Xenophon PCDGS
Veteran Member
If I was a taxpaying 16 year old, I'd want a vote.
Are there any statistics available in the public domain that give the average of the income tax paid by 16 year old workers?
If I was a taxpaying 16 year old, I'd want a vote.
I've always been bad at debating, and find myself bad at expressing my views on other things outside of politics.
This is the first time I think I've ever discussed my own political beliefs outside of close friends and family
Last time someone tried linking representation to taxation there were riots on the streets and the PM who suggested it was kicked out soon after.Are there any statistics available in the public domain that give the average of the income tax paid by 16 year old workers?
Last time someone tried linking representation to taxation there were riots on the streets and the PM who suggested it was kicked out soon after.
I was merely suggesting that our democracy doesn't restrict voting rights to taxpayers, so how much 16-year-olds earn or pay in tax doesn't seem to be very relevant to whether they should have the vote. After all many pensioners don't pay tax, and nobody's suggesting denying them the vote...This is a most unusual response to a question that asked what was the average income tax paid by 16 year old workers, that in itself being asked in response to a statement that made such a claim.
I was merely suggesting that our democracy doesn't restrict voting rights to taxpayers, so how much 16-year-olds earn or pay in tax doesn't seem to be very relevant to whether they should have the vote. After all many pensioners don't pay tax, and nobody's suggesting denying them the vote...
Of course 16 year olds are tax payers unless they never buy anything that attracts VAT...
And I worry if Jezza gets inI worry for my country if the Tories get in. You watch, within the next 5 years, those on the poverty line will be driven further down, workers rights will get eroded, we will have a financial crash and our NHS will get more in the hands of the 1%.
I worry for my country if the Tories get in. You watch, within the next 5 years, those on the poverty line will be driven further down, workers rights will get eroded, we will have a financial crash and our NHS will get more in the hands of the 1%.
And I worry if Jezza gets in
And apparently tonight’s Question Time special was very anti-Boris. So I’m not so sure.
Only if they work for the money in their pockets. Otherwise it is their parents or the state paying any tax.Of course 16 year olds are tax payers unless they never buy anything that attracts VAT...
I'm surprised there isn't more discussion the fact that some train drivers earn over £80k and ASLEF is backed by the Labour party (or vice versa, I don't know) and that train drivers may be paying a subscription to Labour through their ASLEF deductions. So train drivers are supporting a party that wants to take more money off them. Surely that shouldn't be going down well?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/50517136
I wonder if that guy in the QT audience was a train driver!
Have you had sight of the edited printers draft 2020 edition of "Old Moores Almanac" or are you just a distant relation of Nostrodamus and thus gifted with the same hereditary ability of seeing into the future?
Or maybe I live in a area where we have a Tory metro mayor whose obsessed with playing Trams, a Tory council which introduced schemes such as two hours free parking, and now wants to build a new leisure centre reducing parking provision in one of the main town centres and a Tory MP who is a staunch Brexiteer and voted for reducing central government funding of local government alongside replacing Trident with a new system and against giving an increase on benefits to those who are unable to work because they are disabled.
Now you see why I fear for Britain if the Tories remain in power.
In the "big city" of Manchester not so many miles away to the north of our residence, but fortunate for us who live in the different county of Cheshire East, they have a Labour metro mayor who is obsessed with playing trains, a Labour council and a number of Labour MPs with socialist axes to grind.
Now you see why I fear for Britain if the Corbyn/Momentum alliance achieve power.
Always my plan to return there when I retire. Also I still care about my country even if I don’t live there. Many people disparage Donald Trump but don’t live in the USA - I don’t see any difference.Erm, why? You don't live in the UK.
Well statedOn one hand, we have some saying that a 15-16 year old that went to Syria was groomed and taken advantage of because of their age, then on the other hand we have some (often the same people I would suggest) saying that we should stop and listen to a 15-16 year old as an authority on climate change. Which is it? People can't have it both ways.
If you want to lower the voting age, then you can also lower the age at which a person can be named in court from 18 to 16.
So you'd rather have a bunch of Tories with their tax dodging fat cat supporters in power. Giving tax breaks to the rich and stifling the poor. Fat cats running our national utilities and selling our national health service to Trump.
I don't.
I assume you’re not a fan of the NHS then.What is the name given to the socialist opposite of "fat cats" ? What party was favoured by Robert Maxwell?
"Stifling the poor" sounds just like what might have been the title of one of those hilarious "Monty Python" sketches. I am surprised that you have not used part of their "Four Yorkshiremen" sketch in your posting above.
To be honest, of all the cats that we have come across, I suppose the best example I have seen of a fat cat was a lioness many years ago in a nature documentary who had over-gorged herself and certainly had an extended stomach....
I'll put my hands in the air and say I may not be as well informed as other people on this thread. I am after all only 19 and have nowhere near as much life experience as many others. I'm not even THAT interested in politics, I used to be, but not anymore. In recent years it's been far too divisive, and it seems to bring out the worst in people. I believe it shouldn't be about "winning", but about collaborating to ensure all voices are heard, and that the people come first.
Even if you don't agree with my opinions I sincerely thank you for taking the time to read them. It genuinely means a lot
Hmm, if under eighteens are incapable of understanding complex matters such that they could not be trusted to vote perhaps the age of criminal responsibility should be raised from ten to eighteen to also match?
Erm, why? You don't live in the UK.
Exactly! Old enough to be tried for murder. Not old enough to vote. Old enough to join the army but not old enough to vote! Looking at some people in the real world I wonder if there should be an intelligence test to qualify you for voting rather than an age limit!
Looking at some under 16s ages that appeared in a news item in the last 24 hours, did you see the ages of both girls and boys accused of assaulting the police during the disorder that occurred in Birmingham?
Indeed - however assaulting a police officer has a very wide definition and is a useful tool used to easily and quickly arrest someone.