• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Velaro UK construction progress (New Eurostar rolling stock)

Status
Not open for further replies.

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
29,476
Location
UK
The new E320s units do look really nice from the outside and the inside but I was a little disappointed by the 1st Class seating cream and dark grey fabric seats a bit standard if you ask me. I thought it would be a bit more radical like the outside of the E320 units I was envisioning 1st Class with bright yellow and navy blue leather seats like the seats found on the DB ICE 3 1st Class.

I do prefer leather over fabric but that's my own opinion though.

Having been on an IC, ICE2 and ICE3 in Germany recently, the ICE3 was much like these new trains. Not identical obviously, but a lot more simple (which must make it easier to clean and maintain them). I didn't think I'd ever hear myself say it, but I thought the older train that had been refurbished had more character than the newer ones (and I was in first class on all of them FWIW).

The seats in the ICE3 were comfortable enough though, and that's perhaps all that matters. Loads of leg room too.

Ultimately, this is what all new trains look like. Much more sparse and plasticky, and usually a lot lighter - although seeing some colour in things like the luggage racks (and seeing how the HEX trains are), perhaps the lights can be dimmed and this was very much for the press.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

33Hz

Member
Joined
2 Dec 2010
Messages
513
Eurostar only had 28 full length (class 373/e300) sets.
The other 3 have been in domestic service in France with SNCF for years and no longer part of the Eurostar fleet.
Those 3 SNCF sets have already been recently retired and are waiting to be scrapped.

OK so of the original 31 full trains, we are looking at a situation where 17 of them might be out of service well before they are technically life expired, where the operator which took years to reach any sort of profitability still intends to use the new sets for the routes which the old ones are perfectly suited.

An SNCF representative on twitter said that the 3 SNCF sets were already destroyed.


The 7 SNCF operated shorty NoL sets are also due to be retired soon, if what I've read elsewhere is correct.

The same agent claimed they are being prepared for shipment back to the UK.
 

Peter Mugridge

Veteran Member
Joined
8 Apr 2010
Messages
16,248
Location
Epsom
Today they're saying that the fleet is only 24 sets strong. If that's correct and not a mistake, then 3 other sets have already been laid up.

One of them - 3101/2 hasn't run for many years after it was damaged in a derailment. It spent years laid up at Fforest and was eventually moved to Temple Mills and as I understand it the trailers were later taken to France for use in testing various interior layouts and materials ahead of the 373 refurbishments. This isn't the actual first refurbished set being done at Hellemmes - these trailers are at a workshop in a small town I've forgotten the name of but it's somewhere near Poitiers.





Accessible to the public to look round inside?

Neil

Sorry, no - viewable only from the area outside the fence! But you can get close enough to see in through the windows as it's in platform 5.
 
Last edited:

Olaf

Member
Joined
29 Mar 2014
Messages
1,054
Location
UK
Are any high speed lines being upgraded to 320kph? Which lines will they be able to run full speed on?

Back in 2010 there was a review of options for increases of line speed on the UK side with the aim of cutting the London Paris journey time to two hours or less. To achieve that there would also need to be line speed reductions beyond Lille.

There were no specific dates but I think it was targeted to coincide with renewal of the signalling. More recently, the options have not been mentioned as far as I can see in SNCF's funded projects, but perhaps it is too early to show up yet.
--- old post above --- --- new post below ---

Looking back at announcements from April 2013, it looks like there has been a further slip in the deliveries scheduled for 2015 with only half the sets expected to be in service by the end of 2015.

The completion of the order is now at least 17 months behind schedule.

The proposed Koln and Frankfurt services (originally proposed for start in late 2013/mid-2014) now seem to have gone into limbo.
 
Last edited:
Joined
9 Jul 2011
Messages
800
The 7 SNCF operated shorty NoL sets are also due to be retired soon, if what I've read elsewhere is correct.

The same agent claimed they are being prepared for shipment back to the UK.

Unlike the SNCF owned domestic Thee Capitals sets, the 7 NoL sets were leased to SNCF by London & Continental Railways. If the lease has come to an end, then they might well be returned to their owner, for storage or scrapping. I can't think of any practical use for them.....in the real world.
 

SpacePhoenix

Established Member
Joined
18 Mar 2014
Messages
5,491
Unlike the SNCF owned domestic Thee Capitals sets, the 7 NoL sets were leased to SNCF by London & Continental Railways. If the lease has come to an end, then they might well be returned to their owner, for storage or scrapping. I can't think of any practical use for them.....in the real world.

Could the better condition coaches from the NoL sets be shifted around to make up as many "full length" sets as possible with the left over coaches being cannibalised for spares?
 

cjmillsnun

Established Member
Joined
13 Feb 2011
Messages
3,274
Could the better condition coaches from the NoL sets be shifted around to make up as many "full length" sets as possible with the left over coaches being cannibalised for spares?

After being in daily use on SNCF, the coaches are probably not any better than E*'s other 373s.
 
Joined
9 Jul 2011
Messages
800
Could the better condition coaches from the NoL sets be shifted around to make up as many "full length" sets as possible with the left over coaches being cannibalised for spares?

Three points.

1. The updated and refurbished "Three Capitals" sets should be in fairly good as new condition, once they are delivered.

2. It might be rather difficult to reform the NoL vehicles into longer sets, because of the mixed nature of the different types of vehicle in a set, with different vehicle lengths and a mixture of shared articulated bogies and non-articulated bogies.

3. What would Eurostar do with them? There is no requirement for these trains.
Eurostar have just informed us that they will be retiring a further 10 full length ("Three Capitals") sets, as the new 374's are introduced into service.



 
Last edited:

po8crg

Member
Joined
6 Feb 2014
Messages
559
The only use I could see for the NoL sets is as HS2 classic a compatible sets, but they'd be practically decrepit by the time HS2 opens.
 

SpacePhoenix

Established Member
Joined
18 Mar 2014
Messages
5,491
How full are the Disneylabd trains? If there not as full as the "3 capitals" routes then maybe one or two could see out their days on them runs
 

cjmillsnun

Established Member
Joined
13 Feb 2011
Messages
3,274
How full are the Disneylabd trains? If there not as full as the "3 capitals" routes then maybe one or two could see out their days on them runs

I doubt it, they'd require refurbishment to get them to the same standard as the referred three capitals sets.

From the sound of it they have too many of them anyway.
 

Goldfish62

Veteran Member
Joined
14 Feb 2010
Messages
11,812
This is an interesting photo of the cab.

http://PaulBigland.zenfolio.com/p622123184/e54b413

Classic DB cab layout. I assume the AWS reset (needed at least on the approach to St Pancras) is the yellow button at the bottom right. The German PZB is the bank of switches directly ahead and I assume the TVM430 would be on one of the screens.

There's also the LZB lever - basically speed control and a form of ATO for German high speed lines.
 

LaythA

New Member
Joined
14 Nov 2014
Messages
2
Location
WEST YORKSHIRE
It's a real shame if they retired the NoL Eurostars.

If Keolis / Eurostar won the East Coast franchise it would be nice if they could use these sets to run trains from maybe Leeds or York and try test services to Paris, in a similar fashion to the London to South of France service in 2013. I'm pretty sure there is a connecting line from the East Coast mainline that can take the train into St Pancras and pick up passengers from London to fill any remaining capacity.

Of course they would need to sort out border controls at Leeds station for example but I'm sure they could be flexable with platform 1 up there. Fence it and secure it off when the Eurostar train sparked there. Once it has left for Paris, they can open up the platform for the usual local trains.

Anyway....scrapping these eurostars is such a waste.
 

woolwinder

Member
Joined
2 Feb 2009
Messages
26
Location
stevenage
Unlike the SNCF owned domestic Thee Capitals sets, the 7 NoL sets were leased to SNCF by London & Continental Railways. If the lease has come to an end, then they might well be returned to their owner, for storage or scrapping. I can't think of any practical use for them.....in the real world.

If ES and partners should be successful with the East Coast franchise they may be able to supplement the current fleet with Nols, which incedently have not retained their channel tunnel running status.
 

starrymarkb

Established Member
Joined
4 Aug 2009
Messages
5,985
Location
Exeter
This is an interesting photo of the cab.

http://PaulBigland.zenfolio.com/p622123184/e54b413

Classic DB cab layout. I assume the AWS reset (needed at least on the approach to St Pancras) is the yellow button at the bottom right. The German PZB is the bank of switches directly ahead and I assume the TVM430 would be on one of the screens.

There's also the LZB lever - basically speed control and a form of ATO for German high speed lines.

They don't have AWS. ECTS is going to be fitted to Ashford for them to call. St Pancras uses the SNCF KVB system.
 

MCR247

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2008
Messages
9,965
It's a real shame if they retired the NoL Eurostars.

If Keolis / Eurostar won the East Coast franchise it would be nice if they could use these sets to run trains from maybe Leeds or York and try test services to Paris, in a similar fashion to the London to South of France service in 2013. I'm pretty sure there is a connecting line from the East Coast mainline that can take the train into St Pancras and pick up passengers from London to fill any remaining capacity.

Of course they would need to sort out border controls at Leeds station for example but I'm sure they could be flexable with platform 1 up there. Fence it and secure it off when the Eurostar train sparked there. Once it has left for Paris, they can open up the platform for the usual local trains.

Anyway....scrapping these eurostars is such a waste.

Yes, that will definitely happen :lol:
 

jon0844

Veteran Member
Joined
1 Feb 2009
Messages
29,476
Location
UK
I can see the UK Border Agency being well up for a platform that is secure one minute and open the next. Thus forcing a thorough search before the platform re-opens (or closes) for those that might just decide to hide somewhere.
 

33Hz

Member
Joined
2 Dec 2010
Messages
513
Just a thought but I wonder if Eurostar has been sneaky and ordered shorter or splitable trains with this follow on order of 7? Play DB at their own game for the markets where a long set isn't justified.

As for the NoL sets, I've mentioned it before but there are several new French markets where a class 373 could go opening up. If Eurostar doesn't want them, it's in our interests to force them to be made available to someone who does. As UK gov is still a shareholder for the time being, it should be forcing the issue.
 

starrymarkb

Established Member
Joined
4 Aug 2009
Messages
5,985
Location
Exeter
I can see the UK Border Agency being well up for a platform that is secure one minute and open the next. Thus forcing a thorough search before the platform re-opens (or closes) for those that might just decide to hide somewhere.

That happens at Lille for every UK bound E* - The Westbound platform island has a glass divider with several automatic doors in it. When one isn't due the whole island is open for SNCF services. About 20 mins prior to departure the doors in the divider close, the platform for E* is checked and then E* passengers are let out of the holding pen.
 
Last edited:
Joined
9 Jul 2011
Messages
800
If ES and partners should be successful with the East Coast franchise they may be able to supplement the current fleet with Nols........

There is just no need to do that. A brand new fleet of trains is already on the way for the ECML.



--- old post above --- --- new post below ---
...If Keolis / Eurostar won the East Coast franchise it would be nice if they could use these sets to run trains from maybe Leeds or York and try test services to Paris, in a similar fashion to the London to South of France service in 2013.
I'm pretty sure there is a connecting line from the East Coast mainline that can take the train into St Pancras and pick up passengers from London to fill any remaining capacity......

Disregarding all the other factors working against that idea (border control, security, line capacity, train paths, OHLE issues, expensive infrastructure changes etc, etc), there is the crucial issue of viability.

With your suggestion, they would have to run the trains at least half empty to make a call at SPI worthwhile. As the market from Leeds would be quite small and the bulk of the demand is from London, they might have to reserve more than two thirds of the train for passengers boarding at SPI. Therefore the trains would run between Leeds and London with less than a third of the seats occupied.
There is no way that sort of operation would be viable.
Even at two thirds full it wouldn't be economically viable and then the call at SPI would also not be viable. It's a lose lose situation.

Ah! some will say; allow the carriage of domestic passengers on the Leeds - London leg.
OK, so all the international travellers disembark at SPI for border and security clearance?
What's the difference then , between that and the current operation, where there are frequent trains all day between Leeds and London and passengers can connect with frequent Eurostar services at the KX/SPI interchange.
In other words, the Leeds - Paris market, whatever it amounts to, is more than adequately served today, by frequent connecting services, all day, 7 days a week.

Considering the question of the existence of a sufficiently large market to justify running dedicated Leeds (or any other regional city) to Paris services.
All indications are that the market is not there for such services.
Even if you ran one train a day, that would be of little use to business travellers, where frequency and flexibility of travel are paramount. Without business travellers paying the premium fares, any prospect of a service is dead before it starts.

The air market for Leeds - Paris has struggled to support airline services between the two cities.
In years gone by, BMA stopped flying the route for a number of years, before restarting it under their later BMI guise. BMI Regional (as was) used 50 seat regional jets. They eventually pulled out.
In recent years and currently, low cost carrier Jet2 fly the Leeds - Paris route, but can only get enough passengers to run a single flight, four days a week. Not even a daily service, let alone two or more a day.
Four flights a week doesn't even fill one NoL train !!!!

Eurostar are a purely commercial company. If they see potential they will look at the opportunities with great interest, as is the case with their current expansion proposals. They have no plans for UK regional services at the present time.




--- old post above --- --- new post below ---
Just a thought but I wonder if Eurostar has been sneaky and ordered shorter or splitable trains with this follow on order of 7?
Play DB at their own game for the markets where a long set isn't justified.

The extra 7 trains are the same as the first 10.
Regards the DB example, do you mean their general use of joining and splitting, or that which was proposed for their now stalled plans to operate to London?
After putting the proposed start date back twice they've kicked London services into the long grass for now, with no start date in prospect and a likelihood it won't be until the end of this decade, if ever.


.... If Eurostar doesn't want them, it's in our interests to force them to be made available to someone who does.

Our interests?
Why? Although now privately owned assets, they will have virtually no asset value.
Who owns them anyway?
Were they transferred to the new Eurostar company, with the 28 Three Capitals sets, back in 2010, or did they remain in LCR ownership?

...As UK gov is still a shareholder for the time being, it should be forcing the issue.

Although the UK government is currently a 40% shareholder in the stand alone Eurostar company, they are putting their shareholding up for sale. I doubt they have much interest in a small fleet of old trains, that have little or no capital value.


 

33Hz

Member
Joined
2 Dec 2010
Messages
513
You say they have no capital value, yet these are trains that have, in their 20 year lifetimes, not worked for 8 years and been lightly used for 5. Even if you assume a normal 30 year life for HS stock, they clearly have half a lifetime left. They are the only 300 km/h stock that is UK compatible and as I said, they can service new destinations on each side of the channel that do not or cannot take 374s. Thus they have inherent value to the UK traveling public that I think the French management don't appreciate. I'd like to see UK gov step in and at least make them available to an open access operator.
 
Joined
9 Jul 2011
Messages
800
You say they have no capital value, yet these are trains that have, in their 20 year lifetimes, not worked for 8 years and been lightly used for 5.

It doesn't matter how much use they've had, they are 20 year old trains, who's capital costs have been written off.
They have very little inherent book value and therefore would appear purely as a liability on any set of accounts.

If they cannot be sold, they have zero value, unless they could be used to generate enough income to cover their refurbishment costs (which will be a large amount of money), their ongoing operating costs and maintenance overhead. On top of that they would then have to generate a profit to make the exercise worthwhile.
At the present time, there is almost no prospect of them being put to work anywhere that will satisfy those needs and requirements; unless there's a cunning plan that's being kept under wraps?


Even if you assume a normal 30 year life for HS stock, they clearly have half a lifetime left.

Don't get hung up on the myths about the supposed life expectancy of railway rolling stock.
The useful and economic lifetime of any rolling stock could in theory be anything from 30 years to 3 years. The timescale doesn't matter as long as the rational for ordering the stock is realised and the economic case is satisfied.
They are only tools of the trade at the end of the day and in that sense, not much different than any other tools of the trade the company employs, whether it be trains, vans, office accommodation, desk furniture, pens and stationary.

It so happens that as expensive commodities, the economic reality for HS trains is a 25 to 30 year lifespan, but in the case of the NoL trains, the original financial case was blown out of the water at the beginning.

In financial terms, their current expected future lifespan is zero, unless a case can be made to put them to work. If that were to happen, their expected lifespan would only last as long as it was practically and financially viable.

Setting aside the practical financial realities; in terms of their physical usefulness, they would require a lot of money spending on them to bring them up-to-date in order to obtain another 10 or 15 years of useful operation. So that unavoidably leads straight back to the financial reality of trying to make such a plan work.

....they have inherent value to the UK traveling public

Says who?

I'd like to see UK gov step in and at least make them available to an open access operator.

Like the long line of prospective companies, just lining up for the opportunity? Mmmmmm?????


 

MCR247

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2008
Messages
9,965
People need to accept that the only way we'd see Brum/Manchester/wherever getting through trains to Paris would be if no passport checks or luggage screening was required and so the train was essentially a Birmingham - London train that happens to continue to Paris. The chances of that happening though...
 

Noddy

Established Member
Joined
11 Oct 2014
Messages
1,208
Location
UK
People need to accept that the only way we'd see Brum/Manchester/wherever getting through trains to Paris would be if no passport checks or luggage screening was required and so the train was essentially a Birmingham - London train that happens to continue to Paris. The chances of that happening though...

Time to join schengen area then, and also get access to the full schengen database to help reduce international crime.
 

jopsuk

Veteran Member
Joined
13 May 2008
Messages
12,773
I'd love the UK (and Ireland) to join Schengen. But although the % of the populace that want out of the EU completely is dropping (despite the popularity of a certain party), politically at the moment there's very little chance of us doing so.
 

Jordeh

Member
Joined
18 Aug 2010
Messages
372
Location
London
I understand that the drivers and crew need to be familiarised with them and there will no doubt be stringent testing in the Channel Tunnel as well as on the high speed lines but December 2015 still seems a heck of a long time for them to come into service?
 

cjmillsnun

Established Member
Joined
13 Feb 2011
Messages
3,274
Time to join schengen area then, and also get access to the full schengen database to help reduce international crime.

That won't happen. This country is getting increasingly Euro Sceptic sadly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top