Physik
Member
Hi all,
I'd really appreciate your advice regarding a situation I encountered on a CrossCountry train from Manchester to Oxford.
I had purchased a return ticket using my 16–25 Railcard, which I later realised had expired a bit over a week earlier. This was my first time ever encountering such an issue, and I was completely unaware that the Railcard was no longer valid when I boarded.
During the ticket inspection, the revenue officer did not explain anything about penalties or available options. He simply asked me to fill in a form with my personal details and then handed me a new return ticket (without clarifying what would happen next). I was told I would receive a letter in the post the next round he passed us.
Immediately after that, before getting off the train, I renewed my Railcard and purchased a new single ticket for the return leg at around £30, using the newly valid Railcard. I did not use either the original Railcard-discounted ticket nor the new return ticket the officer gave me for my return trip.
I'd really like to clarify:
Any advice would be greatly appreciated — especially on what kind of correspondence to expect, and how best to respond when it arrives.
Thanks in advance!
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
One thing I also noticed: both I and my friend (we are both East Asian) were the only ones who were asked to show our Railcards, even though there were other passengers around us. I’m not making any accusations, but I did find the inconsistency a little unsettling.
I'd really appreciate your advice regarding a situation I encountered on a CrossCountry train from Manchester to Oxford.
I had purchased a return ticket using my 16–25 Railcard, which I later realised had expired a bit over a week earlier. This was my first time ever encountering such an issue, and I was completely unaware that the Railcard was no longer valid when I boarded.
During the ticket inspection, the revenue officer did not explain anything about penalties or available options. He simply asked me to fill in a form with my personal details and then handed me a new return ticket (without clarifying what would happen next). I was told I would receive a letter in the post the next round he passed us.
Immediately after that, before getting off the train, I renewed my Railcard and purchased a new single ticket for the return leg at around £30, using the newly valid Railcard. I did not use either the original Railcard-discounted ticket nor the new return ticket the officer gave me for my return trip.
I'd really like to clarify:
- What kind of letter should I expect from CrossCountry (e.g. Unpaid Fare Notice, Penalty Fare, or prosecution letter)?
- Given that I didn’t use the original ticket nor the new one issued by the officer, and instead bought a valid single fare for the return leg, is there any chance I could challenge the default assumption that I should be fined for the full return journey?
- Is there any scope for leniency or withdrawal, considering that this was a genuine first-time oversight, and that I corrected it immediately by renewing my Railcard and paying again for the rest of my travel?
Any advice would be greatly appreciated — especially on what kind of correspondence to expect, and how best to respond when it arrives.
Thanks in advance!
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
One thing I also noticed: both I and my friend (we are both East Asian) were the only ones who were asked to show our Railcards, even though there were other passengers around us. I’m not making any accusations, but I did find the inconsistency a little unsettling.
Last edited: