• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

New Normanton/Castleford TPE services

Status
Not open for further replies.

YorksLad12

Established Member
Joined
5 Feb 2020
Messages
2,244
Location
Leeds
Why don’t Northern just put in the Normanton call in for all their Nottingham services?

They already do this for the 17:09 from Leeds, it adds a whole extra minute to the journey time looking at the planner!

It's a question I've been asking for the last fifteen years or so.

Realistically the station deserves a roughly half-hourly service to Leeds/Sheffield.
We have had this conversation several times even in the few years I've been here. Southbound, the train crawls through Normanton - so slow that it might as well stop. I think I'd rather have a three-car unit though as services do get busy in the peaks (yes, I know, P17 at Leeds).
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

yorksrob

Veteran Member
Joined
6 Aug 2009
Messages
41,673
Location
Yorks
We have had this conversation several times even in the few years I've been here. Southbound, the train crawls through Normanton - so slow that it might as well stop. I think I'd rather have a three-car unit though as services do get busy in the peaks (yes, I know, P17 at Leeds).

You're right. The old 3-car 144 used to be about equal to a 2-car 158 and much better than a 150.
 
Joined
15 Apr 2020
Messages
353
Location
Wakefield
The short answer is no. Currently nothing that serves Normanton goes to Westgate, the service that uses the Wakefield curve comes from the Featherstone/Crofton line. I also doubt there's the right type of signalling (permissive?) at Wakefield Kirkgate to allow splitting and joining, especially in Platform 3 which is the only one with access to the lines via Crofton.
All platforms at Kirkgate are permissively signalled.

[Currently this is only authorised for contingency use, such as during disruption, as nothing is scheduled to require it therefore drivers should not take the signals without first being spoken to, but it’s the same interlocking just a change in driver/box instructions to use it consistently]
 

61653 HTAFC

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Dec 2012
Messages
18,607
Location
Yorkshire
that shouldnt really matter though should it? seeing as theres a xover to the up doncaster and kirkgate spur just south of the platforms
Both platforms have access to and from the curve, but only one has access to and from the prison siding. By using Wrenthorpe to reverse it could use whichever platform was available first, but if using the prison siding it has to use the Down side.
If you were to have a second train per hour use the curve, there's probably a case for running it through to Leeds like the current Knottingley service does, paths and platforms at Leeds permitting.

All platforms at Kirkgate are permissively signalled.

[Currently this is only authorised for contingency use, such as during disruption, as nothing is scheduled to require it therefore drivers should not take the signals without first being spoken to, but it’s the same interlocking just a change in driver/box instructions to use it consistently]
Surprised by that, as you say it isn't used much and I can't recall ever seeing it being used. I do recall during the 90s there was a SYPTE-sponsored service from Sheffield via Barnsley which terminated at Wakefield Kirkgate- not sure how or where it turned back.
 
Last edited:

tbtc

Veteran Member
Joined
16 Dec 2008
Messages
17,885
Location
Reston City Centre
Why don’t Northern just put in the Normanton call in for all their Nottingham services?

They already do this for the 17:09 from Leeds, it adds a whole extra minute to the journey time looking at the planner!

The Nottingham services are already fairly busy, and restricted to two coach length for reasons previously discussed

They are also pretty uncompetitive against the XC service from Leeds to Sheffield/ East Midlands (around 45m on a Voyager from Leeds to Sheffield vs around an hour on a 158)

Slowing them down further and adding lots of short distance passengers on subsidised West Yorkshire tickets to the longer distance trains feels like asking for trouble

We were meant to have the Nottingham services running fast via Westgate instead (providing a cooperative journey time when compared to the XC service and therefore freeing up a lot of seats on the Voyagers through West Yorkshire) but Arriva’s franchise requirements were obviously ripped up when the franchise became Government operated, and there seems no hope of any of the things previously committed to as part of the franchising procedure

IF that Arriva service had happened then there’d have been a lot more scope for stopping Kirkgate trains at Normanton (and Darton etc) but it’d be a backwards step for the “semi fast” to try to accommodate such short distance passengers
 

YorksLad12

Established Member
Joined
5 Feb 2020
Messages
2,244
Location
Leeds
The Nottingham services are already fairly busy, and restricted to two coach length for reasons previously discussed

They are also pretty uncompetitive against the XC service from Leeds to Sheffield/ East Midlands (around 45m on a Voyager from Leeds to Sheffield vs around an hour on a 158)

Slowing them down further and adding lots of short distance passengers on subsidised West Yorkshire tickets to the longer distance trains feels like asking for trouble
I mostly agree, but I think there's some slack in the semi-fasts timetables. Pre-Covid when I did that return leg to Leeds daily, we'd pause at Barnsley most days, and Kirkgate. Leeds, we'd sometimes arrive early and have to wait for the semi-fast to depart so we could take its place on P17. Plus, that crawl after Horbury Junction towards Kirkgate.

Interestingly: 0804 Leeds to Sheffield (NT) arrives 0904 (60 minutes); the 0811 XC arrives 0854 (43). On the way back, the 1718 NT arrives 1813 (55), the 1721 XC arrives 1802 (41). It's slightly quicker heading north by either route, which I'm guessing is down to the need to flight everything approaching from the north of Sheffield.

I'd rather hoped the faster via Westgate service would be running by now - I guess it's down to pathing, which another difficulty in truncating and redirecting the Huddersfield service to Westgate.
 

xotGD

Established Member
Joined
4 Feb 2017
Messages
6,838
I mostly agree, but I think there's some slack in the semi-fasts timetables. Pre-Covid when I did that return leg to Leeds daily, we'd pause at Barnsley most days, and Kirkgate. Leeds, we'd sometimes arrive early and have to wait for the semi-fast to depart so we could take its place on P17. Plus, that crawl after Horbury Junction towards Kirkgate.

Interestingly: 0804 Leeds to Sheffield (NT) arrives 0904 (60 minutes); the 0811 XC arrives 0854 (43). On the way back, the 1718 NT arrives 1813 (55), the 1721 XC arrives 1802 (41). It's slightly quicker heading north by either route, which I'm guessing is down to the need to flight everything approaching from the north of Sheffield.

I'd rather hoped the faster via Westgate service would be running by now - I guess it's down to pathing, which another difficulty in truncating and redirecting the Huddersfield service to Westgate.
And online journey planners shove everyone onto an already wedged Voyager when there are spare seats on the Northern service.
 

Iskra

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2014
Messages
9,120
Location
West Riding
These services are due to start in the December timetable now.

Does anyone know what impact this new TP service will have on the current Castleford-Leeds service or the Leeds-Castleford-Sheffield stopper? (or any other services it will impact)
 

CaptainHaddock

Established Member
Joined
10 Feb 2011
Messages
2,472
These services are due to start in the December timetable now.

Does anyone know what impact this new TP service will have on the current Castleford-Leeds service or the Leeds-Castleford-Sheffield stopper? (or any other services it will impact)
No idea but this would be an ideal opportunity to remove the pointless Castleford diversion on the Sheffield-Barnsley-Leeds stoppers that adds 15 unnecessary minutes to what is an already slow service.
 

Adam0984

Member
Joined
18 Feb 2014
Messages
1,155
Itll slot in the the existing services, there's about a 20 mins gap between the Leeds bound leaving and the Knottingley/Sheffield leaving, also the Knottingley to Leeds can arrive and depart from the new platform whilst a York bound train leaves the current platform without affecting anything
 

YorksLad12

Established Member
Joined
5 Feb 2020
Messages
2,244
Location
Leeds
These services are due to start in the December timetable now.

Does anyone know what impact this new TP service will have on the current Castleford-Leeds service or the Leeds-Castleford-Sheffield stopper? (or any other services it will impact)
It'll replace northern's Huddersfield-Wakefield-Castleford service, but that's it. There's no recasting on Five Towns services in the works that I've heard.

No idea but this would be an ideal opportunity to remove the pointless Castleford diversion on the Sheffield-Barnsley-Leeds stoppers that adds 15 unnecessary minutes to what is an already slow service.
It's only pointless if you're travelling from Leeds or Woodlesford to Normanton. You can catch the semi-fast to Kirkgate and change there to the stopper for Darton, anything else you catch the semi-fast to Barnsley and change there for intermediate stations to Sheffield.

That said, we've all identified options for adding stops into the semi-fasts without extending journey times thanks to the padding in the timetable which would still allow Leeds-Castleford(-elsewhere) to main 2tph. I think we'd need the long-promised via Westgate service to start first so that any changes to Sheffield-Leeds are made at the same time (and train length / platforming issues at Leeds and Sheffield to be overcome).
 

61653 HTAFC

Veteran Member
Joined
18 Dec 2012
Messages
18,607
Location
Yorkshire
It'll replace northern's Huddersfield-Wakefield-Castleford service, but that's it. There's no recasting on Five Towns services in the works that I've heard.


It's only pointless if you're travelling from Leeds or Woodlesford to Normanton. You can catch the semi-fast to Kirkgate and change there to the stopper for Darton, anything else you catch the semi-fast to Barnsley and change there for intermediate stations to Sheffield.

That said, we've all identified options for adding stops into the semi-fasts without extending journey times thanks to the padding in the timetable which would still allow Leeds-Castleford(-elsewhere) to main 2tph. I think we'd need the long-promised via Westgate service to start first so that any changes to Sheffield-Leeds are made at the same time (and train length / platforming issues at Leeds and Sheffield to be overcome).
One of the advantages of the original plan to divert the Nottingham service to the Westgate route is that would no longer use Platform 17 at Leeds. Until that happens, those services will be limited to 2-car units.
 
Joined
15 Apr 2020
Messages
353
Location
Wakefield
Any evidence of this other than speculation?
This was meant to have happened in the May TT, hence the Northern services stopped, but TPE didn’t start theirs - for various reasons.

The Castleford platform is finished and the TPE work is now underway to enable it to start in December 23 but I can’t give you any proof.

(Not being able to provide evidence is not the same as speculating!)
 

RHolmes

Member
Joined
19 Jul 2019
Messages
652
This was meant to have happened in the May TT, hence the Northern services stopped, but TPE didn’t start theirs - for various reasons.
The Castleford platform is finished and the TPE work is now underway to enable it to start in December 23 but I can’t give you any proof.

No I appreciate that, as I’m one of the guards who would be working the said service. Technically it was meant to happen in 2020!

However, As far as I’m aware though, the focus now for the North routes is on route retention and diversion knowledge rather than new routes for the next few months.
 

507020

Established Member
Joined
23 May 2021
Messages
1,982
Location
Southport
No I appreciate that, as I’m one of the guards who would be working the said service. Technically it was meant to happen in 2020!

However, As far as I’m aware though, the focus now for the North routes is on route retention and diversion knowledge rather than new routes for the next few months.
Is the Castleford - Burton Salmon section not already a diversionary route for knowledge/retention purposes? I remember hearing that the point of starting regular services that way was to improve the resiliency of driver/guard route knowledge on what will be a key diversionary route for Neville Hill - Church Fenton electrification.
 

Iskra

Established Member
Joined
11 Jun 2014
Messages
9,120
Location
West Riding
Any evidence of this other than speculation?
BLN 1425 P41


Although I'm sure some knowledgeable individuals could confirm on here, should they wish...

Is the Castleford - Burton Salmon section not already a diversionary route for knowledge/retention purposes? I remember hearing that the point of starting regular services that way was to improve the resiliency of driver/guard route knowledge on what will be a key diversionary route for Neville Hill - Church Fenton electrification.
This is my understanding too
 

Adam0984

Member
Joined
18 Feb 2014
Messages
1,155
I think the missing route knowledge is the short section from Altofts Jcn to Whitwood Jcn, a lot of crews have the knowledge of Huddersfield to Leeds via Healey Mills and Methley and Leeds to York via Castleford but very few have the knowledge of the 3rd side of the triangle to operate these services
 

RHolmes

Member
Joined
19 Jul 2019
Messages
652
I think the missing route knowledge is the short section from Altofts Jcn to Whitwood Jcn, a lot of crews have the knowledge of Huddersfield to Leeds via Healey Mills and Methley and Leeds to York via Castleford but very few have the knowledge of the 3rd side of the triangle to operate these services
That’s correct, out of the the sections of the triangle, Castleford to Hull/York is the one with the least amount of traincrew knowledge

Hull and York depots are the main two who have daily booked work on this section, my own knowledge has sadly lapsed.

Ps. Cheers @Iskra !
 

nr758123

Member
Joined
3 Jun 2014
Messages
549
Location
West Yorkshire
Any evidence of this other than speculation?
WYCA Transport Committee, 26 May 2023, Item 6, Appendix 2

Castleford – Wakefield – Huddersfield

Changes in May 2023 - All four weekday services are withdrawn, to be replaced by a substitute bus service with extended journey times. No Sunday service, as historically.

Comments - This is a deeply unwelcome move, pending partial resolution when all-day Huddersfield – Wakefield – Castleford service is expected to be provided as part of a regular TPE Manchester – Huddersfield – Wakefield – York service from December 2023. This is subject to confirmation – see main report.
 
Joined
15 Apr 2020
Messages
353
Location
Wakefield
No I appreciate that, as I’m one of the guards who would be working the said service. Technically it was meant to happen in 2020!

However, As far as I’m aware though, the focus now for the North routes is on route retention and diversion knowledge rather than new routes for the next few months.
Sorry for the cynicism- this forum gets a bit painful sometimes!

I’m a Wakefield Kirkgate signaller, we’ve been doing stopping points and platform tests etc recently at Kirkgate, Normanton and Castleford, and working with planners on verifying headways etc. Apparently this is all with the aim of Dec 23 TT addition, the training runs starting in the couple of months beforehand once all the finer points are done.

We shall see!
 

LittleAH

Member
Joined
24 Oct 2018
Messages
1,157
From what I’ve heard, TPE will commence a two hourly service from the DEC 23 timetable change. Subject to staff availability. Unsure of calling patterns.

The service isn’t linked with Northern, they’ve just abandoned the service between Huddersfield and Castleford it seems.
 

yorkie

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Administrator
Joined
6 Jun 2005
Messages
73,368
Location
Yorkshire
From what I’ve heard, TPE will commence a two hourly service from the DEC 23 timetable change. Subject to staff availability. Unsure of calling patterns.
I know people will want to speculate on this, so here is a thread where people can do so:
:D
The service isn’t linked with Northern, they’ve just abandoned the service between Huddersfield and Castleford it seems.
Yes, my understanding is that Northern were told TPE would be taking it over, so withdrew the service at DfT's request (of course, rather predictably the timelines are not quite aligned!)
 

DarrenDJSmith

New Member
Joined
27 Oct 2023
Messages
4
Location
Barnsley
From the Dec timetable TPE will be running passenger services York to Manchester calling at Castleford, Normanton and Wakefield Kirkgate. But only 4 a day each way, 2 morning peak and 2 evening peak.
 

507020

Established Member
Joined
23 May 2021
Messages
1,982
Location
Southport
From the Dec timetable TPE will be running passenger services York to Manchester calling at Castleford, Normanton and Wakefield Kirkgate. But only 4 a day each way, 2 morning peak and 2 evening peak.
Yes this is very good news, I am looking forward to using them and glad it has now been clarified that they will call at Normanton and Castleford. Running through non stop would massively detract from their usefulness.

With 185s on all services, I wonder if first class fares will be available from all stations served, rather than just headline TPE stations, e.g. Stalybridge - York.
 

Tetchytyke

Veteran Member
Joined
12 Sep 2013
Messages
14,928
Location
Isle of Man
With 185s on all services, I wonder if first class fares will be available from all stations served, rather than just headline TPE stations, e.g. Stalybridge - York.
I’d be surprised if they added fares in.

According to the timetable the Castleford trains won’t convey catering. Something to bear in mind for people travelling through from Manchester and Huddersfield to York, especially in first class.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top