• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Do you consider air travel to be comfortable?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Techniquest

Veteran Member
Joined
19 Jun 2005
Messages
21,674
Location
Nowhere Heath
Do I find air travel comfortable? For the most part, yes, and I've mostly flown on low-cost airlines. After a few hours the seats do get a bit uncomfortable, but then if you're in your seat for the best part of 5 hours it's only natural to get a bit of a sore derriere.

I love 777s for the noise factor, but not so much for the legroom on average. I generally have a small enough carry-on that fits under the seat in front of me, which is handy as the overhead luggage bins are usually rammed full by everyone else. Makes it quicker for me to get ready to alight and I can get to my stuff more easily. Only thing is that takes away space to stretch my legs properly, so I do find the legs get a bit of cramp.

Which is mostly why I have a new policy on flights now, especially long-haul ones. I like a seat near the engines for the fun factor, but for comfort I prefer an aisle seat so I can easily get up when I need to. Given I can only sleep on flights when I'm past the point of exhaustion, and even then it's not for long (a couple of hours at most normally), I'd rather not have to wake someone up to leave a window seat and re-wake them up when I come back. I'm sure you can imagine how much I dislike overnight flights, a necessary evil when going around the world sadly.

Generally speaking, I don't have an issue with airports. It's part of the holiday for me, yes some airports are ridiculously overloaded with expensive shopping areas (Heathrow T5 is a perfect example, but so is Sydney), and some have poor catering choices (Vilnius I'm looking at you here), but it's just a necessary thing to deal with. If nothing else I explore the terminal as much as I can, so I can potentially pass on any wisdom, hints or tips for fellow travellers in my trip reports. A bloody good walk around the terminal is not a bad thing for both the obvious health benefits but also being active before sitting down for potentially 12+ hours is just sensible to me.

I discovered this thread by chance this morning, so apologies for catching up on it with a mighty long post! With regards to those commenting on smoking, those who do so by the doors at hospitals really annoy me. Right in front of giant no smoking signs too, indeed the whole grounds is meant to be smoke-free. Such a rule is not commonly enforced from what I've seen, which disappoints me. With regards to smoking on trains or planes, as a current partaker of nicotine, hopefully not for too much longer, I wouldn't want to sit on a flight/train journey in such an environment. I mean, the stench in those indoor smoking areas like at Abu Dhabi is just vile. Scandinavia airports do that better, as while they also have indoor areas they have special ventilation systems that suck the fumes out at all times. So you don't get the smell which is very clever. I'd personally like to see such a thing at more airports.

So, do I find flying comfortable/enjoyable? Generally, yes. Most of the time I don't have legroom issues, not even on LCCs. Only time I have had a significant issue was in the 'regular' seats on a Norwegian 787 in 2016. I'd actually like to see how I fare now on those same seats, given in 2016 I was a fair bit bigger than I am now, and that generally I find better legroom now than I did prior to 2018.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

RichJF

Member
Joined
2 Nov 2012
Messages
1,100
Location
Sussex
Very much dependant on what airline/aircraft/engine config/interior layout:

The newly refitted United 767s (Polaris) are very nice & a real pleasure to fly in transatlantic compared with a Delta one which is horrific.

The BA Dreamliner is a world away from other airlines' 787s but some of their other long-haul fleet are falling apart at the seams (777-200).
 

sprunt

Member
Joined
22 Jul 2017
Messages
1,172
Give me trains any time! If only international tickets weren't so dam fiddly.

There's that whole "the Atlantic ocean" issue if you want to go to North America though.

I don't think air travel is fundamentally uncomfortable - I don't have any issues with a shorthaul flight even on the budget airlines. I've just got back from a trip to Canada though, and for the last couple of hours of each flight I was desperate for it to be over. It's less the inherent comfort level in the seat, it's more just sitting in one place for 95% of the flight, and on the return leg the fact that I really struggle to sleep on a flight in economy.
 

CanalWalker

Member
Joined
13 May 2019
Messages
42
There's that whole "the Atlantic ocean" issue if you want to go to North America though.

I don't think air travel is fundamentally uncomfortable - I don't have any issues with a shorthaul flight even on the budget airlines. I've just got back from a trip to Canada though, and for the last couple of hours of each flight I was desperate for it to be over. It's less the inherent comfort level in the seat, it's more just sitting in one place for 95% of the flight, and on the return leg the fact that I really struggle to sleep on a flight in economy.

Indeed. I cannot manage a direct flight to the west coast and always have to break my journey at Boston or Toronto
 

cactustwirly

Established Member
Joined
10 Apr 2013
Messages
7,455
Location
UK
I find it perfectly fine, not as good as train travel or driving.
As a user of mostly easyJet, the legroom is actually pretty decent, better than a TfW 150 or a EMT HST.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
97,879
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
I find it perfectly fine, not as good as train travel or driving.
As a user of mostly easyJet, the legroom is actually pretty decent, better than a TfW 150 or a EMT HST.

Depends where you sit re legroom on Sleasy. In front of the exit row on a 320 it is notably more generous than elsewhere, as there wasn't the room to squeeze an extra row in as the exit row can't move.
 

scotrail158713

Established Member
Joined
30 Jan 2019
Messages
1,797
Location
Dundee
I don’t do much flying but I find the actual flying part is fine - I find the endless queues before and after to be worse. For some short haul flights you end up spending more time in the airports than in the air. I suppose it’s a necessary evil though.
 

sheff1

Established Member
Joined
24 Dec 2009
Messages
5,496
Location
Sheffield
I don’t do much flying but I find the actual flying part is fine - I find the endless queues before and after to be worse.

Depends where you are travelling.

I recently flew from Tromso to Heathrow via Oslo. Arrived at Tromso airport less than an hour before departure, dropped off my luggage, proceeded through security with no queue at all, had a coffee and pastry and then strolled onto the plane with just of couple of people in front of me at the gate.

One hour in Oslo. No need for any security check, passport control with twice as many border officers as passengers, time for another coffee and, again, a stroll onto the plane.

At Heathrow I walked straight to the border control desk (the only queues were at the e-gates which I always avoid if possible) where I had a brief discussion with the officer who concluded with a friendly "welcome home". A short wait for the luggage and then a two minute walk to the car.

No chance of doing that journey by rail, of course, and driving from Tromso just to Oslo would take around 22 hours (without factoring in any breaks).

On the other hand, being confronted by the shouting numpties at Manchester (Airport security and Piccadilly platforms 13/14) is a different kettle of fish altogether.
 

scotrail158713

Established Member
Joined
30 Jan 2019
Messages
1,797
Location
Dundee
Depends where you are travelling.
Very much so. I’ve flown Heathrow to Hong Kong, Manchester to Milan, and Edinburgh to Copenhagen over the last 12 months and the experience at Heathrow was the nicest of the 3.
I think that’s because Heathrow is used to huge passenger numbers and has expanded for that, whereas Manchester and Edinburgh are only just beginning to expand just now, so they’re currently not big enough for the number of passengers they handle daily.
 

cactustwirly

Established Member
Joined
10 Apr 2013
Messages
7,455
Location
UK
Heathrow is like New St - basically a rebuild that has turned it from one of the worst airports to one of the best.

Used Heathrow yesterday and it was good, except that T5 C gates are annoying as they're a trek from the main terminal building.

Never had to wait for Check in or security for very long, mostly 5 minutes or less.
It is just the queue at the gate which can be annoying. As well as the waiting around
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top