If First were losing that much on the X1 (and I’m sure the figures are accurate), how much are they throwing away running out to Shotts? There’s a JMB bus right in front of every First one, so unless they’re getting a decent number of season tickets (doubtful), it must be haemorrhaging cash. Surely a tactical retreat to Bonkle (or wherever they can turn) would make sense. I’m guessing Hamilton-Newmains does well.
Just now there seems to be a bit of co-ordination between the two of them on the current timetables for Shotts but competitive timings from Newmains.
Monday to Friday from Shotts
Early runs JMB are in front and then they get into their respective frequencies.
JMB xx13, xx28, xx43, xx58
First xx20, xx35, xx50, xx05
However when the JMB gets to Newmains the First journeys from West Crindledyke are timed to be there at the exact same time. Both are supposed to be at Newmains at xx40, xx55, xx10, xx25
Monday to Friday from Motherwell
JMB xx26, xx41, xx56, xx11
First xx33, xx48, xx03, xx18 for Shotts and xx25, xx40, xx55 and xx10 for Newmains- its the Newmains runs that are scheduled to run a minute in front of JMB
Saturdays its First every 20 minutes and JMB every half hour.
It also has to be factored in that the First journeys start from Hamilton and its like pulling teeth getting round the one way system in Hamilton and then the faff of getting from there to Motherwell town centre. So getting to Motherwell to be in front of the JMB will be challenging for the Newmains journeys.
I also remember Wishaw used to be really bad for traffic.
At the end of the day the First drivers could have an easier shift if they wanted to hang back ever so slightly and let the JMB drivers get in front to pick up the Concessions. At the end of the day drivers are paid to drive the bus safely and its your licence and livelihood thats on the line and to the vast majority thats more important than breaking a sweat trying to get in front of the green and cream for a few quid that you wont see the benefit of.
I recon considering how long the competition has been going on customers will have their favourites. If they are only travelling with JMB from Shotts to Motherwell they are quids in, but First offer the more comprehensive network and tickets.