• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Search results

  1. M

    MML Electrification: progress updates

    Sorry for asking, is the Wigston to Leicester electrification ongoing now? Or pending DfT giving go-ahead permission?
  2. M

    Confirmed : HS2 West Midlands-Manchester line to be scrapped and replaced with other projects.

    From a foreigner's perspective, the HS2 plan was overly ambiguous. When Japan first built the HSR, they aimed to connect their two largest cities, much like HS2 Phase 1. They then gradually connected to other cities, following a rolling electrification plan to avoid boom and bust cycles. When...
  3. M

    Confirmed : HS2 West Midlands-Manchester line to be scrapped and replaced with other projects.

    I am not saying they are not consistent, in fact the P2a is a no brainer to go-ahead, Rishi just made a terrible decision to cancel P2 together.
  4. M

    Confirmed : HS2 West Midlands-Manchester line to be scrapped and replaced with other projects.

    To be honest, 8bn over 2019 budget for P1 is in line with most of nation's significant projects. The crossrail 1 also 30 percent overbudget. the HONG KONG HSR is also around 30 percent overbudget. It is the anti-railway PM desepartely want to show differences with his predecessors kill the...
  5. M

    Confirmed : HS2 West Midlands-Manchester line to be scrapped and replaced with other projects.

    The rolling electrification programme was blocked by him in 2021, most of mentioned projects are not new, they just copy from rolling electification plan, IRP, and union connectivity review. AND most of this project, apart from few electification, will never get delivered.
  6. M

    Confirmed : HS2 West Midlands-Manchester line to be scrapped and replaced with other projects.

    Suprisingly Keir Stamer did not directly react to Rishi's speech. And most Labour senior members keep quiet on HS2.
  7. M

    Hope Valley Capacity Scheme updates

    The electification across the Northern England was proposed in 2019 with a rolling electification plan, and blocked by Rishi himself in 2021 when he was in No 11.
  8. M

    HS2 Manchester leg scrapped: what should happen now?

    Cancelling P2a is the most idiotic decision, the cost is not high, the early work is on, and it can benefit Wales and Scotland, and Manchester. 1696411055 There are no other projects will be funded, Rishi himself sinked or at least significantly delayed the rolling electrification plan when he...
  9. M

    Confirmed : HS2 West Midlands-Manchester line to be scrapped and replaced with other projects.

    Why they even ditch B'ham to Crewe section given it is almost the easiest part to build.
  10. M

    More Delay for HS2, and how should we proceed?

    Plus if you upgrade Hope Valley Line into 125mph then the cost would be equally scare off the Treasury.
  11. M

    More Delay for HS2, and how should we proceed?

    It can be built in phrases, as Japan's HSR network started from a single line connect their two biggest city and then gradually expanded in the next 60 years, and still in expansion. The critical things is not propose something and cut it back like what Tory gov in HS2, instead choose a...
  12. M

    More Delay for HS2, and how should we proceed?

    Seems PM face a lot of pressuare from people urge him not to cut phrase 2 of HS2. On Sam Coates Sky: 'Earlier there were reports of a HS2 announcement this week. Now that’s a lot less clear and I’m told is just be in the context of the Autumn Statement in November And I’m told not to expect...
  13. M

    More Delay for HS2, and how should we proceed?

    Did him even know B'ham to Crewe and Crewe to Manchester is totally different level of challenges and difficulties hence it is dumb to axe them all together?
  14. M

    More Delay for HS2, and how should we proceed?

    For example, the first inter province high speed railway, the bill firstly set in 98.6bn CNY in 2006, but when finished in 2011, it actually cost 236bn CNY.
  15. M

    More Delay for HS2, and how should we proceed?

    This section is in Phrase 1 in anyway, the pity thing is they cancel the p2a to Crewe. For surely in P2b, a reasonable option maybe is waiting for inflation cooling down and maybe revise the design. But just cancel all phrase 2 is a mad decision. and no mega project can run on budget, in...
  16. M

    More Delay for HS2, and how should we proceed?

    Yes, it is strange all rumours did not mentioning phrase2a, instead they have said B'ham to Manchester, to me Phrase 2a B'ham to Crewe is a no-brainer for go-ahead.
  17. M

    More Delay for HS2, and how should we proceed?

    In times, they said: 'Downing Street is preparing to scrap the second leg of HS2, which will link Birmingham and Manchester, amid concerns that the costs of the project are “out of control”. So is the northern leg definitely get cancelled, or they still in discussion? Sorry for my first language...
  18. M

    The Construction of the Elizabeth Line being a "national joke"

    Construction project never run on time and on budget, not only in the UK, the rest of Europe, Asian, and American as well. 30% over budget is not too bad. For example, The HK's 9 mile sha tin central link's budget rising from HK$37.4 billion in initial planning, to HK$79.8 billion when...
  19. M

    What rolling stock could be used on East West Rail (EWR) when the line is completed?

    Alstom planning to built Hydrogen trains in 2025, maybe it has a good chance to use on EWR

Top