• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

McGill's Scotland East (Midland Bluebird and Eastern Scottish)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Metal Mickey

Member
Joined
9 Nov 2021
Messages
36
Location
Scotland
Instead of using the fonts specifically designed for destination displays, they picked one designed for Microsoft Word.
I get it now. The font they’re using on front destination screens looks awful and they also no longer show via points.

It’s also a legal requirement for the X10 to be screened as Balfron for Stirling and Balfron for Glasgow but they don’t seem to be doing that either.

McGill’s, Western and First Glasgow screens are done to a much better standard.
 

stevenedin

Member
Joined
26 Jul 2021
Messages
1,169
Location
Edinburgh
I get it now. The font they’re using on front destination screens looks awful and they also no longer show via points.

It’s also a legal requirement for the X10 to be screened as Balfron for Stirling and Balfron for Glasgow but they don’t seem to be doing that either.

McGill’s, Western and First Glasgow screens are done to a much better standard.
Is it definitely a legal requirement? I thought that was just when we were part of the EU that it was?

I am personally a fan of destinations in that format. I prefer the end destination and then Via underneath.
 

kez19

Established Member
Joined
15 May 2020
Messages
2,042
Location
Dundee
I get it now. The font they’re using on front destination screens looks awful and they also no longer show via points.

It’s also a legal requirement for the X10 to be screened as Balfron for Stirling and Balfron for Glasgow but they don’t seem to be doing that either.

McGill’s, Western and First Glasgow screens are done to a much better standard.

It looks like the same font is applied across the McGills network as Xplore Dundee uses that same font on both number and destination (Xplore got rid of the via points too).
 

Jordan Adam

Established Member
Joined
12 Sep 2017
Messages
5,531
Location
Aberdeen
It’s also a legal requirement for the X10 to be screened as Balfron for Stirling and Balfron for Glasgow but they don’t seem to be doing that either.
Is it definitely a legal requirement? I thought that was just when we were part of the EU that it was?
This is a common misconception, there is no legal requirement under PSVAR (Public Service Vehicle Accessibility Requirements) for split registered services to display the end point for each individual registration. The regulation defines destination as being "a word or words to describe the route or final destination", this is rather vague and allows for the destination to be something other than the destination listed on the registration, hence circular routes rarely have the terminal point listed as the destination but will rather have a description of the route itself. Similarly a lot of routes in smaller areas will just display "....Town Service". The Traffic Commissioners Office have also confirmed regarding a previous similar case with another operator that for example a bus departing Glasgow showing "X10 Stirling" would be perfectly within the regulations.
 

Observer

Member
Joined
3 Nov 2014
Messages
709
Problem with the destinations is they just want it all to be in one line, two lines are not being allowed despite requests even though some would make sense "Glasgow via Balfron, Glasgow via Cumbernauld etc".

Also the font that they use, sometimes doesn't work too well with smaller screens like the Mellor Sprinters. All they need to do is get a different font for the small screens and the issues would be addressed.

What I will say is at least it looks better than the tiny text that First were using for a long time. At least there are some positives to changing the destination screens, not all negatives!
 
Joined
31 Dec 2021
Messages
803
Location
Glasgow
Is it definitely a legal requirement? I thought that was just when we were part of the EU that it was?

I am personally a fan of destinations in that format. I prefer the end destination and then Via underneath.
Lothian Buses have done without "via" for years now.

It's a personal choice for the operator, nothing else.
 

Cesarcollie

Member
Joined
5 Jun 2016
Messages
541
Can they not arrange it through their own MOT stations for that though? Larbert has one as does Livingston I believe.

possibly. But certification is not done by a normal MOT tester - so it depends whether DVSA would send out a specialist officer to an operator depot to certify one or two buses.
 

ScotsRail

Member
Joined
19 Aug 2019
Messages
79
Location
Aberfeldy
It’s also a legal requirement for the X10 to be screened as Balfron for Stirling and Balfron for Glasgow but they don’t seem to be doing that either.

Speaking of the X10 looks like they are planning on cutting it back - opinions being asked on proposed cuts from next August.

Option C
X10 - Balfron -Stirling whole Sunday Service would be cut.

Specific Journeys:
Mon - Friday
X10 Balfron-Stirling 09.32
X10 Stirling -Balfron 16.00
X10 Balfron -Stirling 16.42

Saturday
X10 Balfron-Stirling 08.04
These journeys will also affect Strathblane and Killearn residents travelling to Stirling and villages east of Balfron including hospital appointments.

Option B
All of option C above plus

Mon-Sat
X10 Balfron -Glasgow 17.47
X10 Balfron -Glasgow 18.57
X10 Stirling -Balfron 19.05 Mon-Thursday
X10 Stirling -Balfron 20.40
X10 Stirling -Balfron 23.00

Mon- Saturday
X10 Balfron- Stirling 19.29
X10 Glasgow - Balfron 19.10
X10 Glasgow -Stirling 20.35 M-Thursday
X10 Balfron - Stirling 21.47
X10 Glasgow - Balfron 21.40
X10 Glasgow - Balfron 22.40

Option A
Is both B & C - i.e. all of the above plus C30
 

alphabravo43

Member
Joined
1 Mar 2018
Messages
55
Speaking of the X10 looks like they are planning on cutting it back - opinions being asked on proposed cuts from next August.

Option C
X10 - Balfron -Stirling whole Sunday Service would be cut.

Specific Journeys:
Mon - Friday
X10 Balfron-Stirling 09.32
X10 Stirling -Balfron 16.00
X10 Balfron -Stirling 16.42

Saturday
X10 Balfron-Stirling 08.04
These journeys will also affect Strathblane and Killearn residents travelling to Stirling and villages east of Balfron including hospital appointments.

Option B
All of option C above plus

Mon-Sat
X10 Balfron -Glasgow 17.47
X10 Balfron -Glasgow 18.57
X10 Stirling -Balfron 19.05 Mon-Thursday
X10 Stirling -Balfron 20.40
X10 Stirling -Balfron 23.00

Mon- Saturday
X10 Balfron- Stirling 19.29
X10 Glasgow - Balfron 19.10
X10 Glasgow -Stirling 20.35 M-Thursday
X10 Balfron - Stirling 21.47
X10 Glasgow - Balfron 21.40
X10 Glasgow - Balfron 22.40

Option A
Is both B & C - i.e. all of the above plus C30
Not McGill's that are looking to make these cuts however, these are the proposed cuts by Stirling council to the supported services to try and balance the budget
 
Joined
16 Oct 2011
Messages
282
Airport service confirmed

MCGILL’S SCOTLAND EAST LIMITEDAirport ExpressWaterloo Place, EdinburghEdinburgh Airport

Support links​

  • Telephone
 

VioletEclipse

Member
Joined
10 Nov 2018
Messages
716
Location
Dùn Èideann
Airport service confirmed

MCGILL’S SCOTLAND EAST LIMITEDAirport ExpressWaterloo Place, EdinburghEdinburgh Airport

Support links​

  • Telephone
so it seems they aren't giving it a service number, just 'Airport Express'.
Curious to see if it only lasts a year, or if it ends up being very successful and staying around.
 

RomeoCharlie71

Established Member
Joined
18 Sep 2017
Messages
1,725
Location
Scotland
Any link to the source?
Exactly no start date ect?
A relatively quick and simple search on the GOV.UK site reveals this: https://www.vehicle-operator-licens...registered-local-bus-services/details/617907/

Registration number PM0000923/369
Licence Number PM0000923
Variation number 0
Status New
Service number: Airport Express
Service type: Limited Stop
Start point: Waterloo Place, Edinburgh
Finish point: Edinburgh Airport
Via: Haymarket, St John's Road
Date received: 17 Nov 2023
Effective date: 01 Jan 2024
End date:
Supported by subsidies?: No
Local authorities covered by route: The City of Edinburgh Council
TAOs covered by route: Scotland
 

roadierway77

Member
Joined
23 Jun 2019
Messages
361
Location
Edinburgh
Airport service confirmed

MCGILL’S SCOTLAND EAST LIMITEDAirport ExpressWaterloo Place, EdinburghEdinburgh Airport

Support links​

  • Telephone
I hate to be pessimistic but I don't expect this service to stand the test of time, if all its rumoured attributes come to fruition - Airlink will have the upper hand in terms of frequency, capacity, service quality, and brand recognition. The lower fares that Bright Bus Express will offer means that it's going to have to see high patronage to offset operating costs and airport charges, and I just don't see McGill’s abstracting enough passengers from Airlink for this, especially if the presence of a new competing express service leads Lothian to drop their airport fares. But one can never predict the future, it may end up becoming a success - we shall see.
 

Spsf3232

Member
Joined
30 Apr 2022
Messages
108
Location
Glasgow
I hate to be pessimistic but I don't expect this service to stand the test of time, if all its rumoured attributes come to fruition - Airlink will have the upper hand in terms of frequency, capacity, service quality, and brand recognition. The lower fares that Bright Bus Express will offer means that it's going to have to see high patronage to offset operating costs and airport charges, and I just don't see McGill’s abstracting enough passengers from Airlink for this, especially if the presence of a new competing express service leads Lothian to drop their airport fares. But one can never predict the future, it may end up becoming a success - we shall see.
It will do pretty well, tourists just get on the first bus that says City centre and off they go. They don't care about brand or capacity and won't be interested in the Lothian brand.
 

ScotRail158725

Established Member
Joined
27 Nov 2018
Messages
2,177
I hate to be pessimistic but I don't expect this service to stand the test of time, if all its rumoured attributes come to fruition - Airlink will have the upper hand in terms of frequency, capacity, service quality, and brand recognition. The lower fares that Bright Bus Express will offer means that it's going to have to see high patronage to offset operating costs and airport charges, and I just don't see McGill’s abstracting enough passengers from Airlink for this, especially if the presence of a new competing express service leads Lothian to drop their airport fares. But one can never predict the future, it may end up becoming a success - we shall see.
This is exactly what was said about the tours and its turned out to be a profit turner and one of the most valuable assets to the McGills brand
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top