It wasn't meant to be a criticism.
The availbility of the shorting bar (together with appropriate training on it's use) is OK on 3rd rail EMUs, but if the route also carries non-3rd rail passenger stock* then presumably the crew would have to detain the passengers at least until they have confirmation of power shutdown.
* I'm thinking of XC trains on the the SWML west of Basingstoke and WoE line services between there and Waterloo. Then there's the unelectrified islands in 3rd rail land like the Marshlands line and the Uckfield branch, do those DMUs carry shorting bars with suitably trained crews to cover their running diesel over 3rd rail?