• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Lothian Group discussion (Lothian City, Lothian Country Bus and East Coast Buses)

Joined
15 Jul 2024
Messages
96
Location
Edinburgh
Went on 707e today. Pleasant ride, massive fan of the new bus stop system!

It does seems to get the routes in a messed up order (Interchange with: 29, 3, 31, 37, 47, 49, 7). I think it’s because it puts it in order of the first digit, not the number as a whole.

The 8 I was on was packed so seems to be a hit! 10/10 from me.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

VioletEclipse

Member
Joined
10 Nov 2018
Messages
903
Location
Dùn Èideann
Went on 707e today. Pleasant ride, massive fan of the new bus stop system!

It does seems to get the routes in a messed up order (Interchange with: 29, 3, 31, 37, 47, 49, 7). I think it’s because it puts it in order of the first digit, not the number as a whole.

The 8 I was on was packed so seems to be a hit! 10/10 from me.
one effect of the new announcements is that there's hardly any pause in announcements, the monent it's finished there's only a number of seconds until the next announcement.
otherwise I agree, the BZLs seem to be good quality and Lothian have done a brilliant job of making them seem modern and high quality on the inside and outside, and the new design of the rear bench is something I hadn't seen before. Not sure about the new next stop display though, it's much smaller text so unless you're at the front you can't easily read anything but the stop you're currently at when it's on the screen.
 

FlybeDash8Q400

Established Member
Joined
26 Jun 2018
Messages
2,258
Location
Edinburgh
one effect of the new announcements is that there's hardly any pause in announcements, the monent it's finished there's only a number of seconds until the next announcement.
otherwise I agree, the BZLs seem to be good quality and Lothian have done a brilliant job of making them seem modern and high quality on the inside and outside, and the new design of the rear bench is something I hadn't seen before. Not sure about the new next stop display though, it's much smaller text so unless you're at the front you can't easily read anything but the stop you're currently at when it's on the screen.
I don’t understand the move away from Lato as well. It looks cheap amongst an otherwise quality product. The back row downstairs is really well thought out though with the armrests and the luggage space.

Bring back the old announcements. I’m sure the connections could be re-recorded. It also announces pointless connections like N14 at 8am in the morning or 29 (and others) at Leith Street which barely any stop there bar a handful of depot runs at the start and end of the day.
 
Joined
25 Jan 2022
Messages
1,046
Location
Edinburgh
The new BZLs are horrible! They are very cheaply made, some parts were literally not in place in some of them too! I'm not a fan of the white poles, I think it looks hideous The Zero Emissions branding everywhere is laughable. The next stop announcements are shocking, very irritating. The old announcements were fantastic, and the voice wasn't a robot either.

The next stop screens are a mess. They don't look nice whatsoever. The map is thoughtful but still not great. The Arial font on them makes everything nasty as well. The new livery is such a mess in my opinion, particularly in person. I like the armrests on the rear seats however and they luggage spaces too. The seats are great but the seats are the same as featured on most Lothian vehicles anyway. Thankfully they aren't at an odd angle like the Evoras.

The build quality is absolutely shocking, and 701e was broken at Muirhouse for about 10 minutes, and 710e was faulty and an engineer had to have a look at it. 708e replaced 709e very early in the afternoon so you can't imagine that being a good sign either. The new floor texture isn't as favourable but it is still alright. Some stop bells are white, featured on priority seats and wheelchair spaces, which doesn't make sense to me whatsoever, I'd make them all red and have blue for the wheelchair spaces.

Having a look at the materials on the bus, the glass seems awfully thin on them and so does the panels inside, which are also hollow. Now I hope one doesn't go on fire and end up hurting people. Something I do like the addition of is the litter bin inside. And I don't like the screen inside either which is similar to the exterior display, and of course the horrid interior screen.

USBA and USBC cable choices on them is a good implementation, which is now a standard on buses.
 

VioletEclipse

Member
Joined
10 Nov 2018
Messages
903
Location
Dùn Èideann
701e was broken at Muirhouse for about 10 minutes, and 710e was faulty and an engineer had to have a look at it. 708e replaced 709e very early in the afternoon so you can't imagine that being a good sign either.
Teething issues in the first weeks of a new batch aren't unheard of, but we'll have to see in the long term how they fare, it's unlikely that we'll have a repeat of a certain batch of battery electric buses that were delivered 7 years ago in terms of reliability.
 
Joined
15 Jul 2024
Messages
96
Location
Edinburgh
The next stop screens are a mess. They don't look nice whatsoever. The map is thoughtful but still not great. The Arial font on them makes everything nasty as well. The new livery is such a mess in my opinion, particularly in person. I like the armrests on the rear seats however and they luggage spaces too. The seats are great but the seats are the same as featured on most Lothian vehicles anyway. Thankfully they aren't at an odd angle like the Evoras.
I think if they changed the announcements back to the ones on the E400MMCs, reworded some things and changed everything to Lato, it would be better. There’s always room for improvement but at least they aren’t as bad as the milk duds (StreetAirs).
The build quality is absolutely shocking, and 701e was broken at Muirhouse for about 10 minutes, and 710e was faulty and an engineer had to have a look at it. 708e replaced 709e very early in the afternoon so you can't imagine that being a good sign either. The new floor texture isn't as favourable but it is still alright. Some stop bells are white, featured on priority seats and wheelchair spaces, which doesn't make sense to me whatsoever, I'd make them all red and have blue for the wheelchair spaces.
Remember this is their first day in service so there is bound to be issues.

EDIT - Back on another BZL (708e) and immediately noticed the time on the next stop screens says 03:30, in 12 hour format without a PM. This may be simple but it irritates me a lot!
 
Last edited:

FlybeDash8Q400

Established Member
Joined
26 Jun 2018
Messages
2,258
Location
Edinburgh
The build quality is absolutely shocking, and 701e was broken at Muirhouse for about 10 minutes, and 710e was faulty and an engineer had to have a look at it. 708e replaced 709e very early in the afternoon so you can't imagine that being a good sign either. The new floor texture isn't as favourable but it is still alright. Some stop bells are white, featured on priority seats and wheelchair spaces, which doesn't make sense to me whatsoever, I'd make them all red and have blue for the wheelchair spaces.
I got 708 this morning, so are you sure that’s correct?

I completely disagree with you though. The buses are well thought out, well designed and seem decent so far. Yes there’s been a few issues, but it’s the first type in the fleet so there’s a higher chance of problem.
 

Lx008

Member
Joined
16 Jul 2023
Messages
88
Location
Edinburgh
Just took a trip to try out the new buses and ended up on 997 (again) but it felt different inside than when it was a demonstrator, this might just be my memory but has the interior of 997 been changed to be in line with the rest of the BZL‘s?
 
Joined
25 Jan 2022
Messages
1,046
Location
Edinburgh
I find it hard to believe that 708 was taken off then brought back out later on.
I was on 709 when this happened. I was waiting on 709 for about 20 minutes so it wouldn't have been late/bundling up.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

I believe a few bus spotter took photos of it happening as well.
 

CSB0241

Member
Joined
22 Apr 2023
Messages
265
Location
Edinburgh, Scotland
So, just for clarification, is the bus 701 or 701e and does it even really matter?
I don’t think it matters. I’m probably just gonna refer to them without the suffix, & I think that it likely won’t last more than a few months.

Presumably 291-4 and 997 will have e added to their fleet number stickers for consistency
I think it’ll be the other way round (would be odd if they did).

What happens to 351 to 400 once all new buses in service ?
Nothing.

As for it being a marketing gimmick, I doubt any regular passengers ever notice the fleet number of a bus when boarding or alighting, let alone potential passengers.
I’m an enthusiast & I seldom bother to read the fleet number, so I doubt your average joe will either.

291-294 are a microfleet that stick out like a sore thumb in relation to the rest of the fleet thanks to their green colour scheme, and 997 is still technically only a demonstrator I believe? Now that electric buses are going to take up a significant proportion of the fleet, it makes sense to me to officially differentiate them from the regular diesel buses.
It might seem like an odd idea, but I wouldn’t be shocked if Lothian ordered a further 6 BYDs (295-300). Whether they’d have SPEN branding or normal Lothian branding, who knows.

I think that the more interesting question is what happens to those vehicles that are cascaded to other depots, particularly Musselburgh and Livingston. What improvements will we see on ECB and LC services?
I’d be surprised if they did get sent elsewhere.

Just took a trip to try out the new buses and ended up on 997 (again) but it felt different inside than when it was a demonstrator, this might just be my memory but has the interior of 997 been changed to be in line with the rest of the BZL‘s?
You might just be misremembering.

The displaced fleet should in theory be used to increase frequencies within the city fleet. I can’t see ECB gaining any extra buses as Musselburgh as far as I know is at capacity, but LC might gain a small number to increase frequencies or add new routes. Plenty of space to do it, more driver resource dependent than anything.
I think that a couple MMCs (601-610?) could theoretically get sent to Livingston for increases on the X27/8 & 72.

I’ve been thinking that once 701-750 arrive. Maybe some of 670-698 will move to Lothian Country as I’ve heard rumours that these batch may move west or east.
I think they’d go to the earlier half of the fleet.

Are the timetable changes with the 23, 24 and 27 going to take place with the spares that would be on the 8/9?
Considering some of the Central MMCs have moved to Marine (so far 672-680), I guess not.

I can see 926-928, 1000 & 1002-1003 moving to Lothian Country but no repaint (like what happened before the big cuts a while back). If anything, 1000, 1002 & 1003 will get repainted, either that or some other buses move. I have heard that some of Volvo B5TL E400MMCs are to move but it could just be a rumour.
I can see 926-928 moving, but I think 1000-1003 would move to Marine instead.

I've been told all the 400s are earmarked to be transferred out of Central as electrification progresses.
It’d be interesting to see if this happens (I doubt it will though).

Realistically, there will be around 4-8 electrics for Sunday at most. Fleet movements to other depots will be slow to start until the rest of the batch arrive.
Turned out to be 10.

I haven’t seen the full allocations for next week in entirety, though the 8/9 will definitely be “electrified” first.
Correct.

Odd to see that 670 has stayed at Central, unless it will be moved tonight.
I imagine it’ll arrive at Longstone or Marine in the next week.

I just saw 709 and 710. 710 was on the 8
To be fair that livery does go well on them. It’s esentially the same livery as pre Harlequin just with a few different bits of gold trim
When I saw the first few photos, I imagined that they’d look abysmal, but I honestly think they look great (bar the front, bit too much madder & it looks bad on the right hand side under the driver’s window.

670 and 671 still in Central, most of 672-678 out on Marine routes today, assuming these will be to cover the 15/45 extension and the extra peak work despite it only being a PVR increase of 4 or 5
Sounds plausible.

Several of 426-437 still haven’t moved so I think they’ll get round to them later.
I think they’ll use the Ex-Go Ahead G2s on the 22 temporarily, then move the remaining 15-plates over gradually over the next week or so.

Interestingly, the 19 is all 2017 Zoo-branded B5TL/Gemini 3s (normally 2014 B5TL/G3s), the 22 is all 2015 B5LH hybrids, and the 26 has a relatively large number of 2021 B5/E400s.
I was surprised by the 19. Less so the 22 though, only 4(?) 15-plates have moved so they’ll likely be refuelling.

Went on 707e today. Pleasant ride, massive fan of the new bus stop system! It does seems to get the routes in a messed up order (Interchange with: 29, 3, 31, 37, 47, 49, 7). I think it’s because it puts it in order of the first digit, not the number as a whole.
I think you’re on your own about the stop systems. The powerpoint looks like it was designed by an 8 year old, & it bombards you with more information than necessary. Worth noting that they are the same as 10’s trial announcements. I have heard that some drivers are just turning the announcements off altogether due to it being a nightmare (with which I agree), so I doubt they’ll last long before getting the “official” Lothian ones.

one effect of the new announcements is that there's hardly any pause in announcements, the monent it's finished there's only a number of seconds until the next announcement.
My point exactly.

I don’t understand the move away from Lato as well.
I wasn’t actually paying attention to that. Might try go on another after school tomorrow to analyse further.

Bring back the old announcements.
Yes.

The new BZLs are horrible!
From what I’ve heard, that seems to be the general consensus.

There’s always room for improvement but at least they aren’t as bad as the milk duds (StreetAirs).
I haven’t much experience with those unfortunately so I can’t say much.

Remember this is their first day in service so there is bound to be issues.
Fair.

I find it hard to believe that 708 was taken off then brought back out later on.
710 was too, 703 broke down at King’s Buildings so they sent 710 back out to replace it.

I believe a few bus spotter took photos of it happening as well.
I may or may not have been one of those bus spotters (photo linked below). :lol:

Overall, I’m mixed on the BZLs. I went on 5 of them (705>709>710>997>710), so I thinjI have compiled a pros/cons list for my thoughts on them.
  • Pro: I think having both USB-A & USB-C instead of just one or two USB-A ports is a good idea, since quite a few tech companies are replacing their Type-A cables with Type-C, but I’m still probably gonna stick to using Type-A instead.
  • Pro: The redesign at the back is a nice move. The small luggage racks are a neat little addition, along with the extra arm room.
  • Pro: The red strips of light next to the main downstairs lights (which was one of the things I didn’t like about 997) has been removed.
  • Pro: The seats are extremely comfy, & that’s coming from someone who doesn’t really like Lazzerini Highbacks.
  • Con: They have the stretched blinds that the 15-plate hybrids (& 391/497) now have.
  • Con: Why on earth are the handlebars light gray?
  • Con: I don’t think I need to mention the next stop announcements/powerpoints.
  • Con: The Everyone’s Journey display next to the door always has Everyone’s Journey in both italics & another font altogether for some inexplicable reason.
If I were to rate them out of 10, I’d give them a 7/10, but I completely understand why people would dislike them. I also got some photos of the interior of a few of them (along with my aforementioned shot of 708/9), which I shall link below.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3749.jpeg
    IMG_3749.jpeg
    2.7 MB · Views: 101
  • IMG_3780.jpeg
    IMG_3780.jpeg
    1.7 MB · Views: 100
  • IMG_3781.jpeg
    IMG_3781.jpeg
    146.6 KB · Views: 98
  • IMG_3786.jpeg
    IMG_3786.jpeg
    1.2 MB · Views: 96
  • IMG_3790.jpeg
    IMG_3790.jpeg
    3 MB · Views: 95
  • IMG_3796.jpeg
    IMG_3796.jpeg
    1.2 MB · Views: 98
  • IMG_3797.jpeg
    IMG_3797.jpeg
    2.9 MB · Views: 94
  • IMG_3799.jpeg
    IMG_3799.jpeg
    309.5 KB · Views: 96
Joined
15 Jul 2024
Messages
96
Location
Edinburgh
Alright, so the first day of the BZL operation is coming to an end. From what I have gathered on forums, other sites and my experience, here is what I have gathered:
  • The announcement voice is messed up.
  • The next stop screens are cool but need reworded.
  • Bring back Lato!
  • The windows are slightly too thin.
  • They keep breaking down.
  • They are slow and small.
  • 997 is better.
  • No glazed staircases.
  • Why are there so many Zero Emissions branding?
  • The livery is actually pretty nice.
  • Barely any pauses on announcement voice.
  • Interchanged routes for every stop? Really?
  • They are quite smooth.
  • The USBs are a nice touch.
Anything else? Did I miss anything? Keep me updated! :lol:
 

Lothiangem22

Member
Joined
30 Jan 2019
Messages
161
Regarding the announcements…

This is early days - bus 10 also has the same and one of the Longstone 600’s.

The new announcements and visuals are interlinked with the new AVL systems. Now these are fully installed the announcements are being worked on. It seems the default setup is set up for a network with fewer stops - ie: intercity work.

This will eventually roll out on all vehicles in the fleet and will be adjusted to suit the network.

Enhancements include;

Map visuals
Ability to announce on diversion(planned and unplanned)
Ability to take into account stop closures
Ability to announce prior to going on diversion

While the current system is good and what we are used to the new system will be live as such rather than a pre uploaded route with announcements.

Watch this space, as there is lots of other features and when it has been worked on will offer a far better experience
 

stevenedin

Established Member
Joined
26 Jul 2021
Messages
1,572
Location
Edinburgh
I actually noticed that the destination displays are stretched up like 551-570 and also I think it was 660 on the 44 earlier also had a stretched destination screen. I wonder if they are changing them all to stretched.
 

Bus9120UK

Established Member
Joined
5 Oct 2019
Messages
1,680
Location
Edinburgh
I actually noticed that the destination displays are stretched up like 551-570 and also I think it was 660 on the 44 earlier also had a stretched destination screen. I wonder if they are changing them all to stretched.
Its evidently the new standard but there won't be an active effort to replace them across the fleet.
 

ScotRail158725

Established Member
Joined
27 Nov 2018
Messages
2,446
BZLs not the worst, the livery looks decent i don’t see the upset with it, the announcements and next stop displays are terrible though and need changed. As someone who uses the 8 almost daily they dont seem too bad off first impression but the Enviro 400 B5TLs definitely a better vehicles
 

Avenger20

Member
Joined
8 Aug 2011
Messages
208
Good morning all,

Just had the pleasure of boarding 657 on my doorstep after the 44 has been rerouted around Masons Way in Wallyford.

I know some have been chatting about announcements on the BZLs but has the system volume been turned up on the rest of the fleet? We're somewhat being shouted at, at this young hour of the day too! Wondering if it's a fault with this vehicle or if the update has made all announcements louder?
 

ScotRail158725

Established Member
Joined
27 Nov 2018
Messages
2,446
I know some have been chatting about announcements on the BZLs but has the system volume been turned up on the rest of the fleet? We're somewhat being shouted at, at this young hour of the day too! Wondering if it's a fault with this vehicle or if the update has made all announcements louder?
657s always been loud, ive had it at some ungodly hours of the morning after a rough night and its not pleasant at all
 

sannox

Member
Joined
1 Mar 2016
Messages
554
I see the revised route in the Heriot Watt campus for the new 32, which allows buses to go out the west gate has unintentionally cancelled the Oriam Parkrun event as buses now cross the run route.
 

H00V3R

Member
Joined
14 Apr 2024
Messages
42
Location
Edinburgh
I see the revised route in the Heriot Watt campus for the new 32, which allows buses to go out the west gate has unintentionally cancelled the Oriam Parkrun event as buses now cross the run route.
Unless I’m missing something they are only crossing the road twice at the West gate (once out and once back). This road has always been in use for the emergency services, so people should be looking when crossing the road anyway? Seems like an overreaction to cancel it seeing as only 2 buses per hour use it.
 

sannox

Member
Joined
1 Mar 2016
Messages
554
Unless I’m missing something they are only crossing the road twice at the West gate (once out and once back). This road has always been in use for the emergency services, so people should be looking when crossing the road anyway? Seems like an overreaction to cancel it seeing as only 2 buses per hour use it.

My understanding is that the road was closed at weekends and only open daytime on weekdays. Crossing active roads isn't compatible with the parkrun format for safety reasons. Apparently this wasn't communicated to Parkrun organisers, hence the cancellations and need to revise the course to avoid the bus route.

From 8th September, the 32 bus will enter the university campus via the West Gait, crossing our current course at the cottage. We were unfortunately unaware of these plans until they were recently announced by Lothian Buses. Despite our requests, it has not been possible to change the bus schedule to factor in the time of the parkrun.
 

FlybeDash8Q400

Established Member
Joined
26 Jun 2018
Messages
2,258
Location
Edinburgh
My understanding is that the road was closed at weekends and only open daytime on weekdays. Crossing active roads isn't compatible with the parkrun format for safety reasons. Apparently this wasn't communicated to Parkrun organisers, hence the cancellations and need to revise the course to avoid the bus route.
Given the fact a request was made some months ago for the 32 to do this route, I’d say that’s on the Parkrun planners for not being aware of the plan.
 

sannox

Member
Joined
1 Mar 2016
Messages
554
Given the fact a request was made some months ago for the 32 to do this route, I’d say that’s on the Parkrun planners for not being aware of the plan.

Presumably somewhere there has been a breakdown in communication and should have have told them months ago.
 

computerSaysNo

Established Member
Joined
14 Dec 2018
Messages
1,458
I've just noticed that the new bus stop departures screen at Muirston Crescent is showing the minutes countdown instead of timetabled time, and appears to agree with the countdowns on the Lothian app - does this mean that the system has been switched over now? Or is it just another test?
 

Bus9120UK

Established Member
Joined
5 Oct 2019
Messages
1,680
Location
Edinburgh
I've just noticed that the new bus stop departures screen at Muirston Crescent is showing the minutes countdown instead of timetabled time, and appears to agree with the countdowns on the Lothian app - does this mean that the system has been switched over now? Or is it just another test?
It will be a test, unless things have switched in the last hour, the stop I last checked was still displaying timetable information.
 

Top