• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Freight derailment in Tameside (Greater Manchester), with one minor injury (06/09)

littledude

Member
Joined
21 Nov 2011
Messages
65
When I’ve reported incidents like this they hand wash it away by saying the post didn’t contain confidential info, that’s as not the point though the log for the day clearly states confidential not for distribution outside the industry.

Not removing posts only encourages behaviour, I’ll await this post to be removed.
There seems to be a huge song and dance about posting (already widely shared) control logs, especially ones which aren’t showing very much info at all as per here, but for as long as I can remember TOPS info (loco pool, E3, wagon enquiries etc) has been openly posted online without people frothing at the mouth.

I wouldn’t worry yourself over things you have zero control over, it’s not good for your health :smile:
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

bengley

Established Member
Joined
18 May 2008
Messages
1,905
I wouldn't worry about control logs being shared either. It's almost impossible to prevent - they get widely shared amongst staff groups on WhatsApp very quickly, then these naturally get to people outside the industry and before you know it everyone knows about it.

Impossible to prevent - no personal details are contained so it's not a huge issue.
 

Nottingham59

Established Member
Joined
10 Dec 2019
Messages
2,302
Location
Nottingham
The pictures make it look like the train ran for a substantial distance on the ballast, has any information on how far the derailed vehicles got dragged come out yet?
In post #9, the third photo shows three wagons towards the back of the train in place and the ballast not disturbed. So the point of derailment seems to be where the ballast in the four foot changes to metal plate, presumably where the track starts to pass over the bridge.

The first photo shows three wagons derailed. Beyond them there may be a gap, or one or perhaps two wagons out of sight, before the front of the train can be seen visible still on the track.

So I'd guess the derailed vehicles got dragged for three or four wagon lengths.

I might be completely wrong about this of course. The original derailment could have been well before the bridge, but if the wheels came off the rail away from the camera, the ballast on the camera side would not have got disturbed.

The MML derailment of a 222 at Market Harborough showed that a derailed wheel can run on the ballast for some time, until it reaches something like a switch (or a bridge) that causes the derailed bogie to twist out of alignment.

EDIT: https://assets.publishing.service.g...0b62302691bda/120130_R012012_East_Langton.pdf

On 20 February 2010, at around 15:49 hrs, a seven-car Meridian diesel multiple unit
passenger train derailed by one axle of the fourth vehicle, while travelling on the
Midland Main Line near East Langton. The train was travelling at a speed of 94 mph
(151 km/h) when the derailment occurred, and it subsequently ran for a distance of
approximately 2 miles (3.2 km) before it stopped.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Moonshot

Established Member
Joined
10 Nov 2013
Messages
3,749
I wouldn't worry about control logs being shared either. It's almost impossible to prevent - they get widely shared amongst staff groups on WhatsApp very quickly, then these naturally get to people outside the industry and before you know it everyone knows about it.

Impossible to prevent - no personal details are contained so it's not a huge issue.
Indeed they do.....there are some very funny ones as well
 

LRV3004

Member
Joined
17 Mar 2015
Messages
483
Aah bugger, I bought an ALR just this lunchtime and hoping to take the parliamentary Stockport-Stalybridge train at the end of the month. Guess it'll be a parliamentary RRB instead.
Apologies if you’ve already got a reply - not checked the entire thread yet but the parliamentary train ran successfully on Saturday in both directions; 156409 operated it.
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
13,832
Recovery of the derailed train in due course... How many wagons have derailed? How broken up is the trackwork? Presume that if the entire train hasn't derailed, it'll be possible to unhitch the loco and a few wagons at the front end of the failed train, and then perhaps some more at the rear end, and at least get those shifted out of the way? How, then, might whatever's remaining get moved? These are likely to be fully laden wagons, aren't they?
 

Ash Bridge

Established Member
Joined
17 Mar 2014
Messages
4,120
Location
Stockport
Recovery of the derailed train in due course... How many wagons have derailed? How broken up is the trackwork? Presume that if the entire train hasn't derailed, it'll be possible to unhitch the loco and a few wagons at the front end of the failed train, and then perhaps some more at the rear end, and at least get those shifted out of the way? How, then, might whatever's remaining get moved? These are likely to be fully laden wagons, aren't they?
I did witness 3 laden wagons being removed by a GBRf 66 yesterday late afternoon, presumably from the rear of the rake?
 

Horizon22

Established Member
Associate Staff
Jobs & Careers
Joined
8 Sep 2019
Messages
8,613
Location
London
I wouldn't worry about control logs being shared either. It's almost impossible to prevent - they get widely shared amongst staff groups on WhatsApp very quickly, then these naturally get to people outside the industry and before you know it everyone knows about it.

Impossible to prevent - no personal details are contained so it's not a huge issue.

There’s a slight difference between paraphrasing a log and taking a direct screenshot of it and sharing it though I would have thought.

Ultimately there’s a disclaimer on its usage.
 

SouthStand

Member
Joined
8 Aug 2010
Messages
283
There seems to be a huge song and dance about posting (already widely shared) control logs, especially ones which aren’t showing very much info at all as per here, but for as long as I can remember TOPS info (loco pool, E3, wagon enquiries etc) has been openly posted online without people frothing at the mouth.

I wouldn’t worry yourself over things you have zero control over, it’s not good for your health :smile:

Correct.
 

PupCuff

Member
Joined
27 Feb 2020
Messages
562
Location
Nottingham
I wouldn't worry about control logs being shared either. It's almost impossible to prevent - they get widely shared amongst staff groups on WhatsApp very quickly, then these naturally get to people outside the industry and before you know it everyone knows about it.

Impossible to prevent - no personal details are contained so it's not a huge issue.
That's the issue though. Yes, in this case that person hasn't leaked any personal information but there is an absolute ton of personal information in CCIL, and if people are routinely leaking information from industry internal sources going against the already quite clear rules relating to accessing the information in the first place, there's no guarantee that they will take a suitably diligent approach to removing personal info when they do so.
 

dooton

Member
Joined
18 Nov 2010
Messages
94
CCIL Log usage is tracked and questions are asked when somebody the other side of the country has viewed a log item that's been leaked. As has been said above the logs contain person information often as well information that might be wrong in the moment its written, its an event log and filled in as the event progresses. Quoting half of it as fact as has been done here can prejudice an investigation.

Sharing the logs is a disciplinary offence in my TOC, the forum should be handing bans to anybody sharing screenshots or quoting directly. That might not make me the most popular person here, but at some point somebody will share something serious or with personal data. I dont really understand why anybody would risk their job taking screenshots. The logs are exportable - there's literally no need to take a screenshot other than share illegally.
 

RiverDon

Member
Joined
11 Mar 2024
Messages
31
Location
Aberdeen
I’m currently a police officer (hopefully trainee train driver soon!) and if I publicly shared the contents of one of our logs I would be facing a misconduct hearing, certainly lose my job and possibly charges under the Computer Misuse Act 1990. Doesn’t matter how big or small an incident is, anything in the log is restricted and you have to have a genuine policing purpose to view it. Every police officer and civi staff member knows this from day 1 in the job. Surely it’s no different on the rail?
 

LAX54

Established Member
Joined
15 Jan 2008
Messages
3,831
Re the brake demand: That log entry looks like it might be timed before the derailment is reported and before the driver investigated?? So possibly an effect rather than a cause?

I hope whoever leaked the log entry is ready for a meeting invitation.
Log now 'locked' !
 

CAF397

Member
Joined
15 Sep 2010
Messages
1,094
Location
Lancashire
I’m currently a police officer (hopefully trainee train driver soon!) and if I publicly shared the contents of one of our logs I would be facing a misconduct hearing, certainly lose my job and possibly charges under the Computer Misuse Act 1990. Doesn’t matter how big or small an incident is, anything in the log is restricted and you have to have a genuine policing purpose to view it. Every police officer and civi staff member knows this from day 1 in the job. Surely it’s no different on the rail?
I often wonder this when I see photographs from linesode photographers of the Royal Train! Whilst the movements of senior Royals can sometimes be predicted, the Royal Train is apparently well hidden from various online tracking systems, and only those who signal and control it should know of its whereabouts.
 

66701GBRF

Member
Joined
3 Jun 2017
Messages
746
I often wonder this when I see photographs from linesode photographers of the Royal Train! Whilst the movements of senior Royals can sometimes be predicted, the Royal Train is apparently well hidden from various online tracking systems, and only those who signal and control it should know of its whereabouts.
Royal train where abouts (when it runs) was always well known well before the advent of online tracking and even CCIL (Control Centre Incident Log)
 

littledude

Member
Joined
21 Nov 2011
Messages
65
I often wonder this when I see photographs from linesode photographers of the Royal Train! Whilst the movements of senior Royals can sometimes be predicted, the Royal Train is apparently well hidden from various online tracking systems, and only those who signal and control it should know of its whereabouts.
It isn’t hidden from the signalling data feeds (as it would simply be so difficult to do) so the live signalling maps (Open Train Times, Traksy, Railcam, Freightmaster etc) will all show the location of the Royal Train. You do, of course, have to know what you’re looking out for…
 

Mollman

Established Member
Joined
21 Sep 2016
Messages
1,411
I often wonder this when I see photographs from linesode photographers of the Royal Train! Whilst the movements of senior Royals can sometimes be predicted, the Royal Train is apparently well hidden from various online tracking systems, and only those who signal and control it should know of its whereabouts.

It isn’t hidden from the signalling data feeds (as it would simply be so difficult to do) so the live signalling maps (Open Train Times, Traksy, Railcam, Freightmaster etc) will all show the location of the Royal Train. You do, of course, have to know what you’re looking out for…
I think most of the time people get lucky. They are generally already out there filming/ photographing trains (as it usually uses one of the busy mainlines) I think.
 

muz379

Established Member
Joined
23 Jan 2014
Messages
2,373
As has been said above the logs contain person information often as well information that might be wrong in the moment its written, its an event log and filled in as the event progresses
I think this is often overlooked and people quote control logs as if they are gospel , all the log actually does is record the information provided to control as it comes in.

Fairly often with a major incident some of that information will later prove to be incorrect , some of the earlier information is often based on assumptions about what has happened .
 

Greybeard33

Established Member
Joined
18 Feb 2012
Messages
4,335
Location
Greater Manchester
Recovery of the derailed train in due course... How many wagons have derailed? How broken up is the trackwork? Presume that if the entire train hasn't derailed, it'll be possible to unhitch the loco and a few wagons at the front end of the failed train, and then perhaps some more at the rear end, and at least get those shifted out of the way? How, then, might whatever's remaining get moved? These are likely to be fully laden wagons, aren't they?
The amateur video below includes drone footage of the train shot on the day of the derailment. There appear to be nine derailed wagons, with five still on the rails behind them. The rearmost derailed vehicle is on the bridge over Sidmouth Street, so it appears that was the site of the initial derailment, with momentum causing the preceding eight derailed vehicles to continue along the ballast before stopping.

Ahead of the derailed portion there is a gap, and then at least eight more wagons appear to have remained on the rails at the front of the train. Presumably a coupling parted between the front portion and the derailed portion during the incident, with the ruptured brake pipe bringing the front portion to a stand.

 

Harpo

Member
Joined
21 Aug 2024
Messages
569
Location
Newport
The rearmost derailed vehicle is on the bridge over Sidmouth Street, so it appears that was the site of the initial derailment
Or alternatively was the point where a vehicle had run to in a derailed condition before causing track damage, or……..
 

M60lad

Member
Joined
31 May 2011
Messages
1,000
Looking at the video raises some questions:

1> Considering the damage to the bridge could it be that the bridge will need replacing?

2> Looking how close the houses are to the track how are they going re-instate the track which seems to have slipped somewhat?

3> When are the cranes due to remove the wagons and also where will they be coming from?

4> Will any of the work involve a road closure of Audenshaw Road while recovery takes place?

5> Will the wagons have to be emptied and if so how?
 

Freightmaster

Established Member
Joined
7 Jul 2009
Messages
3,706
The biggest deal is the already diverted T & T Ashburys , because of New Mills. Not sure what route that can take now?
This is how it ran today, reversing in the loop east of Guide Bridge:



MARK
 

philthetube

Established Member
Joined
5 Jan 2016
Messages
3,882
The post title states one minor injure, then it never gets a mention, how did this happen?
 

800001

Established Member
Joined
24 Oct 2015
Messages
4,673
The log extract we saw included reports by the driver and permanent way staff. So there may have been other people in the vicinity.
I was under impression it was a member of public walking under the bridge, hit by falling debris.
 

Geeves

Established Member
Joined
6 Jan 2009
Messages
2,207
Location
Rochdale
6G50 (Ashton Moss - Crewe Basford Hall Yard) is on its way with 5 low sided engineering wagons full of Derbyshire's finest export. I assuming they are slowly unloading the derailed wagons (or have already done so)
 

Meerkat

Established Member
Joined
14 Jul 2018
Messages
8,492
6G50 (Ashton Moss - Crewe Basford Hall Yard) is on its way with 5 low sided engineering wagons full of Derbyshire's finest export. I assuming they are slowly unloading the derailed wagons (or have already done so)
How would you do it - the tops are quite tight and the sides rather flimsy for swinging a grab around, so it would be a slow job that way.
 

Geeves

Established Member
Joined
6 Jan 2009
Messages
2,207
Location
Rochdale
How would you do it
I cannot say how the logistics is working up there, I just know that they sent a light engine up there in the morning and it came back with loaded engineers wagons, the same type often seen on track relays and in each wagon was crushed lime stone heading back to Crewe

Presumably they have been either handballing or using something with a shovel small enough to fit in the top of the wagons or even equipment that can transfer the stone out of the bottom of the wagons as they are designed?
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
13,832
Is a fair portion of the failed train still sat on the rail overbridge above the Manchester Piccadilly->Guide Bridge line?
 

Top