DynamicSpirit
Established Member
Mods note. Split from this thread:
www.railforums.co.uk
that seems pretty unlikely to me. Consider that overall living standards today are much higher than they were 30, 50 or 100 years ago. 100 years ago, most of the population had a standard of living that would today be considered to be extreme poverty. Yet obesity levels then were tiny compared to today.
The statistics I've seen do seem to indicate some correlation between obesity and poverty, but it doesn't necessarily follow that the poverty is the cause of obesity. It could be, for example, that obesity and poverty are both influenced by things like lower education levels.
I could imagine that possibly poverty levels contribute something to obesity levels, if (as is claimed) poverty makes it harder to buy healthy food, but it seems implausible that poverty is the main cause of obesity. That is almost certainly going to be down to people's individual life choices regarding how much they eat and how much they exercise.
Has taxation for unhealthy items, such as cigarettes, gone too far in the UK?
I am currently in shock having been relieved of £13 in Tesco for 20 Benson & Hedges Gold o_O My latest "fag run" to Luxembourg last weekend was cancelled by The Foreign and Commonwealth Office's untimely intervention. Had I been able to go I would have been sourcing stock at around £5 a...

But the cause of the obesity epidemic is mainly political, and driven mainly by poverty.
that seems pretty unlikely to me. Consider that overall living standards today are much higher than they were 30, 50 or 100 years ago. 100 years ago, most of the population had a standard of living that would today be considered to be extreme poverty. Yet obesity levels then were tiny compared to today.
The statistics I've seen do seem to indicate some correlation between obesity and poverty, but it doesn't necessarily follow that the poverty is the cause of obesity. It could be, for example, that obesity and poverty are both influenced by things like lower education levels.
I could imagine that possibly poverty levels contribute something to obesity levels, if (as is claimed) poverty makes it harder to buy healthy food, but it seems implausible that poverty is the main cause of obesity. That is almost certainly going to be down to people's individual life choices regarding how much they eat and how much they exercise.
Last edited by a moderator: