Competition 608 (Freight) :: Voting

[Jordy]

http://www.railforums.co.uk/gallery/thumbnails.php?album=255

Votes by 1900 on Sunday please

Cheers

 

[David]

#11 is a cracking photo, but ....

Has someone been playing around a little bit too much in photoshop?

 

[Buffer68]

Only one winner here this week - not going to say which one until voting is closed though.

 

[Temple Meads]

All the pictures seem pretty decent this week, but number 13 edges it for me.

 

[Ivo]

An interesting mix this week, with #4 being my choice. I would have voted #6 but the gantry pole in the centre ruins what is otherwise a very good shot.

#11 is a cracking photo, but ....

Has someone been playing around a little bit too much in photoshop?

I think I agree here. It would have gotten my vote but it does look a bit too well fiddled.

 

[GB]

In what way does #11 look over done in PS?

 

[Ivo]

In what way does #11 look over done in PS?

It probably isn't. But for the light level there seems to be too much detail and brightness for my liking. I guess part of this belief would stem from that imilar one a few weeks ago; to that point, I wonder if the same person took both (in which case this possible criticism is almost certainly unfair)?

 

[Teaboy1]

Are we sure is not 66's theme ??? Some quality shots but to be different I choosing a non-66 photo as a protest vote ..... which rather narrows it down a wee bit .... so #3 for me, blast from the past !!

 

[33056]

Are we sure is not 66's theme ??? Some quality shots but to be different I choosing a non-66 photo as a protest vote ..... which rather narrows it down a wee bit .... so #3 for me, blast from the past !!

Most freight trains are worked by 66s these days and people don't always have the time or inclination to go back through their archives to find something older. Also, don't forget the younger element who were not fortunate enough to remember when there was greater variety on our freight trains or were old enough to point a camera at such things at the time.

Anyway, there are some good photos this week but I have also gone for no.3 (with a user name like mine, you don't really expect any different do you? )

 

[Crossover]

After seeing the photo a couple of weeks ago, I believe #11 is someone who knows photography a lot better than I do and has filters and stuff on the camera (filters which I believe are not post processing digital ones)

A good lot of entries this week, though it is only now I look properly, I realise how shed dominated it is! :P

 

[Jordy]

Congrats to eastwestdivide

01 - EltonRoad
02 - Temple Meads
03 - eastwestdivide
04 - Railfreight 90
05 - sprinterguy
06 - Crossover
07 - stuartmoss
08 - GB
09 - Simon Poole
10 - steve 46010
11 - Swiss Toni
12 - MattE2010
13 - 33056
14 - 4468
15 - 96tommy

 

[eastwestdivide]

Phew, that was close! Do you think two 33s would equal a 66?
Thanks for the votes.

 

[EltonRoad]

D'oh, beaten by one vote! Nice shot though.