• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

CAF Civity for TfW: News and updates on introduction.

sd0733

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2012
Messages
3,625
One point that is sometimes forgotten is that trains are having progressively fewer seats fitted, so more people have to stand. A 2-car 158 has 138 seats. A 2-car 197 has 116 seats, so that is 22 extra people standing before the overcrowding of either is taken into account.

That said, getting more 3-car 197s into service is very much needed it would appear.
2 car 197s struggle across the board with capacity with the reduced seating. People also seem reluctant to spread down the aisles in them, more so than 150s but do spread more than end door stock like 175s.
The next sets to be accepted really are needed to add capacity onto some of the current workings.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Jamesrob637

Established Member
Joined
12 Aug 2016
Messages
5,246
2 car 197s struggle across the board with capacity with the reduced seating. People also seem reluctant to spread down the aisles in them, more so than 150s but do spread more than end door stock like 175s.
The next sets to be accepted really are needed to add capacity onto some of the current workings.

At least if a diagram is scheduled 2x2 car and one has a fault, something is likely to run and get many home albeit a bit cozy and delayed.
 

SWML9102

Member
Joined
28 Oct 2019
Messages
23
Location
bridgend
It won't have helped that the GWR 1639 to Swansea at Cardiff didn't leave until 1711.
Most people waiting for the 1639 Swansea (like me) didn't even bother attempting to board as the GWR was only a couple of minutes behind. The 1703 Carmarthen is always a busy service, made worse by the fact the previously regular 3 car 175 is now booked a 2 car 197. Hopefully we will see more capacity in South Wales eventually!
 

60159

Member
Joined
26 Nov 2018
Messages
227
They normally use a couple of the roads in the Carriage sheds ad they've also got pits there for underframe checks.

I honestly couldnt say for sure but now the 1st class ones are being delivered it would seem likely they'll just follow the other 3 cars through.
The ERTMS sets will AFAIk be last though.
Many thanks for that.
 

RailWonderer

Established Member
Joined
25 Jul 2018
Messages
1,610
Location
All around the network
Has TfW ordered enough 197s or it will the remaining units when in service make up for the capacity shortfall? I would not be happy if a 3/4 car 175 became a 2 car 197.
 

sd0733

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2012
Messages
3,625
Has TfW ordered enough 197s or it will the remaining units when in service make up for the capacity shortfall? I would not be happy if a 3/4 car 175 became a 2 car 197.
Ignoring the ERTMS sets which are more or less a like for like 158 replacement, There's still 20 (including the elusive 045) 197s to enter service, most of them 3 car plus another Mk4 set to enter service (and the 5th coaches).
Thats 68 coaches, almost the size of the entire 175 fleet so once all those are in service there should be a massive reduction in the amount of 2 and 3 car running on long distance routes.
 

nigelsporne

Member
Joined
20 Dec 2012
Messages
91
I was at Shrewsbury last week and all three 197s were two car. Services were still 150s and 158s with a single 153 on the Swansea. Time keeping was very poor not helped by lengthy station stops. All services were packed and certainly would benefit from additional capacity as mentioned above.
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,568
Newport Gwent always annoys me. It’s so unnecessary. It’s not going to be Newport Essex, is it.
I thought it would be obvious as to which Newport the train was about to arrive at.
Obvious to passengers with a reasonable sense of where places are and knowledge of the rail network. However not everyone possesses those qualities. There are least two places called Newport in the southern half of Wales, although the other one I'm thinking of is not on the rail network some passengers may not know that. Wouldn't be a problem for Welsh-language announcements though since one Newport is Casnewydd and the other is Trefdraeth.
 

Peter Sarf

Established Member
Joined
12 Oct 2010
Messages
5,711
Location
Croydon
Rainham Essex and Rainham Kent. Important to get the direction to the correct one otherwise you could get very wet getting from one to the other (Thames) !. But yes TfW do need to be consistent and correct with county/conurbation names.
 

Richard Scott

Established Member
Joined
13 Dec 2018
Messages
3,696
Obvious to passengers with a reasonable sense of where places are and knowledge of the rail network. However not everyone possesses those qualities. There are least two places called Newport in the southern half of Wales, although the other one I'm thinking of is not on the rail network some passengers may not know that. Wouldn't be a problem for Welsh-language announcements though since one Newport is Casnewydd and the other is Trefdraeth.
It's very common in Germany to state where a town/city is e.g. Neustadt as there are quite a few. To be honest there are a few Newports in UK and a foreign traveller may not be familiar. There are also two Gillinghams, which are referred to by the country they're in. Sorry, if going a bit off topic.
 

Caaardiff

Member
Joined
9 Jun 2019
Messages
872
Has TfW ordered enough 197s or it will the remaining units when in service make up for the capacity shortfall? I would not be happy if a 3/4 car 175 became a 2 car 197.
Long term the plan is to run a lot more multiple sets either 2+2 or 2+3.

It's difficult to balance the numbers for TFW as there's been so many changes of late.

The majority of the fleet would have been 158s (24) and 175s (27) along with a number of 150/153's on West Wales, Bidston, Crewe - Shrewsbury and Crewe - Chester to name a few. If you include the 153's (26 - so 13 pairs) that's 64 units vs CAF's 77.
Bear in mind that 153's will be retained for West Wales and HOWL services.
Also throw what was originally planned to be 8 Mk4's, now 7 with a maximum of 5 in service which eventually will be 5 carriages. That's 82 sets for Mainline work.
This excludes where the 231's will be deployed (Maesteg, Cheltenham, Ebbw Vale). I wouldn't be surprised to see them on Cardiff - Swansea Swanline services too.

Then when you take into account SDs analysis that there will be 26 3 car 197's vs 16 3 car 175's, overall carriage capacity will be increased across the board.

The attached photo is from the Franchise proposal of where the fleet would be. Things have changed a lot since then.
The 175's should have gone by Q2 2022
The 158's should have gone by Q1 2023
The 153's should have gone by Q1 2023 (Now staying to replace 170's)
The 150's should have gone by Q4 2023
 

Attachments

  • TFW Fleet Plan.jpg
    TFW Fleet Plan.jpg
    61.7 KB · Views: 95

AdamWW

Established Member
Joined
6 Nov 2012
Messages
3,672
Obvious to passengers with a reasonable sense of where places are and knowledge of the rail network. However not everyone possesses those qualities. There are least two places called Newport in the southern half of Wales, although the other one I'm thinking of is not on the rail network some passengers may not know that. Wouldn't be a problem for Welsh-language announcements though since one Newport is Casnewydd and the other is Trefdraeth.

I can see the need to qualify in timetables, journey planners and the like.

But on a train when there's only one Newport it calls at?

I can't see where there's scope for confusion.
 

Jamesrob637

Established Member
Joined
12 Aug 2016
Messages
5,246
Not sure whether it's been mentioned but 90015 dragged a unit up to (presumably) Crewe not long ago. Electric locomotives dragging diesel units are a rarity.
 

MarkWiles

Member
Joined
21 Jul 2019
Messages
66
Do they announce Bangor as Bangor Gwynedd? Just in case anyone thinks that because they ride a CAF unit they are arriving in Bangor County Down.
 
Joined
13 Feb 2011
Messages
1,063
Location
Cardiff
Do we have an upto date list of which 197s have entered service?

(Apologies if it exists I’ve tried searching and don’t have the patience to hunt through 12 months worth of posts)
 

Bevan Price

Established Member
Joined
22 Apr 2010
Messages
7,346
I was at Shrewsbury last week and all three 197s were two car. Services were still 150s and 158s with a single 153 on the Swansea. Time keeping was very poor not helped by lengthy station stops. All services were packed and certainly would benefit from additional capacity as mentioned above.
For me, the problems with Class 197 are:
1. Rail operators still have not learned that 2 car dmus are inadequate for most UK services; what we really need is a mixture of 3 and 4 car sets**.
2. Too much space is wasted on "that catering cabinet"; an extra 12 or so seats would have been a better use of space.
3. On some sets, useful space is going to be wasted by having "1st / Business" class seating.

** - Of course, the useless DfT/Treasury are probably culpable for us still buying short trains.
 

GWVillager

Member
Joined
2 May 2022
Messages
800
Location
Wales & Western
For me, the problems with Class 197 are:
1. Rail operators still have not learned that 2 car dmus are inadequate for most UK services; what we really need is a mixture of 3 and 4 car sets**.
2. Too much space is wasted on "that catering cabinet"; an extra 12 or so seats would have been a better use of space.
3. On some sets, useful space is going to be wasted by having "1st / Business" class seating.

** - Of course, the useless DfT/Treasury are probably culpable for us still buying short trains.
The DfT/Treasury are not directly responsible for the 197 procurement, TfW is devolved to the Welsh Government. As has been said before, they will also be operating many more services as 3,4 or 5 coach trains than before, as there are simply more units. I agree that the catering space is too large, though.
 

LNW-GW Joint

Veteran Member
Joined
22 Feb 2011
Messages
19,708
Location
Mold, Clwyd
Do they announce Bangor as Bangor Gwynedd? Just in case anyone thinks that because they ride a CAF unit they are arriving in Bangor County Down.
There's actually another Bangor in Wales, Bangor on Dee, east of Wrexham (Bangor-is-y-Coed in Welsh).
Its station, on the old Cambrian, closed with Beeching.
 

The_Train

Established Member
Joined
2 Jun 2018
Messages
4,363
Do we have an upto date list of which 197s have entered service?

(Apologies if it exists I’ve tried searching and don’t have the patience to hunt through 12 months worth of posts)

Type "Active" into the Search Fleet box and it will show all the ones that have carried passengers - I'm confident I am up to date with this but if anyone has any corrections to make, they are always welcomed :)
 

Lurcheroo

Member
Joined
21 Sep 2021
Messages
532
Location
Wales
1. Rail operators still have not learned that 2 car dmus are inadequate for most UK services
TFW certainly operate a very good number of services where 2 coaches is significantly more than adequate.
We will see once all 197’s are in service wether or not they did their sums correctly.
 

GWVillager

Member
Joined
2 May 2022
Messages
800
Location
Wales & Western
Sorry to dig up an older post, but is there anywhere I can see this?
There’s the documentary. I can’t remember the exact time (I believe it’s about 19 minutes in, though I could be completely wrong), but it’s when they are looking around the factory in Newport.

So sorry to be pedantic, but that’s not true; the seats used are the same type as 397/Nova 3 instead. :)
And those in turn are the same seats, as far as I know. I think they’re both variants of the Freedman “Luxury” offering, just with different cushion shaping. The frame is extraordinarily similarly shaped if not.

Edit: they might actually be versions of the Fainsa-Compin High Speed seats. Either way, I do think they are the same seats.
 
Last edited:

superalbs

Established Member
Joined
3 Jul 2014
Messages
2,471
Location
Exeter

There’s the documentary. I can’t remember the exact time (I believe it’s about 19 minutes in, though I could be completely wrong), but it’s when they are looking around the factory in Newport.


And those in turn are the same seats, as far as I know. I think they’re both variants of the Freedman “Luxury” offering, just with different cushion shaping. The frame is extraordinarily similarly shaped if not.
That's cool, thanks.

As I'm in Thailand for a few more days, I can't watch it. Is there any time limit for viewing?
 

Top