• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Caledonian Sleeper

185143

185143

Established Member
Joined
3 Mar 2013
Messages
4,518
I've just booked (Yes, I know...) the Highlander for 4th August.

The seating plan is as per the Mk2s... yet my booking for July, made around a month ago, definately showed an Mk5 layout.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20190626-100010.jpg
    Screenshot_20190626-100010.jpg
    578.9 KB · Views: 82
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

R

RLBH

Member
Joined
17 May 2018
Messages
962
Bletchleyite said:
To be fair with a very short train on a railway designed for 10x26m does make it easier for them to provide lounge and seating coach capacity than CS. The seats don't even require reservations, as there is far more capacity than is ever likely to be needed on the overnight section, and adding another Mk3 if they did need to wouldn't make the train too long for Paddington.

The Riviera is a charming little operation, but it's a much simpler one with far fewer limitations and constraints than CS.
Click to expand...
The equivalent for Caledonian Sleeper would be running five trains a night each way. I don't believe for one moment that they would do that, even if the Train Gods gifted them the rolling stock and a couple of spare platforms at Euston. The operating costs would be ludicrous.
 
MisterT

MisterT

Member
Joined
12 Oct 2014
Messages
405
Location
The Netherlands
I booked the sleeper from Fort William to London for August 28 and just got an e-mail stating that it won't run with the new Mk5 coaches, but with the old ones, and that I can get a £20 refund, or a full cancellation, or change my reservation to a different date:

Good morning

We are contacting you regarding your journey booked with us for travel on our Highland services in the coming weeks.

Unfortunately, we are very sorry to have to inform you that due to a delay in the availability of our new trains, we will not be able to operate our new fleet on your journey. We recognise that this is disappointing news and we apologise for this.

We will instead, be running our current trains and can therefore still ensure you get to your destination and experience our excellent levels of service and hospitality on board.

Our decision to put back the introduction by a few weeks has been taken to allow CAF, the manufacturer, to complete the further work required on the carriages to ensure that they are fit for purpose to be accepted into service. This is intended to ensure that when they do enter service our guests have the best possible experience. We will be confirming a new date for introducing our new trains on our Highland routes as soon as possible.

If you still want to travel with us on your original booking date, you don’t need to do anything else. Your booking will be automatically updated to an alternative accommodation type on our current trains, and the tickets you have remain valid for your journey. You do not require replacement tickets.

Your reservation will be automatically transferred to a room on our current train. We will automatically refund you £20 per room.

Please be aware all rooms will be configured with both beds made up. However you will still receive the First Class amenities that your ticket offers, including complimentary breakfast, Arran toiletries, First Class Lounge access and priority access to the Lounge Car.

However, we understand if you wish to change or cancel your journey with us. If this is the case, we have two options available:

  1. You can cancel your booking and we will give you a full refund, even if you did not book a flexible ticket.
  2. We can re-book you on to a service when our new trains are in operation. Again, this option is available for holders of both fixed and flexible tickets.
Click to expand...

Edit: and that refund is for the Club Room supplement only.
 
Last edited:
MylesHSG

MylesHSG

Member
Joined
3 Oct 2016
Messages
185
MisterT said:
I booked the sleeper from Fort William to London for August 28 and just got an e-mail stating that it won't run with the new Mk5 coaches, but with the old ones, and that I can get a £20 refund, or a full cancellation, or change my reservation to a different date:
Click to expand...

Probably a good decision they've made there. Better to have a few disappointed passengers who wanted the new stock than go ahead with new stock that can't be relied upon.
 
S

Steggets

New Member
Joined
29 Mar 2015
Messages
4
MisterT said:
I booked the sleeper from Fort William to London for August 28 and just got an e-mail stating that it won't run with the new Mk5 coaches, but with the old ones, and that I can get a £20 refund, or a full cancellation, or change my reservation to a different date:
Click to expand...

The email I have received for London to Aberdeen in a club room mid-July states I'm getting a third refunded plus £20 per room.

I'm rather glad they have made the decision to use the old stock.
 
MisterT

MisterT

Member
Joined
12 Oct 2014
Messages
405
Location
The Netherlands
I have only a supplemental ticket for the Club room (I already have a 1st class ticket), so that's where my £20 comes from, I think. It's 1/5 of the total supplement cost, so that's reasonable in my opinion. I mean, the only difference for me is that I don't have my own en suite.
 
Last edited:
L

Leisurefirst

Member
Joined
23 Apr 2013
Messages
412
I too have email about my two September journeys, (in seats so not so much of an issue).
Disappointed but as has been said, rather I got there.
Cancelling and day trains not an option for me as I will either miss two days or have to increase my accommodation spend massively.
Not having much luck with CS.
2016 journey bussed from Waverley to FW due to ScotRail strike.
2018 journey old stock instead of new.
(Mind did treat us to 1st instead of seats as a result coming back and got to sample lounge and meal!)
2019 same again now.
Oh well...
 
M

marcolau

New Member
Joined
9 Apr 2016
Messages
4
If you booked direct with CS, you will receive something different, note the highlighted words in bold; I planned to travel on 29 Sep (Sun), booked 1st Class (old system):

Good morning

We are contacting you regarding your journey booked with us for travel on our Highland services in the coming weeks.

Unfortunately, we are very sorry to have to inform you that due to a delay in the availability of our new trains, we will not be able to operate our new fleet on your journey. We recognise that this is disappointing news and we apologise for this.

We will instead, be running our current trains and can therefore still ensure you get to your destination and experience our excellent levels of service and hospitality on board.

Our decision to put back the introduction by a few weeks has been taken to allow CAF, the manufacturer, to complete the further work required on the carriages to ensure that they are fit for purpose to be accepted into service. This is intended to ensure that when they do enter service our guests have the best possible experience. We will be confirming a new date for introducing our new trains on our Highland routes as soon as possible.

If you still want to travel with us on your original booking date, you don’t need to do anything else. Your booking will be automatically updated to an alternative accommodation type on our current trains, and the tickets you have remain valid for your journey. You do not require replacement tickets.

Your reservation will be automatically transferred to a room on our current train. We will automatically refund you one third of what you have paid plus £20 per room.

Please be aware all rooms will be configured with both beds made up. However you will still receive the First Class amenities that your ticket offers, including complimentary breakfast, Arran toiletries, First Class Lounge access and priority access to the Lounge Car.

However, we understand if you wish to change or cancel your journey with us. If this is the case, we have two options available:

  1. You can cancel your booking and we will give you a full refund, even if you did not book a flexible ticket.
  2. We can re-book you on to a service when our new trains are in operation. Again, this option is available for holders of both fixed and flexible tickets.
Click to expand...

Guess the new train introduction has been delayed significantly...
 
R

RochdalePioneers

Member
Joined
2 Jan 2009
Messages
517
I have just received an email from Serco apologising that my booked sleeper from Inverness to London will now be in Mk3s due to a delay in introduction of the Mk5s:

"Our decision to put back the introduction by a few weeks has been taken to allow CAF, the manufacturer, to complete the further work required on the carriages to ensure that they are fit for purpose to be accepted into service. This is intended to ensure that when they do enter service our guests have the best possible experience. We will be confirming a new date for introducing our new trains on our Highland routes as soon as possible."

My journey is Wednesday 24th July...
 
S

side effect

Member
Joined
20 Jul 2015
Messages
81
My son will be delighted when I tell him the news. He was checking every day to see if he could be on the last ever old highlander that was due on 7th July.

I will text him once he's home from school.
 
R

RochdalePioneers

Member
Joined
2 Jan 2009
Messages
517
Have just spotted the other posts - they're delaying the introduction on the Highlander for a good while then!

Supposedly TPE mess room gossip has it that their Mk5 fleet is going into warm storage - the same for Caledonian Sleeper?
 
MrEd

MrEd

Member
Joined
13 Jan 2019
Messages
587
Have they given a new date for the introduction of Mk5s on the Highlander, or is it delayed indefinitely? Clearly they won’t be ready even in September. Would early October perhaps be an achievable introduction date? It’s perhaps best not to rush their introduction and to make sure that they’re working reliably.
 
B

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
97,873
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
MrEd said:
Have they given a new date for the introduction of Mk5s on the Highlander, or is it delayed indefinitely? Clearly they won’t be ready even in September. Would early October perhaps be an achievable introduction date? It’s perhaps best not to rush their introduction and to make sure that they’re working reliably.
Click to expand...

They would make themselves look less stupid if they didn't give a date.
 
N

nickswift99

Member
Joined
7 Apr 2013
Messages
273
When's the next significant date in terms of rolling stock exams/maintenance? How far out can the Mk 5 sets go before there start to be operational/financial issues?
 
E

Eddd

Member
Joined
8 Apr 2018
Messages
54
Glad to receive my email and text as it lifts my confidence that I'll be notified of any last-minute problems, not that I'm expecting a phone signal at Corrour.

I'm also not too disappointed with a final trip in the old stock, though I thought I did that last year, and a first for my baby daughter.
 
G

GarethC

Member
Joined
22 Aug 2014
Messages
68
I wonder whether someone has been reading this thread, I'm booked on the Highlander on 24th July and have had the email and a text message advising of the change. I booked directly with CS.

Classic Room is just the £20 refund per room.

As with other responses it looks like a positive move to take a bit of control of the situation.
 
E

Essexman

Established Member
Joined
15 Mar 2011
Messages
1,380
U

USRailFan

Member
Joined
2 May 2011
Messages
343
Location
Norway
Rumours have it that the Viewliners CAF are making for Amtrak in the US, and which are extremely delayed (we are talking years) have been sold to Canada without running a single mile on US rails... I think the faster Serco and TPE can get out of this deal, the better.
 
J

jagardner1984

Member
Joined
11 May 2008
Messages
675
I do think this is pragmatic decision and the correct one.

I also think it’s good both Serco and Transport Scotland’s statements stick the boot into CAF’s incompetence here. (I know both aren’t exactly blameless in all this).

Presumably, whatever the next date that’s been given is, the real worry will be not having a complete reliable Mk5 operation before the end of 2019 and the resulting PRM implications.
 
M

matacaster

On Moderation
Joined
19 Jan 2013
Messages
1,603
Perhaps a way forward to ensure sleeper trains are fit for purpose is for there to be a responsibility on the TOC managing director to spend a complete week travelling satisfactorily overnight aboard such train before it can be inflicted on the poor travelling public. One suspects the trains would not have been introduced had this been a feature of the licence to operate them.

A big problem with all recent new fleet introductions appears to have been that the testing is done by people down the food chain and by the time its been raised to director level, there are hardly any issues. Brunel would have gone and had a look himself!
 
DelW

DelW

Established Member
Joined
15 Jan 2015
Messages
3,874
If the old stock is going to have to last another 2 - 3 months (at least?) in peak season, CS need to improve the reliability of the mk2 lounge cars. A combination of a locked-out (or missing) lounge car, with cabins that have both bunks made up even for single occupancy, wouldn't provide anywhere comfortable to sit for a 12-hour journey.
 
MisterT

MisterT

Member
Joined
12 Oct 2014
Messages
405
Location
The Netherlands
USRailFan said:
Rumours have it that the Viewliners CAF are making for Amtrak in the US, and which are extremely delayed (we are talking years) have been sold to Canada without running a single mile on US rails... I think the faster Serco and TPE can get out of this deal, the better.
Click to expand...
Weird, I must have been imagining things then when I was on a CAF built Viewliner diner coach last year :E. From what I heard from the staff, the coaches simply do their job, but the ride quality is worse than the previous generation.
 
Last edited:
DelW

DelW

Established Member
Joined
15 Jan 2015
Messages
3,874
USRailFan said:
Rumours have it that the Viewliners CAF are making for Amtrak in the US, and which are extremely delayed (we are talking years) have been sold to Canada without running a single mile on US rails... I think the faster Serco and TPE can get out of this deal, the better.
Click to expand...
A bit off-topic here, but AIUI at least some of the Viewliner 2 problems stem from changes in Amtrak management and policy as well as from CAF's delayed delivery. The previous regime ordered Viewliner diners, but by the time they arrived, the new boss was cutting back on-train catering to cold or microwaved airline style meals, and the new diners went into storage.

The provision of new passenger stock in the US is if anything in even more disarray than here. The traditional suppliers (Pullman, Budd) have long since gone bust, as have successors like MK and Colorado Railcar. Talgo were left in financial straits when Milwaukee ordered sets that they then decided they didn't want and wouldn't pay for. Nippon Sharyo has been unable to get its proposed (and ordered) bi-levels through structural testing, and they have been replaced by a new order for single-level cars instead.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Top