From the strike thread, I think it fits better here:
Wow......some time ago i was actually advocating this approach and got grief on here about it. The idea of " bidding for paths " is one that came up in the Rail 2020 enquiry some time ago. It works very well in the airline industry, though I accept there are some significant differences between rail and air travel. Nonetheless , it does give an opportunity for the smaller business to have a go. WCR taking over the service ( albeit on a temp basis) may prove to be a blessing in disguise longer term.
It could work for InterCity but not really for regional, where integration is more important. Germany seems to do well with a model a bit like London bus operations, though, i.e. bidding for smaller packages of routes.
But as I've said before, I think "Lakes and Furness to Manchester Airport" is a natural service grouping that could easily stand alone from Northern, and would be quite effectively run using a small fleet of bi-modes (Stadler, or 769 if they ever happen). Hourly from the Airport, split and join at Lancaster.