• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Trivia: Rarest BR locos to survive into preservation

Cowley

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Global Moderator
Joined
15 Apr 2016
Messages
15,807
Location
Devon
The 15 is interesting, as they would almost certainly have gone extinct had it not been for D8233 and 3 others (sorry don’t have the numbers to hand) being saved for ETH (electric train heating) purposes. I forget how the 17 got saved but the 28 was also departmental of some sort. The 15’s close cousins the Class 16 are extinct, which is hardly surprising given how poor the class was.

The class 17 ended up in industrial use, Castle Cement amongst others from what I remember? A pretty remarkable survivor though definitely.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Strathclyder

Established Member
Joined
12 Jun 2013
Messages
3,234
Location
Clydebank
The class 17 ended up in industrial use, Castle Cement amongst others from what I remember? A pretty remarkable survivor though definitely.
D8568 is a real survivor, and her path to preservation was virtually identical to many Class 14s: one or more industrial owner.

She went to Hemilite of Harpenden straight from Polmadie, working under her own power between Glasgow and Harpenden on 11th September 1972. She would remain there until June 1977, when she was sold on again to Castle Cement (known back then as Ribble Cement) of Clitheroe, again working under her own power on the metals of her original owner back north on 20th June 1977. The DTG bought her from Ribble (plus all the stocked Clayton spares they had) and she left for the North Yorkshire Moors Railway on 9th February 1983, this time by road.
 
Last edited:

Strathclyder

Established Member
Joined
12 Jun 2013
Messages
3,234
Location
Clydebank
I wonder if there are any photos of that move?
Or of the Polmadie - Harpenden move. Would be real interesting to see pics of either move if they exist. My affinity for the Claytons as a whole stems largely from the fact they made their base in/around Glasgow for most of their short careers. That, and the fact those two Paxmans sound so supple at full power:

 
Last edited:

JKF

Member
Joined
29 May 2019
Messages
702
Are there any internal works narrow gauge locos surviving? I guess they would be a rarity.
 

D6130

Established Member
Joined
12 Jan 2021
Messages
5,795
Location
West Yorkshire/Tuscany
Are there any internal works narrow gauge locos surviving? I guess they would be a rarity.
I believe that the diminutive Lancashire & Yorkshire narrow gauge saddle tank loco 'Wren' - which spent its working life at Horwich Works - has been preserved. Is it in the National Railway Museum?
 

Strathclyder

Established Member
Joined
12 Jun 2013
Messages
3,234
Location
Clydebank
Class 07's spring to mind too.
As do some 08s and a few of the outwardly similar 10s.

Considering how few were actually built (prototype plus 22 production locos), surely the Deltics are in with a shout. I suppose it depends on your definition of rare.

Perhaps a subject for a separate thread, but the class must have one of the highest percentages of survivors (27.3% - production models only).
The 50s would be within a shout here too I would have thought. But you're right, it's a topic best suited for it's own thread.

D0226 - not "made by BR" but "made for BR" (it was in my ABC long before I met it in real life on the KWVR).
Ah, Vulcan. Cracking wee thing imho (have always been a sucker for the less successful diesel types). A slightly enlarged 08 or a shrunk-down 15/16 in profile and layout (which I think was part of the issue with the design; didn't fit into either bracket and was left floating somewhere in the middle; has found it's niche in preservation though!).

At Bo'ness they have the sole BR/NBL D27xx shunter, think there is only one 06 shunter.
06003/D2420. Currently at Peak Rail in Rowsley, as part of the Heritage Shunters Trust collection.

A 29 would have been nice! :)
Two for me please: one in that fetching version of BR Green they carried and the other in BR Blue. ;)
 

D6130

Established Member
Joined
12 Jan 2021
Messages
5,795
Location
West Yorkshire/Tuscany
Five out of the eight being NBL products...
Yes indeed. Although they were charismatic designs, they were very poor quality products in most respects. Unfortunately the NBL Co. was geared-up for building steam locos to imperial measurements and did not adapt well to building diesels to metric ones.
 

xotGD

Established Member
Joined
4 Feb 2017
Messages
6,091
I believe that the diminutive Lancashire & Yorkshire narrow gauge saddle tank loco 'Wren' - which spent its working life at Horwich Works - has been preserved. Is it in the National Railway Museum?
Currently at Bury Transport Museum.
 

Strathclyder

Established Member
Joined
12 Jun 2013
Messages
3,234
Location
Clydebank
Are there any internal works narrow gauge locos surviving? I guess they would be a rarity.
A Provan Gas Works loco dating from 1946, built by Andrew Barclay in Kilmarnock, named Dougal, and built to a 2ft 6in gauge and 0-4-0 wheel arrangement, survives at the Welshpool & Llanfair Light Railway.
 

JKF

Member
Joined
29 May 2019
Messages
702
I believe that the diminutive Lancashire & Yorkshire narrow gauge saddle tank loco 'Wren' - which spent its working life at Horwich Works - has been preserved. Is it in the National Railway Museum?

A Provan Gas Works loco dating from 1946, built by Andrew Barclay in Kilmarnock, named Dougal, and built to a 2ft 6in gauge and 0-4-0 wheel arrangement, survives at the Welshpool & Llanfair Light Railway.
Those wouldn’t count as ‘BR’ as per thread title! Unless it means operated by rather than built by/for?

At Bo'ness they have the sole BR/NBL D27xx shunter, think there is only one 06 shunter.
Only one known at least! Another was exported to Italy, but details of where it went after anrrival are sketchy. A long lost 03 did reappear over there a few years ago so there’s a slim chance this one could still be around. https://features.rcts.org.uk/diesel...ex-br-03s-06-07-exported-trieste-italy/d2432/
 
Last edited:

Strathclyder

Established Member
Joined
12 Jun 2013
Messages
3,234
Location
Clydebank
Those wouldn’t count as ‘BR’ as per thread title! Unless it means operated by rather than built by/for?
Hmmm, fair point well taken. Perhaps this is another potential off-topic deviation that requires it's own thread?
 

anothertyke

Member
Joined
23 Jun 2023
Messages
75
Location
Leeds
Yes indeed, 5484 does exist! The elusive A4 60004 had the tender from June 1948 until withdrawal in July 1966. Tender 5484 was then transferred to withdrawn 60009 prior to its sale into preservation.

O/T Is it true that 60004 never visited KX in the last ten years of steam on the ECML despite having a corridor tender?
 

Harvester

Established Member
Joined
9 Nov 2020
Messages
1,299
Location
Notts
O/T Is it true that 60004 never visited KX in the last ten years of steam on the ECML despite having a corridor tender?
It made a few appearances on the Elizabethan, but was never Haymarket’s first choice. In 1958 it worked the up train into Kings Cross on 24th August and returned north the next day on the down train. This was 60004’s last appearance in Kings Cross on the ‘Lizzie’.
 

anothertyke

Member
Joined
23 Jun 2023
Messages
75
Location
Leeds
It made a few appearances on the Elizabethan, but was never Haymarket’s first choice. In 1958 it worked the up train into Kings Cross on 24th August and returned north the next day on the down train. This was 60004’s last appearance in Kings Cross on the ‘Lizzie’.
Thank you. So the folk tale I was told..... need to go to Newcastle or Edinburgh, completely impossible of course.... was nearly true.
 

Spamcan81

Member
Joined
12 Sep 2011
Messages
1,079
Location
Bedfordshire
Are there any internal works narrow gauge locos surviving? I guess they would be a rarity.
IIRC three railway works n.g. locos have survived. Two steam : Horwich Works ‘Pet’ and Crewe Works ‘Wren’ and one diesel : Horwich Works ZM32.
Chesterton Jct. PW works had two n.g. Simplex locos but no idea if either have survived.
 

Ashley Hill

Established Member
Joined
8 Dec 2019
Messages
3,295
Location
The West Country
Yep....even though D8512/21/98 survived in BR service much longer than their sisters, working for the Derby Research Centre - latterly on the Mickleover test track IIRC.
If most preservationists at the time were not pre-occupying themselves with rescuing yet another Barry wreck or importing foreign steam locos then these and other rare diesels may have stood a chance of surviving!
 

1Q18

Member
Joined
7 May 2022
Messages
375
Location
Earth
Are there any internal works narrow gauge locos surviving? I guess they would be a rarity.
The Steeple Grange Light Railway have an (adorable) 18” gauge Ruston & Hornsby diesel which was built for Horwich works.

Ruston LAT ZM-32 "Horwich"​


IIRC three railway works n.g. locos have survived. Two steam : Horwich Works ‘Pet’ and Crewe Works ‘Wren’ and one diesel : Horwich Works ZM32.
Chesterton Jct. PW works had two n.g. Simplex locos but no idea if either have survived.
There’s also a 1911-built 3’ gauge Bagnall 0-4-0ST at the Amerton Railway in Staffordshire, which BR purchased in 1956 to work at the sleeper depot in Beeston, Notts.

W.G. Bagnall No. 1889 “No. 1”​

 

AJM580

Member
Joined
31 Jan 2016
Messages
617
Location
Norwich
IIRC three railway works n.g. locos have survived. Two steam : Horwich Works ‘Pet’ and Crewe Works ‘Wren’ and one diesel : Horwich Works ZM32.
Chesterton Jct. PW works had two n.g. Simplex locos but no idea if either have survived.
Both Chesterton locos survive, one at Mountsorrel & the other at the Ashover light Railway
 

norbitonflyer

Established Member
Joined
24 Mar 2020
Messages
2,443
Location
SW London
Difficult to beat the Class 89 - only one built and it has been preserved. Likewise Duke of Gloucester
The 15 is interesting, as they would almost certainly have gone extinct had it not been for D8233 and 3 others (sorry don’t have the numbers to hand) being saved for ETH (electric train heating) purposes. I
8203, 8233, 8237, 8243, numbered ADB968003/001/002/000 in that order

.


06003/D2420. Currently at Peak Rail in Rowsley, as part of the Heritage Shunters Trust collection.

;)
HST have examples of every class from 01 to 09

Then (an 09-geared class 13 replica) would have to be 13101.
That would be terribly confusuing, as the original 13101 still exists, (later D3101, no TOPS number carried as it was sold into industrial use in 1972)

The APT did run in revenue earning service for a time and quite successfully. They made some appearances on services normally loco hauled for about 18mths to 2 years in the mid 80s. My father was most surprised to discover that his normally 86/2 or 87 headed service from Euston was actually an APT-P on one occasion. They were never timetabled or adverrtised though.
That's the electric APT-P - "P" for pre-production (class 370). I understand the OP meant the gas-turbine powered APT-E (for experimental), which is now in the NRM at Shildon, which carried a few [passengers on demonstration runs but never went in to revenue service (or received a TOPS class)
1024px-ATP-E_IN_YARD.jpg


Perhaps a subject for a separate thread, but [Deltocs] must have one of the highest percentages of survivors (27.3% - production models only).
The class 44s haven't done badly at 20% (two out of 10)

Another one off prototype that ran in revenue service and made it into preservation would be the double decker 4DD.
Officially that was two units (albeit they usually ran as one train)

Difficult to beat the Class 89 - only one built and it has been preserved. Likewise Duke of Gloucester

8203, 8233, 8237, 8243, numbered ADB968003/001/002/000 in that order


HST have examples of every class from 01 to 09


That would be terribly confusuing, as the original 13101 still exists, (later D3101, no TOPS number carried as it was sold into industrial use in 1972)


That's the electric APT-P - "P" for pre-production (class 370). I understand the OP meant the gas-turbine powered APT-E (for experimental), which is now in the NRM at Shildon, which carried a few [passengers on demonstration runs but never went in to revenue service (or received a TOPS class)
1024px-ATP-E_IN_YARD.jpg



The class 44s haven't done badly at 20% (two out of 10)


Officially that was two units (albeit they usually ran as one train)
Taking "rare" as being 25 or fewer examples built, but disregarding class 59 as they are all still in service

Class 111 (twin/triple) 0.3/24 (1%) one trailer buffet car - some records have it as a class 101
Class 118 (triple) 0.3/15 (2%) one power car preserved
Class 106 (twin) 0.5/14 (4%) All power cars converted to class 105, one driving trailer preserved)
Class 06 1/25 (4%)
Class 81 1/25 (4%)
Class 71/74 1/24 (4%)
Class 28 1/20 (5%)
Class 83 1/15 (7%)
Class 82 1/10 (10%)
Class 84 1/10 (10%)
Class 103 (twin) 2.5/20 (12%)
Class 44 2/10 (20%)
Class 109 (twin) 1/5 (20%)
Class 48 1/5 (20%) converted to, and preserved as, class 47
Class 207 (triple) 4/19 (21%)
Class 202 (hex) 2/9 (22%)
Class 55 5/22 (23%)
Class 77 2/7 (29%)
Class 201 (hex) 2/7 (29%)
Class 02 7/20 (35%)
Class 122 7/20 (35%)
Class 07 5/14(36%)
Class 121 6/16 (38%)
Class 01 2/5 (40%)
Class 41 (HST) 1/2 (50%)
Class 403 (quin) 2.8/3 (93%) All fifteen cars originally preserved, but one subsequently written off in a fire.
Class 89 1/1 (100%)
Class 140 (twin) 1/1 (100%)

No examples preserved

Class 29 20 built
Class 16 10
Class 23 10 (one replica under construction)
Class 41 (NBL) 5
Class 13 3
Class 70 (SR) 3

Class 112 (25 twin units built)
Class 113 (25 twin)
Class 125 (20 triple)
Class 123 (10 quads)
Class 128 (10 single)
Class 124 (8.5 six-car)
Class 203 (7 six-car)
Class 251 (5 six/eight car)
Class 129 (3 single)
Class 210 (2 three/four car) (one DTSO preserved)

EDITED for class 111
 
Last edited:

Cowley

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Global Moderator
Joined
15 Apr 2016
Messages
15,807
Location
Devon
Difficult to beat the Class 89 - only one built and it has been preserved. Likewise Duke of Gloucester

8203, 8233, 8237, 8243, numbered ADB968003/001/002/000 in that order


HST have examples of every class from 01 to 09


That would be terribly confusuing, as the original 13101 still exists, (later D3101, no TOPS number carried as it was sold into industrial use in 1972)


That's the electric APT-P - "P" for pre-production (class 370). I understand the OP meant the gas-turbine powered APT-E (for experimental), which is now in the NRM at Shildon, which carried a few [passengers on demonstration runs but never went in to revenue service (or received a TOPS class)
1024px-ATP-E_IN_YARD.jpg



The class 44s haven't done badly at 20% (two out of 10)


Officially that was two units (albeit they usually ran as one train)


Taking "rare" as being 25 or fewer examples built, but disregarding class 59 as they are all still in service

Class 118 (triple) 0.3/15 (2%) one power car preserved
Class 106 (twin) 0.5/14 (4%) All converted to class 105, one driving trailer preserved)
Class 06 1/25 (4%)
Class 81 1/25 (4%)
Class 71/74 1/24 (4%)
Class 28 1/20 (5%)
Class 83 1/15 (7%)
Class 82 1/10 (10%)
Class 84 1/10 (10%)
Class 202 (hex) 2/9 (11%)
Class 103 (twin) 2.5/20 (12%)
Class 44 2/10 (20%)
Class 109 (twin) 1/5 (20%)
Class 48 1/5 (20%) converted to, and preserved as, class 47
Class 207 (triple) 4/19 (21%)
Class 55 5/22 (23%)
Class 77 2/7 (29%)
Class 201 (hex) 2/7 (29%)
Class 02 7/20 (35%)
Class 122 7/20 (35%)
Class 07 5/14(36%)
Class 121 6/16 (38%)
Class 01 2/5 (40%)
Class 41 (HST) 1/2 (50%)
Class 403 (quin) 2.8/3 (93%) All fifteen cars originally preserved, but one subsequently written off in a fire.
Class 89 1/1 (100%)
Class 140 (twin) 1/1 (100%)

No examples preserved
Class 112 (twin) (25 built)
Class 113 (twin) 25
Class 111 (twin/triple) 24
Class 29 20
Class 125 (triple) 20
Class 16 10
Class 23 10 (one replica under construction)
Class 123 (quad) 10
Class 128 10
Class 124 (hex) 8.5
Class 203 (hex) 7
Class 41 (NBL) 5
Class 251 5
Class 13 3
Class 70 (SR) 3
Class 129 3
Class 210 2 (one DTSO preserved)

Blimey that must have taken some effort!
 

Top