• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

EMR Regional and Connect refurbishments

FrontSideBus

Member
Joined
11 Feb 2025
Messages
95
Location
Merseyside
Compared with the rock hard thing I had unfortunately just been sat on in a 331, I thought they were very comfortable tbh.
I certainly wouldn't have minded going all the way to Norwich on it!
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

bunnahabhain

Established Member
Joined
8 Jun 2005
Messages
2,175
Why must TOCs cheapen and ruin plans by trying to cut costs?
Because the refurbishment is already eye wateringly expensive. Its gutting that it can't be made even more perfect though. Eg toilet sinks are the same original green ones, panels still look grubby and haven't been repainted.
 

QSK19

Member
Joined
29 Dec 2020
Messages
847
Location
Leicestershire
Because the refurbishment is already eye wateringly expensive. Its gutting that it can't be made even more perfect though. Eg toilet sinks are the same original green ones, panels still look grubby and haven't been repainted.
Agreed. As you say, it’s such a shame that things have been left out; but at least a major wrong (ie EMR’s sometimes-terrible non-IC stock condition) is being put right.

Nevertheless, EMR and its passengers deserve absolutely every penny when it comes to the refurbishment - even if it’s expensive. Years of unacceptable suffering and neglect when it comes stock cascaded from other TOCs.

Finally, I know some may think that EMR doesn’t warrant such an expenditure given the low amount of money it contributes to the railway (many other TOCs are, of course, more lucrative), but IMO that’s no excuse - passengers pay money and they deserve comfortable accommodation.
 

bunnahabhain

Established Member
Joined
8 Jun 2005
Messages
2,175
Agreed. As you say, it’s such a shame that things have been left out; but at least a major wrong (ie EMR’s sometimes-terrible non-IC stock condition) is being put right.

Nevertheless, EMR and its passengers deserve absolutely every penny when it comes to the refurbishment - even if it’s expensive. Years of unacceptable suffering and neglect when it comes stock cascaded from other TOCs.

Finally, I know some may think that EMR doesn’t warrant such an expenditure given the low amount of money it contributes to the railway (many other TOCs are, of course, more lucrative), but IMO that’s no excuse - passengers pay money and they deserve comfortable accommodation.
Liverpool to Norwich is one of the highest earning service groups at EMR. It accounts for 15% of revenue on its own which when you compare to the 2 TPH intercity routes is quite high.
 

QSK19

Member
Joined
29 Dec 2020
Messages
847
Location
Leicestershire
Liverpool to Norwich is one of the highest earning service groups at EMR. It accounts for 15% of revenue on its own which when you compare to the 2 TPH intercity routes is quite high.
Sorry, I was meaning to place emphasis on Regional routes excluding Liverpool-Norwich (which I think account for 5%?).

Nevertheless, the fundamental point is that comparatively low revenues from (many) EMR routes should never be a justification to provide its passengers with substandard accommodation - every passenger has a right to travel comfortably and hopefully this refurbishment delivers on that.
 

bunnahabhain

Established Member
Joined
8 Jun 2005
Messages
2,175
Sorry, I was meaning to place emphasis on Regional routes excluding Liverpool-Norwich (which I think account for 5%?).

Nevertheless, the fundamental point is that comparatively low revenues from (many) EMR routes should never be a justification to provide its passengers with substandard accommodation - every passenger has a right to travel comfortably and hopefully this refurbishment delivers on that.
5% in theory, I suspect that service groups like Derby to Crewe are allocated a fair share of the rather large Scotland and Wales to Derby market, see also Nottingham to Lincoln.

Worksop, Jolly Joint Line etc will always been heavily subsidised basket cases. Skegness would probably wash its face in the Summer if it didn't require such a large number of agency wallahs.
 

LowLevel

Established Member
Joined
26 Oct 2013
Messages
8,224
Yeah, 170530 is also missing a table. View attachment 180947
They're single piece mouldings. People keep sitting on the end of them and cracking them in half which results in them having to be removed as they'd be a hazard in the event of accident.

Don't think there are any spares and as they're being replaced no one is buying any - they tend to get replaced on B exams with spare class 158 tables if anything.
 

fgwrich

Established Member
Joined
15 Apr 2009
Messages
9,855
Location
Hampshire
Because the refurbishment is already eye wateringly expensive. Its gutting that it can't be made even more perfect though. Eg toilet sinks are the same original green ones, panels still look grubby and haven't been repainted.
And of course in this day and age of DfT control, they won’t be allowing expensive refurbishments with the levels of grandeur that we’ve seen in the past. Those days of total strip out and replace refurbishments are well in the past.

I do agree that it’s a shame it can’t be completely perfect, but I’m sure EMR has battled hard enough to even replace the seats in the first place.
 

QSK19

Member
Joined
29 Dec 2020
Messages
847
Location
Leicestershire
And of course in this day and age of DfT control, they won’t be allowing expensive refurbishments with the levels of grandeur that we’ve seen in the past. Those days of total strip out and replace refurbishments are well in the past.

I do agree that it’s a shame it can’t be completely perfect, but I’m sure EMR has battled hard enough to even replace the seats in the first place.
Indeed, but we’re talking about some (relatively speaking) small things that have been missed out. For example, the spec includes brand new seats (170/5) but not a deep clean of the panels; it includes enhanced PIS but they cannot replace an old toilet sink.

You’re absolutely right in saying that refurbishment packages these days will not be as comprehensive as past ones, but this time round, some basic stuff has seemingly been cut out yet wouldn’t have taken much to include.

Nevertheless, I also recognise that EMR must have fought tooth and nail to get the level of refurbishment that it has secured and the observations on 170501 are positive.
 

fgwrich

Established Member
Joined
15 Apr 2009
Messages
9,855
Location
Hampshire
Indeed, but we’re talking about some (relatively speaking) small things that have been missed out. For example, the spec includes brand new seats (170/5) but not a deep clean of the panels; it includes enhanced PIS but they cannot replace an old toilet sink.

You’re absolutely right in saying that refurbishment packages these days will not be as comprehensive as past ones, but this time round, some basic stuff has seemingly been cut out yet wouldn’t have taken much to include.

Nevertheless, I also recognise that EMR must have fought tooth and nail to get the level of refurbishment that it has secured and the observations on 170501 are positive.
Oh indeed, not cleaning the ceiling panels is disappointing. I’d rather that they were repainted but even a deep clean would have made them a little more presentable. Perhaps EMR will be hoping the big windows of the Turbostar will be enough to distract passengers instead? :lol:
 

QSK19

Member
Joined
29 Dec 2020
Messages
847
Location
Leicestershire
Oh indeed, not cleaning the ceiling panels is disappointing. I’d rather that they were repainted but even a deep clean would have made them a little more presentable. Perhaps EMR will be hoping the big windows of the Turbostar will be enough to distract passengers instead? :lol:
Yep, EMR can no doubt spin it so that people can enjoy the view through the large windows (mind you, at least you don’t see the outside in the same way as you did when on board 156917… the corrosion holes in the shell gave natural light with the bonus of air circulation :lol:)
 

Top