Caledonian Sleeper discussion

Discussion in 'UK Railway Discussion' started by LeylandLen, 29 Jul 2015.

  1. TimboM

    TimboM Established Member

    Messages:
    3,009
    Joined:
    12 Apr 2016
    1B26 caped this morning.

    1S26 has worked through to Glasgow, with 90047 running light engine in the wee hours back to Polmadie as 0B26 VSTP.

    Presumably linked to the knock-on disruption caused by the Stonehaven derailment and need to run the extra ECS.
     
  2. 31160

    31160 Member

    Messages:
    59
    Joined:
    18 Mar 2018
    The Ft Bill portion yesterday morning had a pair of 73's and 3xMK3 sleepers, is that due to the extra sleeper or did they need it in Ft William. Also with the continued hire in of the skip and occasional use of a 47 is this an indication that there arnt enough 73's to reliably handle the diagrams or are they still tying one or more up doing MK5 testing?, will tge December timetable change mean anything sleeper changes or will it be as now,timing and motive power wise I know the new coaches are delayed,thanks
     
  3. Highlandspring

    Highlandspring Member

    Messages:
    959
    Joined:
    14 Oct 2017
    Location:
    56°N
    1B26 was cancelled because 1S26 was only running with one brakevan. I think this actually goes back to the failure of 47749 in Aberdeen earlier this week, as it had been intended to run its set from Aberdeen to Carstairs to attach to 1B26 on Tuesday but it had to run to Polmadie instead because the sidings at Carstairs were blocked by a grinder. Things have been out of position ever since.
     
  4. Chrism20

    Chrism20 Established Member

    Messages:
    1,103
    Joined:
    27 Feb 2013
    I think the Aberdeen situation is a combination of a two things, mainly the downturn in Aberdeen and the CS fares.

    The number of flights to/from Aberdeen and London hasn't really changed much but fares have reduced a fair bit whilst at the same time the average room rate in hotels in and around Aberdeen has to be polite fell on its backside. As recent as six years ago you struggled to get a room in Aberdeen for under £100 a night, however the building of hotels hasn't slowed down and going online right now to Hilton or IHG websites will get you a room tonight in a 3/4* for as little as £57. Couple that with the reduced fares and it is now significantly cheaper to fly to/from Aberdeen so unlike the days gone by the sleeper is now looks terribly expensive at £160 each way. Even checking in bags for both flight sectors and staying overnight in Aberdeen its probably just slightly more than a one way trip in a single cabin on the sleeper.

    I disagree with what some others have said that a return to bargain berths is what is required. Even mailing out the people who have signed up for promotional stuff on their website etc would stimulate some demand. Virgin/LNER/EMT/XC etc all do this a couple of times a year with 20/25% off prepaid fares to stimulate demand. I have received not one promotional email from CS this year but in the last few weeks I've had discount codes for Virgin, EMT and XC. Had no plans to go anywhere but am now going to Birmingham for a couple of nights and Newcastle for the day Christmas shopping because the discount made the fares look attractive enough so it does work.

    Also re the targeting of Dundee I think the 6am arrival into Dundee is a negative there tbh. It suits people travelling home to Dundee but tourists will struggle to get into a hotel at 6am without paying extra for it and it's also probably too early for someone arriving on business. Unless you need to be in Dundee at 6am the Lowlander is probably a more attractive option if you wanted to do it by rail.
     
    Last edited: 11 Oct 2018
  5. DuncanS

    DuncanS Member

    Messages:
    205
    Joined:
    16 May 2017
    Location:
    Falkirk
    If you couldn't get a room in Aberdeen for under £100 you were clearly checking the wrong sites.
     
  6. TimboM

    TimboM Established Member

    Messages:
    3,009
    Joined:
    12 Apr 2016
    2x 73s for extra traction in leaf fall season.

    Nothing wrong with the 73/9’s reliability nor any motive power changes planned.

    A 47 has done two runs in about the last year. 67 on hire to cover 73/9 on Mk5 testing in effect.
     
  7. Chrism20

    Chrism20 Established Member

    Messages:
    1,103
    Joined:
    27 Feb 2013
    Well if you want to stay in a hellhole B&B down Crown Street it might have been cheaper but for hotels the ARR was consistently over £100 a night midweek before the oil industry went pop.

    I can remember the days when rooms in Travelodges in Aberdeen used to go for £180 a night.
     
  8. scotrail170407

    scotrail170407 Member

    Messages:
    36
    Joined:
    27 Sep 2018
    Does anyone have the diagrams for which loco hauls the sleepers out of Euston? I am interested in seeing 87002 and 86s. Also do the 86s or the 87s haul the sleeper into Euston in the evening?
     
  9. JohnMcL7

    JohnMcL7 Member

    Messages:
    119
    Joined:
    18 Apr 2018
    I was really hoping the new carriages would offer something suitable between the cabin and the seated option for solo travellers as I did try the seat option and even aside from just about everything being broken, it really wasn't a very pleasant experience.
     
  10. Mag_seven

    Mag_seven Established Member

    Messages:
    3,125
    Joined:
    1 Sep 2014
    87002 tends to work 5S96 from Wembley to Euston (the stock for the lowlander) in the evening and 5M11 from Euston to Wembley in the morning (the stock ex the Lowlander). At the moment 86101 is the other ACLG loco at the Euston end but is out of service at the moment. 86401 is the ACLG loco at the Scottish end and it tends to work 5M11 from Polmadie to Glasgow Central in the evening and 5S26 from Glasgow Central to Polmadie in the morning.

    All of these workings can of course be substituted for CS Class 92s or hired in FL Class 90s. The ACLG machines very rarely work passenger, generally being confined to ECS. Best bet for any passenger use is the Edinburgh-Carstairs portion of the lowlander.
     
  11. telstarbox

    telstarbox Established Member

    Messages:
    4,219
    Joined:
    23 Jul 2010
    Location:
    Wennington Crossovers
    Sorry if this is a stupid question but why do the oil workers live so far from Aberdeen - is it the two weeks on/off which makes it worth living down south and commuting for each rotation?
     
  12. Scotrail84

    Scotrail84 Established Member

    Messages:
    1,862
    Joined:
    5 Jul 2010

    The plan was to shunt a brake van in at Carstairs, until they realised they couldn't do it without poxing the station and mainline for ages.
     
  13. scotrail170407

    scotrail170407 Member

    Messages:
    36
    Joined:
    27 Sep 2018
    Thank you
     
  14. Highlandspring

    Highlandspring Member

    Messages:
    959
    Joined:
    14 Oct 2017
    Location:
    56°N
    I’ve found that CS/GBRf sometimes have a tendency to come up with elaborate plans without seeking the input of Network Rail at an early stage then get upset when it turns out that the available infrastructure cannot support what they hope to do, either in terms of there not being signalled moves for weird and wonderful shunts, possessions blocking routes for last minute VSTP coach swaps from one side of the country to the other, or being unable to accept vehicles being stabled on running lines or in stations for hours on end. In that respect things have gone downhill since the new franchise took over; things that appear simple when looking at a Quail Map in an office in Peterborough aren’t quite so easy to do in real life. The fleet being moved from cyclic maintenance at Inverness to a seemingly more ad hoc arrangement at Polmadie (with the requirement to swap coaches in and out at the Waverley) hasn’t helped matters. Everyone is working towards the same goal but it can be a frustrating situation for both sides.
     
  15. fgwrich

    fgwrich Established Member

    Messages:
    4,953
    Joined:
    15 Apr 2009
    Location:
    Between Edinburgh and Exeter
    If your lucky enough, you can catch one of the ACLG Electrics (usually 87002) on passenger duties when the sleepers are on diversion via East Coast. The 92 will work it from Edinburgh Waverley to Wembley via the East Coast and North London Line, where another loco will then tag onto the end and haul the Sleeper back down into Euston. I was lucky enough to have this with 87002 back in August.
     
  16. swaldman

    swaldman Member

    Messages:
    189
    Joined:
    19 Jan 2013
    No, you're definitely not. I used to do London to/from Inverness and Aberdeen a few times a year back in about 2010-12ish. Now, every time I look at it, it's cheaper to fly down and book a luxury hotel overnight[1] - so there's no way I can justify it to anybody. It makes me very sad, as I dislike unnecessary air travel for a whole host of reasons.
    The fare increases are a large part of the difference, but equally important is that you can't book a bunk in a shared cabin any more - which for a solo traveller who was willing to do that, effectively means another 50% or more onto the cost. Seems very odd to me that when the disadvantage of a sleeper train is already that one can't get many people on it, it runs with a load of berths empty because of this...

    [1] Not that I do - but it demonstrates the absurdity.
     
  17. swaldman

    swaldman Member

    Messages:
    189
    Joined:
    19 Jan 2013
    Hmm. The charitable way of looking at things is that by subsidising a service used mostly by tourists, the government(s) are aiding Scottish tourism, possibly to quite a good return on their investment.

    The cynical view is that the sleeper is the favoured way for many Scottish MPs to get to and from their constituencies... and so it will always get the subsidy that it needs to run, but it doesn't matter how much the tickets cost as they go on expenses anyway.

    Either way I find it absurd that we subsidise a service and yet it's still too expensive for most local people to use.
     
  18. TimboM

    TimboM Established Member

    Messages:
    3,009
    Joined:
    12 Apr 2016
    Good summary of the subsidy rationale...!

    In terms of the final point, the other way of looking at it is even with a multi-million pound annual subsidy, the prices are still high and Serco still make a loss - which gives an indication of how costly (or cost inefficient) a Sleeper train is to run - and quite how much the tickets would be without the subsidy.

    A logical progression maybe that the subsidy should be even bigger to make the fares affordable...?? Can’t see that happening though, nor anyone suggesting it...!

    With all the specialised stock, crew, locos, drivers, shunters, track access, cleaning/prep etc etc for trains which can only work once every 24 hours and can carry comparatively few passengers the Sleeper inherently has a high cost per passenger.

    It’d be interestring to know what that real cost was and compare that to what people think they should pay for it, as there appears to be a big disconnect between the two.
     
  19. swaldman

    swaldman Member

    Messages:
    189
    Joined:
    19 Jan 2013
    That's true - and actually, given the low passenger density, I'd be interested to know the energy use per passenger km compared to flying.
    However, we need to remember that Scotrail were able to make it work with much, much lower fares! I don't know whether the level of subsidy has reduced? Or whether perhaps First Scotrail were cross-subsidising from their other services? Or whether Serco are just hoping to rake it in...
     
  20. Norther Monkey

    Norther Monkey Member

    Messages:
    95
    Joined:
    7 Aug 2011
    For those that work offshore that's exactly the situation. Aberdeen is the departure point for most helicopter transfers to offshore installations. Although many offshore workers do live in the north of Scotland, if you're on an offshore rotation you can pretty much live where you want with one big commute every 2-3 weeks.
     
    Last edited: 11 Oct 2018
  21. pitdiver

    pitdiver Member

    Messages:
    627
    Joined:
    22 Jan 2012
    Somewhere up thread someone mentioned the cost of flying to Aberdeen. I am flying up there next year. £23 Luton-Aberdeen. Aberdeen -Luton £25
     
  22. paul1609

    paul1609 Established Member

    Messages:
    3,251
    Joined:
    28 Jan 2006
    Location:
    Wittersham Kent
    Im a bit sceptical that there were ever many offshore workers on the sleeper to be honest.
    The offshore helicopters tend to leave in a big cluster before 8 am in the morning, then in dribs and drabs throughout the day and then another cluster in the evening I wouldn't have thought that the sleeper was good for maybe 75% of the flights.
    There might well have been more people travelling to the offices of offshore firms in years gone by but I rather think that died out with budget airlines.
     
  23. Highlandspring

    Highlandspring Member

    Messages:
    959
    Joined:
    14 Oct 2017
    Location:
    56°N
    Exactly, check in at Aberdeen for morning offshore helicopter flights is generally around 0500 - 0600. Most of my family and friends who work offshore (and there are plenty of them, having grown up in the north east) are taxied to the airport. I think the whole ‘offshore workers using the sleeper’ thing is a myth perpetuated by those who don’t understand how the oil industry works.
     
  24. TimboM

    TimboM Established Member

    Messages:
    3,009
    Joined:
    12 Apr 2016
    92014 leading 1S25 tonight with 90045 Dead in Train to get it back to Edinburgh (after it brought the Aberdeen ECS south this morning).
    92023 on 5S95/1S26
    92033 on 1M11
    90047 on 1M16
    86401 on 1C11 etc
     
    Last edited: 12 Oct 2018
  25. Sarahs_Railway

    Sarahs_Railway Member

    Messages:
    131
    Joined:
    1 May 2017
    Surely the Aberdeen sections low load is due to the pricing? I for one don't use them anymore. £95 single one year ago and now £160 in the same stock? Dream on Serco.
     
  26. Sarahs_Railway

    Sarahs_Railway Member

    Messages:
    131
    Joined:
    1 May 2017
    This may be interest and other more learned members can add flesh to the bones - 73961 was in Craigentinny around 1700 today in a siding with two DB Cherry red 67's blockng the exit. I think one of the 67's was 014 but I was half asleep so don't take my word on that. Also a Colas 47 with a black nameplate that I presume was "City of Truro"?
     
  27. aar0

    aar0 Member

    Messages:
    126
    Joined:
    13 Sep 2016
    Funnily enough, having Googled LNER 3rd Class sleepers, I found the following link, showing showers in sleeper coaches in the 30s! https://www.steve-banks.org/modelling/233-lner-66-6-1st-sleeping-car
     
  28. TimboM

    TimboM Established Member

    Messages:
    3,009
    Joined:
    12 Apr 2016
    Thanks for the info. However, on Tues am, 86401 (on 5Z26 VSTP) ran the stock that had been stranded at Aberdeen on Sunday night after 47749 sat down out to Carstairs from Polmadie in the early hours. 86401 ran back light (0Z26) and 1B26 then ran (90047) - which suggests they were successfully reunited with the rest of the half-set at Carstairs.

    1S26 this morning was Load 13 (Aberdeen portion currently Load 5 I believe, so a train with that part missing would be a Load 11). This would suggest 1S26 was light of 3 coaches this morning (including a brake) for some other reasons/failures.

    I take it you're referring to this morning? (as the plan to add on coaches from Polmadie did seem to work Tues morning as above)

    The maintenance is still cyclical - the sets rotate around the routes so they pass through Polmadie and Wembley at regular intervals. As for the Fort Bill day coaches, these have always come off/on at Edinburgh and just travel between EDB and FTW, so even when the main depot was Inverness, they'd presumably still have had to do the periodic swaps to/from Edinburgh to change the two "day coaches" over for maintenance?
     
  29. TimboM

    TimboM Established Member

    Messages:
    3,009
    Joined:
    12 Apr 2016
    I take it you saw 73971 (961 is currently in Kent). 971 is at EC for attention along with 970 currently.

    The 47 was indeed 47749, back at EC after its misbehaviour in Aberdeen on Sunday night.

    It'll have been 67004 you saw I think, as 014 is in Crewe IEMD at the moment (and silver!) - 004 is now DB Red (used to be CS Midnight Teal ironically) - it worked 1M16 south last night, but then declared a failure and replaced by 66746 + 73969.

    The other DB Red 67 will have been 010.
     
  30. Sarahs_Railway

    Sarahs_Railway Member

    Messages:
    131
    Joined:
    1 May 2017
    Thank you Tim. I only noticed it because the 73 was blocked by the 2 67's. As I said I was half asleep and gazing into the middle distance!
     

Share This Page