• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

BML closed between Gatwick Airport and East Croydon (various routes) on 12 January

girothedog

Member
Joined
31 Jul 2013
Messages
18
As usual, the diversions via Horsham will stop additionally (for staffing reasons) at Epsom and Horsham, according to RTT. In the past they have let passengers on and off, too.
Thanks. Explains why I can’t see any trains to Horsham on Sunday evening using the National Rail journey planner. Madness. RTT shows the 21:05 off Victoria is booked 6 minutes at Horsham to change direction yet people will end up making a convoluted journey by bus or not travelling at all.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

Fincra5

Established Member
Joined
6 Jun 2009
Messages
2,586
Network Rail are far better at explaining things to the public even though it isn't their job
I disagree, engineering work is NR job... and therefore their Job to explain. Not the TOC.
 

Somewhere

On Moderation
Joined
14 Oct 2023
Messages
908
Location
UK
I disagree, engineering work is NR job... and therefore their Job to explain. Not the TOC.
It's the job of the TOC to communicate with the public. Has been since privatisation. However, NWR are better at it, as and when they do it, than the TOC are
 

Hophead

Established Member
Joined
5 Apr 2013
Messages
1,288
I see from Realtimetrains that, once again, the Brighton / Gatwick Thameslink service is listed as 2 separate trains, splitting at Three Bridges (9Zxx head codes north thereof, 9Sxx to the south); the train simply pauses for three minutes on platform 3 before continuing on its way. That'll be fun for the staff, just as it was last year.
 
Joined
3 Nov 2023
Messages
66
Location
ARUNDEL
Many locals know the Horsham - Dorking route has been badly treated

It's seems to be becoming Southern's equivalent of GW's Greenford - West Ealing
 

najaB

Veteran Member
Joined
28 Aug 2011
Messages
32,291
Location
Scotland
Publicity on station and via information to stakeholders and their email list would have been very useful for example. Rather than just announcing it publicly 5 days before it happens. Ensuring the message gets across is important.
This is well into "damned if you do, damned if you don't" territory.

Publicise it well in advance: "People treat this as a 'turn up and go' service, nobody cares/will remember about work in [suitably long time period]".

Publicise it a week in advance: "Why didn't they make people aware earlier, now people are going to miss [important thing]!"

Publicise it early and late: "Why are you constantly bombarding people with so many notices and information?"
 

75A

Established Member
Joined
31 Mar 2021
Messages
1,774
Location
Ireland (ex Brighton 75A)
This is well into "damned if you do, damned if you don't" territory.

Publicise it well in advance: "People treat this as a 'turn up and go' service, nobody cares/will remember about work in [suitably long time period]".

Publicise it a week in advance: "Why didn't they make people aware earlier, now people are going to miss [important thing]!"

Publicise it early and late: "Why are you constantly bombarding people with so many notices and information?"
That's what it's like dealing with the public.
 

Jan Mayen

Member
Joined
30 Sep 2020
Messages
941
Location
Sussex
The bit of the Brighton line I use is four tracks from Three Bridges (Balcombe Tunnel Junction) to London Victoria. Therefore, for 364 days of the year, there really isn't a need to look at engineering work as it'll either refer to something south of Three Bridges, or that either the Quarry Line (avoiding Redhill) or the route via Redhill is shut perhaps reducing the service rather than shutting it completely.
However, now that I know there is an annual one day shut down, I'll look out for it in future. Any one know when next year's will be?
Also, anyone know why a Horsham to Dorking shuttle can't be put on? Arun Valley users might prefer to go that way.
 

Bikeman78

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2018
Messages
5,427
The Redhill / Quarry lines and branches to Reigate / Tonbridge / Caterham / Tattenham Corner will close for engineering works on Sunday, so no Gatwick Express service.

London passengers will have the choice of a Southern 2tph Victoria-Gatwick service via Epsom and Horsham (calling at Clapham Junction only) or Southern 3tph London Bridge-East Grinstead service with separate rail replacement connections to Gatwick or Three Bridges. Rail replacement services will be provided at the intermediate / branch stations (save for the Caterham branch, where bus route 407 will accept paper tickets).

More details below, including arrangements for other routes.
Some of the schedules are strange. There is a Thameslink from Brighton to Three Bridges which then goes on to form a separate train to Gatwick three minutes later, e.g. 9S22 forms 9Z22.

What formation are the diverted Victoria to Gatwick trains likely to be? Last time they were 12 cars. The stops at Horsham are not shown as public stops but they have released the doors on previous occasions. Why do they do this? The alternative route to Victoria from Horsham southwards requires three changes at Three Bridges, East Grinstead and East Croydon. The up Arun valley trains connect perfectly at Horsham with the diverted Gatwick trains but that is not an option on journey planners.
 
Joined
3 Nov 2023
Messages
66
Location
ARUNDEL
There has long been a view locally, that Southern would prefer the Horsham - Dorking route (ONCE the fast route to Portsmouth) not to exist.
 
Joined
31 Dec 2019
Messages
995
Location
uk
Some of the schedules are strange. There is a Thameslink from Brighton to Three Bridges which then goes on to form a separate train to Gatwick three minutes later, e.g. 9S22 forms 9Z22.
see post 36; this is not new to this closure and is almost certainly to nudge people into using the buses to EGR instead of using the GTW - VIC train
 

Bikeman78

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2018
Messages
5,427
I see from Realtimetrains that, once again, the Brighton / Gatwick Thameslink service is listed as 2 separate trains, splitting at Three Bridges (9Zxx head codes north thereof, 9Sxx to the south); the train simply pauses for three minutes on platform 3 before continuing on its way. That'll be fun for the staff, just as it was last year.
The more I look in to this, tge more bizarre it gets. I did a journey enquiry on National Rail fron Brighton to Gatwick. It says change at Three Bridges with a 33 minute wait, even though the unit runs through. The Bognor to Gatwick and Horsham to Gatwick are both set down only at Three Bridges. So they cannot be used as connections off the terminating trains fron Brighton, Eastbourne and Littlehampton.

see post 36; this is not new to this closure and is almost certainly to nudge people into using the buses to EGR instead of using the GTW - VIC train
Why? I thought it was difficult to get enough buses so wouldn't they prefer people to travel on diverted trains? There have been tines when they ran Brighton-Gatwick-Horsham-Victoria, with a stop at Three Bridges. I don't recall them being severely overcrowded.
 

Somewhere

On Moderation
Joined
14 Oct 2023
Messages
908
Location
UK
The more I look in to this, tge more bizarre it gets. I did a journey enquiry on National Rail fron Brighton to Gatwick. It says change at Three Bridges with a 33 minute wait, even though the unit runs through. The Bognor to Gatwick and Horsham to Gatwick are both set down only at Three Bridges. So they cannot be used as connections off the terminating trains fron Brighton, Eastbourne and Littlehampton.


Why? I thought it was difficult to get enough buses so wouldn't they prefer people to travel on diverted trains? There have been tines when they ran Brighton-Gatwick-Horsham-Victoria, with a stop at Three Bridges. I don't recall them being severely overcrowded.
I expect nothing has been explained to staff, so no doubt they will all be as baffled as you

Some of the schedules are strange. There is a Thameslink from Brighton to Three Bridges which then goes on to form a separate train to Gatwick three minutes later, e.g. 9S22 forms 9Z22.

What formation are the diverted Victoria to Gatwick trains likely to be? Last time they were 12 cars. The stops at Horsham are not shown as public stops but they have released the doors on previous occasions. Why do they do this? The alternative route to Victoria from Horsham southwards requires three changes at Three Bridges, East Grinstead and East Croydon. The up Arun valley trains connect perfectly at Horsham with the diverted Gatwick trains but that is not an option on journey planners.
Because the drivers are not given any instructions about what they should or shouldn't do, so therefore, being none the wiser, just treat them as normal station stops.
What goes on in the minds of planners is not communicated to staff on duty on the day.
 

PGAT

Established Member
Joined
13 Apr 2022
Messages
1,811
Location
Selhurst
I expect nothing has been explained to staff, so no doubt they will all be as baffled as you


Because the drivers are not given any instructions about what they should or shouldn't do, so therefore, being none the wiser, just treat them as normal station stops.
What goes on in the minds of planners is not communicated to staff on duty on the day.
To me what's more baffling is that Horsham isn't an advertised stop this time, I could've sworn it always was in previous diversions
 

Bikeman78

Established Member
Joined
26 Apr 2018
Messages
5,427
see post 36; this is not new to this closure and is almost certainly to nudge people into using the buses to EGR instead of using the GTW - VIC train
Having looked at this again, the Thameslink arrives at Gatwick one minute before the Victoria train departs. That isn't a connection so journey planners would show the bus via East Grinstead. Maybe it's to force people to use the bus from Three Bridges rather than Gatwick. I'm also loving the proposed four minute Interchange onto the bus at Three Bridges.

They'll be rammed
If you say so. I've used them before. Results vary. As mentioned above, Horsham has been advertised on previous diversions. It seemed to work fine.

To me what's more baffling is that Horsham isn't an advertised stop this time, I could've sworn it always was in previous diversions
I've definitely seen them advertised on the PIS at Horsham and boarded there.
 

MCR247

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2008
Messages
9,955
Personally, I think the fact they run direct trains as well as buses is very customer centric for the Airport passengers as they understandably might be put off by buses.

I expect it’d be easier and cheaper for them not to bother, and this is the response they get :lol:

But when there was a tree down at Oxted in the bad wind the other week, you’d have thought southern just couldn’t be bothered to do anything above the bare minimum and should be running and turning trains either side of the blockage!

Why? I thought it was difficult to get enough buses so wouldn't they prefer people to travel on diverted trains? There have been tines when they ran Brighton-Gatwick-Horsham-Victoria, with a stop at Three Bridges. I don't recall them being severely overcrowded.
Southern bussing to East Grinstead has been happening yearly and it is a very sick operation. There’s usually buses parked waiting for passengers and as soon as they’re full they leave, and there are empty 12 car 377s waiting to ship passengers off to London. I expect if every RRB operation was as slick as this RRBs would have a much better reputation.

There has long been a view locally, that Southern would prefer the Horsham - Dorking route (ONCE the fast route to Portsmouth) not to exist.
Yes I think Southern managers have a grudge against this route and they get a bonus everytime there’s no service on the route… or they’re trying to provide for the majority, and that means disadvantaging a minority?
 

Jan Mayen

Member
Joined
30 Sep 2020
Messages
941
Location
Sussex
On Sunday, there will be two trains per hour Horsham to Dorking. Could the infrastructure support more?
 

Somewhere

On Moderation
Joined
14 Oct 2023
Messages
908
Location
UK
Personally, I think the fact they run direct trains as well as buses is very customer centric for the Airport passengers as they understandably might be put off by buses.

I expect it’d be easier and cheaper for them not to bother, and this is the response they get :lol:

But when there was a tree down at Oxted in the bad wind the other week, you’d have thought southern just couldn’t be bothered to do anything above the bare minimum and should be running and turning trains either side of the blockage!



Southern bussing to East Grinstead has been happening yearly and it is a very sick operation. There’s usually buses parked waiting for passengers and as soon as they’re full they leave, and there are empty 12 car 377s waiting to ship passengers off to London. I expect if every RRB operation was as slick as this RRBs would have a much better reputation.


Yes I think Southern managers have a grudge against this route and they get a bonus everytime there’s no service on the route… or they’re trying to provide for the majority, and that means disadvantaging a minority?
There's a massive difference planning something in advance, having crews and buses planned and organised in advance, and an emergency situation without any buses available and no crews available (or anyone to plan them)

On Sunday, there will be two trains per hour Horsham to Dorking. Could the infrastructure support more?
The infrastructure could support far more. But where are the drivers going to come from?
 

Jan Mayen

Member
Joined
30 Sep 2020
Messages
941
Location
Sussex
There's a massive difference planning something in advance, having crews and buses planned and organised in advance, and an emergency situation without any buses available and no crews available (or anyone to plan them)


The infrastructure could support far more. But where are the drivers going to come from?
I have no idea. But for one train an hour, connecting into the SWT service to ClaphamJunctionand London Waterloo, how many would you need?

Or even just extending one Southern train to Horsham per hour?
 

London Trains

Member
Joined
9 Oct 2017
Messages
924
I have no idea. But for one train an hour, connecting into the SWT service to ClaphamJunctionand London Waterloo, how many would you need?

Or even just extending one Southern train to Horsham per hour?
I've always wondered if it would be better and more cost effective to have a half-hourly 3 coach shuttle between Dorking and Horsham, with good connections to the Victoria service at Dorking, particularily as it would only require two units and would save empty 10 coach units being sent along the line?

Just to add, I would have the last train of the night from Victoria to Dorking run through to Horsham (as it does now) as removing that might cause passengers to get stranded at Dorking.
 

MCR247

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2008
Messages
9,955
There's a massive difference planning something in advance, having crews and buses planned and organised in advance, and an emergency situation without any buses available and no crews available (or anyone to plan them)


The infrastructure could support far more. But where are the drivers going to come from?
My post wasn’t clear but I was trying to contrast the responses to Southern going out of their way to keep things running, compared to the disruption the other week where every other post in a thread was “why didn’t they do this? It would’ve been better” or “they could’ve done that”
 

PGAT

Established Member
Joined
13 Apr 2022
Messages
1,811
Location
Selhurst
I've always wondered if it would be better and more cost effective to have a half-hourly 3 coach shuttle between Dorking and Horsham, with good connections to the Victoria service at Dorking, particularily as it would only require two units and would save empty 10 coach units being sent along the line?

Just to add, I would have the last train of the night from Victoria to Dorking run through to Horsham (as it does now) as removing that might cause passengers to get stranded at Dorking.
I don't really see that saving much resources compared to just extending the current services that terminate at Dorking. Bear in mind more services than not run as single 5 car units so there wouldn't be much saving in mileage
 

IrishDave

Member
Joined
30 Jun 2009
Messages
430
Location
Brighton
They are every half hour. I'll have a look at them tomorrow. I don't expect them to be overcrowded.

They'll be rammed
In my experience, assuming they run as 12-car length, the ~6 carriages at the north end of the train (nearest the buffers at Victoria) are often standing room only, even while the ~2 carriages at the very south end of the train are virtually empty (in one case I think I had the carriage to myself). So make sure you walk down to the south end of the train and you should be fine - unfortunately that means a walk at both Victoria and Gatwick!

Some of the schedules are strange. There is a Thameslink from Brighton to Three Bridges which then goes on to form a separate train to Gatwick three minutes later, e.g. 9S22 forms 9Z22.

What formation are the diverted Victoria to Gatwick trains likely to be? Last time they were 12 cars. The stops at Horsham are not shown as public stops but they have released the doors on previous occasions. Why do they do this? The alternative route to Victoria from Horsham southwards requires three changes at Three Bridges, East Grinstead and East Croydon. The up Arun valley trains connect perfectly at Horsham with the diverted Gatwick trains but that is not an option on journey planners.
Last year's diverts were, to put it at its mildest, not the railway's finest hour, and I think they've tried to avoid a repeat by making it harder to use the diverts. The diverts last year had advertised stops at both Three Bridges and Horsham, but were very optimistically timed at just 77 minutes between Victoria and Gatwick, compared to 80 minutes in 2023 and 81 minutes in 2022. And unfortunately in 2024 it all fell apart, with at least one southbound train late in the evening terminating short at Horsham due to late running (caused in part by a passenger taken ill on one of the diverts at Clapham Junction); my journey from Kings Cross to Brighton took four hours (departing about 19:30 and eventually getting home about 23:30).

All the same, I think the better solution would have been to simply add a bit more performance time into the schedules and give them longer turnround times. I can understand pulling the Three Bridges stops, but not advertising the Horsham stops does seem somewhat odd given they have to stop there anyway to reverse. Ordinarily I'd go out and experience the diverts for myself but after last year's experience I'm not in a hurry to do so!

This is the once a year block of all lines at Stoats Nest as it has to be parallel tamped to keep the geometry fit for 70mph crossover speeds as well as ensuring the concrete bearers don't get over stressed across the joints.
I recall the points at Stoats Nest were replaced in a blockade over Christmas 2013 - was that a like-for-like renewal or did that introduce some subtle change to the pointwork that introduced the annual tamping requirement?

Interestingly that blockade at Christmas 2013 was planned to include Victoria-Gatwick trains running via Dorking and Horsham, but there was a landslip at Ockley on Christmas Eve, meaning the diverts had to be scrapped (and the line through Ockley didn't reopen until February 2014).

The similar blockade at Christmas 2015 (which I believe was renewal of the ladder at the London end of Purley station) is the first time I travelled on a diverted Victoria-Gatwick train via Dorking, but I'd be interested to know if they ran previous to that.

Since then there have been diversions via Dorking on the following dates (I do not claim this is a comprehensive list):
  • Sunday 4th March 2018
  • Sunday 27th January 2019
  • Sunday 6th February 2022
  • Sunday 5th February 2023
  • Saturday 20th and Sunday 21st January 2024

The bit of the Brighton line I use is four tracks from Three Bridges (Balcombe Tunnel Junction) to London Victoria. Therefore, for 364 days of the year, there really isn't a need to look at engineering work as it'll either refer to something south of Three Bridges, or that either the Quarry Line (avoiding Redhill) or the route via Redhill is shut perhaps reducing the service rather than shutting it completely.
However, now that I know there is an annual one day shut down, I'll look out for it in future. Any one know when next year's will be?
Also, anyone know why a Horsham to Dorking shuttle can't be put on? Arun Valley users might prefer to go that way.
The Engineering Access Statement for 2026 shows a similar possession with diversions via Dorking on Saturday 10th and Sunday 11th January 2026.

My understanding is that the electrical supply for the third rail between Dorking and Horsham can only support a maximum of 2tph in each direction (at least when they're 12-car in length), so the half-hourly diversions are all that can run. Indeed, when such a possession is required on a Saturday (as happened in 2024), buses replace the normal stopping trains between Dorking and Horsham to enable the diversions to run.
 
Last edited:

Jan Mayen

Member
Joined
30 Sep 2020
Messages
941
Location
Sussex
You should've seen the queues at Gatwick on boxing day
Indeed. I got out at East Croydon and used the stopper via Crystal Palace.

Back to today's diversions. There are about 20 buses and coaches waiting at Three Bridges. There are more vehicles than passengers at the moment
 

Top