• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Lumo - new Open Access operator on the East Coast Main Line

Status
Not open for further replies.

800001

Established Member
Joined
24 Oct 2015
Messages
5,417
It was done to remove them from journey planners and set the mandatory reservation flag due to fears of overcrowding from the amount of anytime tickets sold.
Over 200 left on platform at Newcastle this afternoon for the service heading to London (that isn't due to disruption, due to amount of tickets sold).
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Thumper1127

Member
Joined
19 Jan 2019
Messages
172
Over 200 left on platform at Newcastle this afternoon for the service heading to London (that isn't due to disruption, due to amount of tickets sold).
I can imagine it will be a draw for people all Sundays. Good departure times from both EDB and NCL, fastest journey of the day, good arrival time at KGX for onward connections. Today may possibly be an excess due to Chelsea fans returning after a night out but in my mind it was always going to be the service to go for. Pity about today’s delays of course.
 

TheBigD

Established Member
Joined
19 Nov 2008
Messages
2,042
I can imagine it will be a draw for people all Sundays. Good departure times from both EDB and NCL, fastest journey of the day, good arrival time at KGX for onward connections. Today may possibly be an excess due to Chelsea fans returning after a night out but in my mind it was always going to be the service to go for. Pity about today’s delays of course.

1053 ex Edinburgh Lumo was 19 late from Newcastle, only lost 3 minutes en route to Kings Cross arriving 22 late. Considering the disruption it had a pretty decent run.
 

Thumper1127

Member
Joined
19 Jan 2019
Messages
172
1053 ex Edinburgh Lumo was 19 late from Newcastle, only lost 3 minutes en route to Kings Cross arriving 22 late. Considering the disruption it had a pretty decent run.
Totally agree of course, I was referring to the wider disruption. It’ll be interesting to see what it does on subsequent Sundays.
 

Kite159

Veteran Member
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
20,779
Location
West of Andover
The relief service from Edinburgh to London has 10 passengers in the front coach, after Newcastle.

No idea if the rest of the train is busier.
 

Killingworth

Established Member
Joined
30 May 2018
Messages
5,734
Location
Sheffield
I can imagine it will be a draw for people all Sundays. Good departure times from both EDB and NCL, fastest journey of the day, good arrival time at KGX for onward connections. Today may possibly be an excess due to Chelsea fans returning after a night out but in my mind it was always going to be the service to go for. Pity about today’s delays of course.

A1(M) south from Newcastle was very busy today, 60mph max most of the way until we left at Wetherby, heavy rain not helping.
 

Mainline421

Member
Joined
7 May 2013
Messages
699
Location
Aberystwyth
Over 200 left on platform at Newcastle this afternoon for the service heading to London (that isn't due to disruption, due to amount of tickets sold).
This isn't really Lumo's fault though, LNER still have set the CR flag incorrectly set on all their services which makes it appear to users who book online and aren't knowledgeable about how rail fares work that all trains were "sold out" except that one. Of course they shouldn't have handled the result quite the way they did by claiming people with tickets wouldn't be able to travel, but unless LNER fix this the issue is just going to be repeated every time there's a major event.
 

takno

Established Member
Joined
9 Jul 2016
Messages
6,144
This isn't really Lumo's fault though, LNER still have set the CR flag incorrectly set on all their services which makes it appear to users who book online and aren't knowledgeable about how rail fares work that all trains were "sold out" except that one. Of course they shouldn't have handled the result quite the way they did by claiming people with tickets wouldn't be able to travel, but unless LNER fix this the issue is just going to be repeated every time there's a major event.
The existence of the CR flag is a problem which needs to be addressed really. It doesn't reflect reality on the ground anymore and is just breaking online ticket purchase.
 

800001

Established Member
Joined
24 Oct 2015
Messages
5,417
This isn't really Lumo's fault though, LNER still have set the CR flag incorrectly set on all their services which makes it appear to users who book online and aren't knowledgeable about how rail fares work that all trains were "sold out" except that one. Of course they shouldn't have handled the result quite the way they did by claiming people with tickets wouldn't be able to travel, but unless LNER fix this the issue is just going to be repeated every time there's a major event.
This was a lumo service which left nearly 200 people on platform, nothing to do with lner, other than lner end up with lumo passengers on there services!!
 

43096

On Moderation
Joined
23 Nov 2015
Messages
16,867
This isn't really Lumo's fault though, LNER still have set the CR flag incorrectly set on all their services which makes it appear to users who book online and aren't knowledgeable about how rail fares work that all trains were "sold out" except that one. Of course they shouldn't have handled the result quite the way they did by claiming people with tickets wouldn't be able to travel, but unless LNER fix this the issue is just going to be repeated every time there's a major event.
This is Lumo, the company that got its paths on the basis that it was really getting passengers off the airlines between London and Edinburgh, that we're talking about, isn't it? So why would passengers using them be expected to know about how rail fares work.

The same Lumo that tipped its passengers out at Newcastle when they wanted to go Edinburgh earlier on and started the return working there, presumably with the idea that Edinburgh punters make their own way in between. Now, I know the train was very late, but if you're competing with the airlines, it's not great. Even Mr O'Leary doesn't make a habit of terminating short and kicking the punters off.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
104,834
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
The existence of the CR flag is a problem which needs to be addressed really. It doesn't reflect reality on the ground anymore and is just breaking online ticket purchase.

It strikes me that while the CR flag was a reasonable workaround to a COVID related problem, there need to be several states:

1. Reservations recommended - must be sold with one if any are available, if not then still sell but with a big red warning that the purchaser has to acknowledge
2. Reservations recommended, sale with reservation only - basically what the flag is presently being used for
3. Reservations compulsory - boarding will be refused if no reservation is held and/or a penalty of some kind applies if you do not have one, i.e. as per TGV, Eurostar etc

It's a shame the new reservations system was specced pre COVID.
 

Ianno87

Veteran Member
Joined
3 May 2015
Messages
15,214
It strikes me that while the CR flag was a reasonable workaround to a COVID related problem, there need to be several states:

1. Reservations recommended - must be sold with one if any are available, if not then still sell but with a big red warning that the purchaser has to acknowledge
2. Reservations recommended, sale with reservation only - basically what the flag is presently being used for
3. Reservations compulsory - boarding will be refused if no reservation is held and/or a penalty of some kind applies if you do not have one, i.e. as per TGV, Eurostar etc

It's a shame the new reservations system was specced pre COVID.

I maintain that making it absolutely clear to passengers looking up train times "there are no more reservable seats on this train (but you can still turn up and take your chances)" is funademantally a good thing so people aren't surprised by the fact that the 1600 to Aberdeen on Maundy Thursday is, in fact, rather busy.

Discuss what is the best way to achieve that.
 

Dr Hoo

Established Member
Joined
10 Nov 2015
Messages
4,807
Location
Hope Valley
This was a lumo service which left nearly 200 people on platform, nothing to do with lner, other than lner end up with lumo passengers on there services!!
Struggling to understand all this. Are you saying that Lumo had 'oversold' (i.e. above and beyond its own capacity, with all seats already reserved) by an extra 200 operator-specific tickets and then simply denied boarding?
 

tornado

Member
Joined
6 Apr 2010
Messages
432
Does anyone have a higher resolution version of the LUMO seatplan? This one is floating around but its too blurry to see the numbers!
Lumoseatplan.png
 

cambsy

Member
Joined
6 Oct 2011
Messages
983
I have asked same thing, as this seat plan is awful. I’d advise if not like seat you given, going coach E and sitting in any unreserved seat, especially if boarding originating station, its what I’m doing on my Wednesday trip on Lumo.
 

800001

Established Member
Joined
24 Oct 2015
Messages
5,417
Struggling to understand all this. Are you saying that Lumo had 'oversold' (i.e. above and beyond its own capacity, with all seats already reserved) by an extra 200 operator-specific tickets and then simply denied boarding?
Yes!! As they like all operators sell open tickets valid for any of there services. So yes they have sold lots of Lumo open tickets, still readily available to purchase from tickets vending machines with out reservations.
 

Starmill

Veteran Member
Joined
18 May 2012
Messages
25,230
Location
Bolton
I maintain that making it absolutely clear to passengers looking up train times "there are no more reservable seats on this train (but you can still turn up and take your chances)" is funademantally a good thing so people aren't surprised by the fact that the 1600 to Aberdeen on Maundy Thursday is, in fact, rather busy.

Discuss what is the best way to achieve that.
Is this actually a problem in the minds of anyone other than people on a forum though? The LNER website already has said in a pop up, for many years, if there aren't any seats left...
 

DanNCL

Established Member
Joined
17 Jul 2017
Messages
5,062
Location
County Durham
Over 200 left on platform at Newcastle this afternoon for the service heading to London (that isn't due to disruption, due to amount of tickets sold).
Chelsea playing Newcastle United at St James Park yesterday combined with the end of school half term resulting in an unusually high level of demand for Newcastle - London travel. LNER were at capacity today too.

This was a lumo service which left nearly 200 people on platform, nothing to do with lner, other than lner end up with lumo passengers on there services!!
Of those 200 people reportedly left behind, how many of those actually had Lumo only tickets as opposed to off peak or anytime tickets that would have been valid on LNER regardless? Very few I suspect.

Yes!! As they like all operators sell open tickets valid for any of there services. So yes they have sold lots of Lumo open tickets, still readily available to purchase from tickets vending machines with out reservations.
None of the web booking engines will sell a Lumo only ticket without a reservation because of the compulsory reservation flag - LNER and Northern’s TVMs (therefore all TVMs at Newcastle and Morpeth) also won’t sell them without a reservation as they require you to select an itinerary before it will sell you the ticket. On Lumo’s network the only places to buy a Lumo only ticket without a reservation are at GTR or ScotRail TVMs at Kings Cross and Waverley respectively, and at a ticket office. Though not impossible, it’s not easy to get a Lumo only ticket without a reservation unless you just happen to use the correct TVM or go to a ticket office, both things which very few of Lumo’s customer base will do.
 

Ianno87

Veteran Member
Joined
3 May 2015
Messages
15,214
Is this actually a problem in the minds of anyone other than people on a forum though? The LNER website already has said in a pop up, for many years, if there aren't any seats left...

Yes. See the TOC Twotter feed on any busy Thursday/Friday/Sunday and the "you've sold too many tickets!" Tweets. People simply don't understand that capacity per train is finite, so need some expectation management.
 

cambsy

Member
Joined
6 Oct 2011
Messages
983
One way around Lumo capacity problems, at busy times, would be if 803’s can be coupled up, and there’s spare units, and crews to do it, then run 2 units together, giving a 10 coach service, wether this is in reality feasible, is another thing.

Having short 5 coach trains running services, always gives the same perennial problem, of overcrowding at busy times etc, the railways should have learned this, from right back when operation Princess happened with 4 and 5 coach voyagers, taking over from long intercity trains, and as long a 5 coach trains, are ordered for long distant services, then it will carry on happening.
 
Last edited:

tornado

Member
Joined
6 Apr 2010
Messages
432
I'm just baffled they decided to go for 5 coach to begin with. Running a £30 service over the entire ECML even at peak times was bound to be extremely popular. Should have started with 8 coach.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
104,834
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
I'm just baffled they decided to go for 5 coach to begin with. Running a £30 service over the entire ECML even at peak times was bound to be extremely popular. Should have started with 8 coach.

I think it's in some ways the effect of them not having set the CR flag when LNER, the majority operator, has set it. The Lumo Only Anytime Day Single is not substantially cheaper than the LNER Super Off Peak Single (and it's only those that can be sold unreserved), so it's not about cheap fares, it's about LNER being "sold out" when full and this short train not. I've noticed a similar effect on the WCML where Avanti have done the same thing, which I'm sure WMT are decidedly unbothered about as they have a lot of capacity at the moment with many of the commuters absent.

It highlights to me that policies on compulsory, half-compulsory or non-compulsory reservations on the main IC TOCs can't really be decided by TOC and there really needs to be a consensus.
 

Starmill

Veteran Member
Joined
18 May 2012
Messages
25,230
Location
Bolton
Yes. See the TOC Twotter feed on any busy Thursday/Friday/Sunday and the "you've sold too many tickets!" Tweets. People simply don't understand that capacity per train is finite, so need some expectation management.
Yes but shouting on twitter will occur in all situations regardless of what you actually do.

What I meant was, is there any evidence that negative customer perception actually arises specifically from people who decline a seat reservation / click through a message regarding there being no further available seats on the train in question then getting on and demanding a seat?

When there's disruption you'll get large numbers standing, even from one train being cancelled sometimes. When there's a formation change or no seat reservations on display you'll get the same issue. The solution is to fix the root causes of these things, however
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
104,834
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
I don't believe Lumo's site issues as clear a message as is mentioned there. The LNER one might, but most of them just say subtly "we were unable to reserve a seat", which doesn't normally tally with "you are unlikely to get a seat", rather "you need to join the Euston scrum" (or whatever).
 

Starmill

Veteran Member
Joined
18 May 2012
Messages
25,230
Location
Bolton
I'm just baffled they decided to go for 5 coach to begin with. Running a £30 service over the entire ECML even at peak times was bound to be extremely popular. Should have started with 8 coach.
Significantly higher commercial risk there. Who would choose to bear that?

The access rights framework could have stipulated larger capacity allocation. Unfortunately it didn't.
 

Bletchleyite

Veteran Member
Joined
20 Oct 2014
Messages
104,834
Location
"Marston Vale mafia"
Significantly higher commercial risk there. Who would choose to bear that?

The access rights framework could have stipulated larger capacity allocation. Unfortunately it didn't.

Or they could have just paid a little bit of attention to what was obviously going to happen if they didn't follow the same reservation policy as LNER and Avanti*, and set the compulsory reservation flag?

I am as people are well aware not a fan of what LNER are doing, but a small OAO with a couple of 5-car trains per day doing something different to the incumbent was never going to work.

* I know Avanti is on the WCML, but with the CR flag set on both theirs and LNER's trains there will be "overspill" both ways.
 

Starmill

Veteran Member
Joined
18 May 2012
Messages
25,230
Location
Bolton
I think it's in some ways the effect of them not having set the CR flag when LNER, the majority operator, has set it. The Lumo Only Anytime Day Single is not substantially cheaper than the LNER Super Off Peak Single (and it's only those that can be sold unreserved), so it's not about cheap fares, it's about LNER being "sold out" when full and this short train not. I've noticed a similar effect on the WCML where Avanti have done the same thing, which I'm sure WMT are decidedly unbothered about as they have a lot of capacity at the moment with many of the commuters absent.

It highlights to me that policies on compulsory, half-compulsory or non-compulsory reservations on the main IC TOCs can't really be decided by TOC and there really needs to be a consensus.
You don't get consensus elsewhere. The LNR Crewe to London trains on Fridays are now regularly running full and standing as eight cars while there are vacant seats on Avanti trains at the same times of day, which are "full".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top