• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

First Group: General Discussion

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,198
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
Surprising thing is, if the whole company didn't go around the houses and just slashed and burn it might have been in a better position to weather this storm. It took six just to get to this stage, it needs to speed it up. Stagecoach dont wait about.

WTF..... Apart from culling Midlothian, Northampton and Bury SE, selling London, flogging Wigan, Wirral and Chester, closing Hereford and Bracknell, selling Plymouth, closing Cardiff, scaling back Potteries, GM and SY.... just not enough o_O

How would you deal with the massive balance sheet hit of doing it faster and quicker?

Also, look at something like First Manchester. In 2012, it made >£10m on a £99m turnover. Would anyone have been advocating slash and burn then?
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

overthewater

Established Member
Joined
16 Apr 2012
Messages
8,470
YET it's not enough, there still have the problems its been facing since 2012, it cant clear off its debt... Even your said there planning to cut another 200 buses out of the network across the UK a couple of post back. Then how do First deal with problems of Debt and turnover? Six years and there still no clear sign...

Alas there played a game of roulette and have lost on nearly every turn, which is some bad luck... Lack of new rail franchises, Government cutbacks, change in shopping habit, list goes on. I'm not saying Manchester is including in the crystal ball, but First should have culled it faster or either that did something to get rid of alot of its debts. Where did that 100 million for sell offs actually go? Something will have to give sooner or later.
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,198
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
YET it's not enough, there still have the problems its been facing since 2012, it cant clear off its debt... Even your said there planning to cut another 200 buses out of the network across the UK a couple of post back. Then how do First deal with problems of Debt and turnover? Six years and there still no clear sign...

Alas there played a game of roulette and have lost on nearly every turn, which is some bad luck... Lack of new rail franchises, Government cutbacks, change in shopping habit, list goes on. I'm not saying Manchester is including in the crystal ball, but First should have culled it faster or either that did something to get rid of alot of its debts. Where did that 100 million for sell offs actually go? Something will have to give sooner or later.

But doesn’t part of the bond debt mature this year? And expensive bond debt at that?
 

Cesarcollie

Member
Joined
5 Jun 2016
Messages
689
Hi Winston - as regards the FGM and FSY operations, there are some differences with Stagecoach. Both have suffered abstraction to a degree with Metrolink's expansion though FGM a bit more so. However, I'd venture that South Manchester is generally more affluent than the north and that has impacted on the core ridership; welfare cuts have hit the poorest and that is an issue for bus operators. FSY - I confess, I'm a lot less familiar with the area and why they should be so different; perhaps the benefits of the bus partnerships are yet to be evident?

The ex London stuff (especially deckers) are no bargain. They have all the usual issues of TfL spec and dual doors - that's why most firms (like Stagecoach) are leasing now. Given where First are in terms of having to stretch out their depreciation periods and running 18 year old deckers in Bristol, I don't see how they have the cash to buy or the strength to have considerably more depreciation/balance sheet weight.

First are taking the attention for the cuts but sadly, it's something that Stagecoach are also doing across the country and, as we're seeing with operators going pop regularly, it is a very tough place to be. As I've said before, First were the weakest of all the groups entering into this period and that's down to Moir's tenure IMO.


Agreed. South Manchester is without a doubt the better operating territory - for all the reasons quoted plus the large student market. I suspect Stagecoach knew exactly what they were doing in buying GMBN South and not North!!
 

winston270twm

Established Member
Joined
26 Oct 2012
Messages
1,899
WTF..... Apart from culling Midlothian, Northampton and Bury SE, selling London, flogging Wigan, Wirral and Chester, closing Hereford and Bracknell, selling Plymouth, closing Cardiff, scaling back Potteries, GM and SY.... just not enough o_O

How would you deal with the massive balance sheet hit of doing it faster and quicker?

Also, look at something like First Manchester. In 2012, it made >£10m on a £99m turnover. Would anyone have been advocating slash and burn then?

Sell Greyhound, like they should have done when they first acquired Laidlaw.
 

overthewater

Established Member
Joined
16 Apr 2012
Messages
8,470
They will just do what they always do and reissue it at today's cheaper rates!
Wait a min what happens in X number of years and the bond come around again and the rate go up? This sounds like very dodge system to me? Its like people taking out £1000 a loan a month but only paying the £100 fee a month to cover it, there never get out of the hole.
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,198
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
Is there enough to pay it? and does that mean there will be another hit on the accounts?

Exactly - you don’t know what I’m talking about :rolleyes:

Essentially, they issued a debt security, under which the First owes the holders a debt and is paying over 8% interest. That matures this year so that debt will be serviced.

Really.....
 

overthewater

Established Member
Joined
16 Apr 2012
Messages
8,470
Exactly - you don’t know what I’m talking about :rolleyes:

Essentially, they issued a debt security, under which the First owes the holders a debt and is paying over 8% interest. That matures this year so that debt will be serviced.

Really.....

They will just do what they always do and reissue it at today's cheaper rates!

I fully get that the bonds will give the holders and big whack of money once it matures, This also mean money has to be spent paying for this instead of other more important things like buses or shareholders etc...

I still ask Which one is it? you can't service debt properly if your just going to run off and issues more bonds to cover the debt you go further down the road... back to square one.
 

Kahuna47

Member
Joined
13 Sep 2017
Messages
112
In GM takeover talks have been rife ever since the plans for franchising was announced. Transdev were favourites for this but since they bought out Rosso in the territory next door there wouldn't be anything stopping them running us off the road - most of the customers are itching to use their services, whilst we're watching the service changes lists every month. There's been (unconfirmed) rumours that Rosso are shutting their Haslingden depot and since their Rochdale outstation is nothing more than a muddy puddle, they're in the market for a new depot. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to put two and two together and realise theres a ready, 'out of the box' depot down the road in Bury...

Speaking of Bury, First have been handed a heavy 6-figure fine by TfGM for non-running of services and told in no uncertain terms to reopen Bury or 'they might not get as many routes as they want' in the area.

Its a pretty open market for buyers, and whilst I'd agree with the comments about Stagecoach and CMA approval, there are several big areas where companies have the monopoly - FiG being one that comes to mind.

There my two two penneth anyway :)

K
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,198
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
I fully get that the bonds will give the holders and big whack of money once it matures, This also mean money has to be spent paying for this instead of other more important things like buses or shareholders etc...

I still ask Which one is it? you can't service debt properly if your just going to run off and issues more bonds to cover the debt you go further down the road... back to square one.

You don’t seem to understand

Stagecoach went and paid up a £400m bond at 5.75% in favour of one at 4%. The FGP is over 8% so.... work it out!

Also, what was the net debt position at last full year results vs previous?
 
Last edited:

NorthernSpirit

Established Member
Joined
21 Jun 2013
Messages
2,200
First could always sell Manchester and the Yorkshire fleets to Stagecoach

Perhaps First could flog the Doncaster operation off to Transdev, the Rotherham operation off to Centrebus (who'll need to find a depot since the Midland Road depot has long since closed). They keep Sheffield and bung it with York as another standalone but group it with West Yorkshire.
 

Robertj21a

On Moderation
Joined
22 Sep 2013
Messages
7,691
Perhaps First could flog the Doncaster operation off to Transdev, the Rotherham operation off to Centrebus (who'll need to find a depot since the Midland Road depot has long since closed). They keep Sheffield and bung it with York as another standalone but group it with West Yorkshire.


Not sure that Centrebus will want an operation that far north of their usual operating areas. Are you thinking of Yorkshire Tiger ?
 

Volvodart

Established Member
Joined
12 Jun 2010
Messages
2,691
You do not know the current situation and how much of the losses have been eliminated by the depot closures here and in Manchester.
 

NorthernSpirit

Established Member
Joined
21 Jun 2013
Messages
2,200
19001/4/5/7/8/9/11/13/18/20/23/27 all reported gone for scrap but that was a couple of weeks ago. No doubt someone in W Yorks would have better knowledge.


As far as I'm aware some were ditched at Cherry Row but that depot was sold off causing the fleet to be shifted to various other depots. One was dumped at the back of Skircoat Lane but I'm guessing that it'll have been scrapped by now.
 

overthewater

Established Member
Joined
16 Apr 2012
Messages
8,470
You don’t seem to understand

Stagecoach went and paid up a £400m bond at 5.75% in favour of one at 4%. The FGP is over 8% so.... work it out!

Also, what was the net debt position at last full year results vs previous?

My brain has turned to mush trying to work that out. Why did Stagecoach go for bigger % over the 10 years. I still dont think that a good idea over the long term....
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,198
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
My brain has turned to mush trying to work that out. Why did Stagecoach go for bigger % over the 10 years. I still dont think that a good idea over the long term....

They didn’t.

Go and do your research. Understand what FGPs debt position is now compared to where it was and understand what the difference is having the current bond rate and what Stagecoach were able to secure.

Not that I think FGP will get it at the same rate but it’ll be better than the sellers market rate that Moir had to accept.
 

mic

Member
Joined
22 Mar 2015
Messages
446
In GM takeover talks have been rife ever since the plans for franchising was announced. Transdev were favourites for this but since they bought out Rosso in the territory next door there wouldn't be anything stopping them running us off the road - most of the customers are itching to use their services, whilst we're watching the service changes lists every month. There's been (unconfirmed) rumours that Rosso are shutting their Haslingden depot and since their Rochdale outstation is nothing more than a muddy puddle, they're in the market for a new depot. Doesn't take a rocket scientist to put two and two together and realise theres a ready, 'out of the box' depot down the road in Bury...

Speaking of Bury, First have been handed a heavy 6-figure fine by TfGM for non-running of services and told in no uncertain terms to reopen Bury or 'they might not get as many routes as they want' in the area.

Its a pretty open market for buyers, and whilst I'd agree with the comments about Stagecoach and CMA approval, there are several big areas where companies have the monopoly - FiG being one that comes to mind.

There my two two penneth anyway :)

K

good to see first have been finded for non running of services today i saw 3 yes 3 350 services from Oldham to Ashton one was nearly 1 hour late next one 30 mins late and another was on time they should have kept Tameside (Dukinfield) depot open
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,198
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
Perhaps First could flog the Doncaster operation off to Transdev, the Rotherham operation off to Centrebus (who'll need to find a depot since the Midland Road depot has long since closed). They keep Sheffield and bung it with York as another standalone but group it with West Yorkshire.

Are you picking firms and locations at random?

Why would Transdev want Doncaster? Surely they’d want Halifax or York? Why would Centrebus want a homeless Rotherham operation?
 

Baxenden Bank

Established Member
Joined
23 Oct 2013
Messages
4,306
good to see first have been finded for non running of services today i saw 3 yes 3 350 services from Oldham to Ashton one was nearly 1 hour late next one 30 mins late and another was on time they should have kept Tameside (Dukinfield) depot open
Standard First practice. No on-the-ground regulation of late running services. As Brian Hanrahan could have said "I counted them all out, and I counted them all back, but I haven't a clue where they are in between times." Not technically correct as they have 'a remote satellite tool'.
Our buses also benefit from a remote satellite tool so that we can properly monitor their movements and take corrective action to ensure adherence to the timetable. The Depot Operations Manager is now aware of the concerns you have reported about the recent running of this service please be assured your complaints have been taken very seriously and that the situation will be closely monitored. Any underlying problems with the service will be addressed accordingly.
 

overthewater

Established Member
Joined
16 Apr 2012
Messages
8,470
I had to go and double check how "debt will be serviced" I believe it was: Company A takes out a bond for £100 at 10% for 10 years.. each year the company pays the bond holders £10, once the final year appear that when you pay off the original bond amount. IF you dont have the money to pay off that £100 then "as said above take out another bond" and hope for better financial luck next time. Thus your just wasting alot of money interest etc and going on a merry go round. Surly it would be madness to go for another unless you know when you'd be back on track financially enough to cover it?

Debt levels of the company
* 2013: 2.76Billion
* 2014: 1.95B
* 2015: 1.94B
* 2016: 1.88B
* 2017: 1.79B Current assets of 5.79B
Total debt/total equity 0.8924
Total debt/total capital 0.4691
FirstGroup PLC has a Debt to Total Capital ratio of 46.91%, a lower figure than the previous year's 103.40%.
Year on year FirstGroup PLC grew revenues 8.34% from 5.22bn to 5.65bn while net income improved 24.36% from 90.30m to 112.30m.
That is tad misleading since it still lower than 2015, which is self lower than 2013...

If more bonds are coming along and there no new cash flow pouring in ( over the past few years its been negative, before recovering in 2017 = £40million) No wonder there no spare cash for stuff...

Bonds the company have:

wYnurVc.jpg


With Stagecoach, its a tad more confusing but we'll come back to them later, if anyone wishes to rip this above to shreds please with a red pen ;)
 

DD12

Member
Joined
19 Oct 2014
Messages
175
THANKS to all the regulars on this thread for your interesting info/ debates.

Sorry if it's already been discussed, but is there any likelihood that in the next few years, First Group or First UK bus, could financially crash and be split-up, dissolved ETC ?

(Would they be legally obliged to sell-off profitable bits first ?)
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,198
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
I had to go and double check how "debt will be serviced" I believe it was: Company A takes out a bond for £100 at 10% for 10 years.. each year the company pays the bond holders £10, once the final year appear that when you pay off the original bond amount. IF you dont have the money to pay off that £100 then "as said above take out another bond" and hope for better financial luck next time. Thus your just wasting alot of money interest etc and going on a merry go round. Surly it would be madness to go for another unless you know when you'd be back on track financially enough to cover it?


That is tad misleading since it still lower than 2015, which is self lower than 2013...

If more bonds are coming along and there no new cash flow pouring in ( over the past few years its been negative, before recovering in 2017 = £40million) No wonder there no spare cash for stuff...

Bonds the company have:

wYnurVc.jpg


With Stagecoach, its a tad more confusing but we'll come back to them later, if anyone wishes to rip this above to shreds please with a red pen ;)

Not certain exactly what you're saying and I will defer to Winston who knows a lot more about the markets that me, but here goes....

As regards Stagecoach, they had a £400m bond that they were paying 5.75% (a bit like an interest free mortgage for want of a better analogy). They were paying interest of £23m and indeed, that was what they had to pay to leave that early (again, a bit like an early redemption fee). Instead, they'll now pay £16m in interest so it costs them for 3 years but then they'll be better off, having secured cheaper money over the term. They've probably taken the decision that interest rates will only go one way so bite the bullet now.

First Group have their 2018 bond maturing. As you can see, they have had to pay some hefty bond rates in the past (look at the 2008 and 2009 rates). They were obviously to finance the Laidlaw purchase and so were very much at a sellers rate, I would assume - we can go all round the houses about the Laidlaw purchase but we've had years to discuss that.

So with the 2018 due bond - at the current rate, they're paying just short of £25m a year in interest. Now, they have just been paying the interest - see page 27 of the 2017 results. Let's assume that they replace like for like (£300m) at a rate as per Stagecoach - that's £12m a year representing a near £13m upside by getting a cheaper interest rate. Of course, if they're able to replace with a lesser amount (e.g. £250m), then the benefit is greater still.

Not certain where your debt figures come from. Think the variance with your figures may exclude bond interest. However, they do show the impact of the rights issue in 2012/3 and, when you ask about "what happened to the £100m from UK Bus sell offs", well it was to both support that pay down of debt and to fund the urgently needed investment just to meet DDA deadlines. Down here in the West Country, the paucity of new vehicle investment was laid bare with 2009 (41 new vehicles) 2010 (6), 2011 (6) - that was everything including Bristol, Somerset, Devon and Cornwall. Can't recall anything for Cymru and when I remember their fleet in 2012, it was horrifically dated.

As it is, First's 2017 results showed the net debt as being £1.29bn, a drop of 11.2% vs. 2016's £14.1bn.

Bonds may seem like a waste of money but, like a mortgage, not many can buy a new house with cash and it's the same for businesses. Debt isn't necessarily a bad thing - it's how much it is, how much headroom you have, and your ability to pay it down.

The next set of group results will be very interesting to see a) the headline figures and b) how the debt pile has changed? Will things be sufficiently optimistic on a group level (not withstanding UK Bus) that a dividend could be paid. And yes, you do wonder how things might have been had Moir negotiated with Souter on the sale of Greyhound (rumoured that £750m was offered but Moir wanted £1bn) but, as we've discussed ad nauseum, we will never know!
 

NorthernSpirit

Established Member
Joined
21 Jun 2013
Messages
2,200
Are you picking firms and locations at random? Why would Transdev want Doncaster? Surely they’d want Halifax or York? Why would Centrebus want a homeless Rotherham operation?

No, I'm not picking locations or firms at random.

For starters its to get round the Competition Commission regulations (as per the problem that First had when trying to offload their Devon operations where Stagecoach were unable to buy them because of competition regulations). Transdev already run the 8 from Selby to Drax - what's to stop them wanting to extend the route into Doncaster itself?

You've also got High Peak which is 50% owned by Centrebus, what's to stop them expanding into South Yorkshire? I selected Rotherham simply because the routes are split between Donny and Sheffield and that Centrebus could easily fit in Rotherham as a low cost operation. Didn't Centrebus open a depot in Leeds next to the old First depot on Kirkstall Road? Surely they'd do the same in Rotherham?
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,198
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
No, I'm not picking locations or firms at random.

For starters its to get round the Competition Commission regulations (as per the problem that First had when trying to offload their Devon operations where Stagecoach were unable to buy them because of competition regulations). Transdev already run the 8 from Selby to Drax - what's to stop them wanting to extend the route into Doncaster itself?

You've also got High Peak which is 50% owned by Centrebus, what's to stop them expanding into South Yorkshire? I selected Rotherham simply because the routes are split between Donny and Sheffield and that Centrebus could easily fit in Rotherham as a low cost operation. Didn't Centrebus open a depot in Leeds next to the old First depot on Kirkstall Road? Surely they'd do the same in Rotherham?

Well, there's a world of difference between running an infrequent service through to Drax and the purchase of an entire operation. As I said, surely Transdev may be more interested in something like Halifax were First looking to sell?

High Peak are based in around Buxton. Not certain why they'd want an operation in Rotherham nor why First would want to sell having just amalgamated everything into Olive Grove. Surely by removing those operations, they'd lose all the synergy benefits and contribution to that overhead?
 

TheGrandWazoo

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Feb 2013
Messages
21,198
Location
Somerset with international travel (e.g. across th
THANKS to all the regulars on this thread for your interesting info/ debates.

Sorry if it's already been discussed, but is there any likelihood that in the next few years, First Group or First UK bus, could financially crash and be split-up, dissolved ETC ?

(Would they be legally obliged to sell-off profitable bits first ?)

Your points are quite diverse.

Splitting up of the group - there's always the possibility if there is a groundswell of shareholder support for that move.

Financial implosion - any firm can be at risk of that especially if debt isn't managed. That is what brought down Carillion, and it's why Stagecoach are handing back VTEC.

Adminstration/liquidation - any administrator/liquidator is legally bound to a) not make the situation worse (i.e. by allowing a business to trade insolvently and accrue more debt) and b) to obtain the best settlement for the creditors. The most profitable parts of any business are generally most attractive to prospective purchasers.
 

Top