Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!
Thank you for confirming. That is good to hear. I was not quite sure about this. Good to hear they are guaranteed unlike the OBS on the Southern network.
Does anyone know what method is used on the TFW 769s and what method will be used on the GWR 769s once they finally enter service?
Also has anything been decided yet regarding how the Merseyrail 777s are operated as i am sure it will not be long until they enter service or is the dispute still going on?
Thank you for confirming. That is good to hear. I shall update my list. It will be interesting to see how the GWR ones operate when they finally enter service. I would guess they would operate Guard Open Guard Close just as the Northern Rail and TFW ones all do. But then considering they are replacing the 165s and 166s perhaps they will use Driver Open Guard Close instead.
Thank you for the information. That is shame they are not keeping it Guard Open Guard Close permanently. I suppose they did operate DOO at Thameslink so it is simple to switch to Driver Open Guard Close as all the buttons are already there in the cabs.
I wonder if they will be fitted with SDO on them. Every platform at every station they will serve can fit four coaches with the one exception of Dorking Deepdene where both platforms can only fit three coaches each. If it is local door only at Dorking Deepdene that is going to be chaos as it is such a busy major station.
Thank you for the information. That is shame they are not keeping it Guard Open Guard Close permanently. I suppose they did operate DOO at Thameslink so it is simple to switch to Driver Open Guard Close as all the buttons are already there in the cabs.
I wonder if they will be fitted with SDO on them. Every platform at every station they will serve can fit four coaches with the one exception of Dorking Deepdene where both platforms can only fit three coaches each. If it is local door only at Dorking Deepdene that is going to be chaos as it is such a busy major station.
Pass on that as I don't sign Gatwick ,but if that's the case at Dorking then I'd imagine a local door requirement would be provided like the turbos. I'll ask around next time I'm in the area.
Then there is the odd situation where some of the GWR 165s and 166s journeys between Gatwick Airport and Redhill operate DOO but yet others do have a Guard onboard
I'd really like someone to clear this one up. Redhill and Gatwick are both stations with dispatchers. If it was really DOO then the guard would not go down to Gatwick and back but I watched the dispatch sequence at Redhill (towards Gatwick) the other day and the guard is definitely involved.
I don't recall ever travelling from Redhill to Gatwick on a GWR train without the guard aboard.
Every platform at every station they will serve can fit four coaches with the one exception of Dorking Deepdene where both platforms can only fit three coaches each.
Pass on that as I don't sign Gatwick ,but if that's the case at Dorking then I'd imagine a local door requirement would be provided like the turbos. I'll ask around next time I'm in the area.
Thank you. Another member has pointed out that the platforms have now been extended which i had not realised. Good to hear this so the local door only operation will not be required.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
I'd really like someone to clear this one up. Redhill and Gatwick are both stations with dispatchers. If it was really DOO then the guard would not go down to Gatwick and back but I watched the dispatch sequence at Redhill (towards Gatwick) the other day and the guard is definitely involved.
I don't recall ever travelling from Redhill to Gatwick on a GWR train without the guard aboard.
Platform extensions at Dorking Deepdene mean that both platforms are now 87.8m long, easily enough for a 769 - see Sectional Appendix
If i remember correctly i think it is only the services that are driven by Southern drivers that are DOO with all the services driven by GWR drivers still having a Guard on them. However to make it more confusing not all of the services driven by Southern drivers are DOO as some do still have a Guard onboard. I do not have a full list of which services are DOO but i know the 04:45 Redhill to Gatwick Airport 04:53 is definitely DOO. I think that the return at 05:10 Gatwick Airport to Redhill 05:20 is also DOO. Plus the 00:58 Redhill to Gatwick Airport 01:07 is another one which i think runs DOO. It seems it is mainly the early morning and late evening journeys that seem to run DOO. On most other services there is a Guard who does the doors and despatches the train. Hopefully someone else on this forum may be able to give the full list of DOO journeys.
It will be interesting to see what happens when the 769s come in to use. I wonder if they will be allowed to run in DOO between Gatwick Airport and Redhill on these. The 319s have in the past so i do not see why not.
I never released that Dorking Deepdene had platform extensions done. Thank you for the information. That explains it then. That is good to hear as using the local door only would have been absolute chaos and resulted in very long dwell times.
Therefore I believe the agreement that was reached was that the 80x trains can run DOO, but only with a driver on an ex-TT (or more modern GWR) contract, and only if the service terminates at Oxford - it being deemed the successor to the Turbo service. Whereas if the train runs beyond Oxford, it's deemed an ex-HST service and therefore needs a guard throughout.
Its perhaps also worth mentioning GWR attempted to negotiate a more comprehensive agreement with unions akin to the more recent Greater Anglia DCO deal.
But the Guards are not guaranteed in the Metro area are they? I thought it worked similar to Southern OBS where Guards are suppose to be onboard but the train can still run without Guards to Otford/Sevenoaks/Swanley if it is necessary? Or is it actually guaranteed? So a mainline train can not run at all in the Metro area without a Guard onboard?
Certainly guards are always rostered for entire journeys, you’d never have a situation where a mainline southeastern service would depart a London terminal and meet a guard at, say, Sevenoaks. The theory being that the risk of something going wrong and the train being stranded at Sevenoaks is too high, so it’s simply easier for the guard to remain with the train in and out of London.
Whether there is an agreement in place for mainline trains to operate in the DOO area without a guard during extreme disruption, I don’t know (I’ve certainly never been aware of it happening). Perhaps @ComUtoR or @notadriver could shed some light.
For your second point i should have been more clear. I was referring solely to DOO between Gillingham and Rainham stations. I am aware that Southeastern have always run DOO to Gillingham via Dartford but not on the short one stop section just from Gillingham to Rainham like the Thameslink services do.
I never realised the 139s had level boarding. I suppose it is only two stations and one type of train so that makes sense and is easy to achieve.
If i remember correctly i think that British Rail had a bunch of one coach units similar to the 139s (i think they may have been Pacer trains)? Does anyone know if these ran DOO or if they still had a Guard onboard?
If i remember correctly i think it is only the services that are driven by Southern drivers that are DOO with all the services driven by GWR drivers still having a Guard on them. However to make it more confusing not all of the services driven by Southern drivers are DOO as some do still have a Guard onboard. I do not have a full list of which services are DOO but i know the 04:45 Redhill to Gatwick Airport 04:53 is definitely DOO. I think that the return at 05:10 Gatwick Airport to Redhill 05:20 is also DOO. Plus the 00:58 Redhill to Gatwick Airport 01:07 is another one which i think runs DOO. It seems it is mainly the early morning and late evening journeys that seem to run DOO. On most other services there is a Guard who does the doors and despatches the train. Hopefully someone else on this forum may be able to give the full list of DOO journeys.
It will be interesting to see what happens when the 769s come in to use. I wonder if they will be allowed to run in DOO between Gatwick Airport and Redhill on these. The 319s have in the past so i do not see why not.
Currently all GWR services on the Reading - Gatwick line operate with a guard - including the early morning trips that you mention.
To clear things up a bit; dispatch from Gatwick is by use of the DOO equipment - i.e. the platform staff illuminate the CD/RA and the guard is not involved - however it is not a DOO service! If the train were to come to grief having just departed Gatwick, the guard would be on board and expected to carry out their duties just as they would at any other point on the route. For whatever reason, the agreed method of dispatch from Gatwick is as per DOO services. The same does not apply to Redhill, where GWR services are always dispatched by the guard, in both directions. Hope that helps a bit!
Yes you are right. I forgot about the term DCO instead of DOO for when there is a guaranteed second person on the train. So this is the same system as on the SWR 701s and many AGA routes.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Its perhaps also worth mentioning GWR attempted to negotiate a more comprehensive agreement with unions akin to the more recent Greater Anglia DCO deal.
I thought i remembered hearing something many years ago about GWR wanting the drivers to have full control of the doors and despatch on all routes on the 800 and 802 trains.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Thank you for the information. It must be the prototype one coach pacers i am thinking of.
I just had a look online and it seems that five different one coach pacer trains were built as prototypes:
• 1. LEV1 (now at the National Rail Museum in Shildon)
• 2. LEV2 (now in Connecticut in the USA)
• 3. LEV3 (now in Northern Ireland)
• 4. RB004 (now at the Waverley Route Heritage Association Railway in Scotland)
• 5. RB002 (now in the Republic Of Ireland)
Looking at photos of these they have a very unique design that makes them look like buses. The door seems to be next to driver rather than behind the driver like normal. So this makes me wonder if the intention was that these operate DOO and the train driver also sells tickets to passengers as they board.
I know that these were prototypes but does anyone know how they operated for the short periods when they were actually tested in passenger service? Did they run DOO or with a Guard onboard? Did the train driver sell tickets onboard as passengers boarded?
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Currently all GWR services on the Reading - Gatwick line operate with a guard - including the early morning trips that you mention.
To clear things up a bit; dispatch from Gatwick is by use of the DOO equipment - i.e. the platform staff illuminate the CD/RA and the guard is not involved - however it is not a DOO service! If the train were to come to grief having just departed Gatwick, the guard would be on board and expected to carry out their duties just as they would at any other point on the route. For whatever reason, the agreed method of dispatch from Gatwick is as per DOO services. The same does not apply to Redhill, where GWR services are always dispatched by the guard, in both directions. Hope that helps a bit!
Thank you for clearing this up. Much appreciated. So has it always been like this or has this changed recently? Did some services previously operate between Gatwick Airport and Redhill with no Guard onboard the train at all? I am sure i remember hearing of some trains running without a Guard onboard. Interestingly on the Real Time Trains website it is showing the 04:45 Redhill to Gatwick Airport 04:53 train as a DOO operated service so i am wondering if it was in the past.
Have the GWR services at Gatwick Airport always used CD/RA rather than Guard despatch? Or was it changed from Guard despatch to CD/RA a couple years ago when Southern got rid of Guards and introduced DOO so that just one system is in use at the station?
I remember that Irish Rail also operate a once a day in each direction all stations stopper from Newry to Dublin in the morning and then back from Dublin to Newry in the evening. This is considered to be solely an Irish Rail service rather than an Enterprise service and is operated by 29000 trains. So would i be correct to assume this service has a Guard and uses flags between Dundalk and Newry stations? Or is it allowed to run DOO to and from NI as it only goes one station just over the border?
I never realised that any DOO was allowed to Tonbridge. I always thought Sevenoaks was the limit. When the new Thameslink services to Maidstone finally start (which should have started years ago) will they need a Guard between Otford and Maidstone East stations? Or will DOO be agreed for these trains?
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Thank you for the information. That does make sense. Although it is certainly confusing for passengers who will not have a clue whether or not a Guard is on their train.
If i remember correctly i think the 165s and 166s that run DOO between Gatwick Airport and Redhill are the ones that are driven by Southern drivers where as the ones that are driven by GWR drivers require Guards between these stations.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Thank you for finding out. Much appreciated. That is really interesting to hear. I had always wondered how they did this.
How odd that the Loco Hauled Sets and the 22000 were built with bells but the 29000 were not so have to use flags. There are not many examples of flags still being used nowadays. Do you know how exactly the flags work? For example are there two different colours and one is used to tell the driver to close the doors and another is used to tell the driver to depart? Or do they do it a different way? I would be interested to know as when flags are used here in the UK (such as on the GWR sleeper trains) the Guard still controls the doors?
I remember that Irish Rail also operate a once a day in each direction all stations stopper from Newry to Dublin in the morning and then back from Dublin to Newry in the evening. This is considered to be solely an Irish Rail service rather than an Enterprise service and is operated by 29000 trains. So would i be correct to assume this service has a Guard and uses flags between Dundalk and Newry stations? Or is it allowed to run DOO to and from NI as it only goes one station just over the border?
RE: flags on the Irish rail system, the station work complete handsignal is one arm raised above the head during the day and a white light held steadily above the head during darkness/poor visibility (despatch batons are used generally)
Green flag or green light for when the train is ready to start.
All cross border trains have AWS fitted as well although I believe that's only used once they cross to NI. CAWS is used in the Republic on all units.
With East coast trains rolling out their “train ambassadors” with the lumo brand, I’m aware the drivers will do the doors, but in the event of short notice absence or disruption will the train run DOO or ECS? What training will they be provided with?
Thank you. I was unaware the morning one was a 22000 and the 29000 was only used on the evening one. I shall definitely keep an eye out next time i visit. I will probably visit Northern Ireland later this year so may visit Newry and see how things work.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
RE: flags on the Irish rail system, the station work complete handsignal is one arm raised above the head during the day and a white light held steadily above the head during darkness/poor visibility (despatch batons are used generally)
Green flag or green light for when the train is ready to start.
All cross border trains have AWS fitted as well although I believe that's only used once they cross to NI. CAWS is used in the Republic on all units.
Thank you. That is very helpful to know. Just to confirm are the entire fleets of 22000 and 29000 trains allowed to cross the border and operate on the Northern Ireland services? Or is it only certain units that have been fitted with the necessary equipment?
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
With East coast trains rolling out their “train ambassadors” with the lumo brand, I’m aware the drivers will do the doors, but in the event of short notice absence or disruption will the train run DOO or ECS? What training will they be provided with?
That is what i was wondering too. I have not seen much information saying how this service will operate. But it seems the service will operate DOO. Their website does mention "Onboard Ambassadors" but it is still unclear as to what their roll will be. Maybe someone can confirm.
Will it operate like the OBM on Southeastern 395s where there is a safety critical second member of staff that is 100% guaranteed onboard all trains and the train can not run without one?
Will it operate like the OBS on Southern 377s where there is a non safety critical second member of staff that is not guaranteed and the train can run without one if they are not available?
It will certainly be the longest distance DOO service in the UK. I find it quite interesting how East Coast Trains are going DOO but yet First Hull Trains who introduced their 802s at a very similar time decided to still have Guards onboard who still control the doors. It just surprised me as they are both owned by the same company and both operate very similar stock.
It will certainly be the longest distance DOO service in the UK. I find it quite interesting how East Coast Trains are going DOO but yet First Hull Trains who introduced their 802s at a very similar time decided to still have Guards onboard who still control the doors. It just surprised me as they are both owned by the same company and both operate very similar stock.
It's quite simple - ECTL/Lumo are a brand new company and hence were free to start with a blank sheet and recruit all drivers on DOO terms.
Whereas HT started services 20 years ago, when DOO wasn't really being considered, so they're unlikely to want to touch this hornet's nest when they want to run all services with a guard anyway (for revenue reasons).
It's quite simple - ECTL/Lumo are a brand new company and hence were free to start with a blank sheet and recruit all drivers on DOO terms.
Whereas HT started services 20 years ago, when DOO wasn't really being considered, so they're unlikely to want to touch this hornet's nest when they want to run all services with a guard anyway (for revenue reasons).
Certainly guards are always rostered for entire journeys, you’d never have a situation where a mainline southeastern service would depart a London terminal and meet a guard at, say, Sevenoaks. The theory being that the risk of something going wrong and the train being stranded at Sevenoaks is too high, so it’s simply easier for the guard to remain with the train in and out of London.
Whether there is an agreement in place for mainline trains to operate in the DOO area without a guard during extreme disruption, I don’t know (I’ve certainly never been aware of it happening). Perhaps @ComUtoR or @notadriver could shed some light.
Yes apologies I had misread your previous post, and subsequently qualified my response above.
In times of disruption a mainline service can leave the London terminus without a guard and pick up the guard at Bromley South or Swanley for example. But the drivers must be informed as to what is going on.
Thank you. I was unaware the morning one was a 22000 and the 29000 was only used on the evening one. I shall definitely keep an eye out next time i visit. I will probably visit Northern Ireland later this year so may visit Newry and see how things work.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Thank you. That is very helpful to know. Just to confirm are the entire fleets of 22000 and 29000 trains allowed to cross the border and operate on the Northern Ireland services? Or is it only certain units that have been fitted with the necessary equipment?
Only certain units. Not just because they are custom-fitted with AWS but also because the livery is neutralised so as not to upset a certain political faction!
I also don't believe 29s go over the border now, only ICRs if required to cover the Belfast run. Although I am willing to be corrected. The newry/bray route was put in because a previous CEO lived in Newry but he's long gone and I assume the route has gone with him.
Edit - I see that there is indeed a 6.30am service tomorrow morning. Every day is a school day!
Wikipedia says 22001-22006 and 22036-22039 fitted with TPWS and AWS (although 22001/22002 were at one time specially marshalled to box in the cabs of 22001).
Northern Ireland units 3001-3006 are said to be fitted with CAWS for use on IÉ
There doesn't seem to be anything about 29000 class units being fitted for cross-border operations.
Only certain units. Not just because they are custom-fitted with AWS but also because the livery is neutralised so as not to upset a certain political faction!
Wikipedia says 22001-22006 and 22036-22039 fitted with TPWS and AWS (although 22001/22002 were at one time specially marshalled to box in the cabs of 22001).
Northern Ireland units 3001-3006 are said to be fitted with CAWS for use on IÉ
There doesn't seem to be anything about 29000 class units being fitted for cross-border operations.
Unless the rules have changed, it used to be that non fitted trains could cross the border, but required two drivers to do so. Judging by Bernie Arms' remark about the 29000 class, that appears to still be the case, and that the 29000 class are not fitted.
Only certain units. Not just because they are custom-fitted with AWS but also because the livery is neutralised so as not to upset a certain political faction!
I also don't believe 29s go over the border now, only ICRs if required to cover the Belfast run. Although I am willing to be corrected. The newry/bray route was put in because a previous CEO lived in Newry but he's long gone and I assume the route has gone with him.
Edit - I see that there is indeed a 6.30am service tomorrow morning. Every day is a school day!
In times of disruption a mainline service can leave the London terminus without a guard and pick up the guard at Bromley South or Swanley for example. But the drivers must be informed as to what is going on.
Thank you for confirming this. That is good to know. I thought that may have been the case. I suppose that makes sense as other metro services run DOO without any second member of staff onboard in this area.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Only certain units. Not just because they are custom-fitted with AWS but also because the livery is neutralised so as not to upset a certain political faction!
I also don't believe 29s go over the border now, only ICRs if required to cover the Belfast run. Although I am willing to be corrected. The newry/bray route was put in because a previous CEO lived in Newry but he's long gone and I assume the route has gone with him.
Edit - I see that there is indeed a 6.30am service tomorrow morning. Every day is a school day!
That is interesting to hear. I never realised there were any livery differences. Can i ask what exactly are the livery differences? I have looked at photos online and i can only find one livery for the 22000s (the standard grey with green doors) and two liveries for the 29000s (the older green and blue and white livery and the newer allover green livery) so just wondering what is the livery difference for the cross border units?
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Wikipedia says 22001-22006 and 22036-22039 fitted with TPWS and AWS (although 22001/22002 were at one time specially marshalled to box in the cabs of 22001).
Northern Ireland units 3001-3006 are said to be fitted with CAWS for use on IÉ
There doesn't seem to be anything about 29000 class units being fitted for cross-border operations.
Thank you for the information. That is good to know. Do you know if the 4000 have ever worked on cross border services? I know plenty of 3000 and 22000 and 29000 have but i have never seen any evidence of the 4000 on cross border services so i am guessing that they are not allowed?
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
It always amused me the irony that for many years the Íarnrod Eireann operated trains over the border were bright orange.
Unless the rules have changed, it used to be that non fitted trains could cross the border, but required two drivers to do so. Judging by Bernie Arms' remark about the 29000 class, that appears to still be the case, and that the 29000 class are not fitted.
I have just found two different videos on You Tube of the 29000 trains at Newry and in both these videos there are clearly two drivers in the cab. So that confirms what you have said. So that means any 29000 trains crossing the border must have three staff members (two drivers and one guard) compared to just one staff member needed anywhere on the Republic Of Ireland network.
Would i be correct to presume on 29000 the two drivers are one Irish Rail driver and one Translink driver? I would presume that the Irish Rail driver is the one who actually drives the train?
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Indeed from looking at the timetable both the following services appear to still run:
• 06:30 Newry - Dublin Connolly 08:19
• 17:13 Dublin Pearse - Newry 19:12
Both of them are stopping trains calling at most stations unlike the fast Enterprise services. I am not sure what times the ECS workings are but if anyone knows that would be appreciated. I am surprised they do not just keep a unit in Newry overnight rather than having two ECS working (one in each direction) every day.
Interestingly looking at the current Enterprise timetable around half of the trains are designated as being a "Non Enterprise Train" and as "1ST Class Not Available" in the PDF timetables:
I thought 3000/22000/29000 were only used on rare occasions when the Locomotive Hauled Sets were out of use or unavailable? But it seems this is now a daily regular occurrence? Is this temporary or is this planned to be permanent now? What types are these services booked for?
I thought 3000/22000/29000 were only used on rare occasions when the Locomotive Hauled Sets were out of use or unavailable? But it seems this is now a daily regular occurrence? Is this temporary or is this planned to be permanent now? What types are these services booked for?
That is interesting to hear. I never realised there were any livery differences. Can i ask what exactly are the livery differences? I have looked at photos online and i can only find one livery for the 22000s (the standard grey with green doors) and two liveries for the 29000s (the older green and blue and white livery and the newer allover green livery) so just wondering what is the livery difference for the cross border units?
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Thank you for the information. That is good to know. Do you know if the 4000 have ever worked on cross border services? I know plenty of 3000 and 22000 and 29000 have but i have never seen any evidence of the 4000 on cross border services so i am guessing that they are not allowed?
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
I have just found two different videos on You Tube of the 29000 trains at Newry and in both these videos there are clearly two drivers in the cab. So that confirms what you have said. So that means any 29000 trains crossing the border must have three staff members (two drivers and one guard) compared to just one staff member needed anywhere on the Republic Of Ireland network.
Would i be correct to presume on 29000 the two drivers are one Irish Rail driver and one Translink driver? I would presume that the Irish Rail driver is the one who actually drives the train?
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
Indeed from looking at the timetable both the following services appear to still run:
• 06:30 Newry - Dublin Connolly 08:19
• 17:13 Dublin Pearse - Newry 19:12
Both of them are stopping trains calling at most stations unlike the fast Enterprise services. I am not sure what times the ECS workings are but if anyone knows that would be appreciated. I am surprised they do not just keep a unit in Newry overnight rather than having two ECS working (one in each direction) every day.
Interestingly looking at the current Enterprise timetable around half of the trains are designated as being a "Non Enterprise Train" and as "1ST Class Not Available" in the PDF timetables:
I thought 3000/22000/29000 were only used on rare occasions when the Locomotive Hauled Sets were out of use or unavailable? But it seems this is now a daily regular occurrence? Is this temporary or is this planned to be permanent now? What types are these services booked for?
With due respect you are getting extremely microscopic in the levels of detail here with your questions? Why do you need to know this level of detail?
The livery difference is that the IE symbols on the cross-border ICR capable sets are in black & white.
The 29k sets on the Commuter services use two IE drivers - they are nothing to do with Translink. The ECS workings are immediately before/after they arrive at Newry to/from Dundalk.
Why would Irish Rail stable trains in Newry, rather than in Dundalk where the crews are based? There is nowhere to stable there in any case.
Thank you. That explains it. However from looking online it appears that there are actually four sets for only three diagrams. So i am guessing that there must be a second set out of use as well.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
I am just simply curious about this. There is not so much information available online regarding this compared to information available for operations over here in the UK. I know in NI and ROI a lot less information is available (such as working timetables etc) compared to what we have available online for the UK. No other reason other than that.
Thank you. That explains it. However from looking online it appears that there are actually four sets for only three diagrams. So i am guessing that there must be a second set out of use as well.
== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==
I am just simply curious about this. There is not so much information available online regarding this compared to information available for operations over here in the UK. I know in NI and ROI a lot less information is available (such as working timetables etc) compared to what we have available online for the UK. No other reason other than that.
RailUK was launched on 6th June 2005 - so we've hit 20 years being the UK's most popular railway community! Read more and celebrate this milestone with us in this thread!