• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

East Mids Area Rail Capacity

m_m

Member
Joined
27 Mar 2017
Messages
24
Hi,

Having travelled by train more widely recently, I'm starting to realise just how short and 'low capacity' trains feel on the Midland mainline and the network around Nottingham/Derby.

Jumped on an (I think) 11 coach service from Euston to Manchester the other day, and even within the coaches there seemed to be more rooms and more seats. Likewise, had to get a very long Hitachi train up past York, again, loads of room and loads of carriages.

By contrast, my local services are Emr and XC, almost always very busy, very short trains. Even the local stopper trains are half the length they need to be.

I know EMR have new trains on the way, but again these seem to be shorter units they want to couple up when they fancy it. Why not just run longer trains?

Is there any end in sight to this short train, overcrowding thing? Am I just imagining that even within the trains, the amount of space feels low due to design choices? If so, will things get better if refitted and is this planned?

Sorry if this has been covered a million times, I'd like to think things will improve at some point! Ta
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

joieman

Member
Joined
18 Feb 2024
Messages
60
Location
Loughborough
Hi,

Having travelled by train more widely recently, I'm starting to realise just how short and 'low capacity' trains feel on the Midland mainline and the network around Nottingham/Derby.

Jumped on an (I think) 11 coach service from Euston to Manchester the other day, and even within the coaches there seemed to be more rooms and more seats. Likewise, had to get a very long Hitachi train up past York, again, loads of room and loads of carriages.

By contrast, my local services are Emr and XC, almost always very busy, very short trains. Even the local stopper trains are half the length they need to be.

I know EMR have new trains on the way, but again these seem to be shorter units they want to couple up when they fancy it. Why not just run longer trains?

Is there any end in sight to this short train, overcrowding thing? Am I just imagining that even within the trains, the amount of space feels low due to design choices? If so, will things get better if refitted and is this planned?

Sorry if this has been covered a million times, I'd like to think things will improve at some point! Ta
They used to have longer trains, but they kept on chopping up the longer Meridians to redistribute the carriages to the four-car Meridians.
 

Spartacus

Established Member
Joined
25 Aug 2009
Messages
2,931
Unless St Pancras is rebuilt again, then no. The platforms are short and can only take 2x5 5 car 222s, or 2x5 car 810s, which are a specially built 24m version of the standard Hitachi AT300 unit in order to fit in St Pancras.
 

dosxuk

Established Member
Joined
2 Jan 2011
Messages
1,766
It's the 80x that are non-standard. St Pancras was rebuilt with the standard platform length to allow 10x23m or 12x20m carriages. Until the arrival of the 80x's, there were no 26m carriages on the network, allowing for 10x26m would have been seen as wasting space and money.

A standard 9x26m 80x formation would fit at St Pancras - it's only because they want to run short trains that they need the ability to split and join into halves that means they need space for 10 cars.
 

joieman

Member
Joined
18 Feb 2024
Messages
60
Location
Loughborough
It's the 80x that are non-standard. St Pancras was rebuilt with the standard platform length to allow 10x23m or 12x20m carriages. Until the arrival of the 80x's, there were no 26m carriages on the network, allowing for 10x26m would have been seen as wasting space and money.

A standard 9x26m 80x formation would fit at St Pancras - it's only because they want to run short trains that they need the ability to split and join into halves that means they need space for 10 cars.
They could run four- and five-car sets like they did with the Meridians, but I think the four-car sets would be too short to be used on their own.
 

Trainman40083

Member
Joined
29 Jan 2024
Messages
377
Location
Derby
But the message was supposed to get across "Nobody travels by train. Everyone is working from home". But passengers would not listen and still caught the train. With XC, longer trains should be more common by June 2025 thanks to extra Voyagers . Add in the return of Reading to York trains. Maybe the 158/170 refurb will see thinner seats, and of course the EMR 810s will have more seats than the 222, even as 5 cars. I guess some degree of overcrowding could be solved by removing cheap advance fares. But also, on the Regional fleet we have to consider platform length too.
 

Top