• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Which end (and carriage) of the train do you like to sit the most?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mitchell Hurd

On Moderation
Joined
28 Oct 2017
Messages
1,646
Hello everyone. I thought I'd start this thread to see who likes to sit where and which carriage the most.

On the GWR Class 387's (haven't been on other 387's), my favourite seat is the window seat (there's one next to it) behind the disabled toilet across / opposite the wheelchair spaces. They're forward facing on London services (they have been the last few anyway). There's plenty of legroom at this table seat with no seats opposite your feet!

On the Class 80x trains, for some reason I always like it when I'm given a seat in Coach B after reserving a seat on GWR's website. This is when booking a seat in Standard Class.

If only GWR provided a seating layout when you reserve a seat like a few other TOC's do, I'll aim for a window table seat in Coach B if I go in Standard Class. Same with the LNER Azumas (haven't been on an LNER one yet) if I'm travelling for a journey long enough to possibly require the toilet facilities. This is because the disabled toilet is in Coach A which is bigger than the small ones.

On XC HST's, I particularly like the fact that in the Quiet Coach (G), theres a table seat at the Guards Van end of the passenger area. I'm considering booking one of these window table seats for my first trip to Scotland (Edinburgh), providing I don't have a big suitcase of course! When I do my second First Class trip in a XC HST, I'll try and aim for seat number 40 in Coach A which is a single seat at the power car end facing it.

Another area of the HST's I like is the table seat opposite the luggage rack at the end of coaches C, D, E and F facing towards First Class. The one in Coach F is another one too - it's roughly near the steps at Birmingham New Street where say platform 9A is.

On the XC 170's, I prefer seat number A50 (probably because it's on the "left" hand side). Plus if you're needing the toilet facilities right near it, you don't have to twist your head round to see if it's free or not. Plus, the great thing about commuter trains with tables like the 170's is the table seat is right by the doors compared to trains with end doors (InterCity basically).
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

xotGD

Established Member
Joined
4 Feb 2017
Messages
6,078
Right behind the loco, of course!

Bizarre that this is considered to be the Quiet Coach on Chiltern with a 68 thrashing away just in front.
 

hexagon789

Veteran Member
Joined
2 Sep 2016
Messages
15,775
Location
Glasgow
Right behind the loco, of course!

Bizarre that this is considered to be the Quiet Coach on Chiltern with a 68 thrashing away just in front.

There's quite a few loco-hauled trains where the Quiet Coach is next to the motive power!
 

lxfe_mxtterz

Member
Joined
3 Mar 2018
Messages
820
Location
Sarahdale (West of Emmerdale)
If I'm travelling First Class with Virgin Trains, I always try to reserve a seat in Coach K as I find it to be especially cosy (probably due to how small it is). I have once, however, been denied travel in Coach K (even though my reservation ticket blatantly stated my seat in "Coach K") when a member of train crew came up with the excuse that "tables are larger" in other coaches. Even after being informed that I was reserved in Coach K and "table size" wasn't an issue for me, he insisted that I go and find another unreserved seat in a different coach.

On other trains, I generally enjoy sitting anywhere that's in front of a divider (i.e. with my back facing the divider). I don't know why this is but I find it much more pleasant to travel in (probably because it feels, to a certain extent, private?)
 

Mag_seven

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Global Moderator
Joined
1 Sep 2014
Messages
10,024
Location
here to eternity
I have once, however, been denied travel in Coach K (even though my reservation ticket blatantly stated my seat in "Coach K") when a member of train crew came up with the excuse that "tables are larger" in other coaches. Even after being informed that I was reserved in Coach K and "table size" wasn't an issue for me, he insisted that I go and find another unreserved seat in a different coach.

Was this recently? If it was I am astounded that this behaviour from Virgin Trains on train staff is still being tolerated. Coach K is for fare paying passengers just like any other coach - it is not their private common room!
 

lxfe_mxtterz

Member
Joined
3 Mar 2018
Messages
820
Location
Sarahdale (West of Emmerdale)
Was this recently? If it was I am astounded that this behaviour from Virgin Trains on train staff is still being tolerated. Coach K is for fare paying passengers just like any other coach - it is not their private common room!
No, this was actually quite some time ago now - I'd say a few months. I've seen lots of accounts on this website about the recurring "Coach K conflict", but this was the only time I've ever experienced such a thing. After all, the Virgin Trains website does give you the option to choose your seat when you book!
 

EssexGonzo

Member
Joined
9 May 2012
Messages
636
For my 6 to 10 journeys per week, the answer has to be:

a) Morning: wherever I have the best chance of finding a seat! This is generally in coaches 10 or 11 of a 12-coach train.
b) Evening: Front coach as it's closest to the station steps!

Commuting practicalities rather than long distance comfort.
 

ValleyLines142

Established Member
Joined
25 Jul 2011
Messages
6,850
Location
Gloucester
I always aim to sit on the right hand side facing forward, so that I can spot other units in the opposite direction!

On most trains I always aim for priority seats as I'm just shy of 6ft 5.
 

palmersears

Established Member
Joined
20 Sep 2011
Messages
1,485
On the morning commute it's by the front doors of the rear Pacer (or whichever unit the Northern Random Unit Generator throws up) as that then gives me a quick run up the stairs at Piccadilly to get the 195 from platform 14. I tend to aim for the front of this, given most folk are too idle to walk down the platform, but I've yet to fully work out the best seat on a 195, so this might change. Usually left hand side if I can, to see if I can spot anything new on Edge Hill depot as we pass.

Return journey is by the rear doors of the middle coach of the 185s, again for a quick exit via the stairs at Victoria, then usually the front of the 142 at Piccadilly so I can pop out the side gate at Marple and beat all the traffic out of the car park.

If I'm on a 390 to/from Euston then usually a priority airline seat, but not overly fussed, providing it's on the left going down as that gives decent views of sidings and yards that are more interesting than t'other side!
 

Peter Mugridge

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Apr 2010
Messages
14,817
Location
Epsom
Forward facing, right hand side normally, although southbound on the WCML would generally be the left hand side ( for the Wembley - Willesden complex, you see... ). Within the carriage, I like to try to be at the back end, primarily because I like the "tube" effect of looking down the while length of the carriage but also because I enjoy the bumpier ride from being over the wheels.

Which carriage within the train, however... completely variable and determined more by the likely seat availability than anything else.
 

185143

Established Member
Joined
3 Mar 2013
Messages
4,506
If I'm travelling First Class with Virgin Trains, I always try to reserve a seat in Coach K as I find it to be especially cosy (probably due to how small it is). I have once, however, been denied travel in Coach K (even though my reservation ticket blatantly stated my seat in "Coach K") when a member of train crew came up with the excuse that "tables are larger" in other coaches. Even after being informed that I was reserved in Coach K and "table size" wasn't an issue for me, he insisted that I go and find another unreserved seat in a different coach.

On other trains, I generally enjoy sitting anywhere that's in front of a divider (i.e. with my back facing the divider). I don't know why this is but I find it much more pleasant to travel in (probably because it feels, to a certain extent, private?)
Oh for fu... that's one of the most ridiculous things I've seen on here yet!
 

bramling

Veteran Member
Joined
5 Mar 2012
Messages
17,754
Location
Hertfordshire / Teesdale
Hello everyone. I thought I'd start this thread to see who likes to sit where and which carriage the most.

On the GWR Class 387's (haven't been on other 387's), my favourite seat is the window seat (there's one next to it) behind the disabled toilet across / opposite the wheelchair spaces. They're forward facing on London services (they have been the last few anyway). There's plenty of legroom at this table seat with no seats opposite your feet!

On the Class 80x trains, for some reason I always like it when I'm given a seat in Coach B after reserving a seat on GWR's website. This is when booking a seat in Standard Class.

If only GWR provided a seating layout when you reserve a seat like a few other TOC's do, I'll aim for a window table seat in Coach B if I go in Standard Class. Same with the LNER Azumas (haven't been on an LNER one yet) if I'm travelling for a journey long enough to possibly require the toilet facilities. This is because the disabled toilet is in Coach A which is bigger than the small ones.

On XC HST's, I particularly like the fact that in the Quiet Coach (G), theres a table seat at the Guards Van end of the passenger area. I'm considering booking one of these window table seats for my first trip to Scotland (Edinburgh), providing I don't have a big suitcase of course! When I do my second First Class trip in a XC HST, I'll try and aim for seat number 40 in Coach A which is a single seat at the power car end facing it.

Another area of the HST's I like is the table seat opposite the luggage rack at the end of coaches C, D, E and F facing towards First Class. The one in Coach F is another one too - it's roughly near the steps at Birmingham New Street where say platform 9A is.

On the XC 170's, I prefer seat number A50 (probably because it's on the "left" hand side). Plus if you're needing the toilet facilities right near it, you don't have to twist your head round to see if it's free or not. Plus, the great thing about commuter trains with tables like the 170's is the table seat is right by the doors compared to trains with end doors (InterCity basically).

I always very much prefer to sit facing forwards, and for some reason I always feel much more comfortable on the right-hand side - which I can only put down to being right-handed.

Also prefer to be at the end of a vehicle simply as it marginally reduces the chances of having people around, which in turn reduces the chances of undesirabilities like a screaming baby nearby!
 

St Rollox

Member
Joined
2 Jun 2013
Messages
650
Depends on which station i'm getting off and which mood i'm in.
Is the first carriage near the exit at my destination?
Or do i want the crowd to leave first?
Do i want a table to do the crossword?
Have i drunk too much tea?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top