• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

London Euston - late advertising of services

Status
Not open for further replies.

william.martin

On Moderation
Joined
18 Oct 2022
Messages
844
Location
Telford
I’m currently on the 14:45 LNR service from London Euston to Crewe - this service was advertised and announced no less than two minutes prior to departure, at 14:43.

Luckily for me and a few other people who ‘know’ the tricks, we were already waiting on the right platform for the train.

Although for people waiting on the concourse, is three minutes sufficient time to get to the train and board? (Train left at 14:46) From what I heard, there were still passengers coming down the ramp but subsequently missed the train as the platform dispatcher told them to stand back.
I am quite surprised with this as I have always found Euston to be very informative - the last time I visited (though this was 2 years ago) my platform was showing about 25-30 mins before departure.
I must say this was the best experience I've ever had with Avanti, reasonably quiet 9 car pendo to Blackpool (I left at Birmingham) which arrived at every station either Early or on time.
 
Last edited:
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

cactustwirly

Established Member
Joined
10 Apr 2013
Messages
7,478
Location
UK
IMO they should just set it to make the first announcement and automatically put the platform up 10 minutes before advertised departure time, regardless of TOC. If the staff want to radio through and get it called earlier (if the cleaning/preparation is finished before then) then great.
Or just do it like every other station and advertise the platform as the inbound service arrives
 

Mikey C

Established Member
Joined
11 Feb 2013
Messages
6,886
A crazy situation when the Euston platforms are really wide, with plenty of space for passengers to wait on, and with so many people with seat reservations, there would be a nice spread along the platform as people go to their correct spot to wait.

Instead with 11 car trains operating most services, it requires a real dash if you're at the front, or large numbers of people having to walk through the entire train to reach their seat.

At Marylebone for trains departing from the far platforms (4 to 6) they sometimes tell you to go to a holding area near there, even if the actual platform hasn't been announced, so it's only a short walk to your train when announced.
 

AJDesiro

Member
Joined
10 May 2019
Messages
654
Location
Rugby
How does this solve the already identified problem of bad comms?

LNR and Overground services should be advertised as soon as they go up on the board unless there's a good reason not to. GTR clean their units with customers boarding at Victoria, that's fine for LNRs to Northampton and Birmingham, maybe even the Crewe services unless it's super busy. If a driver wants to lock the train up, then hold the platform until it's locked, but as soon as it is locked get the platform up on the board so people can start queuing along the full length of the platform.
Then it's only Avanti, which will be less of a problem as there's not so many people to fight through on the concourse waiting for LNRs. You could also manage it a bit better by cleaning and then boarding First Class only before the platform is advertised. Cleaning crew tell despatcher, who asks station control to tell the 1st class lounge, etc. Maybe a PA announcement as well. Ticket checkers already in place to manage eager standard passengers.

Are a lot of Euston station staff agency? I wonder if the attitude is more to do with them being roped in last minute rather than full-time Euston people. Maybe not and I'm being massively judgemental for no reason.
Avanti do seem to have begun to hire agency staff at their own stations, it was rather amusing seeing a member of agency staff look rather puzzled when I showed him my ranger ticket, ended up waiting there for about 5 minutes while he consulted the ticket office. Agency staff on the railway in revenue protection and security-related roles do not work, they should only really use agency staff for cleaning imo, like Atalian Servest on Avanti. I've had experiences at Euston where a member of SES group "security" staff (no SIA badge, so just a man in a hi-vis with the agency logo on) refused to allow passengers onto the platforms 12-15 ramp, resulting in a huge crowd of people waiting at the top of the ramp, not helped that a packed 11 car 390 had just arrived, resulting in a rather large crowd of people, some waiting and some trying to leave the hellhole that Euston is.
 

Bikeman78

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2018
Messages
4,616
Euston is unique in this regard, and I hear it is became the comms between station staff, platform staff, crew (of multiple TOCs) and station control is fairly abysmal. Most other inter-city London terminals manage just fine.
I've seen the same at Paddington. 12 car 387 advertised four minutes before departure on platform 10. Massive queue at the barriers. Made worse by the dispatch staff blowing the whistle constantly whilst half the passengers were still the wrong side of the barriers. Just caused a load of stress and irritation, not to mention overcrowding at the back of the train. The sensible move would have been to open the barriers.
 

Urban Gateline

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2011
Messages
1,647
IMO they should just set it to make the first announcement and automatically put the platform up 10 minutes before advertised departure time, regardless of TOC. If the staff want to radio through and get it called earlier (if the cleaning/preparation is finished before then) then great.
All good and well but many of the arrivals that form departures have less than 10mins turnaround time (!) and they won't advertise services when the train hasn't arrived at the platform for safety reasons.

Are a lot of Euston station staff agency? I wonder if the attitude is more to do with them being roped in last minute rather than full-time Euston people. Maybe not and I'm being massively judgemental for no reason.
Not sure about Avanti, but LNR don't use agency dispatchers as far as I'm aware, but not all permanent staff are proactive anyway, some will come round to dispatch trains at the last minute so pot luck as to whether it would be advertised, sometimes the controller upstairs gives them a nudge though asking if a particular service can be boarded though if they haven't been instructed and it's getting near to departure time!
 

Horizon22

Established Member
Associate Staff
Jobs & Careers
Joined
8 Sep 2019
Messages
7,658
Location
London
I've seen the same at Paddington. 12 car 387 advertised four minutes before departure on platform 10. Massive queue at the barriers. Made worse by the dispatch staff blowing the whistle constantly whilst half the passengers were still the wrong side of the barriers. Just caused a load of stress and irritation, not to mention overcrowding at the back of the train. The sensible move would have been to open the barriers.

Sometimes they’ve only got a 7-8 minute turnaround with the 387s even with a 12-car. Issue with opening barriers is the risk of overcharging at destination which isn’t so much of an issue with intercity services.

Not sure about Avanti, but LNR don't use agency dispatchers as far as I'm aware, but not all permanent staff are proactive anyway, some will come round to dispatch trains at the last minute so pot luck as to whether it would be advertised, sometimes the controller upstairs gives them a nudge though asking if a particular service can be boarded though if they haven't been instructed and it's getting near to departure time!

Yes this is the main issue - station comms and it’s much worse at some than others. Either that or simply trains aren’t boarded because they’re not ready for boarding.
 

sheff1

Established Member
Joined
24 Dec 2009
Messages
5,496
Location
Sheffield
All good and well but many of the arrivals that form departures have less than 10mins turnaround time (!) and they won't advertise services when the train hasn't arrived at the platform for safety reasons.
They do at other stations. Is Euston particularly unsafe for some reason ?
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,518
Location
Bristol
They do at other stations. Is Euston particularly unsafe for some reason ?
At major termini they tend to try and avoid it where possible although it often isn't (e.g. Victoria) but the ramps down to the platforms at Euston would pose a risk with conflicting flows as they're quite steep. Easily resolved by advertising the train early enough that the rush is over before the train arrives, of course.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
98,278
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
At major termini they tend to try and avoid it where possible although it often isn't (e.g. Victoria) but the ramps down to the platforms at Euston would pose a risk with conflicting flows as they're quite steep. Easily resolved by advertising the train early enough that the rush is over before the train arrives, of course.

If they posed a risk in that way they wouldn't call a train on say P12 while one has just tipped out on P13, but they do, so it isn't that.

I strongly suspect it's because they've always done it that way and nobody ever thinks about why.
 

Falcon1200

Established Member
Joined
14 Jun 2021
Messages
3,713
Location
Neilston, East Renfrewshire
The same now happens with Avanti at Glasgow Central. Metal railings prevent customers accessing the platform until the train is “ready” then it’s a complete free for all, often with 5 or less minutes to go.

Not (always) any more; Yesterday I boarded the 0736 to Euston which was advertised 20 minutes before departure, and there were no barriers or indeed ticket checks on entering the platform.
 

Urban Gateline

Established Member
Joined
8 Mar 2011
Messages
1,647
They do at other stations. Is Euston particularly unsafe for some reason ?
Most of the Platforms are quite wide so it wouldn't be a huge issue, but it seemed to me that they liked to keep control over the passengers, if they advertise it early with no train down there and then someone ends up on the track...platform staff are not usually waiting to meet arrivals so nobody to watch the train in, platform unsupervised so more could go wrong I suppose. As when I worked for LNR there we were given a range of Platforms to cover, not only an island platform but a whole range (12-18 or 1-7) so not all platforms are constantly staffed.
 

Falcon1200

Established Member
Joined
14 Jun 2021
Messages
3,713
Location
Neilston, East Renfrewshire
This is the queue at Glasgow Central (goes back much further than this!) for the 15:58 to Euston. It’s making it more difficult for people to access the toilets and entrance/exit over this side of the station.

The set to form the 1558 did not arrive until 1542, vice 1517, which would presumably explain that (and they did well to get the 1558 away on time!)
 

Horizon22

Established Member
Associate Staff
Jobs & Careers
Joined
8 Sep 2019
Messages
7,658
Location
London
Most of the Platforms are quite wide so it wouldn't be a huge issue, but it seemed to me that they liked to keep control over the passengers, if they advertise it early with no train down there and then someone ends up on the track...platform staff are not usually waiting to meet arrivals so nobody to watch the train in, platform unsupervised so more could go wrong I suppose. As when I worked for LNR there we were given a range of Platforms to cover, not only an island platform but a whole range (12-18 or 1-7) so not all platforms are constantly staffed.

I agree there's certainly reasons, but in the bit in bold is rather overblown - people are left "unattended" on platforms all the time. It's probably the control point that is more relevant, and the aforementioned comms.
 

[.n]

Member
Joined
8 Apr 2016
Messages
708
Is is actually "legit" to prevent someone with a valid ticket from waiting on a platform at a terminus station?

I don't know Euston station well, but if I had a valid ticket to Glasgow (and lets make its an Open 1st Class Anytime, so no restrictions on time of travel), what's to stop me if I felt like sitting on the platform from 9.00am until a 10.00am departure on the basis that I personally have decided that the next train I'm taking to Glasgow is the next one to leave from platform 12, rather than specifically the next departure to Glasgow and I'm happy to spend my time waiting, reading a book etc.? I could obviously do this in say the 1st class lounge if I felt like it.
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,518
Location
Bristol
Is is actually "legit" to prevent someone with a valid ticket from waiting on a platform at a terminus station?

I don't know Euston station well, but if I had a valid ticket to Glasgow (and lets make its an Open 1st Class Anytime, so no restrictions on time of travel), what's to stop me if I felt like sitting on the platform from 9.00am until a 10.00am departure on the basis that I personally have decided that the next train I'm taking to Glasgow is the next one to leave from platform 12, rather than specifically the next departure to Glasgow and I'm happy to spend my time waiting, reading a book etc.? I could obviously do this in say the 1st class lounge if I felt like it.
I don't believe there is a specific regulation or law against it, although if staff were worried about you being disruptive or dangerous they could ask you to wait on the concourse or in the lounge and if.you refused you could be asked to leave, at which point if.you refused to leave its Trespass and you could be removed felm the station.
 

[.n]

Member
Joined
8 Apr 2016
Messages
708
I don't believe there is a specific regulation or law against it, although if staff were worried about you being disruptive or dangerous they could ask you to wait on the concourse or in the lounge and if.you refused you could be asked to leave, at which point if.you refused to leave its Trespass and you could be removed felm the station.
So in my example (given that we're talking about the weird oddity that is Euston) - I would be quietly sitting on a bench (if there is one), otherwise quietly standing in an unobtrusive area, well away from the platform edge etc., reading my book with a VALID ticket for travel from Euston for a destination that does go from a) Euston b) from that platform during that day c) the station is still open

How in this scenario am I trespassing by being a particular area of the station that is not specifically prohibited?

(I obviously get that in reality, it would be foolish to try and make the point and risk being asked to leave the whole station premises) - just wondered if there was specific piece of railway regulation/law that made this "legit".

Edit: I think in real life I'd do what was suggested by another poster, use the RTT/similar knowledge and wait close to the potential platform so as to be "first in the queue" when announced. What does Euston do for passengers who require assistance with boarding? Are they allowed to board before the platform is announced?
 

43066

Established Member
Joined
24 Nov 2019
Messages
9,573
Location
London
So in my example (given that we're talking about the weird oddity that is Euston) - I would be quietly sitting on a bench (if there is one), otherwise quietly standing in an unobtrusive area, well away from the platform edge etc., reading my book with a VALID ticket for travel from Euston for a destination that does go from a) Euston b) from that platform during that day c) the station is still open

How in this scenario am I trespassing by being a particular area of the station that is not specifically prohibited?

(I obviously get that in reality, it would be foolish to try and make the point and risk being asked to leave the whole station premises) - just wondered if there was specific piece of railway regulation/law that made this "legit".

The railway is private property so you don’t have an intrinsic right to be there. You have an implied right of entry but the legislation dealing with railway trespass makes it clear that, to all intents and purposes, if an authorised person (ie a staff member) asks you to leave, and you refuse to do so, you are likely to be committing the criminal offence of railway trespass. Holding a ticket is neither here nor there.

CPS guidance below gives a good overview:


(It’s a table so difficult to quote from, but Railway Regulation Act 1840 section 16 looks relevant).

IIRC There’s another bylaw offence around failing to obey instructions of staff.

This is why it’s worth speaking to staff first if you want to go and take photos, watch trains or do anything they might make your behaviour seem different to a regular passenger. This is because of obvious concerns around security and people who might be a suicide risk.

EDIT: I’m not commenting on Euston specifically, or in any way defending the staff, because there are clearly major issues there! At my London terminal platform staff will generally want to see an empty (of regular passengers) platform if trains are going to be splitting and joining. Enthusiasts who want to take photos are certainly allowed to do so, so long as they make it clear what they’re up to.
 
Last edited:

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,518
Location
Bristol
So in my example (given that we're talking about the weird oddity that is Euston) - I would be quietly sitting on a bench (if there is one), otherwise quietly standing in an unobtrusive area, well away from the platform edge etc., reading my book with a VALID ticket for travel from Euston for a destination that does go from a) Euston b) from that platform during that day c) the station is still open

How in this scenario am I trespassing by being a particular area of the station that is not specifically prohibited?
You wouldn't be trespassing UNTIL you were asked to leave, and only then if you refused. You could only be asked to leave if staff felt you were being disruptive or dangerous, although I'm not sure what the threshold in the legislation is - I think it's quite low (something like 'in the opinion of a member of staff').
It's quite possible that if you were sat quietly on a bench reading a bit of a way up the platform the staff wouldn't bat an eyelid and you'd be fine. I've certainly had odd looks from staff when hanging around on the end of platforms at MKC using the station clocks to time headways, but the moment I've stepped back from the edge and sat on a bench they've turned around and never a word was said.
 

50002Superb

Member
Joined
18 Aug 2021
Messages
864
Location
Nottingham
I think there have been a few threads like this about Euston/other London termini and the rush to the platforms when services are announced. It's completely unnecessary IMO, but gateline staff seem to get a kick out of being "in control" and denying passengers access to board or simply stand outside the train.
This happened to me at Euston on 3 December having come back from Qatar via Heathrow.

We had just over two minutes to board the 350 and I had a very large suitcase with me. I was absolutely amazed there wasn’t an accident in the rush but it genuinely did seem that the gateline staff enjoyed it
 

Bevan Price

Established Member
Joined
22 Apr 2010
Messages
7,366
Is is actually "legit" to prevent someone with a valid ticket from waiting on a platform at a terminus station?

I don't know Euston station well, but if I had a valid ticket to Glasgow (and lets make its an Open 1st Class Anytime, so no restrictions on time of travel), what's to stop me if I felt like sitting on the platform from 9.00am until a 10.00am departure on the basis that I personally have decided that the next train I'm taking to Glasgow is the next one to leave from platform 12, rather than specifically the next departure to Glasgow and I'm happy to spend my time waiting, reading a book etc.? I could obviously do this in say the 1st class lounge if I felt like it.
I cannot imagine many people wanting to spend a long time in the grim hole containing Euston's platforms. Even worse than Birmingham New Street in my opinion.
 

Bikeman78

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2018
Messages
4,616
You wouldn't be trespassing UNTIL you were asked to leave, and only then if you refused. You could only be asked to leave if staff felt you were being disruptive or dangerous, although I'm not sure what the threshold in the legislation is - I think it's quite low (something like 'in the opinion of a member of staff').
I've only had one incident, about 25 years ago at Waterloo. A particularly angry member of staff took exception to me taking a photo of a CEP. I think it was heading somewhere unusual like Dorking or Chessington. He insisted that I leave the station and I wouldn't be allowed to travel. I was already seated on the train by this point and refused to budge. Amazingly, he found a BTP officer. The copper spoke to me for about 30 seconds, took one look at my ticket, and let me carry on with my day. The angry man looked very disappointed.
 

bramling

Veteran Member
Joined
5 Mar 2012
Messages
17,824
Location
Hertfordshire / Teesdale
I've only had one incident, about 25 years ago at Waterloo. A particularly angry member of staff took exception to me taking a photo of a CEP. I think it was heading somewhere unusual like Dorking or Chessington. He insisted that I leave the station and I wouldn't be allowed to travel. I was already seated on the train by this point and refused to budge. Amazingly, he found a BTP officer. The copper spoke to me for about 30 seconds, took one look at my ticket, and let me carry on with my day. The angry man looked very disappointed.

I had something not too dissimilar at Huddersfield a few years ago. Member of station staff shouting across from one platform to another, which I made a point of ignoring. He then comes marching over with a BTP officer. Hopefully he learned one of life’s little lessons after making a complete fool of himself.
 

43066

Established Member
Joined
24 Nov 2019
Messages
9,573
Location
London
I've only had one incident, about 25 years ago at Waterloo. A particularly angry member of staff took exception to me taking a photo of a CEP. I think it was heading somewhere unusual like Dorking or Chessington. He insisted that I leave the station and I wouldn't be allowed to travel. I was already seated on the train by this point and refused to budge. Amazingly, he found a BTP officer. The copper spoke to me for about 30 seconds, took one look at my ticket, and let me carry on with my day. The angry man looked very disappointed.

I had something not too dissimilar at Huddersfield a few years ago. Member of station staff shouting across from one platform to another, which I made a point of ignoring. He then comes marching over with a BTP officer. Hopefully he learned one of life’s little lessons after making a complete fool of himself.

Unfortunately there seems to be something about working on the railway that attracts this type of insecure person, on a perpetual power trip, who trouble always seems to find. Usually well known to (and despised by) their colleagues.
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,518
Location
Bristol
Unfortunately there seems to be something about working on the railway that attracts this type of insecure person, on a perpetual power trip, who trouble always seems to find. Usually well known to (and despised by) their colleagues.
Not just the railway, they can be found in pretty much every walk of life.
 

bramling

Veteran Member
Joined
5 Mar 2012
Messages
17,824
Location
Hertfordshire / Teesdale
Unfortunately there seems to be something about working on the railway that attracts this type of insecure person, on a perpetual power trip, who trouble always seems to find. Usually well known to (and despised by) their colleagues.

What is rather irritating about such individuals is they have a habit of picking on what would be regarded as "soft" targets, yet won't address other issues like for example a group of teenagers smoking.

I never really get why anyone would *want* to go round stirring up unnecessary conflict. As you say, it's probably an insecurity thing.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
98,278
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
What is rather irritating about such individuals is they have a habit of picking on what would be regarded as "soft" targets, yet won't address other issues like for example a group of teenagers smoking.

I never really get why anyone would *want* to go round stirring up unnecessary conflict. As you say, it's probably an insecurity thing.

I don't think people of that mindset want conflict - it often makes them quite angry and upset. They just want, to coin the South Park phrase, people to respect their authoritaaaaaaah.
 

zwk500

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Jan 2020
Messages
13,518
Location
Bristol
I don't think people of that mindset want conflict - it often makes them quite angry and upset. They just want, to coin the South Park phrase, people to respect their authoritaaaaaaah.
I think there's an awful lot of weight throwing going on in these cases, and part of it is deliberately confrontational, to bully people.
Thankfully these cases are rare and the majority of railway staff are very good.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top