• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Longer trains on XC?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Trainman40083

Established Member
Joined
29 Jan 2024
Messages
2,458
Location
Derby
moderator note : split from


The

Hope not, I was on one a couple of days ago, sat on a metal bar with no cushioning on the seat and the whole thing was shuddering to destruction around Didcot. Voyagers glide along in comparison, looking forward to them being tidied up and refreshed as new inside.
Well, if passenger numbers are rising and Voyagers are rammed, and more services are put back, the joy of say an 8 car IEP would be, you only need one set of crew.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Ayman Ilham

Member
Joined
2 Jul 2016
Messages
448
Location
Blackburn (Lancs)
Well, if passenger numbers are rising and Voyagers are rammed, and more services are put back, the joy of say an 8 car IEP would be, you only need one set of crew.
Meanwhile in Switzerland, SBB have no problem whacking 20 carriages (I'm not joking, I've been on one) on far less populated intercity routes like Zurich to Lugano (equivalent in distance and population with Edinburgh to Inverness) - yes, that's right; they're better at doubling up 10-car units than we are with 4-5 car units on far longer routes connecting much larger cities. That's how far behind we are; XC would kill for a single 10-car unit for each diagram, let alone extra!
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
104,696
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
Meanwhile in Switzerland, SBB have no problem whacking 20 carriages (I'm not joking, I've been on one) on far less populated intercity routes like Zurich to Lugano (equivalent in distance and population with Edinburgh to Inverness) - yes, that's right; they're better at doubling up 10-car units than we are with 4-5 car units on far longer routes connecting much larger cities. That's how far behind we are; XC would kill for a single 10-car unit for each diagram, let alone extra!

To be fair the only units SBB have that they could do that with is the Girunos, which as they are Stadler units have short (17.5m) intermediate vehicles. Two of those is 22 car and 400m long. Still a heck of a train though - only place you'll see that in the UK is Eurostar and HS2 captive.

Totally agree it would be an XC passenger's dream! :)

(Voyager equivalent would be just over 16 car... to be fair 15 car Voyager formations have actually operated in service on Virgin's "blockade busters" !)
 

Northerngirl

Member
Joined
16 Aug 2023
Messages
337
Location
Wirral
To be fair the only units SBB have that they could do that with is the Girunos, which as they are Stadler units have short (17.5m) intermediate vehicles. Two of those is 22 car and 400m long. Still a heck of a train though - only place you'll see that in the UK is Eurostar and HS2 captive.

Totally agree it would be an XC passenger's dream! :)

(Voyager equivalent would be just over 16 car... to be fair 15 car Voyager formations have actually operated in service on Virgin's "blockade busters" !)
What station could they actually use, as far as I' m aware it's only the sleeper stops that are long enough
 

Killingworth

Established Member
Joined
30 May 2018
Messages
5,724
Location
Sheffield
15 car Voyagers ran a shuttle between Birmingham Intl and Euston which both have platforms long enough.

They'd not be much use (nor really necessary) on most of XC.
In days long gone by, before XC, trains from cities in the North East were joined up at Sheffield to head for the South West on summer Saturdays. They seemed very long, possibly 14 car? I didn't count them.
 

Wolfie

Established Member
Joined
17 Aug 2010
Messages
6,997
I agree about looking forward to tidy up as that lets them down massively at the moment. I can just about cope with the other stuff once that's sorted.

What I really want is for them to get all the AVC units that come off lease, I don't care about all these OA operators I want to not stand from Leeds to Birmingham every time I travel to Cornwall. It makes operational, commercial and logical sense for that to happen in my eyes. The OA operators can wait for the 222s.
HMT would beg to differ. Let's see what the new Government has to say. Of course, if the OA operators offer more....
 

Jimini

Established Member
Joined
8 Oct 2006
Messages
1,766
Location
Reading
15 car Voyagers ran a shuttle between Birmingham Intl and Euston which both have platforms long enough.

They'd not be much use (nor really necessary) on most of XC.

Did they stop at Coventry as well, or maybe the one we caught all those years ago was maybe just a double voyager (this was during a Christmas blockade probably nigh on ten years ago)?
 

Ayman Ilham

Member
Joined
2 Jul 2016
Messages
448
Location
Blackburn (Lancs)
To be fair the only units SBB have that they could do that with is the Girunos, which as they are Stadler units have short (17.5m) intermediate vehicles. Two of those is 22 car and 400m long. Still a heck of a train though - only place you'll see that in the UK is Eurostar and HS2 captive.

Totally agree it would be an XC passenger's dream! :)
I wonder what the possibility of a bi-mode version of the Stadler Giruno built to British loading gauge for CrossCountry would be (a 10-car unit for each Voyager to double the capacity on every service and give opportunity for new connections so passenger growth can be managed much easier), if they eventually decide on new trains in the long-term. However, such a thing (10-car bi-modes to replace each 4- or 5- car Voyager) would likely be far easier on the existing IET platform, and probably more realistic to procure specifically for the Manchester to Bristol and Bournemouth routes, allowing all Voyagers to strengthen the North East to South West services.
 

FGWHST43009

Member
Joined
3 Nov 2020
Messages
112
Meanwhile in Switzerland, SBB have no problem whacking 20 carriages (I'm not joking, I've been on one) on far less populated intercity routes like Zurich to Lugano (equivalent in distance and population with Edinburgh to Inverness) - yes, that's right; they're better at doubling up 10-car units than we are with 4-5 car units on far longer routes connecting much larger cities. That's how far behind we are; XC would kill for a single 10-car unit for each diagram, let alone extra!
XC are running more long formations which is good to see. The 0640 from Newcastle to Plymouth was a single Voyager before the June TT change. It's now a double set. When I travelled from Newcastle to South Wales a few weeks ago, both Voyagers I had were double formations.
 

Trainbike46

Established Member
Joined
18 Sep 2021
Messages
3,314
Location
belfast
Have the first cascaded units from Avanti arrived?

When the 13 (?) cascaded avanti units have all arrived it will certainly help with more and longer services on XC - which are desperately needed. Hopefully the remaining ex-avanti units will be leased and come as well
 

Jamesrob637

Established Member
Joined
12 Aug 2016
Messages
5,660
Have the first cascaded units from Avanti arrived?

When the 13 (?) cascaded avanti units have all arrived it will certainly help with more and longer services on XC - which are desperately needed. Hopefully the remaining ex-avanti units will be leased and come as well

221114 to 221116 have definitely arrived
 

Ayman Ilham

Member
Joined
2 Jul 2016
Messages
448
Location
Blackburn (Lancs)
XC are running more long formations which is good to see. The 0640 from Newcastle to Plymouth was a single Voyager before the June TT change. It's now a double set. When I travelled from Newcastle to South Wales a few weeks ago, both Voyagers I had were double formations.
Some cascades from Avanti are definitely helping.
It is definitely a step in the right direction.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top