• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

ScotRail HST Introduction - Updates & Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.

RupertW

Member
Joined
27 Nov 2017
Messages
11
So looking at the document even from 2019 it only says that "most" intercity services will be formed of HSTs (which could mean anything over 50%). Does this mean that there will still be 170 workings from Edinburgh/Glasgow to Aberdeen/Inverness in the long term? Until now I had been under the impression that only HSTs would be used on these routes.
 
Last edited:
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

yorkie

Forum Staff
Staff Member
Administrator
Joined
6 Jun 2005
Messages
73,470
Location
Yorkshire
I am glad to see we are back on topic now, but can I remind people that if you wish to discuss something else (this thread is about Scotrail HSTs), please create a new thread, in the relevant section and with an appropriate title. Thanks.
 

Altnabreac

Established Member
Joined
20 Apr 2013
Messages
2,416
Location
Salt & Vinegar
So looking at the document even from 2019 it only says that "most" intercity services will be formed of HSTs (which could mean anything over 50%). Does this mean that there will still be 170 workings from Edinburgh/Glasgow to Aberdeen/Inverness in the long term? Until now I had been under the impression that only HSTs would be used on these routes.

There is still going to need to be some movement of units between Inverness and the Central Belt and I wonder whether there will be some services that act primarily as commuter services say from Inverurie to Aberdeen in the morning peak that might be better as a 6 car 170? So I'd certainly expect there to be some diagrammed Inverness - Aberdeen and Inverness - Perth services that are not HSTs.
 

connormill

Member
Joined
15 Sep 2017
Messages
52
Could easily believe it, given the way the timeline is going I'd be surprised if we even have 2 refurb sets in time for the December timetable change
 

dmkc

Member
Joined
9 Feb 2017
Messages
76
Unless I was seeing things there was a PC swap going on with the refurb set at Haymarket this morning. Looked like a non-refurb PC was backing down onto it.
 

MatthewJ18

New Member
Joined
11 Sep 2018
Messages
4
Unless I was seeing things there was a PC swap going on with the refurb set at Haymarket this morning. Looked like a non-refurb PC was backing down onto it.
Nope, you're eyes were definitely correct, looked to have one of the FGW PC's at the depot side of the set. With the other FGW PC sitting by itself on the station side of the depot.
 

chuff chuff

Member
Joined
25 Sep 2018
Messages
670
So looking at the document even from 2019 it only says that "most" intercity services will be formed of HSTs (which could mean anything over 50%). Does this mean that there will still be 170 workings from Edinburgh/Glasgow to Aberdeen/Inverness in the long term? Until now I had been under the impression that only HSTs would be used on these routes.

Likelihood the early and late runs might be 170's due to the additional stops these runs usually have.
 

Stoney1979

Member
Joined
23 Jul 2018
Messages
188
Location
Aberfeldy
My view is in recent times the train seems a lot busier to and from Inverness. For example the 6:50 am train is well full most days this last while have been using it twice a week.

Agree that HST will take more passengers back to rail. A lot of my colleagues have said they will come out if their cars and back in the train when that happens.

Monty do you think the HST will be significantly better in snow?

The Inv - Ed A9/M90 etc. experience is grim, but the 170s are worse if you marry-up cost, time, convenience, passenger comfort and general pleasure. Not that the 170s are a actually a bad train, before I get shot down about that. It's just, all things considered, they aren't suitable for the route.

You also have to think that sitting relaxing on a train with some of the best views in the world whizzing by is, in itself, a driver for people to take a train rather than drive.

That's why it's disappointing to hear that the focus of the new HSTs is on lines already pretty well served by LNER, XC and so on. The greatest uplift in experience and capacity will be on the HML, with Aberdeen - Inv a very close second. Sadly, those routes seem to be second last, and last, respectively, in the SR priority list.
 

mullac30

Member
Joined
2 Jul 2017
Messages
128
To be fair, I had a 6 car 170 from INV to HYM on a Sunday a few weeks ago and it was a very quiet and relaxing journey - i think i was quite far away from the engine underfloor because it was unusually silent for a 170. Also the seats on a 170 are really comfortable, more so than the grammer seats on the 158.
 

jingsmonty

Member
Joined
21 Oct 2014
Messages
1,022
Location
Inverness
To be fair, I had a 6 car 170 from INV to HYM on a Sunday a few weeks ago and it was a very quiet and relaxing journey - i think i was quite far away from the engine underfloor because it was unusually silent for a 170. Also the seats on a 170 are really comfortable, more so than the grammer seats on the 158.

Totally agree - that's the one thing that I'll miss about the 170s too...comfortable & correctly pitched seats. Although the GWR grammer seats on the unrefurbished HST (although the same as the 158s) actually aren't quite as bad - not sure why, maybe the pitch is slightly better?

As far as the 'high density' GWR seat layout on a few of the Mk3s, it's actually not that bad either - I've tried them out on our training train & the legroom is perfectly acceptable (& I am fairly tall) - just not good if you like a table seat.

As another poster said, the 170s aren't bad trains, they just aren't suitable for the Scotrail Inter7city network.
 

jingsmonty

Member
Joined
21 Oct 2014
Messages
1,022
Location
Inverness
The Inv - Ed A9/M90 etc. experience is grim, but the 170s are worse if you marry-up cost, time, convenience, passenger comfort and general pleasure. Not that the 170s are a actually a bad train, before I get shot down about that. It's just, all things considered, they aren't suitable for the route.

You also have to think that sitting relaxing on a train with some of the best views in the world whizzing by is, in itself, a driver for people to take a train rather than drive.

That's why it's disappointing to hear that the focus of the new HSTs is on lines already pretty well served by LNER, XC and so on. The greatest uplift in experience and capacity will be on the HML, with Aberdeen - Inv a very close second. Sadly, those routes seem to be second last, and last, respectively, in the SR priority list.

I think this is partly the reasoning behind this decision - there is more experience of HST operation on the ECML North of Waverley, in case of any issues (which will, hopefully, not be major ones, but teething issues).

Agree that the biggest improvement will be in my neck of the woods -the HML, but there is still infrastructure work going on (at Pitlochry, Aviemore & Inverness itself), plus maintenance/traincrew training.

Hopefully, when A2I & HML are mainly HST services, the infrastructure will be in place & any teerhing problems ironed out..
 

Highlandspring

Established Member
Joined
14 Oct 2017
Messages
2,777
It’ll be out this Wednesday (10th) working 1Z51 1527 Edinburgh - Aberdeen calling at Dundee only; a special run for the media apparently.
 

Stoney1979

Member
Joined
23 Jul 2018
Messages
188
Location
Aberfeldy
It’ll be out this Wednesday (10th) working 1Z51 1527 Edinburgh - Aberdeen calling at Dundee only; a special run for the media apparently.

Thanks. This presumably means that the operational service intro of the first set is imminent.

Looks like SR are going with the "this is what it'll all be like, eventually.....", but, in meantime, blaming Wabtec for why it isn't now.
 

marks87

Established Member
Joined
23 Jun 2010
Messages
1,636
Location
Dundee
Maybe that’s why it’s split - run half-and-half with an unrefurbished set to show off the aim, and the current reality ;)





(For the record, I don’t believe this will happen, and the split was due to available siding length at the depot).
 

Stoney1979

Member
Joined
23 Jul 2018
Messages
188
Location
Aberfeldy
Maybe that’s why it’s split - run half-and-half with an unrefurbished set to show off the aim, and the current reality ;)





(For the record, I don’t believe this will happen, and the split was due to available siding length at the depot).

I guess it could go either way on some instances. GWR presumably put that "high density" arrangement in for a reason, which would be that mostly solo-travelling commuters would rather have any sort of seat (largely airline) than stand. So, on the packed into-Paddington commuter trains, the GWR arrangement would probably be quite welcome by many. Whereas, at other times of the week/day families and other wanting less-dense seating and tables would be the majority. Difficult for SR to square the circle.
 

jingsmonty

Member
Joined
21 Oct 2014
Messages
1,022
Location
Inverness
I guess it could go either way on some instances. GWR presumably put that "high density" arrangement in for a reason, which would be that mostly solo-travelling commuters would rather have any sort of seat (largely airline) than stand. So, on the packed into-Paddington commuter trains, the GWR arrangement would probably be quite welcome by many. Whereas, at other times of the week/day families and other wanting less-dense seating and tables would be the majority. Difficult for SR to square the circle.

I've tried the high density seating on the training train - whilst it isn't in any way suitable for long term use on Scotrail, the legroom is fine & extra seats would be welcome on the busiest trains on the HML. The refurbished sets are needed ASAP though.

I'm thinking 12.53 Inverness to Edinburgh & the afternoon Northbound one (probably from Waverley too). I could see the 17.42 Edinburgh to Inverness being an HST in Dec, as, currently, this is the same unit that works the 12.53 South. Could be an 'out & back' working, both for the train crew & the HST set? (Inverness crew to Perth & back).

That would be a logical diagram to start HST working on the HML - I could also see the 06.50 Inverness to Edinburgh being an HST too. This is a limited stop service & is one that business people may use, instead of the LNER Highland Chieftain (07.55 departure). Not sure when that would work back though...

Have heard that the HML will have 2x HST services from Dec....
 

jingsmonty

Member
Joined
21 Oct 2014
Messages
1,022
Location
Inverness
I take it that seat reservations won't work when the HSTs are introduced, due to 3 differing seat layouts being in operation (Refurbished, GWR & High Density GWR)? Also, wonder how the catering will work, given that the 'Refurbs' & 'Classics' will be working on interchangeable diagrams? Scotrail are hardly going to keep fresh food stock on hand, just in case it's a refurbished set that turns up!

Staffing may not be such an issue, as, apparently, all HSTs are supposed to have 2x catering staff on each set (either 2x trolleys or 1 trolley & 1 buffet).
 

cactustwirly

Established Member
Joined
10 Apr 2013
Messages
7,871
Location
UK
I've tried the high density seating on the training train - whilst it isn't in any way suitable for long term use on Scotrail, the legroom is fine & extra seats would be welcome on the busiest trains on the HML. The refurbished sets are needed ASAP though.

I'm thinking 12.53 Inverness to Edinburgh & the afternoon Northbound one (probably from Waverley too). I could see the 17.42 Edinburgh to Inverness being an HST in Dec, as, currently, this is the same unit that works the 12.53 South. Could be an 'out & back' working, both for the train crew & the HST set? (Inverness crew to Perth & back).

That would be a logical diagram to start HST working on the HML - I could also see the 06.50 Inverness to Edinburgh being an HST too. This is a limited stop service & is one that business people may use, instead of the LNER Highland Chieftain (07.55 departure). Not sure when that would work back though...

Have heard that the HML will have 2x HST services from Dec....

I was under the impression that ScotRail had taken on the Low Density sets?
 

jingsmonty

Member
Joined
21 Oct 2014
Messages
1,022
Location
Inverness
I was under the impression that ScotRail had taken on the Low Density sets?

There may be more low density coaches kicking about somewhere, but set HA05 (training train) has a mixture of both. I'm not sure if they have been sorted out in any particularly organised way, but the 'classic' sets will need a fair amount of remarshalling - maybe the high density coaches will be removed? Also, set HA01 has a Buffet First class, which will have to be swapped for a full First Class coach. So maybe some movement of coaches imminent. Maybe the high density coaches will be sent to Wabtec 1st? I'm not sure if the unrefurbished coaches in Scotland currently are in addition to the stock on hand at Wabtec for refurbishment, or will they have to be rotated out & sent down?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top