• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Seat reservations, how are they allocated?

stuu

Established Member
Joined
2 Sep 2011
Messages
3,482
Got on a train to Plymouth at Paddington this evening. There are about 10 reserved seats in this carriage, scattered randomly as far as I can tell. Most of them are ones with terrible window alignment though. Just weird
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

pokemonsuper9

Established Member
Joined
20 Dec 2022
Messages
2,763
Location
Greater Manchester
Travelled on a TPE 397 from Wigan to Liverpool on Saturday, sat in an almost empty and almost completely unreserved Coach B, later on went for a walk up the train and saw that Coach C was almost fully reserved and was packed!
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
104,836
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
Travelled on a TPE 397 from Wigan to Liverpool on Saturday, sat in an almost empty and almost completely unreserved Coach B, later on went for a walk up the train and saw that Coach C was almost fully reserved and was packed!

This seems not entirely unusual on trains with fake compulsory reservations. G and U tend to be quiet on 11 car Pendolinos these days too, because people don't realise the compulsory reservations are fake. I'm slightly surprised Avanti don't reserve some seats in C now, though doing G and U would prevent 9s and 11s being interchangeable so I doubt they'd put them in those.
 
Last edited:

pokemonsuper9

Established Member
Joined
20 Dec 2022
Messages
2,763
Location
Greater Manchester
This seems not entirely unusual on trains with fake compulsory reservations. G and U tend to be quiet on 11 car Pendolinos these days too, because people don't realise the compulsory reservations are fake. I'm slightly surprised Avanti don't reserve some seats in C now, though doing F and U would prevent 9s and 11s being interchangeable so I doubt they'd put them in those.
Oh, is B TPE's Nova 2 (397) unreserved carriage? I saw some reservations at the C-end of the carriage so thought it was more like Avanti Coach D.
I didn't know TPE had unreserved carriages.

I didn't have a reservation since I had about 10 minutes' notice since I didn't plan on the connection (From an ex-Liverpool 331 to a to-Liverpool 397, booked 2 minute change, but we arrived 4 minutes early), I just got on Coach B hoping it would be quiet.
 

OscarH

Member
Joined
15 Sep 2020
Messages
904
Location
Crawley
This seems not entirely unusual on trains with fake compulsory reservations. G and U tend to be quiet on 11 car Pendolinos these days too, because people don't realise the compulsory reservations are fake. I'm slightly surprised Avanti don't reserve some seats in C now, though doing F and U would prevent 9s and 11s being interchangeable so I doubt they'd put them in those.
s/F/G, think it's a typo?
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
104,836
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
s/F/G, think it's a typo?

Yep, sorry, G and U. Edited.

F was until the refurb was complete.

Interestingly if they swap 80x for Pendolino or vice versa they try to map them across rather than just putting everything green. (The 1652 MKC to Birmingham, don't know the Euston time, can be formed of just about anything at the moment, could be a Pendolino of either length or could be 5, 7 or sometimes even 10 cars of 80x, and has been known to be a Voyager when those were about - so little point bothering with the seat picker!)
 

route101

Veteran Member
Joined
16 May 2010
Messages
11,373
This seems not entirely unusual on trains with fake compulsory reservations. G and U tend to be quiet on 11 car Pendolinos these days too, because people don't realise the compulsory reservations are fake. I'm slightly surprised Avanti don't reserve some seats in C now, though doing G and U would prevent 9s and 11s being interchangeable so I doubt they'd put them in those.
What do you mean compulsory reservations ?
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
104,836
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
What do you mean compulsory reservations ?

At present all Avanti and LNER trains plus the TPE Scotland services (and a few, but not many, others) are set in the timetable data to show as "reservation mandatory", the effect of which is that the train will show "sold out" if there is no reservation availability for any ticket type valid on it. This was done to allow a more granular control over which services are on sale, mostly, and as a hangover from COVID when it was done to prevent overcrowding. The reservations aren't actually mandatory - you can just buy a walk up ticket and board any valid train you like and nobody will say anything - but occasional users can be forgiven for not knowing that because it doesn't actually say it anywhere, we just know it is the case.

The only trains in the UK where you'll actually be turned away if you have no reservation are the Caledonian Sleeper and Eurostar. Though you might on the Penzance Sleeper if it's Glastonbury, generally that has about 5 people in 2 coaches of 2+2 seating so you won't. The fact that both of these types of train carry the same "compulsory reservation" flag is confusing and really could do with being sorted, but it's out of the scope of ths thread to go into that as it's not speculative.
 

Kite159

Veteran Member
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
20,779
Location
West of Andover
This seems not entirely unusual on trains with fake compulsory reservations. G and U tend to be quiet on 11 car Pendolinos these days too, because people don't realise the compulsory reservations are fake. I'm slightly surprised Avanti don't reserve some seats in C now, though doing G and U would prevent 9s and 11s being interchangeable so I doubt they'd put them in those.
Don't give them ideas similar to LNER to reduce the unreserved seating area ;)
 

Grecian 1998

Member
Joined
27 Oct 2019
Messages
481
Location
Bristol
I think XC's approach pre-2024 to standard class reservations on Voyagers was to fill D first, then F, then C. 10 minute reservations were placed in C.

During Covid, F became fully unreserved, but that changed again last year.

After XC started receiving AWC Voyagers, I think the reservations have switched to fill C first, then F, then D. There are a few seats at one end of D which are always unreserved as the AWC Voyagers have fewer seats in D than XC Voyagers.

B is always unreserved. The current reservation system therefore lets XC switch between 4 coach 220s or 221s, 5 coach 'legacy' XC 221s and 5 coach ex-AWC 221s without any reservations being lost.

I don't know if XC offer reservations in G - L when running double sets, as I can't recall seeing any. However I have heard guards announce H (equivalent coach B) and L (equivalent coach F) are fully unreserved, so I assume they can offer reservations in the second set.

I always aim for services run by double sets, and to use the standard class carriage furthest to one end of the train in the G - L set (H, I or L). I usually travel at weekends and most leisure travellers seem to pile into the middle of the train. It's quite rare that there are even 10 people in there on trips from Bristol - Exeter - Plymouth or Bristol - Birmingham. Voyagers are very pleasant trains when your carriage is largely empty.
 

317 forever

Established Member
Joined
21 Aug 2010
Messages
2,928
Location
North West
Got on a train to Plymouth at Paddington this evening. There are about 10 reserved seats in this carriage, scattered randomly as far as I can tell. Most of them are ones with terrible window alignment though. Just weird
I wonder whether, as part of selling cheap Advance tickets, TOCs allocate people the least favourable seats.
 

Sealink

Member
Joined
16 Aug 2006
Messages
396
The opposite for me and the Caledonian Sleeper - I've memorised the good seats.

11A is the dream seat - opposite end from the toilet, nobody sat next to you, lots of legroom, and the table is fixed to the wall in front rather than folding down from the seat; this is more spacious, sturdier, and ideal for putting your feet up on (keep your socks on please!) if you struggle to sleep sat upright.

Thanks for this - have picked 11A for my next Sleeper trip. Booking via LNER (needed a through ticket) was tricky but got it in the end!
 

leedsblue

Member
Joined
16 Dec 2015
Messages
7
What I find annoying (from an altruistic perspective) is when I am travelling alone (generally my experience is with TPE) and I am allocated a seat on a table of 4. I would be happy sitting in an "airline" seat, rather than preventing a family/group of 4 from sitting together.
 

PP57601

Member
Joined
3 Jun 2019
Messages
17
Another big bug of mine is when GWR allocate you a seat in a carriage that isn’t platformed at certain ‘short’ stations….
 

Top