I have tried the dinner offerings on the Highlander but personally i am not really bothered about eating on the train and prefer to have something before i get on or if short of time, grab something from Sainsbury's and eat it in the berth and pop down to the lounge later. I wonder if the general consensus is, like me, that people would prefer the lounge to be more of a pub perhaps offering just a few snacks like crisps, cheese & biscuits and maybe a few simple microwave type meals. I always thought the old Mark 3 lounges had a better atmosphere and seemed to be filled with a good crowd sitting in large groups drinking quite late into the night with banter flowing across the tables and sofas. Maybe the layout was better for this. I suspect that many of the people who use this forum would be happy with the pub type arrangement, but that generally the tourists wanting the 'experience' promoted by CS expect to be wining & dining in style.