That wasn't the Southport argument though. The arguments were 1. We need a direct link to the airport (which is utter rubbish, so when that didn't work they moved onto... ), 2. Commuters need a direct link to the south of Manchester.
Even if 2. is true - which I don't buy, because the number of people changing at Wigan or the Crescent to get on a Picc service is not exactly huge - they've shot themselves in the foot because the via Bolton services they're getting to replace the Calder Valleys are slower, more crowded, and since May have also been less punctual.
As a Wigan - Manchester commuter, it's excellent for me because starting the Leeds in Wigan means it'll be quieter and should be more reliable, and therefore offer a pleasent, and fast, link into Victoria.
ButI still think the Southport campaign stinks of turkeys promoting Christmas.