• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Railway books discussion

talltim

Established Member
Joined
17 Jan 2010
Messages
2,454
I’ve recently finished Over The Alleghenies - Early Canals and Railroads of Pennsylvania - Robert J. Kapsch
Pretty thorough and detailed, fairly heavy going and a bit repetitive. What I took away from it is that US canal builders took a completely different approach to UK ones. In the US they used hardly any brickwork or masonry and so their locks and aqueducts were in need of repair and replacement in as soon as 10 years after building. While this may seem short sighted, consider that most British canals were well over engineered, far outlasting their profitable lifetimes annd so cost their builders far more than they needed.

I’m currently reading The Pennsylvania Railroad vol 1 by Albert J. Churrella.
A heavyweight tome in both senses, it runs to 945 pages. A lot about the politics of a once publicly (state) owned railroad.

The book I’ve that I’ve most enjoyed recently was Narrow Gauge by the Sudanese Red Sea Coast by Henry Gunston. Bought it on a whim when I saw if offered on FB marketplace. It’s a fairly standard minor railway history, containing pretty much all the information known about the line, but it’s engagingly written and the subject has a certain romance.
 

Attachments

  • 873C1F10-FB51-4F7D-9E0A-C34793C0FFBD.jpeg
    873C1F10-FB51-4F7D-9E0A-C34793C0FFBD.jpeg
    4.2 MB · Views: 8
  • ED24C301-CEDD-42A2-997B-0509F13CD14A.jpeg
    ED24C301-CEDD-42A2-997B-0509F13CD14A.jpeg
    2.6 MB · Views: 8
  • D16E6C37-997C-4872-BE11-944CB52FA54D.jpeg
    D16E6C37-997C-4872-BE11-944CB52FA54D.jpeg
    3.6 MB · Views: 9
Last edited:
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

LSWR Cavalier

Established Member
Joined
23 Aug 2020
Messages
1,565
Location
Leafy Suburbia
Great British Bus Journeys, Travels Through Unfamous Places by David McKie

There are not so many books about bus travel, but I just looked this out to read again, McKie is a versatile wordsmith like Hunter Davies, finds interest, fascination in 'ordinary' places
..
Two books entitled 'Flying Scotsman' sit together in my library. One is a worthy account of a famous locomotive, the other is by Graeme Obree who had success in cycle sport using unconventional equipment and techniques, quite exciting
..
Does anyone else have suggestions for bus + tram books?
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,305
Jack Simmons is well worth reading, and certainly his one-volume book The Railways of Britain will give exactly that general overall grasp that you refer to. His more detailed works The Railway in Town and Country 1830-1914 and The Victorian Railway are in my opinion the best yet produced on the 19th century railway as a whole, and as part of society, perhaps because they are the work of a professional historian and not a nuts and bolts railway specialist. I don't think you would find them either heavy or super-detailed. Certainly Simmons is in a different class to Hamilton Ellis (who, nevertheless had many admirable points and was a more engaging writer with an artist's eye for picturesque detail).

Simmons's The Railways of Britain anyway, strikes me as per "yours, above", worth reading: should maybe screw up my courage and give it a go. I'm a lover of Hamilton Ellis; enjoy his lyrical style / "aesthetic" more than "super-scholarly" bent / partiality for charming lesser lines. (I have heard it suggested by some, that Ellis's accuracy in his railway histories is occasionally suspect -- he had a bit of a tendency to "wing it".)

I stand amazed and impressed by the detail of J.I.C. Boyd's research on the Welsh narrow gauge lines but no one ever accused him of being readable.

Boyd on the Ffestiniog (I haven't read any of his material on its neighbouring lines): I concur -- encyclopedically knowledgeable, but dry. I find that he could, on occasion, write entertainingly: a book of his -- library-borrowed by me once -- on the Talyllyn from opening to passing into preservation hands, I found to contain plenty of agreeable anecdotal stuff, and not "scholarly to a scary extent"; and in his extreme old age (though his writing remained then on the whole, highly coherent), he produced a couple of books of general reminiscence about railwaying-and-allied experiences in the course of his life -- one re Great Britain (which I've never seen), and one re Ireland (North and Republic), which he loved but I don't think ever wrote on in "historian mode". I found the Irish one of this pair, fascinating and poignant (and very envy-prompting toward J.I.C., re all the wonderful stuff he got to experience in Ireland -- his first visit there, as a kid in 1933). I owned the Irish book, but, maddeningly, it seems to have gone missing -- have thoughts of perhaps seeking to replace it, and get the GB one as well...

An American railroad buff who was also a professional economist and wrote the standard work on the "interurban" electric lines in the States (George Hilton) once proposed a law, that the amount of detailed research on a given railway was in inverse proportion to its real importance; that's why the S&D or the M&GN or the Cambrian got better coverage than the CLC (or the LNWR until M.C. Reed's book).

As regards this law of Mr. Hilton's: my sentiments are "And that's exactly as it should be !" -- silently echoed from heaven, I'd like to think; by such as Bryan Morgan, and Hamilton Ellis and Boyd as above ;) ...

The book I’ve that I’ve most enjoyed recently was Narrow Gauge by the Sudanese Red Sea Coast by Henry Gunston. Bought it on a whim when I saw if offered on FB marketplace. It’s a fairly standard minor railway history, containing pretty much all the information known about the line, but it’s engagingly written and the subject has a certain romance.

Am intrigued by your mention of this one. I haven't read the book, or indeed to my knowledge, ever seen a copy; but I'd heard of it somewhere -- I rather suspect, via a review in the late lamented Continental Railway Journal. The chief line dealt with, the 600mm gauge Tokar -- Trinkitat Light, would certainly seem to rank high in the annals of "highly obscure and geographically remote narrow gauge" ! Wiki indicates that its working life was 1922 -- 52; and that it was constructed and set up with World War I battlefront-light-railways surplus equipment, including Simplex internal-combustion locos (it never used steam). If I have things rightly, it was not a public carrier -- was an agricultural outfit, instituted to serve local cotton-growing undertakings.

One envisages very few enthusiasts ever getting to this line (or, dare I say, wanting to) -- though clearly someone did, hence the book ! Fancy brings to mind Charles S. Small, whom I've mentioned upthread. Small, in his "master-work" Far Wheels, gives a few pages to the French island of Reunion in the Indian Ocean (a fairly close neighbour of Mauritius). In Small's view, the only positive attribute of Reunion was his rating it the most obscure and geographically-remote place with a functioning railway (a quite extensive metre-gauge, public one) which he had ever visited -- reckoning that few other enthusiasts, however venturesome, would be likely to emulate him in that. Otherwise, per the book, it struck him as a horrible place; and he found the railway (all-diesel even in 1954) dreary. Am fantasising about a bragging contest between Small and a rival globetrotting railfan; Small cites Reunion -- the other guy ripostes: "Pooh ! I'll see your Reunion and raise you the Tokar -- Trinkitat !"
 
Last edited:

AJM580

Member
Joined
31 Jan 2016
Messages
616
Location
Norwich
Been reading both volumes of David Maidment's memoirs. The second one, An Indian Summer of Steam covers some interesting trips to France & Germany in search of the last Steam workings, plus some highlights of his work for BR and the Railway Children Charity
 

talltim

Established Member
Joined
17 Jan 2010
Messages
2,454
@Calthrop The Tokar - Trinkitat Light railway was preceded by another short line from Trinkitat to the wells at El Teb, a small fort. This was built in 1895 to 18” gauge and had an inverted saddle tank Bagnall named Rameses. This loco was abandoned and became buried in sand, but was excavated again in 1921 when the newer line was built.
Having had a look at Tokar on google earth it seems a pretty desolate place, although fairly large. Half is built on a grid pattern and the other half is random, the railway came from the north and ran west along the northern edge of the town to the cotton market with a spur south to the town market and a mosque (which used the railway to bring the building materials in)
 
Last edited:

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,305
@Calthrop The Tokar - Trinkitat Light railway was preceded by another short line from Trinkitat to the wells at El Teb, a small fort. This was built in 1895 to 18” gauge and had an inverted saddle tank Bagnall named Rameses. This loco was abandoned and became buried in sand, but was excavated again in 1921 when the newer line was built.

This set-up is seeming -- as well as prodigiously far-flung -- progressively more crazy (in the nicest possible way). I'm feeling increasingly inclined to get the book !
 

birchesgreen

Established Member
Joined
16 Jun 2020
Messages
5,153
Location
Birmingham
I've started reading A.J. Mullay's "Grouping Britain's Railways" on the formation of the "Big 4" and whether it was a good idea or not. Its a well written and well researched book, unfortunately it does suffer from the modern disease in not being proof read properly, even the second paragraph in the intro is missing a word which completely changes the meaning of a sentence (luckily the rest of the paragraph helps out). Just annoys me - the lack of stuff being proofed plagues me in my job too so its really something i hate! Despite that its a good read.
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
11,816
Well annoying when printers introduce numerous spelling mitsakes that weren't ever in the final draft. ;)
 

Western Sunset

Established Member
Joined
23 Dec 2014
Messages
2,511
Location
Wimborne, Dorset
May I give another mention to Grinling's "History of the Great Northern"? I recently got one off eBay and it's a cracking read. Written at the end of the 19th century, it takes a different look at the history of a railway. Not a dry list of dates or engine numbers, but it delves into the politics behind the building (or not) of lines and various amalgamations which did (or didn't) happen. It's a refreshing read; a pity more histories aren't like this. The author's father was a high-up official in the GN, which doubtless helped in him accessing information and opening a few doors.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,305
I reckon an interesting "discovery" of mine (others may disagree) -- a person and a work, mention whereof I have not heard or read from anyone else. A book which some years ago, I came upon by chance -- I think, among second-hand books on sale on some preserved line -- and bought. Titled The Railway Journeys of my Childhood, by one Brigadier John Faviell. This gentleman was born in 1898 -- he is obviously now deceased: it would seem that he was never a famous or indeed not-so-famous name among the railway-enthusiast community of those of his generation. From preambles to the main content of the book, it would appear that its general publication was due to un-looked-for "happenstance" -- through the good offices of the writer of its Foreword: Bernard Kaukas, BR's Chief Architect 1968 - 77, and Director of Environment 1977 - 82. Kaukas received from a friend of Brig. Faviell's (without the latter's knowledge) a sample of Faviell's artwork and written descriptions thereof; impressed and intrigued, he made contact with Faviell -- then in his eighties, but clearly still highly "together": result was full-scale publication in 1983 of TRJomC, which project -- pictures and words -- the author had initially embarked on as a private one, to entertain and inform his step-great-grandchildren.

The Brigadier's book might be likened in some sort, to The Trains We Loved by the more famous, roughly coeval (some ten years younger) C. Hamilton Ellis -- only, a somewhat for-kids, and homespun, version of same. This is not meant disparagingly: Faviell's offering is both charming, and in its own right of great interest. Reminiscences of his experiences of Britain's railways; between his very early boyhood, and World War I -- in the latter part of which he saw active service: copiously illustrated by the author, in the form of many black-and-white line drawings, and some thirty water-colour paintings, usually full-page, in the book's a little over a hundred (quite large) pages. These pictures -- both kinds -- are done with plainly loving care: but the author is clearly a self-taught artist, of the "primitive" kind (in the visual arts, not necessarily a disapproving term) -- proportions and details of locomotives and stock are often obviously wrong; nonetheless, the pictures capture the time and place, to a nicety. The written text is competently and literately rendered: tailored to a juvenile readership, but absolutely not "talking down to" or "dumbed-down" -- and the content is, in a wide variety of ways, fascinating.

The author's family lived during his childhood and adolescence, in Greater London: this circumstance, and the good fortune of having a variety of hospitable "visitable and visited" relatives dwelling at places in assorted directions a good way out of the metropolis, allowed him some experience of nearly all the pre-Grouping companies which worked out of London (and, of what would become the London Underground) -- he seems to have pretty-much missed out on the LB&SC and the Great Central, but "you can't have everything".

Boarding school at Cheltenham gave him interesting experiences of the GWR: in the form of, en route from / to London (not via Swindon, but via Kingham per slip coach); and branch lines in the Forest of Dean. This school location also gave him a splendid opportunity to bag the whole route length of the Midland & South Western Junction Railway. The 1914 camp immediately after the end of the summer term, of his school's Officers' Training Corps, of course including the author; took place at Tidworth on Salisbury Plain -- served by the M&SWJ, at the opposite end of its route from Andoversford near Cheltenham: the Corps's special train was hauled over same, by an M&SWJ 2-4-0 (depicted in a black-and-white sketch). After a week of the camp -- in rather distressingly rugged conditions, per the author's description -- the lads (early / mid-teens) were informed that a state of war with Germany had come about; as a consequence of which the camp's programme was ending ahead of schedule: everyone was to pack up and march before dawn, to the M&SWJ's Ludgershall station. So, very early rising, hasty dressing and ablutions (or none of the latter), and off on foot to Ludgershall: where an LSWR mixed-traffic 4-4-0 was waiting with a special train for Waterloo, departing 0630; this getting the author the last bit of the M&SWJ, from Ludgershall to joining with the L&SW main at Red Posts Junction west of Andover. On the kids' arrival and de-training at Waterloo: the not-very-clued-up passengers on the station at the time, were simultaneously full of admiration for these (untidily) uniformed youngsters, ready and eager to meet the foe; and disconcerted by the impression which they got, that Britain was already in such desperate straits that these scruffy urchins were all that she had left, to pit against the menacing Prussian hordes.

In my opinion, this book is altogether a thing of delight -- can thoroughly recommend it.
 

Cowley

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Global Moderator
Joined
15 Apr 2016
Messages
15,778
Location
Devon
I reckon an interesting "discovery" of mine (others may disagree) -- a person and a work, mention whereof I have not heard or read from anyone else. A book which some years ago, I came upon by chance -- I think, among second-hand books on sale on some preserved line -- and bought. Titled The Railway Journeys of my Childhood, by one Brigadier John Faviell. This gentleman was born in 1898 -- he is obviously now deceased: it would seem that he was never a famous or indeed not-so-famous name among the railway-enthusiast community of those of his generation. From preambles to the main content of the book, it would appear that its general publication was due to un-looked-for "happenstance" -- through the good offices of the writer of its Foreword: Bernard Kaukas, BR's Chief Architect 1968 - 77, and Director of Environment 1977 - 82. Kaukas received from a friend of Brig. Faviell's (without the latter's knowledge) a sample of Faviell's artwork and written descriptions thereof; impressed and intrigued, he made contact with Faviell -- then in his eighties, but clearly still highly "together": result was full-scale publication in 1983 of TRJomC, which project -- pictures and words -- the author had initially embarked on as a private one, to entertain and inform his step-great-grandchildren.

The Brigadier's book might be likened in some sort, to The Trains We Loved by the more famous, roughly coeval (some ten years younger) C. Hamilton Ellis -- only, a somewhat for-kids, and homespun, version of same. This is not meant disparagingly: Faviell's offering is both charming, and in its own right of great interest. Reminiscences of his experiences of Britain's railways; between his very early boyhood, and World War I -- in the latter part of which he saw active service: copiously illustrated by the author, in the form of many black-and-white line drawings, and some thirty water-colour paintings, usually full-page, in the book's a little over a hundred (quite large) pages. These pictures -- both kinds -- are done with plainly loving care: but the author is clearly a self-taught artist, of the "primitive" kind (in the visual arts, not necessarily a disapproving term) -- proportions and details of locomotives and stock are often obviously wrong; nonetheless, the pictures capture the time and place, to a nicety. The written text is competently and literately rendered: tailored to a juvenile readership, but absolutely not "talking down to" or "dumbed-down" -- and the content is, in a wide variety of ways, fascinating.

The author's family lived during his childhood and adolescence, in Greater London: this circumstance, and the good fortune of having a variety of hospitable "visitable and visited" relatives dwelling at places in assorted directions a good way out of the metropolis, allowed him some experience of nearly all the pre-Grouping companies which worked out of London (and, of what would become the London Underground) -- he seems to have pretty-much missed out on the LB&SC and the Great Central, but "you can't have everything".

Boarding school at Cheltenham gave him interesting experiences of the GWR: in the form of, en route from / to London (not via Swindon, but via Kingham per slip coach); and branch lines in the Forest of Dean. This school location also gave him a splendid opportunity to bag the whole route length of the Midland & South Western Junction Railway. The 1914 camp immediately after the end of the summer term, of his school's Officers' Training Corps, of course including the author; took place at Tidworth on Salisbury Plain -- served by the M&SWJ, at the opposite end of its route from Andoversford near Cheltenham: the Corps's special train was hauled over same, by an M&SWJ 2-4-0 (depicted in a black-and-white sketch). After a week of the camp -- in rather distressingly rugged conditions, per the author's description -- the lads (early / mid-teens) were informed that a state of war with Germany had come about; as a consequence of which the camp's programme was ending ahead of schedule: everyone was to pack up and march before dawn, to the M&SWJ's Ludgershall station. So, very early rising, hasty dressing and ablutions (or none of the latter), and off on foot to Ludgershall: where an LSWR mixed-traffic 4-4-0 was waiting with a special train for Waterloo, departing 0630; this getting the author the last bit of the M&SWJ, from Ludgershall to joining with the L&SW main at Red Posts Junction west of Andover. On the kids' arrival and de-training at Waterloo: the not-very-clued-up passengers on the station at the time, were simultaneously full of admiration for these (untidily) uniformed youngsters, ready and eager to meet the foe; and disconcerted by the impression which they got, that Britain was already in such desperate straits that these scruffy urchins were all that she had left, to pit against the menacing Prussian hordes.

In my opinion, this book is altogether a thing of delight -- can thoroughly recommend it.
That does very interesting. I’m going to pop that on my list of books to consider buying.
That’s an era in time on the railways that I could probably do with finding a bit more about actually.
 

S&CLER

Member
Joined
11 Jan 2020
Messages
785
Location
southport
I don't know how many enthusiasts still have their railway periodicals bound. I'm well on the way to completing a 100-year run of the Railway Magazine for 1897-1997. I stopped taking it then because it ceased to be interesting, and also has the worst page design of any railway periodical. But access to any information needs a good index, and for a long run preferably a cumulative index. In the bad old days before computers, indexes were prepared manually and usually arrived promptly in the January issue; now, with the benefit of digital technology they are often months late, or not provided, or else only available by downloading. A periodical that doesn't index its contents is effectively admitting that they have no permanent value.

Has anyone ever produced a cumulative index to the RM? It sounds like the kind of project that the NRM library might undertake. It might not pay for itself as a hard copy publication, but as a paid-for online resource it might well work. The same would apply to an index to the 19th century periodicals from Herapath onwards, including the Illustrated London News, which had much of interest on railways.
 

Taunton

Established Member
Joined
1 Aug 2013
Messages
10,086
In the bad old days before computers, indexes were prepared manually and usually arrived promptly in the January issue; now, with the benefit of digital technology they are often months late, or not provided, or else only available by downloading. A periodical that doesn't index its contents is effectively admitting that they have no permanent value.
Always amused me in the Ian Allan era of magazines, they produced three, Modern Railways, Railway World and Modern Tramway.

Modern Railways had the key business turnover and the editorial staff, the index came out in maybe the following March, just based on headings. Railway World was apparently a one-man editor job, but its index came out in January. Modern Tramway, which was put together by amateurs, and just printed and distributed by Ian Allan to professional standards as something of a personal favour, actually managed to index itself for the year in its final, December issue, including all the articles in that copy, even the news items, with detailed cross-references of article contents. Apparently done by an enthusiast schoolmaster who did each issue as they came and just worked with the production team on that final one.
 

bspahh

Established Member
Joined
5 Jan 2017
Messages
1,736
I don't know how many enthusiasts still have their railway periodicals bound. I'm well on the way to completing a 100-year run of the Railway Magazine for 1897-1997. I stopped taking it then because it ceased to be interesting, and also has the worst page design of any railway periodical. But access to any information needs a good index, and for a long run preferably a cumulative index. In the bad old days before computers, indexes were prepared manually and usually arrived promptly in the January issue; now, with the benefit of digital technology they are often months late, or not provided, or else only available by downloading. A periodical that doesn't index its contents is effectively admitting that they have no permanent value.

Has anyone ever produced a cumulative index to the RM? It sounds like the kind of project that the NRM library might undertake. It might not pay for itself as a hard copy publication, but as a paid-for online resource it might well work. The same would apply to an index to the 19th century periodicals from Herapath onwards, including the Illustrated London News, which had much of interest on railways.

https://www.steamindex.com/library/campbell.htm mentions that there are three copies of an index to the Railway Magazine, from 1897-1957 held at at London, York and Edinburgh. I think "Ottley" means the bibliographies by George Ottley https://www.amazon.co.uk/George-Ottley/e/B001KDSZL2

www.steamindex.com is written by Kevin Jones (my father-in-law).
 

Ashley Hill

Established Member
Joined
8 Dec 2019
Messages
3,263
Location
The West Country
One thing I find annoying about specialist railway books is that they are often one print run and OOP before you know it and never reprinted. Many often command a high price second hand too or more often impossible to obtain. It took me some years to obtain Dave Cannings book about signalling on the B&H and it wasn't cheap. Why do some authors/publishers not reprint books now and again,it's so frustrating!
 

Busaholic

Veteran Member
Joined
7 Jun 2014
Messages
14,086
Why do some authors/publishers not reprint books now and again,it's so frustrating!
Because it's fraught with difficulties and is not the cashcow that many assume it would be. If done as a labour of love and you're prepared to lose money, then go ahead. How will you even inform the general public, most of whom have a yawning uninterest, of the new print run, assuming a regular specialist publisher is not involved, and through which channels do you hope to sell it? The Amazon behemoth will want a large cut (of nothing) for subsuming it among tens of thousands of similar (in their eyes) products: if you take the bold move of distributing it independently, you'll find the cost of sending out individual copies to subscribers (say) will be charged by the Post Office at somewhat less preferential rates than Amazon get.
 

Ashley Hill

Established Member
Joined
8 Dec 2019
Messages
3,263
Location
The West Country
Because it's fraught with difficulties and is not the cashcow that many assume it would be. If done as a labour of love and you're prepared to lose money, then go ahead. How will you even inform the general public, most of whom have a yawning uninterest, of the new print run, assuming a regular specialist publisher is not involved, and through which channels do you hope to sell it? The Amazon behemoth will want a large cut (of nothing) for subsuming it among tens of thousands of similar (in their eyes) products: if you take the bold move of distributing it independently, you'll find the cost of sending out individual copies to subscribers (say) will be charged by the Post Office at somewhat less preferential rates than Amazon get.
I take your point about cost/risk but I believe some books should get a second run. I'm not going to make suggestions here as that wouldn't be appropriate but when a book that was only released 20yrs ago and instantly sold out now sells for a £100 at auctions does indicate a demand amongst new aficionados of that subject. (ps,it wasn't the Canning book).
 

Mcr Warrior

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Jan 2009
Messages
11,816
Depends on the size of the print run, I suppose. Some books are now seemingly being published on a "print on demand" basis, but the print quality of some of these often seems a bit blurry.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,305
Book acquired a year or so ago -- at a "distress sale" price, marked-down to a fraction of the original, from a bookshop which was about to close. Lavishly endowed with photographs, maps, and occasionally pictures of other provenance -- measuring 24 by 21 cm., thus admirably equipped for photographic "showcasing". Approximately 200 pages. Title Lost Railway Journeys from Around the World, by Anthony Lambert; published 2018.

The "Around the World" claim is, for sure, lived up to: book divided into sections pertaining to Europe (including the British Isles), Asia, Australasia, the Americas, and Africa; with, in each section, a number of chapters varying between eleven and three, each devoted to a particular line / route. There is plentiful -- basically informed and literate -- text accompanying the lavish illustrative material. Some of the chapters / lines are to me, fascinating: for instance, the Nice -- Digne metre-gauge line's very-long-gone one-time matching route (same parent company) parallel to the coast but way inland, from near Nice via Grasse and Draguignan, to Meyrargues near Aix-en-Provence (line perished in / a few years after World War II -- from, it is widely reckoned, a mixture of late-in-war damage, and reprehensible local corruption and skulduggery).

Much in the book, of great interest -- and many of the pictures are wonderful -- though some IMO, rather "hack / ubiquitous". I feel rather Scrooge-ish in expressing negative thoughts concerning the book -- but admit to a slightly "hinky" feeling, concerning the author's seemingly all-over-the-metaphorical-map definition of "lost-ness". His chapters range from covering genuine delectable, conventional lines and routes which have gone for good; to freakish relatively, or highly, short-lived outfits
which vanished very long ago (the Listowel & Ballybunion; and the Patiala State Monorail Trainway [the thing in India's rail museum at Delhi -- monorail per rail, with the huge wheel at one side, which ran on the adjacent road]). Regular passenger working across the Victoria Falls Bridge -- can still be done, on occasional tourist / railfan specials; and there are still respective regular passenger services to the respective Zimbabwean / Zambian towns on either side. "Massawa -- Asmara -- Agordat" in Eritrea -- most of the chapter and its pictures, are about the recreated-for-preservation Massawa -- Asmara section; onward east from Asmara, long out of use and only briefly mentioned, I feel to "legitimise" the "lost" meme. Australia's "Ghan" -- OK, the 3ft 6in line to Alice Springs, largely commemorated here, is gone; but there are now standard-gauge services, albeit route differences, to "the Alice", and indeed on to Darwin.

OK, I'm a miserable, negative "whatever" -- but just-mentioned stuff (there's a fair bit more of it, beyond examples given) has me feeling a little uncomfortably, that the book's author / other progenitors might have been more focused on -- in their own interests -- slapping together a railway "coffee-table" book (the photographs carrying most of the load); than wishing disinterestedly, to entertain / educate the railway-enthusiast community. Granted: doing what I, as just-above, suspect the author of, isn't a crime; and it's quite possible for the just-referred-to seeming opposites, to co-exist in author-and-associates' intentions; and I'm a miserable so-and-so who would whinge about anything, probably up to and including Heaven...
 
Last edited:

Busaholic

Veteran Member
Joined
7 Jun 2014
Messages
14,086
I take your point about cost/risk but I believe some books should get a second run. I'm not going to make suggestions here as that wouldn't be appropriate but when a book that was only released 20yrs ago and instantly sold out now sells for a £100 at auctions does indicate a demand amongst new aficionados of that subject. (ps,it wasn't the Canning book).
Yes, there are individual books that fall into that category. One in my own specialist subject (London buses) is rarely priced much lower than £130 for second hand copies, because it is recognised as being the definitive book (amongst many) on the subject. I'm often asked to consider selling my own almost pristine copy, but I'd never do so, or lend it to anyone.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,305
A -- for me -- highly fascinating book: which I have owned for some years, but only recently re-read. Coming Up With The Goods ["pun intended"] by Michael Pearson, published 1999 -- when the then-obtaining EWS rail-freight undertaking, was fairly new.

To me -- one of the septuagenarian hopeless-sentimentalist school of (non-?) thought, who tend to feel that everything which was worthwhile on Britain's railways, ceased to be during the 1960s -- this book gives at least, pause for reconsideration. Brings home that there was in fact very interesting stuff happening on a variety of Great Britain's rail lines, after "the evil year of '68". Also gives rise to, on my part, some degree of shame concerning my having 90% disregarded and set at naught, Great Britain's post-1968 rail scene -- save for "getting in the bag" hitherto not-travelled-by-me lines, until I wearied of that pursuit also, and mostly ceased to engage in it; including my never having become au fait with our rail system's sundry diesel loco types since first introduction of same (Pearson knows them all, and joyously identifies them in their haulage roles on his assorted EWS journeyings of which he tells). Attempted self-exoneration to some degree: I am a highly non-technical sort; my railway enthusiasm has always tended strongly to the aesthetic / vague-and-woolly-love side, so that -- for all my adoration of steam traction -- I was for long, none too good even on the niceties of different steam classes. Resembling here, my a-lifetime-ago hero and role model Bryan Morgan, who was very much "about" the aesthetic and sentimental, not the technical, aspects of the hobby; who writes, "I doubt if the Walschaerts gear holds any very mind-cracking secrets, but I simply cannot be troubled to learn even how to spell it".

Pearson's book concerns assorted non-passenger journeys, in great geographical and functional variety, carried out by EWS on Great Britain's rail network in the late 1990s. The author travelled -- with official permission -- on the runs involved; most often, in the loco cab. There are comprised a "round dozen" of chapters: a journey per chapter, with a pretty-much universal twelve pages per chapter -- albeit big pages with smallish, though excellently clear, print -- and in each chapter a map, of excellent clarity, of the relevant journey, and numerous illustrative colour photographs of various sizes: one is inclined to feel the book to be an impressive "much in little" feat.

Mr. Pearson's erudition and comprehensive coverage, have me in awe -- plus, he writes smoothly, literately, and in an agreeably chatty and readable, often humorous, fashion: having the reader greatly wishful of being themself able to experience his journeys of a couple of decades ago (many of which -- at least as per my poor understanding of the country's rail situation -- are not happening, and cannot be experienced, nowadays). The author's journeys and their routes and what seen along same; and relevant historical reflections; and the nature and rationale of the traffic carried on each; and the railway employees with whom / under whose guidance he made the runs -- conversations with them reproduced, and their careers and positions, and reminiscences, told of -- sometimes all-but "thumbnail" mini-biographies; contribute to IMO a beautiful balance of all aspects, and very-readably written of. This guy strikes me as a writer of much talent -- to the point that he could successfully tweak, to generate interest, that celebrated mythical and boring document the List of Huntingdonshire Cabmen.

An interesting thing, at any rate to such as me: some few of the older locomen, talking and time spent with whom the author recounts, had in their youth worked regularly on steam locomotives in everyday service. A couple of decades back, it was entirely possible for this to be the case with someone in late middle age; and indeed for him to have worked on steam earlier and longer than just for its final few BR years.

The dozen-odd journeys cover a splendidly varied-and-inclusive geographical spread of England and Scotland (Wales gets sold a bit short; but in an imperfect world, someone or something usually ends up having to be the loser). I won't weary people with the entire list -- a sample is: Ayr to Fife with coal; Bristol to Penzance with the mail; and King's Lynn to Doncaster with sand. The last two, have to be my best-liked chapters in the book. Bristol to Penzance... tells of a scene which obtained a couple of decades ago but has now effectively vanished: night mail trains nationwide (this in the West Country, only one of many) with Travelling Post Office sorters frenetically doing their thing en route, and a public posting-box slot in the coach side, affording people a very last chance of getting correspondence notionally "collected" and sent on its way that day. On this journey, the majority of the author's time is spent not on the loco, but in the sorting coaches, observing the postal staff's doings and -- their gruelling work-load permitting -- talking with them.

A lot of the recounted journeyings are over main-line trackage; but some involve also remote, long-since freight-only, branches or "twigs" of the system -- one such (on a journey not among those I name here) covering a remnant few miles of a branch which lost its passenger service in 1925 ! Part of the appeal for me, of King's Lynn to Doncaster... is that its earlier half or so, traverses parts of the world where my childhood and adolescence were spent. Its starting-point is very much an out-of-the-way freight-remnant location: Middleton Towers, three miles east of King's Lynn on the one-time secondary route K.L. -- Dereham, which lost its passenger service -- and, I understand, freight beyond Middleton Towers -- in 1968 (I had the good fortune to travel over the route, once, a few years before closure). At Middleton Towers, sand was quarried on a big scale, hence the retention of the three-mile stub: the chapter's train conveys sand thence -- initially over a highly roundabout route -- to a glassworks near Doncaster: as ever, the run is delightfully and fascinatingly recounted.

Altogether, an offering which is becoming one among the small list of my "very top favourite" railway books; and one which I feel I could heartily recommend to not-far-off any enthusiast, whatever their particular angle on the hobby.
 

EbbwJunction1

Established Member
Joined
25 Mar 2010
Messages
1,565
Does anyone know anything about The Big British Railway Puzzle Book which is published in paperback by the National Railway Museum, please? I've just had a trailer for it from Waterstone's, and although it looks interesting, I'm wondering whether it's value for money at £11.99 (reduced from £14.99)? Thanks.
 

Calthrop

Established Member
Joined
6 Dec 2015
Messages
3,305
A surprise Christmas gift for me -- from a long-time friend who is well aware of my railway enthusiasm, though sharing it to only a small extent -- was Britain's Hidden Railways by Julian Holland, published by The Times newspaper -- first publ. 2018. "One of a quite well-established kind"; but IMO good fun, shading into poignant: a "travelogue" book of a chosen fifty former rail lines throughout Great Britain plus the Isle of Man, which have been converted into long-distance paths / cycleways, plus the odd preservation set-up. Plentiful informative text -- good on the history of the routes concerned, as well as their present "incarnations"; and copiously illustrated -- about half-and-half: present-day situation; vis-a-vis pictures taken (earliest, pre-WWII) on the relevant lines, when they were still rail-served.

At the risk of being reckoned to be bragging, consequent on the accident of my being born at the end of the 1940s -- extra poignancy for me by reason of my good fortune in having travelled on a considerable number of the routes featured, when they were still railways (a considerable number also, I missed). By happenstance -- a couple of things to remark on, involving the city of Lincoln. The eastern end of the one-time Lancashire, Derbyshire & East Coast concern's route -- Dukeries Junction on the East Coast Main Line, to Lincoln -- is now a recreational path between Fledborough and Lincoln. I feel fairly sure that some 4 / 5 decades ago, I travelled over the Dukeries Jun. -- Lincoln section, on a railtour (likely, organised by the Branch Line Society); but "what with one thing and another", I'm not 100% certain. Another section of the book deals with the former route Lincoln -- Woodhall Junction -- Boston; the majority of same (a significant rail-line-route part in the middle, is inaccessible) now made over into a footpath / cycleway. A laudable undertaking; but I hate the thing's title -- proudly "bannered" in the book's relevant chapter -- "The Water Rail Way". I greatly dislike oh-so-archly-witty "marketing branding" namings of things, of this kind -- weak and far-fetched pun involving the pathway's being a former railway, "watery" in that it runs closely beside the river Witham; plus the association with the bird species the Water Rail (Rallus aquaticus). For me -- to quote a favourite American author of mine, "funny like a crutch" ... just a Scrooge-ish personal pet hate.
 

Taunton

Established Member
Joined
1 Aug 2013
Messages
10,086
I was the recipient of the "Big British Railway Puzzle Book" https://www.theworks.co.uk/p/brain-...MI9c695fjr7QIVh-3tCh0A9AKGEAQYASABEgLhMvD_BwE , already seemingly remaindered down to one third of its original 2020 publication price. Strangely it seems co-published by the NRM but there's not much sign of that inside, and I suspect it's the type of commercial "co-production" that the Science Museum and others think is the way forward for the museum staff's salary and pension funding. It has a low-level summary of British Railway history, written it seems for an adult readership, at least without the notable apparent blunders that often plague such outsider publications, but it's mostly various puzzle pages like something for a 10 year old. In the 1950s when this was a top age group for trainspotters it would probably have hit a big market; now it seems to fall strangely between stools. There are various throwbacks - several of the children's puzzles are within a correctly scaled 1950s BR double-sausage totem graphic, otherwise unexplained.
 

Ashley Hill

Established Member
Joined
8 Dec 2019
Messages
3,263
Location
The West Country
Some years ago I purchased Tim Helme's excellent book "Derby Trainman". It has since been reissued as Derby Trainman 2nd edition & Lost Lines. Is there much difference between the two books to warrant buying the new edition?
 

birchesgreen

Established Member
Joined
16 Jun 2020
Messages
5,153
Location
Birmingham
One of my Christmas presents was "Seats of London", a guide to London Transport moquette patterns, how they are designed, made et cetera. Best railway (though also covers other transport) book got for ages.
 

Busaholic

Veteran Member
Joined
7 Jun 2014
Messages
14,086
I was the recipient of the "Big British Railway Puzzle Book" https://www.theworks.co.uk/p/brain-...MI9c695fjr7QIVh-3tCh0A9AKGEAQYASABEgLhMvD_BwE , already seemingly remaindered down to one third of its original 2020 publication price. Strangely it seems co-published by the NRM but there's not much sign of that inside, and I suspect it's the type of commercial "co-production" that the Science Museum and others think is the way forward for the museum staff's salary and pension funding. It has a low-level summary of British Railway history, written it seems for an adult readership, at least without the notable apparent blunders that often plague such outsider publications, but it's mostly various puzzle pages like something for a 10 year old. In the 1950s when this was a top age group for trainspotters it would probably have hit a big market; now it seems to fall strangely between stools. There are various throwbacks - several of the children's puzzles are within a correctly scaled 1950s BR double-sausage totem graphic, otherwise unexplained.
Off topic, but salient to your observations. Just before I gave up bookselling, or it gave me up, not sure which, I ordered a copy of the annual Whitaker's Almanack, cover price £45 but obtainable by me for a 40% discount on the cover price. It came out in November, just in time for the Christmas market. I was flabbergasted to see this book on sale for £10 in The Works a mere week later, and phoned Bloomsbury Books to demand to know what was going on. A very embarrassed Sales Director told me a mistake had obviously been made and he'd arrange for the book to be withdrawn forthwith: he later said only one branch had been supplied with the book, which I took with a pinch of salt but couldn't investigate further. I did receive a few choice Bloomsbury titles free in the ensuing days, which you could interpret as 'hush money' if you wish; I was an occasional letter writer to the Bookseller mag in those days, usually adopting an acerbic tone on something or other, but I neglected to write on this occasion! My point is that 'remaindering' is not always what it seems and some of it stretches legislation on pricing indications for public consumption to the limit and, I'd suggest, beyond in some cases.
 

Gloster

Established Member
Joined
4 Sep 2020
Messages
8,423
Location
Up the creek
I picked up copies of Whitaker’s in the local discount shop on two or three occasions. The last time it was the 2014 edition, of which a couple of copies were on sale before the end of the previous year. I think that the 2012 or 2013 edition was also available in the shop before the end of the previous year.
 

Top