Purple Train
Established Member
Indeed, Winterbourne would be a total non-starter. I'd love to see a new station at Coalpit Heath, as going by road anywhere vaguely close to the centre of Bristol is a lost cause. The buses in the area are also utterly dreadful, which might also help to push up local support.The Friends of Bristol Suburban Railways support (re)opening the nearby Coalpit Heath station, having concluded there are problems with the site at Winterbourne. See: https://fosbr.org.uk/coalpit-heath-station/
They concluded that at either location there would be a need for passing loops (given this is on the busy section of the line shared by GWR's South Wales services as well as the Gloucester-Bristol line). Aside from whether the demand exists (and the relative proximity, for those driving to the station, of Bristol Parkway and Yate), the cost of loops must be a killer - and that assumes that they would actually mitigate the capacity / timetabling issues.
As a complete aside, the FoSBR article quotes locals canvassed in the village. The "mixed" views are almost all negative... I love this response: "There are already too many trains running too fast along the viaduct at the end of my garden, the electric ones are just as noisy as the diesel trains."
Coalpit Heath would also work better as it is further away from Parkway, and, even if you could build a station without passing loops at Winterbourne, say in the cutting, access would also be a bit of a nightmare. The downside with Coalpit Heath is that the railway runs along the southern border of the village, so isn't as useful in that regard as a station would be at Winterbourne, where the railway cuts the village in two... sort of.
The other factor to be considered in a potential Coalpit Heath station would be passengers from the likes of Bromley Heath, south of the motorway. I could potentially see people from the outer suburbs driving to Coalpit Heath, but given the nature of the station's surroundings, building a Park & Ride may not go down well with the locals.
Either way, there are enough issues with the proposals - i.e. they're not a nailed-on no-losses problem-busting genius idea - that any stations in the north-east of Bristol (given there is the A4174, which gives rise to enough connections without the issues of trying to actually drive into Bristol) would have to take priority behind projects such as Portishead and Henbury. Which, in the world of Bristol suburban railways, means that, for the elderly population, who may perhaps have more reliance on public transport, the benefits of such a scheme may well not affect them.
In short, I think that, even with the current economic climate on the railways (no money to swing a cat, let alone room), a wealth of new projects will see the light of day before Coalpit Heath or Winterbourne is even thought about.
My favourite response was the one that went, "we should stop funding public transport and fix all the potholes before I break my axle"!
Last edited: