug 2014
Messages
1,439
Gosh!

That puts things in a little context, I suppose - there must be a lot of rural bus services chopped that required lower passenger subsidies than that (especially as the 15H was a relatively short route).

it does seem very high. People must be actively avoiding them to have such an extreme difference with the standard 15. Is it the contactless issue, do people not recognise it as a TfL service or what? I suspect even fewer regular passengers will use it when it only operates on tourist days.
 

Andyh82

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2014
Messages
3,525
it does seem very high. People must be actively avoiding them to have such an extreme difference with the standard 15. Is it the contactless issue, do people not recognise it as a TfL service or what? I suspect even fewer regular passengers will use it when it only operates on tourist days.
The 15H is much shorter, much less frequent and has much lower operating hours

Also because it is the same route as a 15, if a real 15 is already on the stop, quite often in my experience the Routemaster will just go past. Very few are specifically waiting for the 15H for it to make a point of pulling in behind, because very few people actually know about it.
 

158756

Established Member
Joined
12 Aug 2014
Messages
1,439
The 15H is much shorter, much less frequent and has much lower operating hours

That should also mean that, before the cost of maintaining a Routemaster, operating costs should be much lower too. If the shortness of route is a problem, that suggests the 15H section isn't any busier than the rest of the 15, which goes with the next point;

Also because it is the same route as a 15, if a real 15 is already on the stop, quite often in my experience the Routemaster will just go past. Very few are specifically waiting for the 15H for it to make a point of pulling in behind, because very few people actually know about it.

that it doesn't sound like it's attempting to provide a genuine public transport service, and as such shouldn't have been funded by TfL to begin with.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
97,784
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
If anything they'd be better off operated by the tour companies, but the tour companies aren't interested.

I'd just get rid. That massive subsidy can't be justified for something like that.
 

700007

Established Member
Joined
6 May 2017
Messages
1,195
Location
Near a bunch of sheds that aren't 66s.
I am sad that the 15H is going however I don't think TfL even tried with this one. I do agree, the subsidy is absolutely crazy, but I think operating a tourist routemaster service has a large potential but TfL did not explore this.

As previously mentioned, TfL should have allowed Contactless payments and I think for this one of bus route should have retained the passenger right to pay by cash as well.

The Routemasters should also be operating a different bus route, not the 15. The 15, as a result of several bus cuts and increasing congestion along the route with barely any attempt to tackle this issue made the route more unattractive to use over the years and also lose its high profile.

Lack of promotion of this bus route meant that most of the public did not know this route ran or that this route was not a tour bus.

I would have put the Routemasters on a bus route like the 88, between Westminster and Regents Park for London Zoo (or Camden Town), with better promotion to the public, more ways to pay for your fare and a less congested route.

Surely a private operator could run the route because as long as it follows an existing bus route that is DDA compliant I believe the route would be granted?
 

James H

Member
Joined
25 Jun 2014
Messages
1,098
I always thought that it was a shame that neither of the heritage RM routes crossed the river.

A Routemaster on, say, Westminster Bridge - you can hardly get a more 'London' image than that.
 

carlberry

Established Member
Joined
19 Dec 2014
Messages
3,169
I am sad that the 15H is going however I don't think TfL even tried with this one. I do agree, the subsidy is absolutely crazy, but I think operating a tourist routemaster service has a large potential but TfL did not explore this.

As previously mentioned, TfL should have allowed Contactless payments and I think for this one of bus route should have retained the passenger right to pay by cash as well.

Surely a private operator could run the route because as long as it follows an existing bus route that is DDA compliant I believe the route would be granted?
It isnt TfL's job to run old buses. Any operator could register it however if it dosent cover it's costs when it's run at normal fares I suspect it'll have no chance once 'excursion' type fares apply.
 

Hadders

Veteran Member
Associate Staff
Senior Fares Advisor
Joined
27 Apr 2011
Messages
13,093
Diamond Geezer wrote a blog about this a couple of weeks ago. Seems it is a popular service but TfL need to make more effort to collect fares.

It strikes me as a removal by stealth.

http://diamondgeezer.blogspot.com/2019/01/route-15h.html?m=1

Route 15H: Trafalgar Square to Tower Hill
London's 5th shortest bus route
Length of journey: 2.36 miles (25 minutes)

Route 15 need not detain us here, being six miles long, but its heritage subset is considerably shorter. This was introduced in 2005 when Routemasters were phased out for accessibility reasons, mainly as a sop to ensure no politician could be accused of withdrawing them completely. Its fellow service on route 9H bit the dust in 2014 so the 15H soldiers on alone, now only every twenty minutes, on the tourist-friendly stretch from Trafalgar Square to the Tower. But a recent plan proposes cutting back the service to summer weekends and bank holidays only, which is basically nothing, after the new Ultra Low Emission Zone takes effect. Come ride soon, before it gets a lot lot harder.

15start.jpg

'Heritage Routemasters operate additional journeys between 0941 and 1841', according to the timetable on the Strand, but wheelchairs cannot be carried. Other than this small red writing there are no clues that an icon of London is about to emerge round the corner from Northumberland Avenue and offer an anachronistic ride for a very reasonable fare. TfL's promotion of this very special service has always been poor. One family definitely know it's coming, and their son beams with delight as it pulls up and they grab the prized front seats. Other tourists suddenly notice, and wander over because the conductor knows to wait for a bit, and before long there are 15 of us on the top deck and a fair few more down below. Ding ding.

Some are here to remember. A retired man in a sensible jacket whips out his iPad for a photo before resting his arm lovingly on the moquette. Others are here because it's what you do in London. A Japanese girl in a bright red coat ensures the lens is trained on her, because it wouldn't be a photograph otherwise, and ends up taking a 90° selfie-panorama. Some are here because they would have caught the ordinary 15 but this turned up instead, and they'll be smiling for the next few stops. But most are here to travel religiously to the end of the route, because nowhere else would they ever get the opportunity. Another 15 passengers have boarded before we reach Aldwych, and numbers only ever rise.

15topdec.jpg

The engine's definitely judderier than on a modern bus, and/or the suspension less effective, but that's part of the appeal. A family of five can't believe their luck when we pull up, the parents looking at each other as if to say shall we, and they do. We pass a row of protesters in tents outside the Royal Courts of Justice, and the net-curtained windows of the Art Deco Daily Express building, and the magnificent facade of Wren's cathedral. You get a much better view from a 1964 vehicle than the hermetically sealed red bubbles rushing the other way. Top deck seats generally fill up from the front backwards, and there are now very few of them left.

And still they come - two more on Ludgate Hill, seven at St Paul's and three on Cannon Street. Admittedly I made my journey at the weekend, but tourists come to London all year round, and I am very impressed by the loadings. I see the London Stone is back in place, and labelled. I see the House of Fraser facing London Bridge closed its doors for good on 29th December. I see security guards sitting alone in echoing receptions beneath shiny towers. And even at the penultimate stop a trio of French tourists board, their brief journey fortuitously extended by a traffic jam at Mincing Lane. On reaching the Tower they look somewhat bemused, there being no automated messages to explain what's going on, but a yell from the conductor confirms yes, this is where everyone has to get off.



By my calculations at least 60 passengers have boarded during our journey, the majority of whom stayed on to the bitter end. But, and here's the rub, AT NO POINT DID THE CONDUCTOR EVER COME UPSTAIRS AND COLLECT ANY FARES. I don't know what he did downstairs, but he never once attempted to climb the stairs and none of us paid a penny for our journeys. The 15H has longstanding issues in that no touchpads are fitted and staff have to use archaic card readers that can only cope with Oyster, not contactless. But by not even attempting to collect fares from those who could have paid, nor registering how many of us were on board, no wonder official figures show this is the 15th least-used bus route in London. Come ride before indifference turns to near-dismissal. It could be the best free ride in town.
 

alex397

Established Member
Joined
6 Oct 2017
Messages
1,551
Location
UK
More proof that TfL are not the amazing organisation that people perceive them to be.

The 15H is ridiculously unadvertised - to see the timetable I've had to look it up on the Londonbusroutes website, basically a website for enthusiasts. For any tourists, there is a tiny note underneath he ordinary 15 timetable mentioning the Heritage Routemasters. It's no wonder it is under-utilised. If properly advertised, this service could have made TFL a profit, and possibly help to subsidise their other services. They could have even charged a premium price for this service - I'm sure most would have been willing to pay it for this service, to ride on a classic London bus.

To reduce this service to summer weekends is surely less efficient. They might as well withdraw it altogether. Vehicles will still have to be maintained, and there will be the cost of having special rotas. What will the Routemaster drivers and conductors be doing when it's not a summer weekend?
 

Andyh82

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2014
Messages
3,525
The report two posts above shows that the income generated is misleading because they aren’t generating all that is there.

Why did they not install an Oyster reader on board somewhere around the rear platform?
 

Dai Corner

Established Member
Joined
20 Jul 2015
Messages
6,337
The report two posts above shows that the income generated is misleading because they aren’t generating all that is there.

Why did they not install an Oyster reader on board somewhere around the rear platform?

Or even enable the conductor to sell souvenir tickets for cash. The full heritage experience!
 

Antman

Established Member
Joined
3 May 2013
Messages
6,842
The fact that the 15H doesn't accept contactless has prevented me from using it on several occasions.

You can still use it, you get a free ride. As others have alluded to advertising of the service is poor to non existent and people are often unsure if it's a regular bus service. It does provide support to the main 15 service at busy times and the running costs of half a dozen Routemasters really are a spit in the ocean in the overall scheme of things.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top