• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Failed twice

Status
Not open for further replies.

deanboy7

Member
Joined
14 Feb 2023
Messages
17
Location
Cardiff
Hi, I failed twice during computer assessments with TFW within 8 months. First attempt failed Atavt, second attempt failed Wafv. Currently got an application in with XC...am I right in saying my 2 lives are up even though I've passed all the tests but at different dates?
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

TacoTraveller

Member
Joined
30 May 2018
Messages
382
If you've failed the tests twice then that's your lives up you get no more as far as I'm aware, doesn't matter if you pass all the other tests.
 

Class2ldn

Member
Joined
25 Feb 2011
Messages
1,173
Doesn't really matter which element you pass or fail, if you fail any part twice its game over im afraid.
 

ayaz2001

Member
Joined
9 Mar 2023
Messages
128
Location
Blackburn
if its for the same tests then yeah ur lives are up, but for different tests then its just one life
 

notadriver

Established Member
Joined
1 Oct 2010
Messages
3,653
Is that two fails and you’re out
fair given you could resit for example a bus or lorry driving test until you pass?
 

Class2ldn

Member
Joined
25 Feb 2011
Messages
1,173
if its for the same tests then yeah ur lives are up, but for different tests then its just one life
No its not, its any part of the opc assessments twice and you're out.
Slightly different if there are additional tests involved that some tocs make you take that are classed as enhanced passes but for the base tests, any part of it twice and you are out. That includes the mmi as well
 

baz962

Established Member
Joined
8 Jun 2017
Messages
3,320
No its not, its any part of the opc assessments twice and you're out.
Slightly different if there are additional tests involved that some tocs make you take that are classed as enhanced passes but for the base tests, any part of it twice and you are out. That includes the mmi as well
People keep forgetting that the base tests also sometimes are enhanced. Don't want to give anyone false hope , but might be worth checking if you passed to national or not.
 

Class2ldn

Member
Joined
25 Feb 2011
Messages
1,173
People keep forgetting that the base tests also sometimes are enhanced. Don't want to give anyone false hope , but might be worth checking if you passed to national or not.
Yeah its a bit of a difficult one but you get what I'm trying to say anyway.
Generally you'll be told if you'd passed or failed so if you've failed any of them base tests then you wouldn't have reached national level or they would class it as a pass.
 

baz962

Established Member
Joined
8 Jun 2017
Messages
3,320
Yeah its a bit of a difficult one but you get what I'm trying to say anyway
I do absolutely. But I keep seeing it on here that it's extra tests that make psychometrics enhanced. However on my first day some people got sent home for only passing the base tests to standard and we hadn't done the extra tests yet. Also I went for a job somewhere soon after as I had passed everything to enhanced but failed dmi. I went to the first day again but didn't need to do anything , but I met someone there that passed the group bourdon to standard and the company wanted enhanced. Not to mention that I feel for people that are in the op position and I'm praying that it isn't over for them.
 

Class2ldn

Member
Joined
25 Feb 2011
Messages
1,173
Oh yeah I get that but a pass is a pass , it may not be for the company you are applying but there is a national level and you'll be told if you meet that as you could apply elsewhere.
The OP sounds like he's just out and out failed these 2 assessments so I believe that his 2 attempts gone.
If any of them are extra ones that TFW do and others don't then it will be different but im not sure what tests are done by every toc and whats extra now , been years and years since I done them lol
 

Samzino

Member
Joined
5 Dec 2020
Messages
1,146
Location
London
Depends on what the TOC requires. I've known some TOCs to say you've failed of which really you've ended up meeting the national level but failed the enhanced level they require. Some TOCs will mention you've failed yes and that its however met the national standard and others won't and will just say you've failed outright so I'd defo say like baz962 said just double check that it isnt an enhanced level fail.
 

Juliet Barvo

Member
Joined
24 Oct 2017
Messages
187
Hi, I failed twice during computer assessments with TFW within 8 months. First attempt failed Atavt, second attempt failed Wafv. Currently got an application in with XC...am I right in saying my 2 lives are up even though I've passed all the tests but at different dates?
Never ever retake a test that you have already passed

If you pass a test and then fail it later then after that moment you have failed it

You are only allowed to fail a test twice before you are not allowed to retake it.
 

deanboy7

Member
Joined
14 Feb 2023
Messages
17
Location
Cardiff
Tfw didn't give me the choice to resit the initial test I failed. They said I had to do the 3 tests again which I did and ended up failing another 1 that I passed first time around
 

NTD

Member
Joined
19 Jul 2023
Messages
25
Location
London
Never ever retake a test that you have already passed

If you pass a test and then fail it later then after that moment you have failed it

You are only allowed to fail a test twice before you are not allowed to retake it.

Well, what about being forced to resit a test that you've previously passed due to having passed it more than 3 years ago? Most TOCs these days only accept test results of 3 years or newer.
 

GalaxyDog

Member
Joined
7 Jul 2022
Messages
204
Location
Outer Space
Avanti West Coast will not tell you whether you've passed to National. They require Enhanced (and it is a high standard indeed) and if you fail one but pass two of the computer tests, they will simply tell you that you failed, and walk you out of the building. OPC are about as useful as a chocolate fireguard in enquiries as well, afterwards.

OP mentions that he has sat for TFW twice. TFW require only National. A former colleague of mine who sat for Avanti and got as far as the computer tests (passed the hand eye, passed the traffic photos, failed the black square) had to resit all three parts of the computer test (hand eye, photos, black squares) for TFW but crucially, did not have to resit the paper tests or pre-assessment tests.

The issue is, is that the computer tests are all done on one console, in one sitting, consecutively with no official breaks betwene tests or distinctions such; this is one element that makes them harder than they seem.
to answer OPs query, if you failed even one part of this section twice, ie failed the section overall, twice, than it is game over and you cannot try again for a Driver until/if when OPC changes the tests, I'm sorry to say. It's a bleak and horrible moment for any so-called 'railwayman' who sees the railway as more than 'just a job' but it is a heart wrenching reality alas.

I wish you all the best in finding happier pastures elsewhere.
 

Spincity

Member
Joined
23 Nov 2019
Messages
133
Location
London
Avanti West Coast will not tell you whether you've passed to National. They require Enhanced (and it is a high standard indeed) and if you fail one but pass two of the computer tests, they will simply tell you that you failed, and walk you out of the building. OPC are about as useful as a chocolate fireguard in enquiries as well, afterwards.

OP mentions that he has sat for TFW twice. TFW require only National. A former colleague of mine who sat for Avanti and got as far as the computer tests (passed the hand eye, passed the traffic photos, failed the black square) had to resit all three parts of the computer test (hand eye, photos, black squares) for TFW but crucially, did not have to resit the paper tests or pre-assessment tests.

The issue is, is that the computer tests are all done on one console, in one sitting, consecutively with no official breaks betwene tests or distinctions such; this is one element that makes them harder than they seem.
to answer OPs query, if you failed even one part of this section twice, ie failed the section overall, twice, than it is game over and you cannot try again for a Driver until/if when OPC changes the tests, I'm sorry to say. It's a bleak and horrible moment for any so-called 'railwayman' who sees the railway as more than 'just a job' but it is a heart wrenching reality alas.

I wish you all the best in finding happier pastures elsewhere.
I’m perplexed. The opc are running the tests for Avanti, the opc give feedback on the day about the computer tests, the candidates are told if passed to national/enhanced so not certain what more is needed?
 

Samzino

Member
Joined
5 Dec 2020
Messages
1,146
Location
London
I’m perplexed. The opc are running the tests for Avanti, the opc give feedback on the day about the computer tests, the candidates are told if passed to national/enhanced so not certain what more is needed?
Depends. Not all the assesment days one is informed on the day that they've failed the enhanced level for x and y toc but passed to national level as I assume they can't on the day keep doing that for all candidates that such situation is met in-between tests.

Would be to email them back for clarification if it's truly sat at OPC testing center. If its in-house sat at a TOC it's quite rare they'd tell you from what I've seen that you've passed or failed to another level that they're not intrested in unless you ask I believe anyway.
 

Spincity

Member
Joined
23 Nov 2019
Messages
133
Location
London
Depends. Not all the assesment days one is informed on the day that they've failed the enhanced level for x and y toc but passed to national level as I assume they can't on the day keep doing that for all candidates that such situation is met in-between tests.

Would be to email them back for clarification if it's truly sat at OPC testing center. If its in-house sat at a TOC it's quite rare they'd tell you from what I've seen that you've passed or failed to another level that they're not intrested in unless you ask I believe anyway.
The OP stated it was the computer tests, they’d just say you’d failed and Avanti would walk you out. My point is Avanti don’t administer any of the tests, the opc do, you are given the computer results on the day, if pass it’s the interview, if fail you given the feedback before leaving. On the day I as was there, all candidates got computer results on the day, those that failed were told if met nationals/enhanced before leaving.
 

GalaxyDog

Member
Joined
7 Jul 2022
Messages
204
Location
Outer Space
It was the computer tests, at Avanti West Coast, conducted at Crewe. Having checked with my said former colleague, they were told whether they'd passed each test individually, so "hand eye...pass. Photos. Pass. Black Squares, unfortunatly not." He is adamant that he was not told whether he had passed to National but had only failed the Enhanced, or whether he had Failed below national standard. As soon as he had received these results, he was escorted out the building and day was over.

He found out that he could contact OPC afterward to try and establish what his passes and fails were, but when he phoned them up, he was fobbed off.
 

SCDR_WMR

Established Member
Joined
17 Dec 2017
Messages
1,578
Never ever retake a test that you have already passed

If you pass a test and then fail it later then after that moment you have failed it

You are only allowed to fail a test twice before you are not allowed to retake it.
Sometimes you don't have the choice! I've sat all driver testing twice now as TfW would only take up to 2 years from testing. Would I really not sit again to get the job I want? If you can pass it once you can pass it again.

Similarly, if you can fail it once, you can also fail again.
 

Carl98k

Member
Joined
5 Apr 2020
Messages
286
Location
Plymouth
Just contact the OPC directly. They’ll tell you what you and haven’t passed, and to what standard.

I know a driver that failed to the enhanced standard, but passed to national standard. He was told by the TOC it’s a straight fail, clearly this isn’t the case.

Unfortunately everyone has an opinion, but it’s not always right. Contact the OPC directly and you’ll get the correct answer.

Good luck.
 

RyanC87

Member
Joined
26 Jul 2022
Messages
185
Location
Holyhead
Am I right in thinking if they change any part of the tests you can go again.

I'm not sure if it has to be the same part you failed or any part.

Tfw recently changed the tests on the written section where you read a page then answer questions on it
 

skyhigh

Established Member
Joined
14 Sep 2014
Messages
5,330
Am I right in thinking if they change any part of the tests you can go again.

I'm not sure if it has to be the same part you failed or any part.

Tfw recently changed the tests on the written section where you read a page then answer questions on it
TfW may have changed the tests they require but it is not the same thing as the OPC changing the tests (and therefore resetting fail counts).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top