• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Caledonian Sleeper

theblackwatch

Established Member
Joined
15 Feb 2006
Messages
10,714
The two sleeper trains leave Edinburgh between 0415 and 0445 to get their paths back north. Running them later than scheduled may not be possible within driver hours and pathing them later they will be in the way.

They seem to manage it on the rare (or not so rare :lol: ) occasion when the trains run late. Unfortunately, the railway often seems to look for reasons not to run something rather than try and find solutions on how to.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

paul1609

Established Member
Joined
28 Jan 2006
Messages
7,189
Location
Wittersham Kent
The last southbound overnight Megabus I took did Glasgow Buchanan St to London Green line Bus station in 7 hrs 2 mins including about 10 mins for driver changeover at Forton Services, about 20 miles of 50 mph average speed cameras have gone on the M6 since then. Knock off 15 mins starting from Euston vice Victoria and even Edinburgh wouldn't be that far fetched. We didn't use the M6 toll not sure how much time that saves.
 

JonathanH

Veteran Member
Joined
29 May 2011
Messages
18,536
The last southbound overnight Megabus I took did Glasgow Buchanan St to London Green line Bus station in 7 hrs 2 mins including about 10 mins for driver changeover at Forton Services, about 20 miles of 50 mph average speed cameras have gone on the M6 since then. Knock off 15 mins starting from Euston vice Victoria and even Edinburgh wouldn't be that far fetched. We didn't use the M6 toll not sure how much time that saves.

2245 for 0615 from Buchanan Street to Victoria (ie 7 and a half hours) on Megabus on Tuesday night - M74, M6, M6 toll, M42, M40, M25, M4 - non-stop except for driver change somewhere. I would have thought 2350 for 0707 should be doable from Glasgow although you are an hour later in the London traffic. Might be a shade more difficult from Edinburgh.
 

Bald Rick

Veteran Member
Joined
28 Sep 2010
Messages
29,070
The last southbound overnight Megabus I took did Glasgow Buchanan St to London Green line Bus station in 7 hrs 2 mins including about 10 mins for driver changeover at Forton Services, about 20 miles of 50 mph average speed cameras have gone on the M6 since then. Knock off 15 mins starting from Euston vice Victoria and even Edinburgh wouldn't be that far fetched. We didn't use the M6 toll not sure how much time that saves.

M6 toll will save nothing overnight, unless there’s roadworks on the M6 proper.
 

Peter Sarf

Established Member
Joined
12 Oct 2010
Messages
5,642
Location
Croydon
Well. Another reason I travel more and more by coach. The train is so expensive and you are not buying any reliability for the price. If I am going to end up on a coach then I might as well pay for..... a coach.

I have been stuffed by railway engineering closures involving coaches. Invariably going by coach for the whole journey would have been quicker, less faff changing vehicles/modes and a lot cheaper.

I fear the railways give in too easily especially for the price charged.
 

gray1404

Established Member
Joined
3 Mar 2014
Messages
6,575
Location
Merseyside
CS should have arranged ticket acceptance on other TOCs on both this evenings services and for travel tomorrow on daytime TOCS. This should have been in addition to them arranging an overnight coach. Their website displayed no warning information about the trains they cancelled. They should have been asking customers to call them for either a refund or to rebook for another day.

Really poor show. They should have given their customers options.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
97,540
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
They seem to manage it on the rare (or not so rare :lol: ) occasion when the trains run late. Unfortunately, the railway often seems to look for reasons not to run something rather than try and find solutions on how to.

They are also quite good at designing things for minimum flexibility, such as LHCS using non-standard couplings (so you can't just bang any D-lok on the front) and that gets confused if you swap a couple of coaches round. The absolute pits of design, that.
 

Darandio

Established Member
Joined
24 Feb 2007
Messages
10,674
Location
Redcar
And don't get me started on overnight bus replacements for luxury guests, which is what seems to be the only offer.

Don't get me started either, I spoke at length about it in this very thread a couple of months ago. :lol:
 

Antman

Established Member
Joined
3 May 2013
Messages
6,842
It is odd that a fifteen year Franchise (or whatever it is) doesn’t have a suitable plan B if the power is down.... it’s almost as if they know that is someone else’s problem (public purse/contractor). I used to love the WCML diversions around the NW on summer Sundays. All sorts of random locos hauling 86s and 87s and their coaches around... I am Sure the drivers did well out of their OT as well. So would volunteer for it. Plus more possession time on maintenance for WCML infrastructure. It’s just a shame the entire thing is pegged off contract metrics not service these days.
 

Mathew S

Established Member
Joined
7 Aug 2017
Messages
2,167
Don't get me started either, I spoke at length about it in this very thread a couple of months ago. :lol:
Thing is, though, that's all that's currently required of them under the NRCoT. As I've said before, I would love to see someone challenge them on it under the Consumer Rights Act*, because I really don't think CS have a leg to stand on, given their advertising but, until someone does, they seem content to keep doing the minimum that's required of them.

* Though if they've got any sense, CS would just settle any claim out of court to avoid setting a precedent, as other TOCs have done in the past.
 

s'land

Member
Joined
23 Oct 2007
Messages
61
This links back to what was discussed on this thread some time ago. As CS style themselves as a "luxury" operator they should do the equivalent of what a luxury hotel would do. In this case, they should have given the passenger (and anyone else who wants to travel tonight) an any-card ToD collection code for a ticket valid on the 1900.

And don't get me started on overnight bus replacements for luxury guests, which is what seems to be the only offer.
My son was booked on the sleeper last night from Glasgow to London, to be at Waterloo Network Rail offices, he booked into a hotel for an extra night through work, and traveling back down on the sleeper tonight instead.
 

Fleetwood Boy

Member
Joined
11 Oct 2017
Messages
189
Whilst I have some sympathy for CS when things go wrong which aren't within their control, I do agree that where necessary they should be pulling out the corporate credit card and buying tickets even if ticket acceptance is refused by other operators. Happened to me once flying with FlyBe between Birmingham and Glasgow back in the day when BA flew on the route too - FlyBe station manager stomped across to the BA desk and bought 10 singles to Glasgow on the next BA flight. Must have cost a wack, but I was impressed that a low-cost carrier would do such a thing, rather than just point us towards their next flight in many hours' time. Of course with the mayhem between London and Scotland yesterday, a journey by an alternative route might not have been much fun either.
 

JonathanH

Veteran Member
Joined
29 May 2011
Messages
18,536
They really need to give consideration to replacement flights, not buses. Charter an aircraft.

...and transport from the Airport to central London, and a hotel room for the rest of the night?

Seriously, are people's journeys and experience that vital? Are people willing to pay the increased cost of this 'insurance' for their journey such that they expect Caledonian Sleeper to pay for this rather than themselves?

Even personal travel insurance wouldn't do any better than putting you on alternative existing transport to London or Scotland as appropriate.
 

trebor79

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2018
Messages
4,435
They really need to give consideration to replacement flights, not buses. Charter an aircraft.
Very expensive, even if you could charter a plane at the drop of a hat.
What about people who don't like flying? What about people who have lots of luggage, or stuff you aren't allowed on planes?
And what do you upon arrival at Glasgow or Edinburgh in the middle of the night? Sit about the airport?
Far more practical response would be a choice between:
Full refund and don't travel.
Travel on a different date.
Bus
Hotel and travel on the first morning train.
Travel on evening train and hotel at destination.
 

BRX

Established Member
Joined
20 Oct 2008
Messages
3,602
Very expensive, even if you could charter a plane at the drop of a hat.
What about people who don't like flying? What about people who have lots of luggage, or stuff you aren't allowed on planes?
And what do you upon arrival at Glasgow or Edinburgh in the middle of the night? Sit about the airport?
Far more practical response would be a choice between:
Full refund and don't travel.
Travel on a different date.
Bus
Hotel and travel on the first morning train.
Travel on evening train and hotel at destination.
I would agree with this.

I'd have thought that you could at least have pre-agreed deals with other TOCs for last trains of the day, which you could activate as soon as you knew the sleeper was cancelled. So, if it becomes apparent at say 5pm that it's going to be cancelled, you can automatically notify passengers that if they want, and are able to, they can travel on the last daytime service, with no time being lost in negotiations or twitter arguments.
 

side effect

Member
Joined
20 Jul 2015
Messages
81
Could they not pull out a spare train at bounds green depot. I know it's probably a stupid suggestion but it's not like we are in the 16th century. And while we are at it, why cant brand new rolling stock be hybrid instead of only being able to be pulled by electric locos.
 

trebor79

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2018
Messages
4,435
Could they not pull out a spare train at bounds green depot. I know it's probably a stupid suggestion but it's not like we are in the 16th century. And while we are at it, why cant brand new rolling stock be hybrid instead of only being able to be pulled by electric locos.
The Mk5 are capable of being hauled by diesel or electric locos, provided they have Delner couplings and are electrically compatable.
 

alangla

Member
Joined
11 Apr 2018
Messages
1,178
Location
Glasgow
Laughable. :lol:
Yep, pretty ridiculous, though I believe First used to offer overnight accommodation on parked sleeper coaches at the main stations & a single to Heathrow the next morning if people were in a rush. That might be an option from Glasgow, Edinburgh, Aberdeen, Inverness & maybe Dundee, but there’s no way aircraft are being chartered.

One thought- if CS were to buy accommodation & an airline ticket for a passenger & let’s say they were delivered to Heathrow or London City by 0700, is there any refund due on the rail ticket? You’re in London at the scheduled time after all and had a bed for most of the night. That might be cheaper than refunding some of the top price fares & arranging ticket acceptance the next day
 

JonathanH

Veteran Member
Joined
29 May 2011
Messages
18,536
Could they not pull out a spare train at bounds green depot. I know it's probably a stupid suggestion but it's not like we are in the 16th century. And while we are at it, why cant brand new rolling stock be hybrid instead of only being able to be pulled by electric locos.

Hybrid is not needed 99% of the time - you are wasting effort maintaining engines that are rarely used, using additional natural resources and wasting energy lugging the unused engines around.
 

option

Member
Joined
1 Aug 2017
Messages
636
They really need to give consideration to replacement flights, not buses. Charter an aircraft.

Indeed

I know that the food isn't included in the price (why not?), but the dining & bar are part of the package they're selling.
Can't provide those on a coach, so it's nowhere near good enough as a replacement.
 

side effect

Member
Joined
20 Jul 2015
Messages
81
Ok thanks for that. I remember back in the 80s following West Ham all over the country on inter city instead of football specials. One night we paid £11 return to Sheffield Wednesday not knowing the last train back was 9ish. Anyway, we took a big crowd up that night and there were 100s of us stranded and the police kept us on the platform until gone midnight and we ended up being forced onto a loco hauled.

Point being was that already planned or did they just pull out a spare train. We got back 5am.
 

JonathanH

Veteran Member
Joined
29 May 2011
Messages
18,536
I know that the food isn't included in the price (why not?), but the dining & bar are part of the package they're selling.

There isn't capacity to provide food in the service vehicle for everyone and some people will have eaten before travelling.

On the Lowland sleeper departure is too late for most people to want to eat anyway.

Can't provide those on a coach, so it's nowhere near good enough as a replacement.

Not sure you have to offer food - the primary reason to travel is to get from one place to another.
 

sheff1

Established Member
Joined
24 Dec 2009
Messages
5,461
Location
Sheffield
What about people who don't like flying? What about people who have lots of luggage, or stuff you aren't allowed on planes?

Also kind of sticks two fingers up at people who choose the Sleeper for environmental reasons...

Nobody would be forced to fly. They could take the overnight bus or the next day's train if that was their preference.
 

option

Member
Joined
1 Aug 2017
Messages
636
Very expensive, even if you could charter a plane at the drop of a hat.
What about people who don't like flying? What about people who have lots of luggage, or stuff you aren't allowed on planes?
And what do you upon arrival at Glasgow or Edinburgh in the middle of the night? Sit about the airport?
Far more practical response would be a choice between:
Full refund and don't travel.
Travel on a different date.
Bus
Hotel and travel on the first morning train.
Travel on evening train and hotel at destination.

The issue is that a lot of their customers won't be able to change the travel date, & won't be able to get to Euston much earlier.
The train is usually available from 22:30, so a lot of people will have other plans up to that sort of time.

So really the only suitable choice is the hotel & travel in the morning.
 

Top