Which is best? Wensley, FrostedOrange and JayBee60163 want your opinion!

[wensley]

Hi,

We all know each other away from the forum and met up for a day or two at the NYMR gala, taking plenty of photos in the process. However, we decided we would like a separate opinion on who had the best shots. Below please find three sets of images, A, B and C. We would be grateful if you could pick your favourite and vote in the attached poll.

We also welcome feedback on the images and welcome you to rip them to shreds.

For anyone with a good eye the shots were all take on full manual with a Cannon 60D, Cannon 500D and a Fuji HS10. Which is which?!

We look forward to hearing your comments and seeing who is the winner,
Jonathon, Jack and Nic

* Please note the random white line is a mistake that was made on photoshop when merging the images! Sorry

 

[HST Power]

They all look exactly the same to me! But I think I'll go for Set A.

 

[T163R]

I'll go for Set A too.

 

[wensley]

Just to clarify...the photos are meant to look the same apart from the lighting in a few of them and the composition varies slightly. Different cameras, different styles, subtly different settings.

Ta all for votes so far!

 

[Peter Mugridge]

I voted for set B; I like the deeper evening like colours.

 

[curly42]

Set B ruled out totally - too much saturation.
The shot of the Deltic I would go for set A,mainly because I feel it's better positioned.
The 2 class 20s,set C.
The 31 + 37,set C.
Overall I feel that set C is the more satisfying in terms of colour balance/exposure and placement of subject,although the Deltic shot is cropped too close to the edge for my tastes.The colours in set A are,I feel,a little too bland.

 

[Drimnagh Road]

Is this the most pointless poll in Rail Forums history?

 

[HST Power]

Is this the most pointless poll in Rail Forums history?

I don't think so, it's nice to see a bit of extra competition.

 

[MidnightFlyer]

Set A

 

[windoze11]

Set A for me . set b looks to Dark

 

[valenta]

Couldn't really see much difference between A and C, so I went for C.

 

[wensley]

Thanks to all for the votes and comments!
I've won it with the HS10, JayBee60163 is second and FrostedOrange a very close third.
Thanks again

 

[Peter Mugridge]

Who was which set please?

 

[wensley]

Who was which set please?

A - JayBee60163 (60D)
B - Wensley (HS10)
C - Frosted Orange (500D)

 

[Peter Mugridge]

Interesting; from the comments being posted I was beginning to think I was the only one who had voted for set B...

 

[YorkshireBear]

SET A for me, the position of the trains in the photograph seemed very good. HAving the front of a train in the centre ruins it for me.