• Our booking engine at tickets.railforums.co.uk (powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

Wales & Borders Franchise Consultation

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

ChooChooChloe

Member
Joined
25 Oct 2017
Messages
19
As an occasional user of ATW in Cheshire/North Wales, ATW trains are almost always late, don't have enough carriages and are horrendously overcrowded.
 

Llanigraham

On Moderation
Joined
23 Mar 2013
Messages
6,114
Location
Powys
A few things:

Everyone celebrating the demise of ATW are either wearing whatever the opposite of rose-tinted glasses are, have no knowledge of ATW, are lazily basing their opinion on Wales Online, or, given the forum this is less likely, have no knowledge of franchising/at least ATW.

Are they perfect? Nope. Would any company have been? Nope. Irrespective of who signed the franchise agreement in 2003, the situation would be the same/worse.

@craigybagel is right - less choice for the WG means less likelihood of any real change. It's lazy, easy, and frankly shows a lack of knowledge of the ATW franchise, to simply celebrate this news.

Quite!
Unfortunately there are a group of members here who will find any excuse to knock ATW, often based on a few journeys and not from living in Wales and using them regularly.
 

Llanigraham

On Moderation
Joined
23 Mar 2013
Messages
6,114
Location
Powys
Dirty trains/buses, failure to complete repairs other than those required to make the train go etc. Very similar to Central Trains if anyone remembers them.

The state of buses is irrelevant!
Repairs are completed as soon as is possible/practical.
 

JetStream

Member
Joined
27 Oct 2016
Messages
155
As an occasional user of ATW in Cheshire/North Wales, ATW trains are almost always late, don't have enough carriages and are horrendously overcrowded.

I'll disagree with the lateness, and would point out it costs millions for just one new train - as for overcrowded, should trains leave more people behind?
 

Llanigraham

On Moderation
Joined
23 Mar 2013
Messages
6,114
Location
Powys
Did you ever use Arriva buses in MK? They are appallingly bad. They do seem to have got some new buses of late, but it won't be long before the complete lack of maintenance ("does it go? That'll do.") will result in bits hanging off those, too.

As I said, Stagecoach would never tolerate it.

When I've used ATW I've found it to be the same. Quality refurb jobs left to rack and ruin over time.

And that is the passenger's problem because?

Again, buses are irrelevant, but you seem to be using that in your continual "rant" against anything Arriva.
And by your own admission your use of ATW is minimal but you are very quick to criticise.
 

ChooChooChloe

Member
Joined
25 Oct 2017
Messages
19
I'll disagree with the lateness, and would point out it costs millions for just one new train - as for overcrowded, should trains leave more people behind?

I'm not talking London Midland 'overcrowded' though. I mean dangerously overcrowded - it's like sardines in there, and you've got people with bikes as well. When I went on holiday in August to Llandudno I had to miss the train I was due to catch and wait an hour for the next one because it was absolutely full to bursting. And it's not the first time either.
 

Eccles1983

On Moderation
Joined
4 Sep 2016
Messages
841
As an occasional user of ATW in Cheshire/North Wales, ATW trains are almost always late, don't have enough carriages and are horrendously overcrowded.


And as a daily user in the same area I am telling you that you are wrong.

Very rarely late. And only ever overcrowded (in very loose terms considering trains in and out of manchester) in the peaks.

ATW is by a long way the best TOC in the north.
 

ChooChooChloe

Member
Joined
25 Oct 2017
Messages
19
And as a daily user in the same area I am telling you that you are wrong.

Very rarely late. And only ever overcrowded (in very loose terms considering trains in and out of manchester) in the peaks.

ATW is by a long way the best TOC in the north.

It depends what you mean by 'in the north'. If you mean 'based in the north' then personally I prefer Northern. If you mean 'serving the north', then I don't think anyone is better than Virgin.
 

Llanigraham

On Moderation
Joined
23 Mar 2013
Messages
6,114
Location
Powys
I'm not talking London Midland 'overcrowded' though. I mean dangerously overcrowded - it's like sardines in there, and you've got people with bikes as well. When I went on holiday in August to Llandudno I had to miss the train I was due to catch and wait an hour for the next one because it was absolutely full to bursting. And it's not the first time either.

Wow!!
One journey and you condemn the whole franchise across the whole Principality!!
Do you consider that a balanced viewpoint?
 

Doctor Fegg

Established Member
Joined
9 Nov 2010
Messages
1,856
Central Trains were run into the ground by that well known coach company National Express, Arriva have never been involved with them.

Central Trains had a no-growth franchise too, so they make an interesting comparison.

CT: ordered a 33-strong fleet of 170s. Shared 30 350s with Silverlink.

ATW: no new units.

CT: repeatedly cut off-peak fares to grow ridership.

ATW: nope. Some of the most extortionate regional fares in Britain, and some pretty unjustifiable pricing anomalies too.

I use the Marches Line frequently (and services from Gloucester and along the South Wales main line infrequently). They are pretty much the most unpleasant services I travel on, in terms of crowding, high prices, inconvenient timetabling and poor-quality stock. Maybe elsewhere they're better, but my real-world experience is that ATW - despite some excellent on-the-ground staff - has been run as a don't-give-a-**** operation comparable to the old Thames Trains or, guess what, today's CrossCountry.
 
Last edited:

Eccles1983

On Moderation
Joined
4 Sep 2016
Messages
841
It depends what you mean by 'in the north'. If you mean 'based in the north' then personally I prefer Northern. If you mean 'serving the north', then I don't think anyone is better than Virgin.

Serving in and out of manchester.
I meant regional (ish) railways. So out of Northern, Merseyrail, TPE and ATW.

ATW wins hands down. And twice on sundays.

And I work for one of the companies listed, and ATW is better than it.
 

313103

Established Member
Joined
13 May 2006
Messages
1,595
Ah, the living proof that #2 rises to the top. Good news for Wales I would say.

I wouldn't say it was good news for Wales, certainly not for the staff anyway. I would say it was good news for my colleagues at London Midland they have certainly been happy since he moved. What we do know is that the staff on ATW are venturing into the unknown. The passengers may very be glad they have got rid of Arriva, however i would err on the side of caution 'be careful what you wish for'.
 

Eccles1983

On Moderation
Joined
4 Sep 2016
Messages
841
It's neither agressive or rudeness.

Frankly, such misguided nonsense should and is being challenged robustly.

No one minds genuine fact based gripes, none of which you have provided.
 

Eccles1983

On Moderation
Joined
4 Sep 2016
Messages
841
Well by your own musings your opinion flys in the face of people using the services daily.

So your opinion is invalid unless you add some substance to it.
 

Rhydgaled

Established Member
Joined
25 Nov 2010
Messages
4,584
Arriva pulling out is an huge surprise, particularly as they were reported as having part-funded the lease on the micro-fleet of 769s into the early 2020s and SARPA's latest newsletter had Abellio and Arriva as the only two bidders still in the running. From various comments earlier in this topic (and maybe other topics/fourms), I can think of three possible reasons for Arriva pulling out:
  1. They are expecting a direct award and therefore it isn't worth them sinking any more funds in bidding, since a new contest will follow the direct award
  2. The Welsh Government / Transport For Wales is asking for something that Arriva does not want to offer in their bid, because they consider it too high risk
  3. Similar to (2.), Arriva consider the partial vertical integration of the south Wales metro too high risk
Possible reasons for a direct award could be a further delay to devolution of the franchising powers or the issue of Pacer replacement and TSI-PRM compliance for the class 153 and mark 3 fleets.
 

JetStream

Member
Joined
27 Oct 2016
Messages
155
I'm not talking London Midland 'overcrowded' though. I mean dangerously overcrowded - it's like sardines in there, and you've got people with bikes as well. When I went on holiday in August to Llandudno I had to miss the train I was due to catch and wait an hour for the next one because it was absolutely full to bursting. And it's not the first time either.

Summer holidays, potentially around a bank holiday/weekend, along a known holiday route. Shy of running multiple trains an hour/having 6+ carriage trains, there's no way of battling the sardines I'm afraid. Next time I'd recommend travelling early/late, and generally avoiding Mondays, Fridays, and Saturdays. Inconvenient, perhaps, but it's a choice between being a sardine or travelling a few hours earlier/later than you'd want.
 

6Gman

Established Member
Joined
1 May 2012
Messages
8,493
I use the Marches Line frequently (and services from Gloucester and along the South Wales main line infrequently). They are pretty much the most unpleasant services I travel on, in terms of crowding, high prices, inconvenient timetabling and poor-quality stock. Maybe elsewhere they're better, but my real-world experience is that ATW - despite some excellent on-the-ground staff - has been run as a don't-give-a-**** operation comparable to the old Thames Trains or, guess what, today's CrossCountry.

I use the Marches Line quite often. Can't remember the last time I had to stand. Haven't noticed the fares being out of kilter with other operators. A basic hourly service along the Crewe - Cardiff section (plus 2hourly Shrewsbury - Cardiff) is miles better than what it was historically. And "poor quality stock"? Really? 175s - perhaps the most comfortable DMUs in existence! (Though they could do with a refurb and some TLC)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top