How do you get the sign in screen for public wifi system if the only internet access is via the VPN?
-
Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!
Free WiFi in Standard - Virgin West Coast
- Thread starter Ant158
- Start date
- Status
How do you get the sign in screen for public wifi system if the only internet access is via the VPN?
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R
RailUK Forums
There's various ways of doing it. At my place we use a custom written Windows 10 app, but there are other ways.
SHD
Member
- Joined
- 18 Jul 2012
- Messages
- 459
If no Internet access at all is possible unless the VPN is connected, it may prevent the user to connect to public WiFi networks that require an authentication on a Web portal (and there are many such public WiFi networks), especially when the network logon page is hosted on the private network of the
(Edit: Sorry, had not seen previous messages)
Puffing Devil
Established Member
- Joined
- 11 Apr 2013
- Messages
- 2,766
My experience using Vodafone on MiFi and a Samasung S7 and Note9 has been very poor. All devices seem to struggle to hold a signal at speed, only becoming reliable when we slow for a station. The Faraday cage of the train won't help, either. At least the train WiFi has a better, external aerial. I've also recently had to move to an Exchange email account, which seems unnaturally fussy about a constant connection.
LNER only give you 15 minutes free in standard class.
It's arguable whether that's more or less useful than GWR's 30Mb cap...
d9009alycidon
Member
I used Virgin West Coast to co to Crewe a few weeks ago, on business so first class, on the way down the Wi-fi was fine, no connection issues at all, on the return it was abysmal, the connection kept dropping out (trying to follow progress on Traksy too, most annoying), I mentioned it to the staff and they apologized saying that it had not been upgraded yet, seems some units have better kit fitted
theironroad
Established Member
Well I'm confused now, because I thought it was only 15 mins free but a few people on here are saying that's all free now......
It was 15 minutes about 2 weeks ago.
(at least on the train I was on. If it's changing, I guess they might not all change at once)
londonmidland
Established Member
LNER *should* now have free WiFi on all their trains. Though I don’t know the process of how long it takes to change it across the whole fleet.
It’s been free since around three weeks give or take now.
It’s been free since around three weeks give or take now.
It is a new(ish) supplier - McLaren Applied Technologies.
https://twitter.com/VirginTrains/status/1059411696689782784
The DfT mandates free WiFi in its latest franchise specifications, so this change will have been agreed as part of the ICWC Direct Award extension.
http://www.mynewsdesk.com/uk/virgin...of-passengers-on-its-west-coast-route-2142595
As others have said, EMT is now unusual in still having paid for WiFi in Standard. When (or if?) the new EM franchise is awarded, that will change.
Access is completely free for all passengers in all travel classes on all LNER services operated with WiFi fitted rolling stock.
As an aside, it takes seconds to enable free access when it has hitherto been a paid service.
Indeed, it was normal procedure to disable the paywall on specific services subject to disruption, as a concession to affected passengers.
ATW Alex 101
Established Member
I still remember the days when Coach D on the Super-Voyagers were configured to the first-class WiFi... 
But after the refurbs around 2015-2016 they got shut of that, so free WiFi for all, especially in this day and age, is very welcome news to me. 
But after the refurbs around 2015-2016 they got shut of that, so free WiFi for all, especially in this day and age, is very welcome news to me. The email I had said free WiFi on Pendolinos, and the full Beam offering on Voyagers. My reading of that was that the WiFi on Voyagers would still be chargeable.I still remember the days when Coach D on the Super-Voyagers were configured to the first-class WiFi...
Bletchleyite
Veteran Member
There are ways, as someone else also said, to allow access to only the sign-in page unless connected.
Blinkbonny
Member
- Joined
- 16 Mar 2018
- Messages
- 349
Is it just me, but since the advent of free Wi-Fi on Virgin is it proving impossible to get a service at all?
Last half-dozen journeys for me have resulted in absolutely nothing in either standard or first class.
No point in having free Wi-Fi if nobody can access it.
Last half-dozen journeys for me have resulted in absolutely nothing in either standard or first class.
No point in having free Wi-Fi if nobody can access it.
paddington
Member
- Joined
- 19 Feb 2013
- Messages
- 964
I took about 10 different VTWC trains in April. Out of these, I received a good wifi service on one train. On the others, my device couldn't even connect, much less get to a sign-in page.
I was very pleased with the free wifi on XC and WMT - it made standing on the packed XC trains a bit more bearable. The sign-in page for WMT is annoying, but at least it accepts the shortest possible email ([email protected])
I was very pleased with the free wifi on XC and WMT - it made standing on the packed XC trains a bit more bearable. The sign-in page for WMT is annoying, but at least it accepts the shortest possible email ([email protected])
LNW-GW Joint
Veteran Member
Couldn't connect to VT free wifi yesterday out of Liverpool.
Connects to wifi but can't load even the BBC web site.
What is even more galling is the repeated fawning announcement of how great it is.
Connects to wifi but can't load even the BBC web site.
What is even more galling is the repeated fawning announcement of how great it is.
Probably because a load of passengers in standard have just started sharing all the bandwidth on the backhaul
It was always going to happen. There's only limited bandwidth and now more people are using it.
What's more, people who use VPNs are able to access services that are meant to be restricted, putting a further drain on limited resources.
What's more, people who use VPNs are able to access services that are meant to be restricted, putting a further drain on limited resources.
Bletchleyite
Veteran Member
It doesn't seem to be a problem on other TOCs. So have VT failed to put the required infrastructure in place?
Puffing Devil
Established Member
- Joined
- 11 Apr 2013
- Messages
- 2,766
Virgin seem to have blocked by my company and private VPN.
The service is poor though - however getting any sort of signal into a train filled with electrical noise and rattling through the countryside at 125mph is a feat in itself.
3rd rail land
Member
I traveled on 2 VTWC Voyagers in April and I gave up on the WiFi in standard. It repeatedly failed to connect. Seems like I am not the only one with this issue.
In the end I just used 4G. The coverage was very good and I always have plenty of spare data so no chance of hitting my cap.
As others have said its is never going to be much good if you give more people free access to WiFi but don't improve the bandwidth sufficiently to handle the increased user base.
Ultimately Virgin won't lose any revenue over this and it meets what I presume is a franchise commitment. If you need to go from A to B and VTWC operates the route connecting those 2 stations you can't exactly boycott them in favour of another toc. Perhaps by offering poor WiFi in standard they hope people will opt for 1st class with better connectivity? Or is it the same WiFi shared across the entire train?
In the end I just used 4G. The coverage was very good and I always have plenty of spare data so no chance of hitting my cap.
As others have said its is never going to be much good if you give more people free access to WiFi but don't improve the bandwidth sufficiently to handle the increased user base.
Ultimately Virgin won't lose any revenue over this and it meets what I presume is a franchise commitment. If you need to go from A to B and VTWC operates the route connecting those 2 stations you can't exactly boycott them in favour of another toc. Perhaps by offering poor WiFi in standard they hope people will opt for 1st class with better connectivity? Or is it the same WiFi shared across the entire train?
Last edited:
There's only so much they can do. They already use multiple SIMs but I assume to add more capacity would require more hardware. Plus the data SIMs aren't free.
Plus you're more likely getting business users and tourists and the like wanting Wi-Fi on an Intercity service than use Wi-Fi on a suburban commuter route.
paddington
Member
- Joined
- 19 Feb 2013
- Messages
- 964
Even when it was not free for all in Std and I was in 1st, the wifi experience was variable - mabye a third of the time it worked great, mostly it was slow but usable, and sometimes it was just turned off and the train managers would simply say they tried but couldn't get it restarted
Most people don't really have any other option.
Admittedly there are some stations (like Sheffield) that you could travel to another and use another operator for London, but I seriously can't see "the droves" doing that when there's a direct service.
I'd say wifi on the move is slowly on the way out.
Nobody wants to sort out some sort of reliable fast system, so we're left with different experiences all over the shop. All this at a time where data is king on mobile contracts - my contract is 34Gb for £15 a month. I'll never use more than about 5Gb a month, much less on average.
Just like Fibre internet.
The cost of putting it in is expensive (BT fibre doesn't really count), so in the end it'll be long range wifi / mobile networks that'll replace a physical line into the house.
Nobody wants to sort out some sort of reliable fast system, so we're left with different experiences all over the shop. All this at a time where data is king on mobile contracts - my contract is 34Gb for £15 a month. I'll never use more than about 5Gb a month, much less on average.
Just like Fibre internet.
The cost of putting it in is expensive (BT fibre doesn't really count), so in the end it'll be long range wifi / mobile networks that'll replace a physical line into the house.
benbristow
Member
- Joined
- 5 Dec 2017
- Messages
- 94
Can you not run the VPN through port 443 (same as HTTPS)? Should get around it.
Psiphon, while not a true VPN, will usually find its way through any restrictions on free WiFi. Then, if you need a different/corporate VPN, you can connect that over the top.
It's now government policy that all new franchises have to offer free basic wifi to all passengers, so that should change when the franchise changes
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/free-wi-fi-to-help-rail-commuters-stay-connected
Though there was some clarification, and apparently it only needs to be 1Mbps, which is very slow
https://www.theguardian.com/busines...twork-fast-cheap-wi-fi-trains-internet-access
Last edited by a moderator:
- Status