• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Bourdon group dot tests

Status
Not open for further replies.

Robnw67

Member
Joined
6 Jan 2020
Messages
59
Location
Preston, uk
I am just practicing my bourdon group dot tests and I'm not doing very well. I did 5 pages of 15 lines each spending 2 minutes per page. For my first attempt I got 5 lines of the 45 correct.

Just how critical are these...? :oops::(
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

PickleTree

Member
Joined
10 Jan 2020
Messages
340
Location
Hampshire
I am just practicing my bourdon group dot tests and I'm not doing very well. I did 5 pages of 15 lines each spending 2 minutes per page. For my first attempt I got 5 lines of the 45 correct.

Just how critical are these...? :oops::(
I think most people will agree that accuracy here is key. You will be told that speed and accuracy are just as important on the day but I got no further than 10-11 lines down with no errors and passed. Initially when you start practicing I would concentrate on making no mistakes and then start increasing your speed, remembering the accuracy part.
 

GPR

Member
Joined
16 Oct 2011
Messages
91
Location
Liverpool
I done roughly 10-12 lines each page with minimal wrong and passed my assessment a month ago.
Practice is key.
 

Liam00086

Member
Joined
11 Mar 2019
Messages
219
I am just practicing my bourdon group dot tests and I'm not doing very well. I did 5 pages of 15 lines each spending 2 minutes per page. For my first attempt I got 5 lines of the 45 correct.

Just how critical are these...? :oops::(
Like the others have said 10/12 lines fault free will get you a pass, this is probably the only test you can really practice for so you may as well.
 

Robnw67

Member
Joined
6 Jan 2020
Messages
59
Location
Preston, uk
Thanks for the replies. I'll carry on doing them, but maybe do them earlier in the day and in a quieter environment.
 

richfoz84

Member
Joined
13 Oct 2018
Messages
344
i failed last year as one section didn't have enough lines completed. I was told in some instances, speed is some times better than accuracy.. which i assume means if i was a few more lines down, with only 1 mistake, it may have faired better than no mistakes but not quite enough lines completed.
 

CreamNCookies

Member
Joined
10 Aug 2018
Messages
414
Thanks for the replies. I'll carry on doing them, but maybe do them earlier in the day and in a quieter environment.

I found doing the tests in all sorts of environments good for me.

Like I'd do it on the train when it was shaking, in the lunch room when people were talking and with music blaring. When it came to the tests I felt at ease almost.

But thats just me.

I also found that running my finger along the dots and the pencil just infront if my finger helped (if that makes any sense).

Thankfully i passed.

Ultimately youll find your own way.
 

Louby

Member
Joined
16 Feb 2012
Messages
669
just do an hour a night no more, you start off ok , get worse then get better, it's speed and accuracy they are looking for, you will be doing it in a quiet environment with just others doing the same round you
 

Robnw67

Member
Joined
6 Jan 2020
Messages
59
Location
Preston, uk
When doing the tests, I have to fight a natural urge to go from left to right on the first (odd) row, but then scan from right to left on the second (even) rows. Do you think this is causing me an issue? Should I always go right to left? I didn't think it would matter, but maybe so....
 

fourandbov

Member
Joined
15 Nov 2019
Messages
9
Location
Yorkshire
When doing the tests, I have to fight a natural urge to go from left to right on the first (odd) row, but then scan from right to left on the second (even) rows. Do you think this is causing me an issue? Should I always go right to left? I didn't think it would matter, but maybe so....

I'd always go left to right.

My understanding is that if you went right to left and say the furthest right was a four, if you marked that and then it was time to change page, any four's that were to the left of that on the row would be marked as omitted.
 

CreamNCookies

Member
Joined
10 Aug 2018
Messages
414
I'd always go left to right.

My understanding is that if you went right to left and say the furthest right was a four, if you marked that and then it was time to change page, any four's that were to the left of that on the row would be marked as omitted.
Excatly this!
 

deepblue82

Member
Joined
14 Aug 2019
Messages
33
Location
UK
I was very worried about this test in advance of my level 1. In practice if I pushed for 11 rows I was making 2-3 errors per sheet. If I worked to 9-10 rows I was getting 0-1 per sheet, occasionally 2.

I think on the test I think I did 10 rows each sheet and I am not sure of how many errors I made (though remember closing the sheet and seeing one missed right in the middle of the page!) but I passed to an enhanced standard. Steady pace, but accurate I would say and aiming to be consistent page to page.

ETA - I tried the left to right, right to left approach in practice thinking I could stich half way through the time on each sheet to just left to right but left too risky on the day and fairer to just go left to right and it was fine.
 
Last edited:

Robnw67

Member
Joined
6 Jan 2020
Messages
59
Location
Preston, uk
I was very worried about this test in advance of my level 1. In practice if I pushed for 11 rows I was making 2-3 errors per sheet. If I worked to 9-10 rows I was getting 0-1 per sheet, occasionally 2.

Interesting, I thought that all 15 rows had to be completed! When doing my practice, I am regularly completing only 10 rows and thought this would be really bad. Having said that, I am regularly only getting one or two rows accurate anyway. Do partial scores count? ie if I get 9 groups out of 10 on a row, do I get nine tenths of a credit or do I get zero for an inaccurate row?
 

deepblue82

Member
Joined
14 Aug 2019
Messages
33
Location
UK
I am not sure anyone knows but if you're get getting 15 rows in I would suggest slowing down and focusing on accuracy and aiming for minimal or zero omissions or errors per sheet.

I did one or two practice sheets with 0 errors across the 5 sheets but from memory was only doing 9 ish rows. I genuinely have no idea how they score them but I would say if you are getting to 15 rows but there are lots of errors on each page you are likely to fail.

Slow down, target less rows and more accuracy but sounds like you are doing pretty well to me (not sure id have got to 15 rows no matter how accurate I was!)
 

Robnw67

Member
Joined
6 Jan 2020
Messages
59
Location
Preston, uk
I am not sure anyone knows but if you get getting 15 rows in I would suggest slowing down and focusing on accuracy and aiming for minimal or zero omissions or errors per sheet. I did one or two practice sheets with 0 errors across the 5 sheets but from memory was only doing 9 ish rows. I genuinely have no idea how they score them but I would say if you are getting to 15 rows but there are lots of errors on each page you are likely to fail. Slow down, target less rows and more accuracy but sounds like you are doing pretty well to me (not sure id have got to 15 rows no matter how accurate I was!)

Thanks for your reply - I'm not able to do 15 rows. I'm regularly only getting 10 and from what you're saying this seems to be acceptable. I'm feeling a bit more positive about the quantity of rows that I can complete, if only I could get my accuracy up!
 

Louby

Member
Joined
16 Feb 2012
Messages
669
the test is not just speed and accuracy, it's also about following instructions, you are clearly told to go left to right, if you don't instant fail
 

BoroAndy

Member
Joined
11 Jan 2020
Messages
221
Location
Scarborough
I've printed off some sheets but they have many more than 15 rows, or is it landscape? So how many should there be rows x columns?
 

Jon1930

Member
Joined
15 Jun 2019
Messages
93
Interesting, I thought that all 15 rows had to be completed! When doing my practice, I am regularly completing only 10 rows and thought this would be really bad. Having said that, I am regularly only getting one or two rows accurate anyway. Do partial scores count? ie if I get 9 groups out of 10 on a row, do I get nine tenths of a credit or do I get zero for an inaccurate row?

I think you're overthinking way too much, none of us know how they mark the exam paper, like someone else said try and achieve 10-12 lines on each page with ideally zero mistakes and you will achieve enhanced pass. I did about 10-11 per page and passed.
 

Robnw67

Member
Joined
6 Jan 2020
Messages
59
Location
Preston, uk
I think you're overthinking way too much, none of us know how they mark the exam paper, like someone else said try and achieve 10-12 lines on each page with ideally zero mistakes and you will achieve enhanced pass. I did about 10-11 per page and passed.

Yes, thanks for the information. I tried this last night and my accuracy was much improved. I thought that all lines had to be completed and hence I rushed. I tried what you and a couple of other commenters suggested and my accuracy has much improved.
 

Robnw67

Member
Joined
6 Jan 2020
Messages
59
Location
Preston, uk

andyccfc

Member
Joined
12 Sep 2018
Messages
98
I have been practicing on and off for my stage one in a couple of weeks, getting 10 lines consistently but one or two mistakes creeping in. Cut those out and i hope i will be ok on the day as you tend to really lock in your concentration in a real test environment which is hard to reproduce at home.
 
Joined
1 Mar 2018
Messages
988
My advice would be to use both the paper and computer versions of the test if you can - the latter is harder in my opinion, and limit the amount of practice to a max of 30 mins in any one session or you'll start to make mistakes.
 

Jon1930

Member
Joined
15 Jun 2019
Messages
93
You will pass no problem, the dots test paper you print off from online is harder as the gaps between the dots are close, on the assessment day the gaps between each set of dots are much bigger making it much easier.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top