• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Caledonian Sleeper

trebor79

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2018
Messages
4,445
Again... power that could be used elsewhere in place of fossil fuel derived power, if the WCML wasn't using it. No power is really zero carbon until all of our power is zero carbon.
At night, when demand is lowest it's probably actually helpful to be pulling a few MW out of the grid to avoid wind turbines having to be switched off.
And it is zero carbon if that's the source of the power Network Rail are buying. To use an analogy, I don't accuse my wife of pretending to be vegetarian because I eat meat. "No one's vegetarian until everyone's vegetarian so you might as well have a bacon sarnie love" would be absurd.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Lozzy0603

Member
Joined
3 May 2016
Messages
63
Did a Class 91 on the lowland sleeper 1M11 cause a de-wirement at Kensel Green tunnel east portal this morning on the UF?
 

Brissle Girl

Established Member
Joined
17 Jul 2018
Messages
2,619
And it is zero carbon if that's the source of the power Network Rail are buying. To use an analogy, I don't accuse my wife of pretending to be vegetarian because I eat meat. "No one's vegetarian until everyone's vegetarian so you might as well have a bacon sarnie love" would be absurd.
That’s not the same at all. At any point in time the country needs a given amount of electricity. How the sale of that power is divvied up between it’s sources is purely a paper exercise.
 

Merle Haggard

Established Member
Joined
20 Oct 2019
Messages
1,979
Location
Northampton
Did a Class 91 on the lowland sleeper 1M11 cause a de-wirement at Kensel Green tunnel east portal this morning on the UF?
According to O T T Maps, (11.15) 1M11 now 5M11 but still in the same position (UF just North of Queen's Park) that it has occupied since around 0645. Interestingly, DS now shown as blocked, which might be bad news for the trains standing on the DS immediately south of this point (DF shown as blocked for some time).
 

sprinterguy

Established Member
Joined
4 Mar 2010
Messages
11,060
Location
Macclesfield
Did a Class 91 on the lowland sleeper 1M11 cause a de-wirement at Kensel Green tunnel east portal this morning on the UF?
Mentioned on the previous page in this post here:
https://www.railforums.co.uk/threads/caledonian-sleeper.176365/page-179#post-4269332
Another day, another delay for the sleeper, 1M11 has come to a stand near Queen’s Park, passed it on another train and it’s got its pantograph down. Damage to overheads is being said on National Rail
With a photo from Twitter of the damaged class 92 here:
https://www.railforums.co.uk/threads/caledonian-sleeper.176365/page-179#post-4269514
 

LeylandLen

Member
Joined
28 Oct 2013
Messages
779
Location
Leyland Lancs
https://twitter.com/NetworkRailEUS/status/1190185978998251520/photo/1
LNR has just tweeted a photo of the damaged windscreen of the 92:
https://twitter.com/LNRailway/status/1190201640311312385

View attachment 69990
It appears , from twitter, that passengers have been taken of 1M11 outside Euston (#Kensal Green ) but without luggage,so how will the luggage be re-united with its owner ? Seems a bit hard on anyone planning to take an early flight out of London or catch early Eurostar ..
 

Lozzy0603

Member
Joined
3 May 2016
Messages
63
2!!! 2.... 2 :oops: Would be truly incredible if a Class 91 pulling a Caledonian Sleeper came off the wires on the WCML. That would raise a number of questions.
 

BRX

Established Member
Joined
20 Oct 2008
Messages
3,629
And it is zero carbon if that's the source of the power Network Rail are buying. To use an analogy, I don't accuse my wife of pretending to be vegetarian because I eat meat. "No one's vegetarian until everyone's vegetarian so you might as well have a bacon sarnie love" would be absurd.
The correct analogy would involve a finite supply of vegetarian food. Let's say you and your wife are in Greggs and there are two meat sausage rolls and one veggie one. The person behind you in the queue would prefer a veggie one. 2/3 of you would potentially go veggie but only 1/3 of you can. In terms of reducing meat consumption overall, it doesn't make any difference what your wife chooses.
 

side effect

Member
Joined
20 Jul 2015
Messages
81

theironroad

Established Member
Joined
21 Nov 2014
Messages
3,697
Location
London
Yes, albeit a bit stiffly on Monday morning!

To be fair I’ve done it more often by day train on the way up - train north after work, either a lift or late hire car to ‘base camp’ that night, or overnight in Glasgow or Edinburgh and an early hire car straight to the hills. However the late flights back from Glasgow, Edinburgh and Inverness are terribly convenient, usually cheap, and have me in my own bed well before midnight Sunday.

I’ve done this about a dozen times. I have also tried the sleeper (new and old) for the journey north, and it gives little if any extra time on the hills, and has the disadvantage of a day on the hills feeling half asleep, which isn’t necessarily a good idea.


A few years back , I'd quite often take the lowlander north to Glasgow in a berth , rent a car drive to rowardennan , do Ben Lomond and take the sleeper back that night. Fair to say I slept much better on the return leg..
 

Lee_Again

Member
Joined
29 Sep 2007
Messages
646
Location
Stevenage
Railtours seem to be a 1000 mile round trip without the benefit of the exercise therefore need to be immediately banned.

By that logic, all return tickets should be banned.

I find all this talk about travelling and the environment rather pointless. And until the government ban all private jets, luxury yachts, anything other than economy seats in trains/planes, sports cars etc. etc. I shall continue to travel when and where I like.
 

Lozzy0603

Member
Joined
3 May 2016
Messages
63
The Mk5 set is now in Euston 13 being unloaded of belongings. Front is being hooked up to a new Class 92.
Don't know where the damaged 92 has gone.
Up fast is still out. :'(
 
Last edited:

cb a1

Member
Joined
9 Mar 2015
Messages
352
Id guess that you don't fly very often. As someone who commuted from Garelochead to kent for 3 years id much rather go through security at Glasgow than have to do a cross London connection with luggage. thats before your train gets later and later coming down the WCMl effectively missing your last connection in London. Trying to get assistance from the various rail companies for the last 65 miles is almost impossible you just get fobbed off although you usually do get you money back eventually.
If I commuted regularly from Garelochead to Kent maybe I'd prefer flying.
For my usual trips to London though, I have flown before but as it's a walk to station in my home city, walk to event in London, and walk to office in Glasgow that is so much easier than taxi to airport, fly to London, tube or train into London, walk to event and reverse. Plus I miss out on the social side of things when down in London if I'm flying back.
 

trebor79

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2018
Messages
4,445
The correct analogy would involve a finite supply of vegetarian food. Let's say you and your wife are in Greggs and there are two meat sausage rolls and one veggie one. The person behind you in the queue would prefer a veggie one. 2/3 of you would potentially go veggie but only 1/3 of you can. In terms of reducing meat consumption overall, it doesn't make any difference what your wife chooses.
The supply of food is no more finite than the supply of electricity. Need more food, grow more food. Need more power, build more power stations.
Anyway, I fear we will get knuckle-rapped if we continue to stray off topic. Suffice to say I believe travel by Caledonian Sleeper to be a very low carbon way to travel.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
97,784
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
And I’m not sure a sleeper train with its low density, (particularly if single occupied cabins) is as carbon efficient as one might intuitively think a train service is.

But then your argument is to withdraw the service, not to discourage specific uses of it. The carbon emitted would barely be different between it running empty or full.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
97,784
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"

They've already missed them anyway. It's probably better sitting in Euston waiting for it (at least you can go to the pub) than on a stuck train in a tunnel with no power.
 

Brissle Girl

Established Member
Joined
17 Jul 2018
Messages
2,619
Again... power that could be used elsewhere in place of fossil fuel derived power, if the WCML wasn't using it. No power is really zero carbon until all of our power is zero carbon.

I agree with @Brissle Girl - anyone seriously wanting to reduce their impact should probably think twice about travelling that large distance just for a day or two. Just like those European weekend city breaks by air. It's not saying that no-one should ever do anything - just to be conscious of the impact of what we do do, and not to pretend that using the sleeper in this way has no impact, even if (hopefully) it's better than flying (and it would be great to know what the real numbers are).

Spot on. That was exactly my thinking. By the way, I’m not a carbon footprint saint myself, and am not advocating a complete cessation of leisure activities. But maybe we all need to think before popping off for a long return trip at the weekend and thus (in aggregate with others of similar minds) aggravating growth in our carbon footprint.
 

Bassman

Member
Joined
14 Dec 2018
Messages
79
whttps://www.railforums.co.uk/threads/how-green-are-caledonian-sleeper-stock.181973/

as a thread discussing the carbon footprint of the sleeper previously

Personal choices to reduce carbon footprint are I believe a matter for individual conscience.

However government policies should be strategic and towards carbon neutral : tax and not subsidise heavy CO2 use e.g. air travel, luxury holidays around the world, etc. : invest in rail travel and make better use of overnight rail travel to make best use of the network.
 

Grumpy Git

On Moderation
Joined
13 Oct 2019
Messages
2,135
Location
Liverpool
Not sure if it has been mentioned before, but there were three Caledonian Sleeper carriages at the back of Crewe station last night, (by what would have been the furthest platform back in the day by the rear entrance).
 

Leisurefirst

Member
Joined
23 Apr 2013
Messages
409
Looking forward to my first Lowlander journey and first on the new stock (have done the Highlander in the old stock a few times mostly in seats).
Any pair of seats offering the best leg room and or worst to avoid please?
I know certainly there were ones to avoid in the past!
Was thinking about 11B & C as no-one in front but is the wall there more of a hindrance?
 

Kite159

Veteran Member
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
19,239
Location
West of Andover
Looking forward to my first Lowlander journey and first on the new stock (have done the Highlander in the old stock a few times mostly in seats).
Any pair of seats offering the best leg room and or worst to avoid please?
I know certainly there were ones to avoid in the past!
Was thinking about 11B & C as no-one in front but is the wall there more of a hindrance?

I like 9A as there isn't a foot level vent giving you cold feet.

I would probably avoid those seats with the wall in front as you haven't got the legroom
 

FtoE

Member
Joined
27 Jul 2015
Messages
66
Ah, cheers.
Station signs are now saying that Sleeper tickets are valid on the 08:11 ScotRail to Inverness.
 

John Bishop

Member
Joined
15 Nov 2018
Messages
584
Location
Perth
Brake issues with the MK5s again

This issue is getting beyond a joke now. Have these issues been identified in a known set or are they fleet wide?

The resulting disruption to CS passengers and other TOCs trains and passengers is unacceptable. It is also reflecting badly on the brand. I read about this mornings problems in the press!
 

bobbyrail

Member
Joined
25 Dec 2018
Messages
101
Brake issues with the MK5s again

Is their a reliable source for this? RTT is quoting code M7 (Door and Door system faults) the brakes would be MN (Brake and brake systems faults)

I know RTT is not always correct but it can only relay what is in TRUST, so someone must have entered this correctly or not.
 

John Bishop

Member
Joined
15 Nov 2018
Messages
584
Location
Perth
Is their a reliable source for this? RTT is quoting code M7 (Door and Door system faults) the brakes would be MN (Brake and brake systems faults)

I know RTT is not always correct but it can only relay what is in TRUST, so someone must have entered this correctly or not.

If a door becomes open or the train thinks it’s open then the brakes come on, which why it maybe confused with a brake issue.

I think this is the ongoing issue causing the numerous unsolicited brake applications every other night.
 

Top