• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Northern Pacer Withdrawals - Info?

Status
Not open for further replies.

IamTrainsYT

Member
Joined
8 Dec 2018
Messages
1,073
Location
Glossop
Also this week especially the last couple of days on Thursday 18th November 2020 and Friday 19th November 2020 have seen at least two 142 diagrams with the 142 no longer on it, especially on Kirkby/New Mills Central workings and the peak am Manchester Victoria to Wigan diagram on both days

Maybe a chance that the northern 142s are now being stored awaiting withdrawal.
One Kirkby set was lost yesterday due to the 150 it was with failing, and there was indeed a New Mills pacer all day yesterday.

However today, there was no all day New Mills 142. (2S22 is usually packed as a 4 car. even in lockdown!)

I've also noticed recently they’ve dropped the 142 off the AM Stalybridge diagram
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Killingworth

Established Member
Joined
30 May 2018
Messages
4,927
Location
Sheffield
At least one Chester via Altrincham diagram still involves Pacers as of this week.

Why can't the 08:08 Piccadilly to Chester have Pacer on it? It's only booked 2-car which is hopeless for social distancing. The 13:49 Piccadilly to Sheffield needs it if anything even more desperately given that there is neither a fast TPE nor a fast EMR between 12:44 and 14:18.
The 13.49 Piccadilly-Sheffield is a 2 car 195. I don't know what it's like other days but on the return service out of Sheffield on Monday more than half the rear coach was taped out of use and passengers were directed to the front coach - where the front third was also taped off. The guard didn't patrol the train. Seeing a 195 at the platform I thought there'd be enough distancing space, and there was, but it was more crowded than it needed to be. Using a Pacer would require deploying a 150 as well. It's currently a 150, 195/0 and 195/1 combination on Hope Valley at present.
 

warwickshire

On Moderation
Joined
6 Feb 2020
Messages
1,916
Location
leamingtonspa
At least one Chester via Altrincham diagram still involves Pacers as of this week.

Why can't the 08:08 Piccadilly to Chester have Pacer on it? It's only booked 2-car which is hopeless for social distancing. The 13:49 Piccadilly to Sheffield needs it if anything even more desperately given that there is neither a fast TPE nor a fast EMR between 12:44 and 14:18.
The 0808 Piccadilly service to Chester beforehand comes in from Buxton and 142 are banned to Buxton. Timetable should have been thought out a lot better beforehand say for example using the 0556 Chester to Manchester Piccadilly 142/150 combination instead off sending to newton Heath T.M.D until its next booked working at around 2300 pm. However what Northern should seriously do now is at least to March 2021, when the 769 start is to retain at least some 142s especially again for the Chester to Manchester Piccadilly lines and Kirkby lines.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

IamTrainsYT

Member
Joined
8 Dec 2018
Messages
1,073
Location
Glossop
The 13.49 Piccadilly-Sheffield is a 2 car 195. I don't know what it's like other days but on the return service out of Sheffield on Monday more than half the rear coach was taped out of use and passengers were directed to the front coach - where the front third was also taped off. The guard didn't patrol the train. Seeing a 195 at the platform I thought there'd be enough distancing space, and there was, but it was more crowded than it needed to be. Using a Pacer would require deploying a 150 as well. It's currently a 150, 195/0 and 195/1 combination on Hope Valley at present.
Was on that train, ridiculous that one guard gets half a train.. but the paying passengers have to be crowded into one half. I’ve been getting that a lot recently, but luckily it was only crowded that one day.

I’ve observed several short formations on the hope valley recently:
3 car 195 - 2 car 150
4 car 150 - 2 car 150
And probably one of the worst ones, as I use this on a regular basis (and it’s usually full with people standing as a 4 car). is service 2S22 MAN-NMC, which was swapped from a 142 + 150 to a solo 150.
 

northernchris

Established Member
Joined
24 Jul 2011
Messages
1,509
The 0808 Piccadilly service to Chester beforehand comes in from Buxton and 142 are banned to Buxton. Timetable should have been thought out a lot better beforehand say for example using the 0556 Chester to Manchester Piccadilly 142/150 combination instead off sending to newton Heath T.M.D until its next booked working at around 2300 pm. However what Northern should seriously do now is at least to March 2021, when the 769 start is to retain at least some 142s especially again for the Chester to Manchester Piccadilly lines and Kirkby lines.

If the 142s aren't retained the unit shortages will only worsen, especially if the Wigan - Blackburn service is restored in December
 

irish_rail

Established Member
Joined
30 Oct 2013
Messages
3,921
Location
Plymouth
If the 142s aren't retained the unit shortages will only worsen, especially if the Wigan - Blackburn service is restored in December
It does seem crazy that people will be forced to put their health at risk all in order to fulfill DDA compliance. I cant help but feel DDa should not be a priority until this pandemic is over.
 

AMD

Member
Joined
6 Dec 2017
Messages
610
If the 142s aren't retained the unit shortages will only worsen, especially if the Wigan - Blackburn service is restored in December
It should be noted that the unit refurbishment programme is starting to wind down, 195 utilisation isn't really high and there's a lot of strengthened formations running about; so the loss of half a dozen 142s isn't going to make a difference.
 

AMD

Member
Joined
6 Dec 2017
Messages
610
Anyone else notice the disastrous impact the withdrawal of about 70 pacers has caused so far...?
 

northernchris

Established Member
Joined
24 Jul 2011
Messages
1,509
It does seem crazy that people will be forced to put their health at risk all in order to fulfill DDA compliance. I cant help but feel DDa should not be a priority until this pandemic is over.
I would also agree with this so long as they continue to only work with a compliant unit
It should be noted that the unit refurbishment programme is starting to wind down, 195 utilisation isn't really high and there's a lot of strengthened formations running about; so the loss of half a dozen 142s isn't going to make a difference.
Less units away for refurb will help, unless they then go away for Wifi and USB installation. Retaining the few 142s would provide some contingency especially with the delays to the 769s entering service
 

IanXC

Emeritus Moderator
Joined
18 Dec 2009
Messages
6,343
Was on that train, ridiculous that one guard gets half a train.. but the paying passengers have to be crowded into one half. I’ve been getting that a lot recently, but luckily it was only crowded that one day.

I’ve observed several short formations on the hope valley recently:
3 car 195 - 2 car 150
4 car 150 - 2 car 150
And probably one of the worst ones, as I use this on a regular basis (and it’s usually full with people standing as a 4 car). is service 2S22 MAN-NMC, which was swapped from a 142 + 150 to a solo 150.

Remember that during the disruption caused by the derailment at Sheffield, the Hope Valley services have been limited to platform 2c and hence 2 cars.
 

Killingworth

Established Member
Joined
30 May 2018
Messages
4,927
Location
Sheffield
Remember that during the disruption caused by the derailment at Sheffield, the Hope Valley services have been limited to platform 2c and hence 2 cars.
We're straying from Pacers but lthe last return service to operate on the Hope Valley last night seems to have been a 5 car 195/0 and 195/1 combination. It's a long time since stations in the valley will have seen that length of train stop. Another train had been cancelled so stock postioning may have been needed.
 

HST43257

Established Member
Joined
10 Apr 2020
Messages
1,456
Location
York
Apologies if I’ve missed anything, but has the final day of operation for Northern pacers been confirmed as of yet?
 

Jamesrob637

Established Member
Joined
12 Aug 2016
Messages
5,283
Apologies if I’ve missed anything, but has the final day of operation for Northern pacers been confirmed as of yet?

I don't think it would be a good idea to announce it yet. Pacer could receive a stay of execution into 2021, and many of us here hope it will, even if only for reasons of capacity.
 

adc82140

Established Member
Joined
10 May 2008
Messages
2,938
Genuine question: Given that over the last year or so Northern have gained the entire 195 fleet, the 331s, the 170s and a handful of 158s and 156s, how can it be that they are desperately short of capacity and need to hold on to the Pacers? Aside from the 142s and 144s, the only other stock to leave the franchise has been a small amount of 319s. As far as I'm aware the only stock they are still awaiting is the 769s.
 

Geeves

Established Member
Joined
6 Jan 2009
Messages
1,951
Location
Rochdale
From an inside perspective I can say Northern have actually been struggling to find places to store the sheer number of trains it now has. A lot of the short forms recently have been because of staff shortages with regards to moving stock around to the correct depots. The 769s coming into service will free up the last units needed to cover the 142s.
 

Jamesrob637

Established Member
Joined
12 Aug 2016
Messages
5,283
Got denied travel on 142078 today - a very short journey for exercise purposes - not happy! Guard wasn't rude about it or anything, he just sent everybody (all 3 of us boarding!) into the leading 150.
 

Robertj21a

On Moderation
Joined
22 Sep 2013
Messages
7,525
It does seem crazy that people will be forced to put their health at risk all in order to fulfill DDA compliance. I cant help but feel DDa should not be a priority until this pandemic is over.
DDA has been delayed far too long already.
 

TheSel

Member
Joined
10 Oct 2017
Messages
867
Location
Southport, Merseyside
Got denied travel on 142078 today - a very short journey for exercise purposes - not happy! Guard wasn't rude about it or anything, he just sent everybody (all 3 of us boarding!) into the leading 150.
That's a shame. Have this as a consolation prize - photographed at Rainford yesterday on the 1435 Kirkby - Manchester Victoria.

55728 - 142078 - Rainford (final).jpg
 

sprinterguy

Established Member
Joined
4 Mar 2010
Messages
11,071
Location
Macclesfield
Genuine question: Given that over the last year or so Northern have gained the entire 195 fleet, the 331s, the 170s and a handful of 158s and 156s, how can it be that they are desperately short of capacity and need to hold on to the Pacers? Aside from the 142s and 144s, the only other stock to leave the franchise has been a small amount of 319s. As far as I'm aware the only stock they are still awaiting is the 769s.
The 331s didn't do a great deal for Pacer replacement, as they're all operating on lines that were already electrified (Albeit quite recently in the case of Manchester - Preston).

As such, 102 Pacers comprising 214 carriages, formed of 79 class 142s (158 carriages) and 23 class 144s (56 carriages) have so far been replaced by:

5 x 2-car Class 156 (10 carriages)
8 x 2-car Class 158 (16 carriages)
16 x Class 170 (48 carriages)
25 x 2-car Class 195 (50 carriages)
33 x 3-car Class 195 (99 carriages, final unit only just delivered)

Which gives a total of 91 units, representing 223 carriages. Electrification of Manchester - Preston a couple of years ago will have taken pressure off the Pacer fleet as well.
 
Last edited:

bengley

Established Member
Joined
18 May 2008
Messages
1,845
Got denied travel on 142078 today - a very short journey for exercise purposes - not happy! Guard wasn't rude about it or anything, he just sent everybody (all 3 of us boarding!) into the leading 150.
Make a complaint if this happens again.

Because of social distancing requirements, Northern guards have been instructed not to lock out units unnecessarily - they should only be locked out if there's a fault, or if required for short platforms. For example a Manchester Victoria to Kirkby service should be fully unlocked until Wigan Wallgate, then after there passengers should be on the front unit only.
 

Jamesrob637

Established Member
Joined
12 Aug 2016
Messages
5,283
That's a shame. Have this as a consolation prize - photographed at Rainford yesterday on the 1435 Kirkby - Manchester Victoria.

View attachment 86316

Thanks, the return of mine from Upholland to Rainford! If you live in Rainford you're lucky - looks a very nice small town.

Make a complaint if this happens again.

Because of social distancing requirements, Northern guards have been instructed not to lock out units unnecessarily - they should only be locked out if there's a fault, or if required for short platforms. For example a Manchester Victoria to Kirkby service should be fully unlocked until Wigan Wallgate, then after there passengers should be on the front unit only.

Ah so it's effectively 2-car west of Wigan - that explains things thank you!
 

Greybeard33

Established Member
Joined
18 Feb 2012
Messages
4,303
Location
Greater Manchester
As such, 102 Pacers comprising 214 carriages, formed of 79 class 142s (158 carriages) and 23 class 144s (56 carriages) have so far been replaced by:

5 x 2-car Class 156 (10 carriages)
8 x 2-car Class 158 (16 carriages)
16 x Class 170 (48 carriages)
25 x 2-car Class 195 (50 carriages)
33 x 3-car Class 195 (99 carriages, final unit only just delivered)

Which gives a total of 91 units, representing 223 carriages. Electrification of Manchester - Preston a couple of years ago will have taken pressure off the Pacer fleet as well.
And those 223 replacement carriages are all 23m long, giving a total length of 223*23=5130m. The 214 Pacer carriages were only 16m, so their total length was 214*16=3420m. Arguably a 50% increase in capacity!

Still to enter service are the eight 769s, each comprising 4*20m carriages. That makes a further 32*20=640m, which will increase the total length of replacement diesel trains to 169% of that of the Pacer fleet.

The 150s that have been cascaded in from the Midlands and GW are not included in this calculation. On the other hand, the 153s are presumably still going to leave at some point.
 

bengley

Established Member
Joined
18 May 2008
Messages
1,845
Thanks, the return of mine from Upholland to Rainford! If you live in Rainford you're lucky - looks a very nice small town.



Ah so it's effectively 2-car west of Wigan - that explains things thank you!
Yes so in this case the guard was right to have the unit locked out. If this happens East of Wigan it's usually not allowed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top