• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

First South West (Kernow & Buses of Somerset)

Goldfish62

Veteran Member
Joined
14 Feb 2010
Messages
11,800
It seems a very retrograde step. I know they had a bad season last year but this is a bad move. I appreciate not knowing the financials but Lands End and Atlantic Coasters would seem to be good moneyspinners. I'd love to see the data that they've captured that shows how local the passenger usage is...
When they cut back the service so much this last year they were leaving people behind - on the last bus.

I did think that the 2020/1 splurge on elderly opentoppers was a bit much (e.g. Lizard, Exeter) plus the Sunseeker singles, the oddball Solo but these are more dependable core products.
Agreed. It was a complete farce - running buses that should have been scrapped
No excuse for the carnage that is currently taking place though.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

K219UHA

Member
Joined
5 Jan 2018
Messages
49
Gutted if this pans out. The Lands End Coaster is a firm part of our yearly venture to Cornwall, purely because it is open top. It’s far less attractive as a closed top.

Seems like an incredibly short sighted and frankly insane decision by First.
Having visited Cornwall to take in the Land's End open tops and others in between over the last decade, multiple summer trips to mix it in with the usual family activities. I shall vote with me feet and cancel the planned and thankfully not yet booked in trip for late May, 2 x weekly tickets revenue for First lost and again the same in August. Closed top B9TLs in unloved acquired liveries on a tourist uplift summer service, what a complete farse! 300 mile drive was worth the effort for the overall experience as it was, Cornwall is great but take the other interest away of enjoying scenic open top runs as part of the explore and not worth the effort of cost of visiting anymore, plus be an anti climax of what was better times.

The services were rammed with tourists, particularly in the peak summer months, and not always in sunny weather either. Penzance to Newlyn was a common sight to see the bus rammed when I was on it. There was clear faffing around with the Sunday and Bank Holiday times last year, people been left behind in some cases seen, no joke!

As the for locals comment, yes some of the workers to Land's End and some families taking their kids on a cheap day out, do enjoy a open top ride, they clearly made it known!

Remote management strikes again!

Sad times...
 

buscoaster

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2021
Messages
85
Location
Bristol
It seems like a particularly strange decision considering the fleet now used on Lands End is not especially elderly - the vehicles are already depreciated and already within the fleet, so the cost of running it open top is tiny.
 

Goldfish62

Veteran Member
Joined
14 Feb 2010
Messages
11,800
It seems like a particularly strange decision considering the fleet now used on Lands End is not especially elderly - the vehicles are already depreciated and already within the fleet, so the cost of running it open top is tiny.
I notice that they're not being stored with tarpaulins over the open section, so the seats will be soaked through and water will have ample opportunity to cause corrosion and to get into the electrics.
 

fgwrich

Established Member
Joined
15 Apr 2009
Messages
9,845
Location
Hampshire
I notice that they're not being stored with tarpaulins over the open section, so the seats will be soaked through and water will have ample opportunity to cause corrosion and to get into the electrics.
Damage by self sabotage?

I’ve already made my feelings known about this on a post on Facebook but I completely agree that this seems to be a very disappointing decision. The transformation by Marc & Alex seems to almost be a distant memory now and the new South West Management seem determined to run Kernow back into the First Group dumping ground Cornwall always was. Sure, some of their ideas didn’t work out, and I agree about the purchasing of the elderly presidents, but the Atlantic Coasters / Lands End Coaster was one of the more successful ones (a shame the Lizard open topper didn’t work out!). This seems like a rather naive decision made by somebody with little care or thought about what routes are operated down in Cornwall - perhaps they’ve never been there?
 

Flange Squeal

Established Member
Joined
17 Jul 2012
Messages
1,535
That is a shame. I’ve had a few friends/colleagues, who aren’t bus enthusiasts but know I am, come back from family holidays and mention to me that they saw some open top buses and went for a ride, where as they’d normally have driven to Lands End or wherever.

I don’t know how many other holidaymakers use the affected routes in a similar manner (see them and use them in place of an otherwise planned/likely car journey), but it does seem a real shame that this could end up with less patronage and increased traffic. I didn’t get the impression that those friends/colleagues would have considered using (or perhaps even noticed) the buses if they were big standard closed tops.
 

baza585

Member
Joined
1 Aug 2010
Messages
707
Obviously we don't have access to the same financials as the First management but I am surprised that the Weymouth open top routes are thought more viable than the Lands End coaster.
 

MarkC

Member
Joined
3 Nov 2016
Messages
250
Unfortunately this seems to indicate a return to the bad times for First SW with decisions made by Management miles away from the area. This sadly seems to be a re run of a decade or so ago where interference from up country resulted in First collapsing in Plymouth and before that North Devon. Why do they not learn?. A big shame but I can see First withdrawal from Cornwall in next few years too!
 

DaveHarries

Established Member
Joined
12 Dec 2011
Messages
2,447
Location
England
perhaps go ahead will have a go
Indeed they might if they can get some Open Top buses and have a means of putting the roof back on at the end of the summer operating period. I can't see Open Top buses (or any double-deckers for that matter) being worth running outside of the summer period though.

Meanwhile, and going back to First SW, the next meeting of Somerset Council's Bus Advisory Board is scheduled for Tuesday 28th January and the opportunity is there for operators to present any timetable changes proposed for 06th April (Item 6). Last I heard the plan was for First to launch the electrics for Taunton and Minehead in the Spring so I wonder if anything will arise in connection therewith (ie. changes in preparation for the launch of the buses in question) and I can think of one or two other changes First might be looking at without knowing if they actually are. In connection with the electric buses I think items 7 and 9 could also be of interest.

The minutes and agenda for the BAB meeting are at https://democracy.somerset.gov.uk/ieListDocuments.aspx?CId=873&MId=7255&Ver=4
Somerset Council said:
6.Timetable changes proposed for 6th April 2025
Operators to present their proposals.

7. Update from Operators on Taunton £1.50 fare, Government £3 and any other relevant updates
To receive any updates from operators.

[...]

9. Any Other Business
To raise any other relevant issues from the Chair or Board members.

The meeting is livestreamed, or scheduled to be so.

HTIOI,
Dave
 

GBM

Member
Joined
18 Jan 2016
Messages
205
Location
West Cornwall
Seems the Cornish RMT were also unaware of the open top removal plan (despite being assured by First that the Unions had been consulted).
 

fgwrich

Established Member
Joined
15 Apr 2009
Messages
9,845
Location
Hampshire
Seems the Cornish RMT were also unaware of the open top removal plan (despite being assured by First that the Unions had been consulted).
That doesn’t surprise me in the slightest. The bad old days of First Devon and Cornwall are feeling ever closer than before.
 

Goldfish62

Veteran Member
Joined
14 Feb 2010
Messages
11,800
That doesn’t surprise me in the slightest. The bad old days of First Devon and Cornwall are feeling ever closer than before.
At least FDC recognised the value of open top buses even if the operation of them was a bit scrappy.
 

vla50

Member
Joined
21 Mar 2021
Messages
499
Location
South East
Given the B7s are looking ropey at best, and FK have now binned their open top fleet, are there any replacements planned for the B7s or are they going to keep soldiering on?
 

Andyh82

Established Member
Joined
19 May 2014
Messages
3,981
Given the B7s are looking ropey at best, and FK have now binned their open top fleet, are there any replacements planned for the B7s or are they going to keep soldiering on?
If there isn’t going to be any open tops then surely they don’t need replacing?
 

buscoaster

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2021
Messages
85
Location
Bristol
I'm assuming he means that the closed top PVR will increase as open tops are not being used, but I'm not sure this is actually the case in all reality
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,095
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
I'm assuming he means that the closed top PVR will increase as open tops are not being used, but I'm not sure this is actually the case in all reality
I'm not certain that the PVR will increase if the Atlantic Coasters don't come back, and depends on whether the Lands End Coaster will be shorn of many of the seasonal extras. The 2024 service pattern clearly reflected and accommodated the college/uni terms and I suspect that these moves are to maximise year round vehicle utilisation.

The B7TLs are on the hit list and I can't see anything particularly impacting that.
 

vla50

Member
Joined
21 Mar 2021
Messages
499
Location
South East
I think he's talking about the closed top B7TLs but I'm not clear what the connection is between getting rid of the open top fleet and the replacement of the remaining B7TLs?
Just if there were any updates really - there’s clearly been a review of the fleetlist and it’s slightly peaked my curiosity as to whether anything else is due in
 

Whiteway215

Established Member
Joined
15 Sep 2015
Messages
2,055
Location
Bath
Given the B7s are looking ropey at best, and FK have now binned their open top fleet, are there any replacements planned for the B7s or are they going to keep soldiering on?
37711/22/25 were reported to be transferring to Kernow from West Yorkshire but were diverted supposedly on a temporary basis to Eastern Counties.
They are still with EC at the present time so whether they will eventually reach Cornwall who knows?
 

DaveHarries

Established Member
Joined
12 Dec 2011
Messages
2,447
Location
England
I listened in to the Bus Advisory Board meeting of Somerset Council this morning (28th January) and it was mentioned in the course of the meeting that two routes currently operated by First have gone out to tender since the October meeting: Service 99 (Taunton - Staple Fitzpaine - Chard, currently operated by First South West) and Service 126 (Weston-s-Mare - Hutton - Cheddar - Wells, currently operated by First West of England). First are apparently not interested in continuing either route.

I could see Hatch Green taking the 99 (unless Stagecoach fancied interworking with Service 20 - I can't see them running any huge distance as dead runs and I think the nearest Stagecoach yard to Chard would be Honiton unless they have one at Axminster) but I wonder who might look to pick up the 126. I gather no route or TT changes are anticipated for the 99 (although I don't know about the 126) when the new contracts start on 06th / 07th April.

HTIOI,
Dave
 

M803UYA

Member
Joined
24 May 2020
Messages
699
Location
Under my stone....
I listened in to the Bus Advisory Board meeting of Somerset Council this morning (28th January) and it was mentioned in the course of the meeting that two routes currently operated by First have gone out to tender since the October meeting: Service 99 (Taunton - Staple Fitzpaine - Chard, currently operated by First South West) and Service 126 (Weston-s-Mare - Hutton - Cheddar - Wells, currently operated by First West of England). First are apparently not interested in continuing either route.

I could see Hatch Green taking the 99 (unless Stagecoach fancied interworking with Service 20 - I can't see them running any huge distance as dead runs and I think the nearest Stagecoach yard to Chard would be Honiton unless they have one at Axminster) but I wonder who might look to pick up the 126. I gather no route or TT changes are anticipated for the 99 (although I don't know about the 126) when the new contracts start on 06th / 07th April.

HTIOI,
Dave
Stagecoach kept the Cooks outstation on Millfield Trading Estate in Chard when they took over in 2007. As for 'dead mileage' - aren't they operating the Taunton Park & Ride from Tiverton still? Equally Hatch Green would be interested in it too - a one bus PVR service running fairly regularly.

Were any reasons given as to why First doesn't want the routes?
 

DaveHarries

Established Member
Joined
12 Dec 2011
Messages
2,447
Location
England
Stagecoach kept the Cooks outstation on Millfield Trading Estate in Chard when they took over in 2007. As for 'dead mileage' - aren't they operating the Taunton Park & Ride from Tiverton still? Equally Hatch Green would be interested in it too - a one bus PVR service running fairly regularly.

Were any reasons given as to why First doesn't want the routes?
No reasons given that I heard of on the latter point. As for the Taunton P&R being operated from Tiverton there is no out-of-service mileage involved because Stagecoach have a Service 24 (Tiverton - Silk Mills P&R) to get the vehicles up there and home again: 3 journeys each way which are 0507, 0527 and 0547 Tiverton - Silk Mills and 2005, 2025 and 2045 Silk Mills - Tiverton; journey time around 40mins.

Dave
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,095
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
Stagecoach kept the Cooks outstation on Millfield Trading Estate in Chard when they took over in 2007. As for 'dead mileage' - aren't they operating the Taunton Park & Ride from Tiverton still? Equally Hatch Green would be interested in it too - a one bus PVR service running fairly regularly.

Were any reasons given as to why First doesn't want the routes?
I can understand why First might not want to run the 126, as they continue to have challenges in driver retention and recruitment at Wells and Weston depots. That's probably the equivalent of four drivers fewer they need to find. Of course, one operator that might be interested could be Libra Travel who operated it before albeit Wells to Axbridge.

The 99 is slightly more intriguing. BoS surrendered the 29, 77 and 75 to be integrated into the existing West of England 376 and that made some semblance of sense. However, not certain why they'd sacrifice the 99 unless they are so challenged on drivers? It's a one vehicle working and another loss of vehicle across which to spread their fixed depot costs; a depot that it appears they're keeping given the electrification and new vehicles arriving.
No reasons given that I heard of on the latter point. As for the Taunton P&R being operated from Tiverton there is no out-of-service mileage involved because Stagecoach have a Service 24 (Tiverton - Silk Mills P&R) to get the vehicles up there and home again: 3 journeys each way which are 0507, 0527 and 0547 Tiverton - Silk Mills and 2005, 2025 and 2045 Silk Mills - Tiverton; journey time around 40mins.

Dave
The mileage might be registered but it really is dead mileage. Doubt you get anybody on those journeys.

Stagecoach don't have an Axminster base and never have had. The 4/44/380 was always run from Exeter or the Honiton outstation. Honiton is now gone (work done from Matford or Sidmouth) and I think even the 20 is operated by Matford.
 

DaveHarries

Established Member
Joined
12 Dec 2011
Messages
2,447
Location
England
Stagecoach don't have an Axminster base and never have had. The 4/44/380 was always run from Exeter or the Honiton outstation. Honiton is now gone (work done from Matford or Sidmouth) and I think even the 20 is operated by Matford.
Thanks for that info. Surprising that Honiton was dispensed with given that it could have been used for the 4, 44, 44A and now the 20. I suppose with the 20 a vehicle runs a 4/44 to Honiton and then becomes a 20. Odd way of doing it though because of the potential long distance involved if a bus on any of those routes broke down.

Dave
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,095
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
Thanks for that info. Surprising that Honiton was dispensed with given that it could have been used for the 4, 44, 44A and now the 20. I suppose with the 20 a vehicle runs a 4/44 to Honiton and then becomes a 20. Odd way of doing it though because of the potential long distance involved if a bus on any of those routes broke down.

Dave
I don't know - might not have been their choice. Or possibly issues like vandalism or fuel theft?

Looks like the 20 consists of two standalone duties with the drivers running out of Matford and then spending all day with their bus. The 20 runs via Honiton so no real interworking opportunity. IIRC, and getting back on topic, First outbased a couple of vehicles for the 20. I think it was somewhere like Hemyock.
 

M803UYA

Member
Joined
24 May 2020
Messages
699
Location
Under my stone....
Looks like the 20 consists of two standalone duties with the drivers running out of Matford and then spending all day with their bus. The 20 runs via Honiton so no real interworking opportunity. IIRC, and getting back on topic, First outbased a couple of vehicles for the 20. I think it was somewhere like Hemyock.
It was Hemyock before the route extended, then it moved to Honiton around the time the two low floor Darts arrived in 1998.

The 99 is slightly more intriguing. BoS surrendered the 29, 77 and 75 to be integrated into the existing West of England 376 and that made some semblance of sense. However, not certain why they'd sacrifice the 99 unless they are so challenged on drivers? It's a one vehicle working and another loss of vehicle across which to spread their fixed depot costs; a depot that it appears they're keeping given the electrification and new vehicles arriving.
The 99 wouldn't require BoS to use a non standard type of vehicle. I think they were operating Dart SLF/Enviro 200 sized 38 seat buses on the working. They have plenty within the fleet. Even with the rump of buses left from Taunton Towns/21/28 you'd need stuff to cover Wellington, which is commercially sustainable and unlikely to be withdrawn. Although I don't recall the electric bus announcement mentioning Service 22 it'd be part of the group of commercially viable routes out of Taunton depot. I remember travelling on the 99 over the section of route it now operates (back in 2002 before it was converted to low floor operation) and thought some of the roads 'narrow' - so if First have had a high level of accident damage on the service that'd be one thing I'd guess at!
 
Last edited:

DaveHarries

Established Member
Joined
12 Dec 2011
Messages
2,447
Location
England
Although I don't recall the electric bus announcement mentioning Service 22 it'd be part of the group of commercially viable routes out of Taunton depot.
It was mentioned by First that the electric double-deckers are to be for the 21/21A/22 with the single-deckers being for Taunton 1 & 2 and the 28.

FirstBus South & South West News Page said:
The electric buses will provide smoother, quieter bus journeys for passengers and will run on routes including:

Route 28: Taunton to Minehead
Route 21: Taunton to Bridgwater
Route 22: Taunton to Wellington
Route 1: Taunton Town Service
Route 2: Taunton Town Service

The above is taken from here - https://news-ssandsw.firstbus.co.uk...ication-projects-pave-way-for-green-bus-fleet

That news release says the buses will start operating "from Spring 2025" but I was slightly surprised that there was no update on this, or anything else relating to the electric buses, during the meeting of the Bus Advisory Board (Somerset Council) on 28th January. I wonder where the Enviro400 deckers will go once the electrics come in: I guess they might keep some for any school and college services but I think they will continue to see service on the 30 and 54 routes as well. I look forward to trying the U11DD buses as a taste of the future before Bristol gets them later in the year.

Dave
 
Last edited:

Top