I read the Cambridge Independent article. As the headline indicates, it is a bit of pressure group grandstanding. It doesn't have any official status.
I don't agree that there is no prospect of the line being reinstated, but, at present, the prospects are not good, probably less than 10 per cent. I don't see that Railfuture's campaign changes that. For the line to be reopened three other things need to happen first:
- East West Rail goes ahead using the southern approach, without 4 tracks from Shepreth Branch Junction there is no capacity for Haverhill line trains;
- the Greater Cambridge Partnership need to abandon their proposal to use part of the trackbed for a busway, which is currently on hold, and switch their support to using the trackbed for rail;
- the rail solution needs business and University support from the Cambridge Biomedical Campus, and, more importantly, Granta Park.
None of these are going to happen very quickly, if at all. And even if they all happen, there are yet more challenges to negotiate.
Furthermore, there is a lot of political uncertainty at present, with a General Election and a Cambridgeshire Mayor election both due within the next 18 months. By that time, Cambridge South station should be almost ready to open: when it does, I think that the benefits of heavy rail on the Haverhill line trackbed will be much more plain to see.
Finally, one interesting little bit of news, at the end of the article, is the appointment of Anthony Browne as a junior transport minister. This will constrain what he is able to say about Cambridge area transport policy.